Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?

210 replies

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:26

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4).
One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

OP posts:
EmpressCixi · 27/03/2022 14:30

@Curly3456

You can't force someone to speak, but refusal to answer questions could be an offence itself with possible legal consequences.
That would then constitute duress. Duress is any coercion to speak whether economic (fines, loss of job), imprisonment (loss of liberty), or physical (torture).

The right to remain silent was created because of the above old practices of obtaining confessions under duress.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/03/2022 13:44

In the defendents defence (!), someone else is claiming that they did the crime. They shouldn't need to speak. Whoever is claiming they did it should be the one who has to speak and prove their reasoning.

OneTC · 27/03/2022 13:43

When I did jury service the defendant didn't take the stand and the judge told us that we could infer what we wanted from that, the emphasis seemed to be that we should infer that an innocent person would seek to clear themselves through testimony

PurpleCarpets · 27/03/2022 13:28

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Simple answers to complex questions - from the people who brought you brexit. Is there really no limit to the stuff some people will link to Brexit. That is just as fucking ridiculous as the OP’s and similar comments.
TBF letting people who don't understand complicated systems make simplistic decisions against the advice of experts who do invariably ends very badly!
zingally · 27/03/2022 12:52

The right NOT to speak is one of the oldest laws in the English speaking world. It was designed to protect the defendant from all sorts of twists and turns and clever word-play employed by lawyers and the like. Who were often highly educated and more intelligent than the person on the stand.

And also, even if HAVING to speak in court became legal, how on earth could it be enforced? Yes, you could threaten prison etc, but you can't physically force another person to speak. And that also goes against the premise of "innocent until found guilty".

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/03/2022 12:48

Simple answers to complex questions - from the people who brought you brexit.
Is there really no limit to the stuff some people will link to Brexit. That is just as fucking ridiculous as the OP’s and similar comments.

Thelnebriati · 27/03/2022 12:43

Google was unhelpful, but Wikipedia says;

''...from the 17th century. The defendant was considered "incompetent" to give evidence and attempts to force defendants to provide answers...were judged unlawful.
Being unable to speak at their own trial, the practice of defendants giving an unsworn statement was introduced and was recognised in law in 1883.
Defendants testifying in their own defence was also introduced in the 1880s (and extended to all offences by 1898) although the right to silence was clearly protected.''
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence_in_England_and_Wales

bellac11 · 27/03/2022 12:07

Up until a while ago, the defendant wasnt allowed to give evidence. Cant remember when it changed, 1800s or something?

Daftasabroom · 27/03/2022 12:03

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
You mean guilty until proven innocent? You've never been falsely arrested then?
x2boys · 27/03/2022 09:35

Our justice system isn't perfect
But when my dh was wrongly charged with a crime ( I was present throughout the situation) I was very great full for the innocentuntill proven guilty System ,and also that the jury has to find the defendant guilty beyond all reasonable doubt ,in my dh case ,it was resolved prior to trial .

LardyDee · 27/03/2022 09:10

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
Simple answers to complex questions - from the people who brought you brexit.
SolasAnla · 27/03/2022 08:27

@5foot5

5foot5

Where were you on the 3 of August 1999?

@SolasAnla
I give in. What happened?

I presume that’s the point being made: the answer for most people will be “I can’t remember” - which for the purposes of wanting to make it a criminal offence for a defendant not to answer accurately when questioned, will eventually be taken as a refusal to answer, and therefore contempt of court.

Oh I see! I thought she must be referencing a particularly memorable case. I have been googling "what happened on 3rd August 1999" Grin

(Not much from what I could find)

People made a business of googling birthday facts Eg www.mybirthdayfacts.com/

👍

EdgeOfACoin · 27/03/2022 08:27

They were educated grammar school pupils

But you can't have one law for educated grammar school pupils and one law for kids from the local sink school.

SolasAnla · 27/03/2022 08:19

@5foot5

Where were you on the 3 of August 1999?

@SolasAnla
I give in. What happened?

No idea🤷🏼‍♀️, but everyone aged 23 or older, who cant answer is at risk of going to prison😣.
Thelnebriati · 26/03/2022 23:17

Society decided it would be better for potentially guilty people to go free rather than convict the innocent on a technicality.
The reason its stupid not to support that is it could be any one of us.

BronwenFrideswide · 26/03/2022 23:14

Plus in the case the OP refers to the failure to prove guilt, if indeed the defendants were guilty, lies squarely at the feet of the Prosecution, blaming the loss of the case on one of the Defendants not taking the stand is ridiculous.

Libertaire · 26/03/2022 23:06

The defendant is innocent until proven guilty. That is a fundamental principle of the criminal justice system and the basis of fair trials. If you, OP, were unfortunate enough to be falsely or maliciously accused of committing a criminal offence, you would be grateful for the presumption of innocence.

