Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?

210 replies

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:26

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4).
One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

OP posts:
PurpleTrilby · 28/03/2022 23:31

Fuck me, I didn't really need more examples of why the jury system is an outdated load of shit, but here's loads of people proving just that. Well done everyone who wants summary extrajudicial killings due to arbitrary rules. Are you fans of Priti Patel?

Blackberrycream · 28/03/2022 23:23

@BronwenFrideswide
The attack he is implicated in is mentioned widely in the press and in the police review also. It’s important as the events following on from this event suggest premeditation and motive.

The defence are not at fault but the prosecution absolutely are.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 23:17

@Blackberrycream

And actually cases are affected by ‘likability ‘. It is very naive to think that rich, well connected boys from Hale are not seen in a more empathetic light than those involved in inner city knife crime.
THIS!! Exactly what I meant in my last post…
BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 23:16

On not in!
Will catch up tomorrow. Interesting thread OP.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 23:15

ldontWanna
I agree with everything you say in your last post. The loss of life is so utterly pointless.

Blackberry
It really does stink.

In a final note (tonight at least) One of the things that irritated me the most about the C4 documentary was the comment made by someone from the investigating team about the defendant. Privately educated, from a ’good’ middle class family.
What makes his family ‘good’?

Blackberrycream · 28/03/2022 23:11

And actually cases are affected by ‘likability ‘. It is very naive to think that rich, well connected boys from Hale are not seen in a more empathetic light than those involved in inner city knife crime.

BronwenFrideswide · 28/03/2022 23:05

[quote Blackberrycream]@BronwenFrideswide
The truth may lie between…This isn’t some kind of character competition/ comparison though. Molnar plunged a knife into Yousef’ s heart. Yousef was the victim.He was not on trial.
The actual known and proven facts show Molnar to have a history of carrying knives and a previous incident of a threat with a knife. He made videos of himself carrying out pretend knife attacks. He is implicated in much more. There were several incidents leading up to this attack and an internal police review was held that identified failings in the investigation in that they failed to make the connections between these incidents. They also failed to search Molnar’s home until a few days later. The clothing had been washed and his room cleaned by then. His dna was on the knife. The so called knife he claimed he thought Yousef had was never found. Funny that. The case stinks.[/quote]
So a shoddy investigation then? How is that the fault of the defence and the expensive lawyers who defended their client on the basis of the evidence against him?

Implicated in much more is just that implicated not proof.

Blackberrycream · 28/03/2022 23:00

@BronwenFrideswide
The truth may lie between…This isn’t some kind of character competition/ comparison though. Molnar plunged a knife into Yousef’ s heart. Yousef was the victim.He was not on trial.
The actual known and proven facts show Molnar to have a history of carrying knives and a previous incident of a threat with a knife. He made videos of himself carrying out pretend knife attacks. He is implicated in much more. There were several incidents leading up to this attack and an internal police review was held that identified failings in the investigation in that they failed to make the connections between these incidents. They also failed to search Molnar’s home until a few days later. The clothing had been washed and his room cleaned by then. His dna was on the knife. The so called knife he claimed he thought Yousef had was never found. Funny that. The case stinks.

BronwenFrideswide · 28/03/2022 22:55

@BrokenNHS

Bronwen: You are saying the Jury only took into account the Defence argument regarding the character they portrayed, they based their decision entirely on this totally which is a ridiculous assumption.

I don’t think that at all.
Your assume too much!

Well what are you saying, because your posts about the ever so expensive defence and their character assassination seem to be saying that is what swayed the Jury to find the defendants not guilty of murder or manslaughter?

Or are you saying the defence had no right to pursue that path even though they were arguing it was a case of self defence?

As for the Channel 4 programme, they told the side of the story they wanted to tell, did they give chapter and verse of every bit of evidence in the court case or just pick out the bits that suited their agenda?

On the evidence and arguments presented by both sides the Jury did not believe the case met the high bar for murder or manslaughter, if you had seen all the evidence they had and heard all the arguments they heard you may well have come to the same conclusion. Cases are not judged (or shouldn't be) on whether or not the defendants or victim are likeable, they are judged on the facts and arguments presented.

ldontWanna · 28/03/2022 22:46

@BrokenNHS

ldontWanna I don’t think that the C4 documentary glossed over the victim’s behaviour. I guess the real injustice is that Yousef isn’t here to tell his side of the story. The two accused were proved to be lying far too many times so it’s difficult to believe anything they say.
Don't get me wrong. I struggle with the verdict and whatever measly sentencing they received. There's nothing positive about their hidden lifestyle, and tbh it's very worrying that bright teens with good futures and lives felt drawn to that lifestyle and thought acting and behaving like that was cool. How stupid and fucked up is that. Now their friend is dead. One of them murdered him no matter what the verdict said and has to live with that. They both have a record ,have been named ,everyone knows who they are and what they did. As pathetic as the sentencing was ,he did go to jail. And for what? For likes , and street cred and blud ? Ffs...
BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:45

There might be a plea bargain before the trial and some negotiations, for example the defendant pleads guilty of manslaughter instead of having a trial for murder. Or CPS decides that all they can prove is manslaughter rather than murder so that's what the charge is.

I think that’s the point. A good (expensive in this case) defence lawyer will often bargain and negotiate.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:42

ldontWanna

The way in which real evidence is presented to the jury is crucial.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:40

ldontWanna
I don’t think that the C4 documentary glossed over the victim’s behaviour.
I guess the real injustice is that Yousef isn’t here to tell his side of the story.
The two accused were proved to be lying far too many times so it’s difficult to believe anything they say.

ldontWanna · 28/03/2022 22:39

@Hoplesscynic

So if a client has committed murder but the defence can spin it as manslaughter (e.g the evidence or lack there of allows for that), the defence wouldn't? Because they have to act with honesty and integrity? Yeah, right.
The defence don't spin anything at the trial. If CPS go for murder instead of manslaughter and they can't prove murder with all the legal requirements,the defendant walks free. It doesn't suddenly change to manslaughter in the middle of the trial.

There might be a plea bargain before the trial and some negotiations, for example the defendant pleads guilty of manslaughter instead of having a trial for murder. Or CPS decides that all they can prove is manslaughter rather than murder so that's what the charge is.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:36

ldontWanna

True.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:33

Bronwen

Of course that was the aim of C4.
We heard plenty about the ‘poor misunderstood’ accused 1&2 in court reports and press.
I’m glad C4 told the other side of the story.

ldontWanna · 28/03/2022 22:32

@BrokenNHS

Was the character "assassination " , some would say context, completely made up then?

I doubt very much it was completely made up. Who knows what the truth is? A person can be a lot of things all at once. If all is fair, did the prosecution do a good enough job character assassinating the defendant’s personality in return? Possibly not.
C4 did though.

The thing is ,they probably couldn't find anything factual that was worse than what the defence presented. Don't forget that the defence didn't say only Yousef was into drugs,knives , stupid videos or that the "plot" was just his idea or that he coerced the other two into it.

Of course it sounds like shoddy tactics and character assassination when it's about the victim, particularly a very intelligent,scholarship winning,grammar going young man.

Do you really believe that if they found anything worse that wouldn't come out as part of the trial they wouldn't have used it?

The trouble is one young boy was the victim, so his actions are character assassinations. The other two are the criminals/perpetrators , so we expect the worst from them and their actions (not including the killing) just aren't bad enough or the prosecution didn't try hard enough.

Lockheart · 28/03/2022 22:31

@Hoplesscynic

So if a client has committed murder but the defence can spin it as manslaughter (e.g the evidence or lack there of allows for that), the defence wouldn't? Because they have to act with honesty and integrity? Yeah, right.
The defence barristers job would be to make the prosecution prove that the threshold was met for a murder conviction. They would not "spin it" as manslaughter, they would make the prosecution prove it was murder.

Remember, the defence barrister's duty is first and foremost to the court, not to their client.

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:29

@Hoplesscynic

So if a client has committed murder but the defence can spin it as manslaughter (e.g the evidence or lack there of allows for that), the defence wouldn't? Because they have to act with honesty and integrity? Yeah, right.
Exactly.
BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:28

You

BrokenNHS · 28/03/2022 22:28

Bronwen: You are saying the Jury only took into account the Defence argument regarding the character they portrayed, they based their decision entirely on this totally which is a ridiculous assumption.

I don’t think that at all.
Your assume too much!

Hoplesscynic · 28/03/2022 22:27

So if a client has committed murder but the defence can spin it as manslaughter (e.g the evidence or lack there of allows for that), the defence wouldn't? Because they have to act with honesty and integrity? Yeah, right.

BronwenFrideswide · 28/03/2022 22:26

@BrokenNHS

Was the character "assassination " , some would say context, completely made up then?

I doubt very much it was completely made up. Who knows what the truth is? A person can be a lot of things all at once. If all is fair, did the prosecution do a good enough job character assassinating the defendant’s personality in return? Possibly not.
C4 did though.

And you don't think Channel 4 had an agenda to do just that?

Do you not think the truth lies somewhere in the middle of both those character assassinations?

BronwenFrideswide · 28/03/2022 22:21

His character was destroyed by the (obviously) stronger defence team the accused paid God knows how much for. He was made out to be person he wasn’t.

I assume you are talking about the victim when you say he was made out to be a person he wasn't, how can you be absolutely sure of that?

So far we've had:

The case was lost because one of the defendants wasn't forced to take the stand in their own defence.

The case was lost because the defence made the victim out to be something he was not.

You are saying the Jury only took into account the Defence argument regarding the character they portrayed, they based their decision entirely on this totally which is a ridiculous assumption. Immediately before the Jury retires to consider their verdict the Judge sums up the case, goes over the facts of the case and tells the Jury, about the relevant law. The Judge also gives advice to the Jury. Are you saying the Judge was blinded by the expensive defence team too?

Some defendants do have their team chosen for them and paid for by the tax payer, in my opinion defendants should have the best possible team for their defence, whatever you personally may think of or about the people in the dock they are entitled to have a robust defence as they are presumed innocent until they are proven guilty to do anything else reverses that assumption and take us down a very slippery slope that ends with kangaroo courts and no justice at all.

Lockheart · 28/03/2022 22:19

@Hoplesscynic

"That's a perverted but sadly common view of what defence barristers do."

Are you for real? Of course the defense lawyer's job is to get the lightest sentence, they are there to work in the best interests of their clients.

Yes, I am for real. Their job is not to get the lightest sentence possible or to get all charges dropped. Their job is to make sure the prosecution is sound (i.e. the conviction is just and inarguable) and appropriate (i.e. they're not being convicted of or sentenced for murder when they're only provably guilty of theft).