Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?

210 replies

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:26

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4).
One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

OP posts:
LoveFall · 27/03/2022 17:13

The burden or proof beyond a reasonable doubt rests on the prosecution.

If you are accused if a crime, you are not required to incriminate yourself.

If you do decide to testify, many thing such as prior history become fair game.

Our common law system has long had the right to remain silent.

BronwenFrideswide · 27/03/2022 17:06

[quote Daftasabroom]@Curly3456 also if you do get arrested and interviewed never ever ever give a statement to the police without a lawyer present.[/quote]
Very wise advice.

BronwenFrideswide · 27/03/2022 17:05

Exactly, eastegg, the documentary was only ever going to put the side/conclusion they wanted the viewer to accept/come to. The simple fact in this case is that the Prosecution failed to convince a Jury of 12 of their case, if it is a miscarriage of justice for Yousef it is down to that failure not the fact that one of the defendants didn't take the stand in his own defence.

Daftasabroom · 27/03/2022 17:04

@Curly3456 also if you do get arrested and interviewed never ever ever give a statement to the police without a lawyer present.

Tiphaine · 27/03/2022 17:02

How many steps are there between making it a crime for a defendant to refuse to give evidence and forcing them to read a script? Is compelled speech valid as evidence in UK law?

eastegg · 27/03/2022 16:59

The thing that’s really coming through on this thread is how misleading tv documentaries can be, on pretty much anything but I think especially on the criminal justice system.

OP has changed her mind pretty much straightaway on finding out about adverse inferences, something the doc obviously didn’t mention! I find even respected news sources are pretty bad at this sort of thing, they just want to tell the baddies/goodies narrative.

BronwenFrideswide · 27/03/2022 16:59

You'd have to impose a mandatory penalty for not speaking in court if you're capable of speech and if you're a defendant. Which I don't technically disagree with in principle; if your actions are defensible, it would be extremely unusual not to wish to defend them.

I absolutely disagree with it on principle, there's nothing principled about it at all.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/03/2022 16:56

@HerculesMulligan

You've got to love an OP who's watched a short documentary and worked out how to fix the criminal justice system once and for all. Oh, apart from the justice bit.
Agreed - and who also seeks to argue against an absolute right enshrined in the constitutions of many countries including the USA. But of course, they're all wrong.
crispmidnightpeace · 27/03/2022 16:56

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
Is there a group this would affect mostly? A group perhaps who have a lack of education and attainment in general due to discrimination?
BronwenFrideswide · 27/03/2022 16:54

It's a cornerstone of Justice that the person in the dock is presumed innocent until proven guilty at the end of the trial, it is rather concerning that some people on here fail to grasp this fundamental tenet of the Justice system and where it leads if it is subverted.

Mayorquimby2 · 27/03/2022 16:53

Injured party

crispmidnightpeace · 27/03/2022 16:53

@speakout

How will you impose such a rule?
This is the best point. People often ask these things without considering the practicalities.
SexiestDogWalker · 27/03/2022 16:51

You'd have to impose a mandatory penalty for not speaking in court if you're capable of speech and if you're a defendant. Which I don't technically disagree with in principle; if your actions are defensible, it would be extremely unusual not to wish to defend them. It can be reasonably assumed that only the guilty choose not to answer questions, but there will always be an outlier. For example, say we impose a mandatory 3 year prison sentence for interfering with the course of justice for all the defendants who choose not to answer to the prosecution. Served consecutively if any other sentence is imposed. Out of 1000 people sentenced to this, two had extreme social anxiety, five had ADHD which meant they couldn't pay enough attention and process things well enough so knew they'd stumble no matter what, eleven had experienced prejudice due to their race, background or prior criminal record and felt nothing they said would be listened to. 28 people out of 1000 served that sentence not out of choice but out of circumstance. Even if they did the crime they were meant to be questioned over, should they have done that extra sentence on top? Is that ok if they're already a criminal?

Too murky in practice, I think.

Mayorquimby2 · 27/03/2022 16:49

[quote PixieLaLa]@Daftasabroom Because victims and witnesses have to speak/be cross examined by lawyers but the person who committed a crime doesn’t have to. In my opinion that doesn’t seem fair.[/quote]
They have to speak and be cross examined because the prosecution want them to form part of the prosecutions case.

If the defence want the defendants evidence to form part of the defence case then they have to speak and be cross examined.
Textbook fair procedures

The defendant would be quite happy for none of the witnesses or alleged United party to give evidence.

Blimecory · 27/03/2022 16:47

[quote PixieLaLa]@Daftasabroom Because victims and witnesses have to speak/be cross examined by lawyers but the person who committed a crime doesn’t have to. In my opinion that doesn’t seem fair.[/quote]
The defendant is always innocent, though - unless proven guilty of the crime at the end of the trial.

BronwenFrideswide · 27/03/2022 16:46

[quote PixieLaLa]@Daftasabroom Because victims and witnesses have to speak/be cross examined by lawyers but the person who committed a crime doesn’t have to. In my opinion that doesn’t seem fair.[/quote]
Because it is up to the Prosecution to provide the proof that the Defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of the crime they are alleged to have committed so of course the victims and witnesses have to be cross examined. The onus is not on the Defendant to prove their innocence, it is on the prosecution to prove their guilt, of course it is fair and right that's the whole basis of innocent until proven guilty.

HerculesMulligan · 27/03/2022 16:44

You've got to love an OP who's watched a short documentary and worked out how to fix the criminal justice system once and for all. Oh, apart from the justice bit.

Daftasabroom · 27/03/2022 16:43

@PixieLaLa why are you so sure the defendant committed a crime?

BronwenFrideswide · 27/03/2022 16:39

Rubbish. In theory, the defence doesn't have to do anything to prove they didn't commit a crime, the prosecution need to prove they did.

Not speaking is unwise, and may harm their defence, but it's still the prosecutions job to present the evidence that they did what they are accused of.

May being the crucial word. If the Prosecution case is relying solely on the defendant taking the stand to be cross examined by them to convince the Jury of their guilt then there is something amiss with the Prosecution's case.

PixieLaLa · 27/03/2022 16:38

@Daftasabroom Because victims and witnesses have to speak/be cross examined by lawyers but the person who committed a crime doesn’t have to. In my opinion that doesn’t seem fair.

Daftasabroom · 27/03/2022 16:28

@PixieLaLa why would it be unfair?

PixieLaLa · 27/03/2022 16:20

I agree with you, it doesn’t seem fair

ZippeeDeeDoohDah · 27/03/2022 16:03

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
Rubbish. In theory, the defence doesn't have to do anything to prove they didn't commit a crime, the prosecution need to prove they did.

Not speaking is unwise, and may harm their defence, but it's still the prosecutions job to present the evidence that they did what they are accused of.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/03/2022 15:02

TBF letting people who don't understand complicated systems make simplistic decisions against the advice of experts who do invariably ends very badly!
I think you have just described democracy (universal suffrage) and argued against it.

Anniefrenchfry · 27/03/2022 14:39

Some people really can’t speak in court, anxiety, mental health etc can actually make people behave in ways they wouldn’t wish to. Your assumption makes it seem everyone is capable. Many innocent people end up in court, that’s why we have a court system, simoly being tried doesn’t make you guilty, and some people just can’t get up and respond on a lucid manner.