It is for the prosecution to prove the defendant’s guilt. The defendant, as an innocent person, is not required to prove anything at all. The defendant also has the right not to incriminate themselves. In the United States this right is written into the nation’s constitution, in the famous Fifth Amendment. Under English law, a simple ‘no comment’ will suffice.

BronwenFrideswide · 26/03/2022 22:52

I agree NeverDropYourMoonCup, some posters on here, including the OP, seem to be of the opinion that once someone is charged with a crime they are automatically guilty of said crime, if that's the case then why bother with a Trial at all, just pack them off to jail, do not pass Go? I mean even under the current system it's not like there have never, ever, been any cases where defendants were 'fit up' for the crime, never any miscarriages of justice. Their version of 'Justice' makes my blood run cold, do they really want to live in a society without judicial safeguards, if so then I can recommend a few places they may like to move to.

The symbolism of the Lady Justice statue, some people on here need to think about it:

Balance Scales: These represent impartiality and the obligation of the law (through its representatives) to weigh the evidence presented to the court. Each side of a legal case needs to be looked at and comparisons made as justice is done.

Sword: This item symbolizes enforcement and respect, and means that justice stands by its decision and ruling, and is able to take action. The fact that the sword is unsheathed and very visible is a sign that justice is transparent and is not an implement of fear. A double-edged blade signifies that justice can rule against either of the parties once the evidence has been perused, and it is bound to enforce the ruling as well as protect or defend the innocent party.

Blindfold: This first appeared on a Lady Justice statue in the 16th century, and has been used intermittently since then. Apparently, its original significance was that the judicial system was tolerating abuse or ignorance of aspects of the law. However, in modern times, the blindfold represents the impartiality and objectivity of the law and that it doesn’t let outside factors, such as politics, wealth or fame, influence its decisions.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/03/2022 18:15

If they choose to remain silent then the jury should be able to draw negative conclusions from their silence

Jesus.

I could, if I felt so inclined, absolutely tie DP up in knots with questions and spurious assumptions and accusations to the point at which he'd either admit assassinating the Queen - even though she's not dead yet - or do himself in to make it all stop.

If your demands were met, you have singlehandedly ensured that any autistic person who had mutism in their symptoms is no longer able to access justice. You've ensured that people who have crippling anxiety are no longer to access justice. You've ensured that people with speech impediments such as stammering no longer have access to justice. You've ensured that people who are d/Deaf and hard of hearing or auditory processing disorders no longer have access to justice. You've ensured that a large number of poorly educated, lower than average cognitive ability, or are already traumatised aren't able to access justice. And, frankly, a large number of people who have accents associated with particular areas or ethnicities are going to be treated prejudicially as a result of your expectation that everybody should be able to stand up to the verbal parries of professional speakers and wordsmiths.

In addition, if the defendant is compelled to speak or they are deemed guilty, 'fairness' would dictate that victims would have to be compelled to speak or the defendant would automatically be found not guilty. Which means many cases would not proceed on the grounds of their fear, their inability to be cross examined, on their ethnicity/accent and disabilities.

There are no fair trials in those circumstances.

Onceuponatimethen · 26/03/2022 17:48

Yabu

The onus has to be on the prosecution to prove the case because of innocent until proven guilty.

iolaus · 26/03/2022 17:42

I''ve been a witness in court, it was horrendous and though I wouldn't say I completely went to pieces I feel the prosecutor twisted what I said and gets you to a point where you start wondering exactly what you even know

5foot5 · 26/03/2022 17:26

5foot5

Where were you on the 3 of August 1999?

@SolasAnla
I give in. What happened?

I presume that’s the point being made: the answer for most people will be “I can’t remember” - which for the purposes of wanting to make it a criminal offence for a defendant not to answer accurately when questioned, will eventually be taken as a refusal to answer, and therefore contempt of court.

Oh I see! I thought she must be referencing a particularly memorable case. I have been googling "what happened on 3rd August 1999" Grin

(Not much from what I could find)

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/03/2022 17:21

@5foot5

Where were you on the 3 of August 1999?

@SolasAnla
I give in. What happened?

I presume that’s the point being made: the answer for most people will be “I can’t remember” - which for the purposes of wanting to make it a criminal offence for a defendant not to answer accurately when questioned, will eventually be taken as a refusal to answer, and therefore contempt of court.
SwedishEdith · 26/03/2022 17:12

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
Christ, let's hope you're never on jury service.
5foot5 · 26/03/2022 17:03

Where were you on the 3 of August 1999?

@SolasAnla
I give in. What happened?