Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?

210 replies

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:26

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4).
One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

OP posts:
WouldBeGood · 26/03/2022 13:07

YABVVU

It’s for the state to prove guilt. No one has to prove their innocence.

JudgeJ · 26/03/2022 13:04

@speakout

How will you impose such a rule?
If they choose to remain silent then the jury should be able to draw negative conclusions from their silence.
balalake · 26/03/2022 12:47

It is a fundamental principle of justice. In practical terms if it was abolished, all someone would say is 'I decline to answer' or some form of evasive response. Or claim they were too ill to be in the dock and so justice would be delayed.

HaggisBurger · 26/03/2022 12:42

The right to silence and the burden on the prosecution to prove guilt (rather than on the defendant to prove their innocence) are connected and a very necessary cornerstone of our criminal justice system. YABU.

DockOTheBay · 26/03/2022 12:38

*common sense

DockOTheBay · 26/03/2022 12:38

[quote Curly3456]@Georgeskitchen Yes, both defendents were highly educated[/quote]
Doesn't mean they're not stupid though. I know private school kids who did fine in school but are as thick as two short planks when it comes to social situations or commons else. They wouldn't have the personality to win over a jury or the intelligence not to say something stupid.

BronwenFrideswide · 26/03/2022 12:29

Of course they shouldn't be compelled to speak in their own defence and how exactly would you compel them to do so? The burden of proof is on the prosecution not the defence.

Much like the 'no comment' responses in Police interviews, as infuriating as they may be, the person being interviewed has the right not to answer the questions put to them, the onus is on those investigating the crime to find the evidence of that person committing the crime not on the person suspected of the crime doing their work for them.

Juries can and do judge defendants in both those scenarios.

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 12:17

@Aroundtheworldin80moves

Consider if a dependent had a low IQ. They may not fully understand the questions, so give incriminating but wrong answers.

The prosecution has to proved beyond reasonable doubt. Otherwise you might as well lock up anyone.

This is not in particular to that specific case. In general terms.

Yes, I agree with this.
OP posts:
OnAWobblyFence · 26/03/2022 12:15

You’re looking at it the wrong way.

You are assuming that not taking the stand means that the defendant is being “excused” from a duty or being given a free pass. But the defendant doesn’t have to do anything. They are presumed innocent. The prosecution has to do all the work in proving, beyond reasonable doubt, that the person is guilty.

How can a presumed innocent person have committed a crime just because they elect not to defend themselves but rather let the evidence speak for itself? That doesn’t make sense.

A cross-examination is no walk in the park. Those people spend years training and perfecting the skill. It’s designed to trip the person up, using language and question formats that confuse people. It’s possible that in this case the defense lawyer recommended that the defendant not speak.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 26/03/2022 12:07

Consider if a dependent had a low IQ. They may not fully understand the questions, so give incriminating but wrong answers.

The prosecution has to proved beyond reasonable doubt. Otherwise you might as well lock up anyone.

This is not in particular to that specific case. In general terms.

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/03/2022 12:05

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
The English justice system presumes innocence and the onus is on the prosecution to prove guilt, not the defendant to exonerate themselves.

There are plenty of countries where this is the other way around, and they aren’t generally held up as bastions of human rights and fair justice. Funnily enough, the people who hold views like yours never seem in a hurry to emigrate there to live under the auspices they think correct.

bellac11 · 26/03/2022 12:02

Would you poke them with a stick OP?

Blimecory · 26/03/2022 12:00

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
That would be obscene and lead to many miscarriages of justice. There’s a reason why right to silence is enshrined in most of the world’s legal systems.
Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 12:00

@PurpleDaisies

Some people just come across as unlikeable. Or regardless of their educational background would go to pieces on the stand.
Yes agreed. I think you have all persuaded me why we have the right to remain silent.

It's hard not to feel from the documentary that the defendent who didn't give evidence seemed to get off lightly.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 26/03/2022 11:58

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.

PurpleDaisies · 26/03/2022 11:55

Some people just come across as unlikeable. Or regardless of their educational background would go to pieces on the stand.

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:54

@Georgeskitchen Yes, both defendents were highly educated

OP posts:
Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:52

@Momicrone

Pretty cowardly for him not to give his version of events in court though considering his friend had died
Agreed.
OP posts:
Momicrone · 26/03/2022 11:51

Pretty cowardly for him not to give his version of events in court though considering his friend had died

Georgeskitchen · 26/03/2022 11:51

@BlusteryLake

Some defendants are inarticulate and poorly educated. Speaking in court against a clever lawyer could give a wrong impression so they prefer to let the evidence speak.
They were educated grammar school pupils
Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:49

@IDoAllMyOwnStunts

It's called an 'adverse inference' OP.
Thank you!
OP posts:
SolasAnla · 26/03/2022 11:47

@Curly3456

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4). One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

The accused is just that. The individual is presumed to be innocent of the crime.

The trial is there to give the State the oppertunity to provide sufficient evidence to prove beond reasonable doubt that a crime took place and that the person accused is the person who carried out the crime.

If the evidence will not suffice why should the State be allowed to force an individual to collaborate in their own prosecution? Confused

IDoAllMyOwnStunts · 26/03/2022 11:43

It's called an 'adverse inference' OP.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?
IDoAllMyOwnStunts · 26/03/2022 11:40

Refusal to speak can have consequences for the defendant. ( ^^See my earlier post)

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:40

@BlusteryLake

Some defendants are inarticulate and poorly educated. Speaking in court against a clever lawyer could give a wrong impression so they prefer to let the evidence speak.
This is a good point. Thank you for making it.
OP posts: