Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?

210 replies

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:26

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4).
One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/03/2022 22:15

Fuck's Sake.

A Barrister's Core Duties:

To observe their duty to the court in the administration of justice.

They;

must not mislead a court or a judge or waste a court’s time and may need to make sure the court has all the relevant information it needs
must not abuse their role as an advocate; and
they must ensure that their ability to act independently is not compromised.

To act in the best interests of each client

A barrister who is working for you must always think about what is best for you and do their job in a way that reflects that. This does not mean that a barrister can lie on your behalf, or that they must do everything you tell them. Their duty to the court comes above even their duty to you as their client and barristers must act with independence, honesty and integrity. This means, for example, that they cannot do anything for you that would go against their duty to the court.

To act with honesty, and with integrity

The duty to act with honesty and with integrity includes not misleading or lying to anyone, not encouraging other people to mislead or be untruthful, and only accepting money and fees that they are legally allowed to. Barristers should also show integrity by upholding the professional standards expected of them.

To maintain their independence

To make sure barristers maintain their independence, they are not allowed to offer, promise or give gifts or referral fees to any client (or intermediary such as a solicitor), or to accept any money from a client or intermediary unless it is as payment for their professional work. They cannot work for you if there is, or they think there might be, a conflict of interest for them in doing so.

Not to behave in a way that is likely to diminish the trust and confidence which the public places in them or the barrister profession

Things that would be likely to diminish trust and confidence in the profession could include committing a crime, being dishonest, harassing others, offensive conduct towards other people, or abuse of their position as a barrister.

To keep the affairs of each client confidential

This means that barristers are not allowed to talk to other people about what you tell them without your consent.

To provide a competent standard of work and service to each client

A competent standard of work and service includes promoting a client's best interests, treating clients with courtesy and consideration, advising a client in terms that they can understand, avoiding unnecessary costs for a client, and reading a client's instructions promptly.

Not to discriminate unlawfully against any person

Barristers must not treat anyone less favourably or harass them or victimise them because of their race, colour, ethnicity or nationality, citizenship, sex, gender reassignment, sexual orientation, relationship status, disability, age, religion, belief or pregnancy/maternity.

To be open and cooperative with regulators

This means that barristers have to do what is asked of them by us or the Legal Ombudsman and provide the Bar Standards Board with information they need about them.

To take reasonable steps to manage their practice...

... or carry out their role within their practice, competently and in such a way as to achieve compliance with their legal and regulatory obligations

This means that a barrister must run their practice in a way that follows the rules in the BSB Handbook.

Just because people don't like the verdicts, that doesn't mean the barrister is doing something wrong - that means they're doing something right.

Hoplesscynic · 28/03/2022 22:05

"That's a perverted but sadly common view of what defence barristers do."

Are you for real? Of course the defense lawyer's job is to get the lightest sentence, they are there to work in the best interests of their clients.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:02

That was a bit garbled but hope you understand what I mean! 😄

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:01

Was the character "assassination " , some would say context, completely made up then?

I doubt very much it was completely made up. Who knows what the truth is? A person can be a lot of things all at once. If all is fair, did the prosecution do a good enough job character assassinating the defendant’s personality in return? Possibly not.
C4 did though.

ldontWanna · 28/03/2022 21:52

@BrokenNHS

BronwenFrideswide

I really don't understand what point you are trying to make here, of course the family of Yousef can't pay for lawyers for the simple reason the State prosecutes crimes, are you suggesting that individuals should be able to fund criminal prosecutions? Where the hell do you think that would lead?

The State/Prosecution is the voice of the family.

We all know that the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) prosecutes!
They are indeed meant to be the voice of the family but in this case they obviously didn’t do a good enough job. Did Yousef’s family get to choose the prosecution team? No, of course not.
His character was destroyed by the (obviously) stronger defence team the accused paid God knows how much for. He was made out to be person he wasn’t.
The victim’s family get given their team. The defendant should also have their team chosen for them.

Was the character "assassination " , some would say context, completely made up then?
BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 21:48

Voice of the family AND, more importantly, voice of the victim.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 21:47

BronwenFrideswide

I really don't understand what point you are trying to make here, of course the family of Yousef can't pay for lawyers for the simple reason the State prosecutes crimes, are you suggesting that individuals should be able to fund criminal prosecutions? Where the hell do you think that would lead?

The State/Prosecution is the voice of the family.

We all know that the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) prosecutes!
They are indeed meant to be the voice of the family but in this case they obviously didn’t do a good enough job. Did Yousef’s family get to choose the prosecution team? No, of course not.
His character was destroyed by the (obviously) stronger defence team the accused paid God knows how much for. He was made out to be person he wasn’t.
The victim’s family get given their team. The defendant should also have their team chosen for them.

PebbleMillAtOne · 28/03/2022 21:42

It’s up to the prosecutors to show the defendants guilt. Same as it’s up to the police to prove your guilt, which is No Comment I’d used so much . Innocent until PROVEN guilty

ldontWanna · 28/03/2022 21:36

@EmeraldShamrock1

That teenager will kill again.
How can you say that with such conviction? Based on what?

Don't get me wrong, I believe he should've been done at least for manslaughter,if not murder, and I still don't fully get how he wasn't.

Nothing I've read or seen though points to premeditation, maliciousness or any ill intent until things went fatally wrong.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 28/03/2022 21:22

@BrokenNHS

What do you mean by your last sentence? The prosecution team is appointed by the CPS and nothing to do with the victims family.

His family are on the side of the prosecution. Do you think that they were able to pay for the ‘best’ lawyers in the land to stop their son’s character from being destroyed by the prosecution? No, the only thing they could do was rely on the CPS to prosecute the defendants. They had no voice.

Yes that was what I said
Lockheart · 28/03/2022 21:05

@BrokenNHS Even in cases where the evidence against defendant is damning (i.e. the evidence clearly proves they have committed the crime), some defence lawyers will do everything they can to minimise the crime for their client. If this involves twisting the facts - if they have to exaggerate or paint the victim in a bad light, they will do so.

It’s still a game, just a different one - yes, their client is clearly guilty but their aim becomes a different one: to get a light sentence.

Their aim is not to get their client a light sentence. That's a perverted but sadly common view of what defence barristers do.

Their job is to make sure that any conviction passed is sound and the sentence appropriate. To do this you need to test the prosecution in every way possible.

The onus of proof is always on the prosecution (usually the Crown / State). The defence must make sure the Crown / State's case is watertight and that the sentence is in line with the severity of the crime.

A poor defence which does NOT do this risks the defendant being able to successfully bring appeals in future.

Better to have a rock-solid case which stands up to every single ounce of scrutiny the defence team can muster than a lazy defence barrister who doesn't bother to test the prosecution properly.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/03/2022 20:58

That teenager will kill again.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/03/2022 20:57

I was shocked they couldn't have good character witnesses in court.

Blackberrycream · 28/03/2022 20:56

@BronwenFrideswide

I think that the legal team that loses should be punished in some way too, especially in particularly bad cases where the accused is clearly guilty

How do you know the accused is clearly guilty? What special powers do you have that escapes the Prosecution when they couldn't manage to convince 12 random members of the public on the Jury of this obvious guilt?

Are you familiar with the case?
Blackberrycream · 28/03/2022 20:55

@BrokenNHS

Take 2:

His family are on the side of the prosecution. Do you think that they were able to pay for the ‘best’ lawyers in the land to stop their son’s character from being destroyed by the DEFENCE? No, the only thing they could do was rely on the CPS to prosecute the defendants. They had no voice.

Absolutely I think most understand the legal system and why it operates as it does. That doesn’t mean that certain cases should not cause concern. Miscarriages of justice happen. It’s really not ok to glibly brush away what happened to this boy and later to his family as they had to listen to the portrayal of their son, the victim, in court. The silence did speak volumes. Events involving the defendent since speak volumes. The fact that his first response was to try and blame randoms from Hume and Moss Side speak volumes. When that failed, they painted a scholarship boy as an inner city thug. The suggestion of the Op clearly is not ok, but her outrage is understandable. It would be good to see a little more outrage about this case.
BronwenFrideswide · 28/03/2022 20:53

I think that the legal team that loses should be punished in some way too, especially in particularly bad cases where the accused is clearly guilty

How do you know the accused is clearly guilty? What special powers do you have that escapes the Prosecution when they couldn't manage to convince 12 random members of the public on the Jury of this obvious guilt?

ldontWanna · 28/03/2022 20:51

@BrokenNHS

Always better to have an overzealous defense attorney trying to get a guilty person off, than an uninterested defense attorney who does not like the defendant just phoning it in.

