Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think defendents should not have right to remain silent in court?

210 replies

Curly3456 · 26/03/2022 11:26

I have just finished watching "Killed by a rich kid" (documentary on Channel 4).
One of the boys accused of killing Yousef chose not to be questioned in court.

The two boys charged with Yousef's murder were found not guilty. Yousef's family were left feeling justice had not been done.

I can't help feeling that people accused of a crime shouldn't be able to opt out of being questioned in court?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SeasonFinale · 31/03/2022 20:10

The main reason is that the prosecution have to provide evidence that the dependent committed the crime beyond reasonable doubt and it is not for the dependent to assist them if they are pleading not guilty.

BasiliskStare · 31/03/2022 20:06

I think you have to somewhat trust barristers whose whole job is to take on a case to decide whether their client may alienate a jury for whatever reason if they speak or cross examined. & yes innocent until proven guilty. Better that ( as above Blackstones ratio) 10 guilty people go free that one innocent man is convicted.

OK I sound a bit wishy washy but there you go

LabMix · 29/03/2022 23:51

@Curly3456

You can't force someone to speak, but refusal to answer questions could be an offence itself with possible legal consequences.
Don’t be so ridiculous
Blackberrycream · 29/03/2022 23:40

Well I think there was certainly an appeal to jury bias.
Also as @BrokenNHS says, the investigation and I would add the prosecution of the case show bias. I think most here understand quite well how the judicial system works. That doesn’t mean people can’t feel anger at the way this particular case was handled. I actually think it’s worrying that some so glibly dismiss concerns.
I suppose if these issues will never affect you personally it is easy to look away. For working class city youth it appears you can be knifed to death on the street and still be painted as a ‘threat’. I wonder who actually did feel threatened. It would be laughable it if wasn’t so offensive.

Verysadatwork · 29/03/2022 23:25

I suspect the OP has never been falsely accused.
When it happens to you it’s very different, especially if the accuser is your abuser.

LardyDee · 29/03/2022 22:45

But in this hypothetical the prosecution has proven that the defendant is lying.

BronwenFrideswide · 29/03/2022 22:43

@LardyDee

The defendant may be lying. The prosecution may well prove they are lying - the defence team stick to the story, regardless.

In which case the jury will convict.

I think the posters are arguing that the defendant must take the stand so the Prosecution can cross examine, catch them out and prove the lie that way, but as we keep pointing out the defendant does not have to prove anything.
LardyDee · 29/03/2022 22:32

The defendant may be lying. The prosecution may well prove they are lying - the defence team stick to the story, regardless.

In which case the jury will convict.

BrokenNHS · 29/03/2022 20:55

@Lockheart

I think quite a few posters might benefit from watching this:

It's 12 mins long but it explains the core principles and how they interact, and what barristers can or should do or not do if the client admits they are guilty.

Yes, they can claim that their client (despite admitting killing the victim) acted in self defence. This may or may not be actually true. The defendant may be lying. The prosecution may well prove they are lying - the defence team stick to the story, regardless.
SolasAnla · 29/03/2022 20:45

[quote Blackberrycream]@SolasAnia
That is quite a jump in logic you made there.
I was stating that there is inequality in the treatment of certain groups/communities in the justice system. It’s really not that controversial a statement. Some cases in particular bring this to the fore. I believe this is one of them. It needs review.[/quote]
The whole thread is about removing parts of the justice system.

Its a jury who sits and listens to the evidence.

The duty of the 12 citizens is to listen to evidence and leave their personal bias (in so far as humanly possible) at the door.
This thread proves that basic civics lessons on the how the system works should be part of the ongoing educational process.
Likeability is an apeal to jury bias. Even with professional jury's or relying on the Judge decision wont eliminate that risk.

BrokenNHS · 29/03/2022 20:44

Blackberry

I was stating that there is inequality in the treatment of certain groups/communities in the justice system. It’s really not that controversial a statement. Some cases in particular bring this to the fore. I believe this is one of them. It needs review.

