Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?

210 replies

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:26

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4).
One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

OP posts:
MoltenLasagne · 26/03/2022 16:42

When I was 19 I witnessed a crime and was called to give evidence. The prosecution probably thought I'd be a good witness seeing as I was articulate in the police interviews and I was completely independent of either the accused or the victim so couldn't be biased.

I absolutely went to pieces on the stand. I was tripped up, accused of racism, told I had an ulterior motive, over elaborated in my answers rather than just sticking to answering the question. It is still up there as one of the worst experiences in my life. If someone wishes to remain silent and let the evidence speak for itself they should have that right.

grapewines · 26/03/2022 16:38

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
Utterly nuts.
grapewines · 26/03/2022 16:36

@Curly3456

You can't force someone to speak, but refusal to answer questions could be an offence itself with possible legal consequences.
YABVU.
steff13 · 26/03/2022 16:34

You're being terribly unreasonable.

Mayorquimby2 · 26/03/2022 16:17

One of the worst ideas I've ever heard

HaggisBurger · 26/03/2022 15:49

@NannyKrampus exactly!! The mind truly boggles.

NannyKrampus · 26/03/2022 15:47

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
Are you on glue?
BronwenFrideswide · 26/03/2022 15:00

What you, OP, and one or two other posters, are advocating for here is that we completely reverse the whole basis of justice to one where the presumption is guilty until proven innocent, and that is the stuff of dystopian nightmares and totalitarian regimes.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 26/03/2022 14:46

If DH and I were accused of the same crime which one of us do you think would do better in a witness box
Me - well educated British born lawyer with mother tongue English

DH - North African Muslim immigrant who grew up speaking Arabic and French

The onus is on the prosecution to prove their case beyond reasonable doubt. The defendant doesn’t have to prove anything or answer anything.

ButterfliesAndPancakes · 26/03/2022 14:37

YABU. Haven’t you heard of innocent until proven guilty? The onus is on the prosecution to prove that the defendant did it, not for the defendant to prove that they didn’t.

lljkk · 26/03/2022 14:01

Justice doesn't mean "get a conviction"

Justice = "make sure we can believe this conviction is justified"

That's where the "Innocent until proven guilty" principle comes from.

Chinese justice is great. They execute people all the time for terrible crimes. I wonder how many of the executed were actually guilty.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/03/2022 13:52

@Curly3456

You can't force someone to speak, but refusal to answer questions could be an offence itself with possible legal consequences.
That’s utterly ridiculous and would be unworkable.
JakeyRolling · 26/03/2022 13:49

If the presumption is that they are innocent until proven guilty and that it's for the Crown to prove the case, why should they be forced to potentially incriminate themselves?

If they choose to give evidence then they must answer questions.

SolasAnla · 26/03/2022 13:43

@maddening

You could make it a contempt of court and in itself carry a custodial sentence
Where were you on the 3 of August 1999?
ComtesseDeSpair · 26/03/2022 13:40

@maddening

You could make it a contempt of court and in itself carry a custodial sentence
I’d imagine in these circumstances solicitors would simply instruct their clients to answer “I do not remember” or “I can’t say for sure” to all questions. Do we then also jail defendants who genuinely cannot remember or say for sure? If so, we’ll just have to accept an awful lot of made up answers from defendants desperate not to be jailed simply because they can’t remember.
KrisAkabusi · 26/03/2022 13:37

@maddening

You could make it a contempt of court and in itself carry a custodial sentence
Again, why? It is not my job to prove that I am innocent. It is the prosecution's job to prove that I am guilty.
midsomermurderess · 26/03/2022 13:35

The onus is on the prosecution to prove a defendant guilty, not on the defence to establish their innocence. We start from a presumption of innocence which has to be overturned.

Thatswhyimacat · 26/03/2022 13:34

Look at the case of Louise Woodward. She did take the stand, when she didn't have to. The evidence against her wasn't strong and would never hold up today. She was tripped up and tongue tied by lawyers over points of language and a big factor in the jury's decision to convict her OF MURDER was that they found her cold and didn't like her. Her conviction was overturned.

maddening · 26/03/2022 13:31

You could make it a contempt of court and in itself carry a custodial sentence

Thatswhyimacat · 26/03/2022 13:28

There are SO many reasons why you cannot force defendents to speak. You are talking about putting potentially uneducated, highly vulnerable people on a stand and insisting they, even when innocent, are ripped to shreds by a barrister whose whole job would be to exploit their weaknesses and judged by a jury not on the evidence but on how well they come across as people, leading to immense bias. It's just bloody nasty.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 26/03/2022 13:21

@PotteringAlong

How do you propose to make people speak?
Tickle machine
KrisAkabusi · 26/03/2022 13:20

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
So the prosecution doesn't even have to have a case any more, the accused just needs to be too afraid to speak and they'll automatically be found guilty. Does that sound like a fair justice system to you?
moonbedazzled · 26/03/2022 13:14

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
That is a very worrying position to take. There should be enough evidence supplied by the police to convict without relying on the accused to self-incriminate.
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/03/2022 13:13

It's the Prosecutions job to demonstrate that the accused committed the crime beyond all reasonable doubt.

The defendent doesn't need to speak publicly for that. The evidence gathered (including statements or previous words spoken by the accused) should either be sufficient enough to prove beyond all reasonable doubt (guilty) or insufficient (not guilty).

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/03/2022 13:10

@bellac11

Would you poke them with a stick OP?
A VERY pointy one.