Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate doing minutes of a meeting

141 replies

CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 10:55

Last week, due to the absence of a person who usually does the minutes, I was asked two minutes for before a meeting started to do minutes.

I hate doing minutes. I can't keep an accurate record of a meeting and participate in it at the same time. People also talk too quickly for me to take notes of all that was said. The end result is that I always end up with scores of complaints any time I have taken minutes. It also takes me a really long time to write them up afterwards and if things are busy with my main responsibilities people keep pestering me for them when I really have no time to write it all out and share them.

These days I make sure that minutes are not part of my job repsonsibilities anymore and I refuse to even consider a job where that is a requirement.

I told the person who asked that I am no good at doing minutes, that I never end up with anything useful and that I only jot down a few things for myself. Despite my telling him this, he came back later and asked me what I got. I got all of two lines of the two hours meeting. I hope his own notes were more useful, but I never agreed to do them.

So was I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
CruCru · 26/03/2022 11:39

@HalfShrunkMoreToGo

I don't love doing them but they're not hard.

It's minutes not a transcript, it just needs to capture the talking points and agreed actions so my basic format is

Date:
Time:

Attendees:
Apologies:

Agenda: - copied from calendar invite or take a photo/screen print of the slide deck

Actions and agreements (formatted as a table)

Summary. Action/agreement. Owner. Due date.

Jack hates Jill. Action: Mediation session. Joan. 15th April
Date of dinner. Agreement: next Sunday. Jill. 15th April

The thing is, minute taking is a real skill (and one I took years to learn). You need to understand what is going on and what is required. The chair CANNOT take the minutes (it’s amazing how often it’s assumed they will) nor can the person doing all the technical presenting. It’s outrageous to ask someone to do them two minutes before the meeting starts.

I like HalfShrunk’s format. I can’t bear minutes that are a wall of text. They also shouldn’t be too long - I do them in landscape but that largely depends on your organisation (some have a specific format for minutes).

Minutes should be provided within two business days of the meeting - otherwise they’re pointless make-work.

Can you address that as one of only two women in the department, you were asked to do minutes with only two minutes’ notice? That isn’t cool and is a habit that needs breaking.

SnowyPetals · 26/03/2022 11:33

The rule of thumb where I work is that, in the absence of a minute taker whose sole job that is, whoever is otherwise least involved in the meeting takes the minutes. If that was you in this case, then fair enough, but if not, he should have asked that person instead.

CounsellorTroi · 26/03/2022 11:32

God I hated this. One of my duties was to organise team meetings (30 people). I’d get the dates in well in advance then as diaries filled up other things would take priority and people dropped out I would get flak for arranging such an inconvenient date. Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursday mornings were out for business/operational reasons, A few people didn’t work Fridays or worked from home (this was pre zoom). Mondays were weekly catch up days. I also had to find a guest speaker (someone from another team to talk about their work) which people were not that keen to do, and get someone to cover our phones while we were in the meeting (again people weren’t keen). And we had a rotating chair system so that people could get used to chairing in a “safe environment” (everyone was supposed to take a turn) and again people weren’t keen, or at the last minute said they couldn’t’ attend the meeting as they were interviewing or sifting or something. And I had to take the minutes. It was an absolute nightmare. Thank god I retired.

cremeeggsonboxingday · 26/03/2022 11:31

I HATE minutes with a passion, but unfortunately I never seem to be able to get a job that doesn't require doing them. I'm currently going through an ADHD diagnosis so am hoping I'll be able to get some sort of reasonable adjustment for them, even if just using a dictaphone (we don't seem to be allowed to record for some reason). Meetings make me so anxious

CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 11:31

@Hercisback

I'd argue if there was only 2 lines in a 2 hour meeting then was it worth your time being there?

If you were asked because you're a woman that puts a whole different spin on things.

It definitely wasn't worth my time. The project has been running for months. My boss insists I sit in on these meeting. They take up the whole morning every two weeks. It drives me batty. Why have meetings for the sakle of having meetings?
OP posts:
CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 11:29

@chatw0o0

I used to be a PA, and one my roles was very heavily minute taking focused (they didn't tell me that at the interview!). It was all clinical/medical stuff as well... I used to churn them out, several meetings a week, but still hated it. However, it made me pretty good at noting the salient points, even though I didn't always understand them!

Would be pretty annoyed to be dropped in it at the last minute though. It's not something that can be picked up just by being flung into it (people like to think minute taking is easy "anyone can do it - just note the key points" but a specialised skill at the same time (ie, they don't want to do it)). Plus, yes, it always seems to be women who are "volunteered" Shock

That's exactly how I feel. If it were that easy this guy would be doing them himself and not ask anyone else. My role is purely technical. He knows that. That's where my expertise lies. I am a problem solver. I really hated the whole situation.
OP posts:
lookforthesun · 26/03/2022 11:28

If you’re one of only two women it sounds like he asked you because you’re female.

Well done not doing it.

Jerabilis · 26/03/2022 11:26

I always focus on what actions were agreed rather than minutiae of discussion. I actually quite like taking minutes as you can massage the message a bit to focus on what you think is important and also make sure actions you want others to take are set out in the way you want them.

0penALLTours · 26/03/2022 11:26

Record the meeting
Upload for everyone to view

Hercisback · 26/03/2022 11:25

I'd argue if there was only 2 lines in a 2 hour meeting then was it worth your time being there?