I agree. The detectives interview in this documentary constantly talked about the boy's 'young' age, 'good', middle class background, school, academic ability. They didn't even search their houses immediately.

Young people from less affluent areas (not too far from Hale Barns) are, without a doubt, viewed and treated differently.

BasiliskStare · 29/03/2022 19:59

Not sure if mentioned and quite old is Blackstones ratio

Blackberrycream · 29/03/2022 18:07

@SolasAnia
That is quite a jump in logic you made there.
I was stating that there is inequality in the treatment of certain groups/communities in the justice system. It’s really not that controversial a statement. Some cases in particular bring this to the fore. I believe this is one of them. It needs review.

SolasAnla · 29/03/2022 11:58

@Blackberrycream

And actually cases are affected by ‘likability ‘. It is very naive to think that rich, well connected boys from Hale are not seen in a more empathetic light than those involved in inner city knife crime.
So to solve that remove the jury who are the ones making the decision to like the boy from posh area more that the not posh at all area?

No prosecution
No defence
No jury
😶

thepastisanothercountry · 29/03/2022 11:46

@Viviennemary

I agree. If they refuse to speak then it should be an automatic guilty verdict by default.
I disagree completely.

What you are saying here is that if someone refuses to speak all other evidence should be considered beyond reasonable doubt. There are loads of reasons many mentioned by PPs why someone may not want to speak.

Supposing for example something another witness says undermines the prosecution case or the complainants evidence is inconsistent or there is doubt cast on DNA or forensic evidence...

Silence does not necessarily correspond to guilt.

Lockheart · 29/03/2022 11:23

I think quite a few posters might benefit from watching this:

It's 12 mins long but it explains the core principles and how they interact, and what barristers can or should do or not do if the client admits they are guilty.

BronwenFrideswide · 29/03/2022 11:15

[quote Blackberrycream]@BronwenFrideswide
The attack he is implicated in is mentioned widely in the press and in the police review also. It’s important as the events following on from this event suggest premeditation and motive.

The defence are not at fault but the prosecution absolutely are.[/quote]
The shoddy investigation seems at the heart of this, the Prosecution can only prosecute on the evidence supplied by the investigating team.

BronwenFrideswide · 29/03/2022 11:12

@Blackberrycream

And actually cases are affected by ‘likability ‘. It is very naive to think that rich, well connected boys from Hale are not seen in a more empathetic light than those involved in inner city knife crime.
That is why I used the words should not be, yes it happens and no it shouldn't which is why the Judge directs the Jury to find on the facts of the case and the Law.
Jonny1265 · 29/03/2022 01:16

[quote LardyDee]@Jonny1265

The duties are not contradictory. You just don't understand them!

Nothing you have cited (and indeed, nothing) requires the barrister to reveal anything to the court without the client's consent. Withholding confidential information is fine. Misleading the court is not.[/quote]
I do understand them and the whether they are contradictory is open to interpretation. The entire notion of an adversarial system ensures that their is a winner and loser and the truth gets lost in that process.

LardyDee · 29/03/2022 00:55

@Jonny1265

The duties are not contradictory. You just don't understand them!

Nothing you have cited (and indeed, nothing) requires the barrister to reveal anything to the court without the client's consent. Withholding confidential information is fine. Misleading the court is not.

Jonny1265 · 29/03/2022 00:41

[quote LardyDee]@Jonny1265
This is bullshit and you know it. If a client disclosed they are guilty, then according to the above, you should state that in court

What are you talking about? Did you even read the principles in @NeverDropYourMooncup's post? In particular:

To keep the affairs of each client confidential

This means that barristers are not allowed to talk to other people about what you tell them without your consent.[/quote]
Yes but I also read
To observe their duty to the court in the administration of justice.

They;

must not mislead a court or a judge or waste a court’s time and may need to make sure the court has all the relevant information it needs
must not abuse their role as an advocate; and
they must ensure that their ability to act independently is not compromised.
To act with honesty, and with integrity

The duty to act with honesty and with integrity includes not misleading or lying to anyone, not encouraging other people to mislead or be untruthful, and only accepting money and fees that they are legally allowed to. Barristers should also show integrity by upholding the professional standards expected of them.

These core duties are contradictory and the legal system is built upon getting your client off and not seeking the truth.

LardyDee · 29/03/2022 00:03

@Jonny1265
This is bullshit and you know it. If a client disclosed they are guilty, then according to the above, you should state that in court

What are you talking about? Did you even read the principles in @NeverDropYourMooncup's post? In particular:

To keep the affairs of each client confidential

This means that barristers are not allowed to talk to other people about what you tell them without your consent.

LoveFall · 28/03/2022 23:58

If your client is testifying and you KNOW they are lying, really your only option is to immediately step aside and no longer represent the client, even in the middle of court.

You must do that without saying why and certainly without pointing to your client and saying he or she is lying.

A judge will always accept your withdrawal.

LoveFall · 28/03/2022 23:51

If a client tells you they are guilty it is absolutely not a lawyer's duty to tell the court.

Exactly the opposite.

But, then you cannot put your client on the witness stand and have them testify under oath that the are innocent,

Jonny1265 · 28/03/2022 23:33

@NeverDropYourMooncup

Fuck's Sake.

A Barrister's Core Duties:

To observe their duty to the court in the administration of justice.

They;

must not mislead a court or a judge or waste a court’s time and may need to make sure the court has all the relevant information it needs
must not abuse their role as an advocate; and
they must ensure that their ability to act independently is not compromised.

To act in the best interests of each client

A barrister who is working for you must always think about what is best for you and do their job in a way that reflects that. This does not mean that a barrister can lie on your behalf, or that they must do everything you tell them. Their duty to the court comes above even their duty to you as their client and barristers must act with independence, honesty and integrity. This means, for example, that they cannot do anything for you that would go against their duty to the court.

To act with honesty, and with integrity

The duty to act with honesty and with integrity includes not misleading or lying to anyone, not encouraging other people to mislead or be untruthful, and only accepting money and fees that they are legally allowed to. Barristers should also show integrity by upholding the professional standards expected of them.

To maintain their independence

To make sure barristers maintain their independence, they are not allowed to offer, promise or give gifts or referral fees to any client (or intermediary such as a solicitor), or to accept any money from a client or intermediary unless it is as payment for their professional work. They cannot work for you if there is, or they think there might be, a conflict of interest for them in doing so.

Not to behave in a way that is likely to diminish the trust and confidence which the public places in them or the barrister profession

Things that would be likely to diminish trust and confidence in the profession could include committing a crime, being dishonest, harassing others, offensive conduct towards other people, or abuse of their position as a barrister.

To keep the affairs of each client confidential

This means that barristers are not allowed to talk to other people about what you tell them without your consent.

To provide a competent standard of work and service to each client

A competent standard of work and service includes promoting a client's best interests, treating clients with courtesy and consideration, advising a client in terms that they can understand, avoiding unnecessary costs for a client, and reading a client's instructions promptly.

Not to discriminate unlawfully against any person

Barristers must not treat anyone less favourably or harass them or victimise them because of their race, colour, ethnicity or nationality, citizenship, sex, gender reassignment, sexual orientation, relationship status, disability, age, religion, belief or pregnancy/maternity.

To be open and cooperative with regulators

This means that barristers have to do what is asked of them by us or the Legal Ombudsman and provide the Bar Standards Board with information they need about them.

To take reasonable steps to manage their practice...

... or carry out their role within their practice, competently and in such a way as to achieve compliance with their legal and regulatory obligations

This means that a barrister must run their practice in a way that follows the rules in the BSB Handbook.

Just because people don't like the verdicts, that doesn't mean the barrister is doing something wrong - that means they're doing something right.

This is bullshit and you know it. If a client disclosed they are guilty, then according to the above, you should state that in court. This clearly isn't the case and the duty to the client is above that to the court. This is why there is so much injustice in the system.
Swipe left for the next trending thread