Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate doing minutes of a meeting

141 replies

CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 10:55

Last week, due to the absence of a person who usually does the minutes, I was asked two minutes for before a meeting started to do minutes.

I hate doing minutes. I can't keep an accurate record of a meeting and participate in it at the same time. People also talk too quickly for me to take notes of all that was said. The end result is that I always end up with scores of complaints any time I have taken minutes. It also takes me a really long time to write them up afterwards and if things are busy with my main responsibilities people keep pestering me for them when I really have no time to write it all out and share them.

These days I make sure that minutes are not part of my job repsonsibilities anymore and I refuse to even consider a job where that is a requirement.

I told the person who asked that I am no good at doing minutes, that I never end up with anything useful and that I only jot down a few things for myself. Despite my telling him this, he came back later and asked me what I got. I got all of two lines of the two hours meeting. I hope his own notes were more useful, but I never agreed to do them.

So was I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Spongebobfrillypants · 26/03/2022 13:33

Sounds like that old classic - you were asked to take the mins because you're female.
Could you send an email out to all the participants saying - 'Apologies, X has asked me to write up the mins from the meeting on [date] &, as I wasn't aware I was given this role, my notes aren't sufficient. Can you please let me have any salient points that were discussed that should be included in the minutes?'
Next time you attend a meeting, check if someone is there to do the minutes (otherwise it will keep happening) & if not, suggest a rota, with you last because you've done your bit!
There is nothing wrong with being upfront about it - you were put on the spot with no time to prepare & your role is not to take minutes!

RubiesandRose · 26/03/2022 13:21

I used to have a job that was minute taking for all governance meetings on our business, my tips would be:-

Look at a set of minutes that are in the preferred style of the company and adopt the same language, complexity/brevity.

If the meeting has a pack, print it out and use that to take notes on. You can underline statements in the pack and use arrows to it to add comments etc.

Don't record general chat/discussion, just note down any challenges/agreed views. If one person expresses a view and several others then agree using slightly l different language then don't write it all down, It can read for example
"the meeting discussed XYZ, Mr W challenged the proposed decision stating ABC, other attendees were in agreement with this view and it was agreed to defer a decision until further clarification was sought."

As opposed to he said, she said then he said.

Adopt your own shorthand. I used ticks or crosses for positive/negative approvals or views and then captured key statements of words.

If I really missed something or didn't understand I would just put a few ?? by the agenda item and contact the speaker at a later date to clarify my understanding.

I hope this helps and practice really does help, probably not what you want to hear though!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/03/2022 13:14

People also talk too quickly for me to take notes of all that was said

Why are you writing down "all" that was said? In the decades I've spent doing this it usually goes something like:

Agenda item - few words to outline what's being discussed
Suggestions/Input offered (with names if necessary)
Details of decision made

OstrichFeathers · 26/03/2022 13:12

@RockaLock

Oh god, I've just agreed to take on our company CoSec role, and I am dreading having to take minutes!!

Some good tips on this thread, though, thank you to all the PPs.

I'm CoSec for my day job and an off shoot that we established. I'm also very involved operationally in both companies so I use the agenda as my minutes template and add what I will be reporting as bullet points in advance of the meeting. Means I have a cheat sheet for my own report and don't have to worry about missing bits when I tidy up my notes afterwards. Once you find a way that works for you, it's not as daunting but definitely type as you go rather than handwriting and transcribing.

I guess somehow, senior people manage to lose the ability to think or write once they get promoted.
I've worked places where it seemed like that! I used to have a weekly meeting where I'd literally type up the notes as we were walking into the next one, utterly useless. Now they are board meeting minutes so a legal requirement.

Silverclocks · 26/03/2022 13:08

Doesn't that mean "someone" has to sit through the whole meeting again?

Silverclocks · 26/03/2022 13:06

I don't like it either and agree you can't really participate and do minutes.

I take my laptop loaded with the agenda and type notes under each section.

Then after the meeting all you have to do is spellcheck.

emmathedilemma · 26/03/2022 13:00

@CaptSkippy

I am in my forties. I work in tech and I am only 1 of two women in my department.
And this is exactly why you were asked to do them! It's always the woman in a room full of men who picks these things up. Ditto booking the meeting, chasing up people for slides etc for the meeting, making visitors drinks for the meeting etc......
anothernamedoesntsmellsosweet · 26/03/2022 12:59

Can you not just record it on your phone and type it up from that?

okletsdothis · 26/03/2022 12:58

Teams has a transcription tool so if you set it up it will transcribe everything said by everyone and the provide it at the end

Have you ever actually used this though? Maybe it's just the accents (our team is made up of scottish, irish and welsh accents) but the transcription that came out of our last meeting was hilarious, and would have been absolutely no use if you were relying on it for minutes. 'Clear and concise' for example, somehow became 'thieves in the night' Confused

But yes, I hate minute taking with a passion, and dread every meeting.

AllOfUsAreDead · 26/03/2022 12:53

I always find that minutes only seem to be needed for senior people in businesses. Everyone else is expected to take their own notes for what work needs done. I guess somehow, senior people manage to lose the ability to think or write once they get promoted. Explains why so many bad decisions are made.

RockaLock · 26/03/2022 12:53

Oh god, I've just agreed to take on our company CoSec role, and I am dreading having to take minutes!!

Some good tips on this thread, though, thank you to all the PPs.

TeenPlusCat · 26/03/2022 12:52

There is such a difference between:
Action: Jim to look into the options for X
and
Action: Jim to look into the options for X and circulate a proposal by Y date and if no objections to implement by Z date.