If you were asked because you're a woman that puts a whole different spin on things.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 26/03/2022 11:25

I take minutes as a part of my role, it's technical based and half the time I have no idea what they're talking about, but it must work as I'm now minute taker for lots of meetings 😂

Did you actually say outright I won't be taking minutes as I'm not good at them, or just I'm not good. Because if it's the latter it sounds as though you're agreeing to but warning they won't be verbatim.

CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 11:24

@JudgeRindersMinder

I was banned from minute taking in a previous job because ai wrote them up with a heavily sarcastic tone Grin
I like that, but I think next time I'll just give them a clear no. I think I have been unreasonable because I did not outright refuse as I should have done.
OP posts:
Thatswhyimacat · 26/03/2022 11:24

And don't even get me started on my current role where I am supposed to both chair my meetings and take the minutes...

Fuckitsstillraining · 26/03/2022 11:23

Not your job, you didn't agree to do it and if he wanted minuted he should have done them himself, you were asked because your female, he probably wanted you to bring him coffee while you're there too. Don't back down, tell him a straight no if asked again, offer to send him the template a pp suggested.

Littlelottielulu · 26/03/2022 11:23

I'm a senior secretary and looooathe minute taking but they certainly aren't 'hard'. Like a PP said, you don't write them up word for word, you just pick out the key points such as ' NP gave presentation (attached) and discussion followed. Outcome was decided that......

I also record them so anyone who didn't attend the meeting can view it, and I can remind myself of any bits I missed.

chatw0o0 · 26/03/2022 11:23

I used to be a PA, and one my roles was very heavily minute taking focused (they didn't tell me that at the interview!). It was all clinical/medical stuff as well... I used to churn them out, several meetings a week, but still hated it. However, it made me pretty good at noting the salient points, even though I didn't always understand them!

Would be pretty annoyed to be dropped in it at the last minute though. It's not something that can be picked up just by being flung into it (people like to think minute taking is easy "anyone can do it - just note the key points" but a specialised skill at the same time (ie, they don't want to do it)). Plus, yes, it always seems to be women who are "volunteered" Shock

Thatswhyimacat · 26/03/2022 11:22

I hate doing it as well. I used to work in an organisation where we had a pretty flat structure of manager - several people of equal seniority managing different remits - several admin staff whose job was to assist and part of that was meeting minutes. However, in meetings where admin staff weren't allowed to attend due to confidentiality issues or noone was available, the manager would ALWAYS ask me, the youngest of the senior staff by some margin, to do the minutes. I would be cheesed off because like you, I felt like I couldn't contribute properly while taking minutes, I wouldn't have minded rotating between us but it was ALWAYS me, and not that I consider admin work or minutes 'beneath' me, but when I pointed out that I was struggling to engage with the meeting and create minutes, nothing changed, and it told me a lot about how I was viewed within my team. Younger woman = assistant, older men = important strategists.

SpikyJugs · 26/03/2022 11:17

@HalfShrunkMoreToGo

I don't love doing them but they're not hard.

It's minutes not a transcript, it just needs to capture the talking points and agreed actions so my basic format is

Date:
Time:

Attendees:
Apologies:

Agenda: - copied from calendar invite or take a photo/screen print of the slide deck

Actions and agreements (formatted as a table)

Summary. Action/agreement. Owner. Due date.

Jack hates Jill. Action: Mediation session. Joan. 15th April
Date of dinner. Agreement: next Sunday. Jill. 15th April

This is ideal.

Yes minutes are a pain in the arse, and I totally sympathise with you OP for being asked to do them last minute. But if ever required to do it again in the future, this format suggested above is perfect.

It sounds like your colleague tried to railroad you into doing the minutes, and even though you said no, they assumed you were doing it. So to avoid that in future - if you're asked, you say no, but then say 'before we proceed can we agree who is taking the minutes as I am unable to do so'. Don't let them carry on with the meeting assuming you're doing it only to find out 2 hours later that you aren't.

MarinoRoyale · 26/03/2022 11:16

Sorry but managing 2 lines in a 2 hour meeting is ridiculous, you honestly can’t remember any of the discussions which took place other than those which directly rebate to your work?!

PollyPutTheKettleOnKettleOn · 26/03/2022 11:16

@Piggy42

Sounds like you were given the job as you’re female…
I agree.

You were definitely not unreasonable and absolutely stand your ground.

MrsDoylesTeacup · 26/03/2022 11:16

Could you use a dictaphone or your phone to record them and type them up later? This is what I used to do when I did them, that way you can still take an active part in the meeting. Inform everyone at the start they’ll be recorded so you can do accurate minutes and you could always turn it off it anything sensitive is being discussed.

HarrietSchulenberg · 26/03/2022 11:15

I used to be a PA and verbatim minute taking was part of my role, but I was not a participant so that was my sole focus.
Very different role now but I often take minutes while participating and sometimes chairing (not verbatim, thank god). I concentrate on recording key discussion points and their outcomes, and stick to the agenda for the framework. I type them rather than handwrite as it's quicker so I only have to spellcheck and tidy up a bit later. It's a bit trickier if you have to record exactly who said what, and verbatim, but it's rare for that level of detail to be needed and if it was, I'd ask for a dedicated minute taker.

JudgeRindersMinder · 26/03/2022 11:13

I was banned from minute taking in a previous job because ai wrote them up with a heavily sarcastic tone Grin

Babysharkdoodoodood · 26/03/2022 11:13

I record on my phone then type up as said in a PP

Piggy42 · 26/03/2022 11:13

Sounds like you were given the job as you’re female…

Swipe left for the next trending thread