There is no doubt - defendants need defending.

However, the fact that some people have the means to hire top lawyers and others don’t make the whole system unfair.

True which is what makes some of the suggestions on these threads even more bonkers and make it even more unfair.
Thelnebriati · 28/03/2022 20:46

I think that the legal team that loses should be punished in some way too, especially in particularly bad cases where the accused is clearly guilty.

There are people who believe that if a rape victim fails to gain a guilty verdict she should be prosecuted for making a false allegation. These kinds of attitude have nothing to do with justice, and I agree with the poster that said some people shouldn't be on a jury. They're probably part of the reason we have 12 jurors.

BronwenFrideswide · 28/03/2022 20:45

@BrokenNHS

Take 2:

His family are on the side of the prosecution. Do you think that they were able to pay for the ‘best’ lawyers in the land to stop their son’s character from being destroyed by the DEFENCE? No, the only thing they could do was rely on the CPS to prosecute the defendants. They had no voice.

I really don't understand what point you are trying to make here, of course the family of Yousef can't pay for lawyers for the simple reason the State prosecutes crimes, are you suggesting that individuals should be able to fund criminal prosecutions? Where the hell do you think that would lead?

The State/Prosecution is the voice of the family.

BigupPemberleyMassive · 28/03/2022 20:07

Op, some people giggle/laugh/smile when under stress.

It would be reported as 'when asked if they killed him, the defendant laughed'

In the USA they can plead the fifth amendment, which is the right not to incriminate oneself.

In the UK, they can remain silent, but as pp have said, an 'adverse inference ' can be taken from silence.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 20:01

Always better to have an overzealous defense attorney trying to get a guilty person off, than an uninterested defense attorney who does not like the defendant just phoning it in.

There is no doubt - defendants need defending.

However, the fact that some people have the means to hire top lawyers and others don’t make the whole system unfair.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 19:59

Take 2:

His family are on the side of the prosecution. Do you think that they were able to pay for the ‘best’ lawyers in the land to stop their son’s character from being destroyed by the DEFENCE? No, the only thing they could do was rely on the CPS to prosecute the defendants. They had no voice.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 19:57

What do you mean by your last sentence? The prosecution team is appointed by the CPS and nothing to do with the victims family.

His family are on the side of the prosecution. Do you think that they were able to pay for the ‘best’ lawyers in the land to stop their son’s character from being destroyed by the prosecution? No, the only thing they could do was rely on the CPS to prosecute the defendants. They had no voice.

samyeagar · 28/03/2022 19:57

No system is perfect because there are humans involved, but as distasteful as it might be to some, especially those outside the legal system, being adversarial, win at all costs, is one of the aspects that allows for a defendant to receive quality representation. It helps minimize biases on the defense side, in fact, ineffective assistance of counsel is grounds for appeal of a conviction.

Always better to have an overzealous defense attorney trying to get a guilty person off, than an uninterested defense attorney who does not like the defendant just phoning it in.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 28/03/2022 19:34

@BrokenNHS

Nicholethejewellery

I understand what you are saying.

I agree it is win/lose game for the prosecution/defence lawyers. They are getting paid to win the case for their side. Some will stop at nothing to get the result their client wants.

Even in cases where the evidence against defendant is damning (i.e. the evidence clearly proves they have committed the crime), some defence lawyers will do everything they can to minimise the crime for their client. If this involves twisting the facts - if they have to exaggerate or paint the victim in a bad light, they will do so.

It’s still a game, just a different one - yes, their client is clearly guilty but their aim becomes a different one: to get a light sentence.

Everyone has the right to be defended. There is no question about that but what tactics are lawyers using to get the result they want?
In this tragic case, Yousef’s character was destroyed by the defence team. Joshua Molnar’s family had the money to hire a top lawyer, PR team and bodyguards for their son who did the job for their client.
Yousef’s family were not able to match this level for the prosecution side.

What do you mean by your last sentence? The prosecution team is appointed by the CPS and nothing to do with the victims family.

The rest of your post just describes the justice system - you can focus on the defence teams actions in this instance but the onus is, as always, for the prosecution to present enough evidence for the jury to have no doubt in their minds about guilt, and in other cases to mitigate the guilt.