TeenPlusCat · 26/03/2022 12:50

I used to quite like taking minutes as it gave me 'power' to ensure that actions were clear.
I never recorded who said what, only final decisions and actions.
For contentious things I might have written 'there was some debate .... but it was agreed ....'
For very contentious things I might have written 'there was some debate, arguments for A were ...., arguments for B were .....and in the end JoeBloggs (chair) decided to go for A'.

NewYearCalavicci · 26/03/2022 12:47

@HalfShrunkMoreToGo, that really useful thank you, I dont often set the meetings up but if I do I will use this Smile

Butterfly44 · 26/03/2022 12:44

In our organisation all meetings are now by zoom - recorded so makes minutes easier.

IncompleteSenten · 26/03/2022 12:37

Why is minute taking still a thing? Surely recording it then taking the points from it is far more sensible and accurate. Plus if there's disagreement later, there's proof.

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/03/2022 12:33

Accurate minute taking is a skill, and I think it’s both unfair and remiss of a manager or project leader to ask it of somebody who doesn’t have that skill / hasn’t had the opportunity to develop the experience.

I’m a company secretary. I love taking minutes and the whole process which follows. I get paid an awful lot of money to do it. It isn’t just taking notes of what happened in the meeting, but I suspect that that view of it is what leads some managers to ask it of people who don’t know how to do it and hate doing it.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 26/03/2022 12:25

@NewYearCalavicci

I have to take minuets too and I hate it , a lot of our meetings are on teams so it is hard to decipher everything if they are all talking at the same time .

Next time first as PP said when you are asked say no as you have too many points to bring up / want a more interactive role etc , then firmly say can we clarify who will be taking the minuets so I can send my points to raise over.

If somehow you still get pushed into it ,
Make sure you know who will be attending and write their full names down, email / talk to everyone first ask them what they will be bringing up and make a note of it and leave space to then fill in the response from others in the meeting .
Then using just their initials fill in who is bringing what up

so as PP said

reason for meeting new product
date/ time 26/02/23
Attending John Davies , Sara smith, Paul Jones , Joe Bloggs , Dean Smith .

SS wants us to start using this new product be cause it is evnviro friendly
space for response ......
JD said its to expensive
PJ said its comparable to costs now
SS will come back with costs break down on 04/04/23

JB said we should be loyal to current provides

And so on ,

And while I certainly advocate using your phone to record the meeting , make sure you are allowed to first ( privacy / security / nondisclosure etc) dont rely on it all together , even the best phone will miss some bits and as happened to me , my phone ran out of space without me realising and I missed the last 15 mins of the meeting when all the decisions were finalised !

Then when sending it out use a word doc table
Initial - point - by date - follow up by

Teams has a transcription tool so if you set it up it will transcribe everything said by everyone and the provide it at the end
NewYearCalavicci · 26/03/2022 11:58

I have to take minuets too and I hate it , a lot of our meetings are on teams so it is hard to decipher everything if they are all talking at the same time .

Next time first as PP said when you are asked say no as you have too many points to bring up / want a more interactive role etc , then firmly say can we clarify who will be taking the minuets so I can send my points to raise over.

If somehow you still get pushed into it ,
Make sure you know who will be attending and write their full names down, email / talk to everyone first ask them what they will be bringing up and make a note of it and leave space to then fill in the response from others in the meeting .
Then using just their initials fill in who is bringing what up

so as PP said

reason for meeting new product
date/ time 26/02/23
Attending John Davies , Sara smith, Paul Jones , Joe Bloggs , Dean Smith .

SS wants us to start using this new product be cause it is evnviro friendly
space for response ......
JD said its to expensive
PJ said its comparable to costs now
SS will come back with costs break down on 04/04/23

JB said we should be loyal to current provides

And so on ,

And while I certainly advocate using your phone to record the meeting , make sure you are allowed to first ( privacy / security / nondisclosure etc) dont rely on it all together , even the best phone will miss some bits and as happened to me , my phone ran out of space without me realising and I missed the last 15 mins of the meeting when all the decisions were finalised !

Then when sending it out use a word doc table
Initial - point - by date - follow up by

NeedAHoliday2021 · 26/03/2022 11:57

I hate them and it’s certainly not my job but with high sickness levels there’s a chance I’ll be asked. My male colleagues in the company Secretary’s office usually do them as stand by but our pas refuse, which is mad as we’ve had a guy doing minutes of a meeting he’s trying to chair, which is really hard to do.

Wife2b · 26/03/2022 11:55

You got two lines for a two hour meeting? That is strange, even writing by hand you should be able to jot down more than that. I have to regularly chair meetings and take minutes, laptop is the way to go and tidy up after.

godmum56 · 26/03/2022 11:54

yanbu but when I used to do minutes (and I often ran the meeting too) I used to keep in mind the saying "who controls the minutes controls the meeting". Its AMAZING what you can do in the way of slanting minutes on the way you want them and "failing" to minute stuff that won't be helpful....but then I am a sly old witch. Its also worth being asserive if you want discussion to stop or slow down so that you can stay with the flow and also so that you can make your own contribution.

Fanacapan · 26/03/2022 11:54

This happens to me all the time, I just note actions and decisions, attendance and apologies.

Catclean · 26/03/2022 11:44

I used to take minutes as a large part of my self employment - clerk to school governors. It's a skill, and some people really struggle with it.
You aren't unreasonable because you didn't agree to take these minutes, so it was perfectly fine to come away from the meeting with a brief note that was relevant to you.
Minutes aren't one size fits all - minutes for an internal team meeting are very different, and much easier, than minuting something like a governors meeting where they have to be much more detailed.

Sounds like you need to try to stick to your guns and refuse to do them. If you get ordered to then I suggest that you concentrate on just making a note of what was agreed at the end of each item discussed. Who cares what was said and who said it? In an internal meeting the important thing is what was agreed at the end of it all. Then if they don't like that approach they know what to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread