Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate doing minutes of a meeting

141 replies

CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 10:55

Last week, due to the absence of a person who usually does the minutes, I was asked two minutes for before a meeting started to do minutes.

I hate doing minutes. I can't keep an accurate record of a meeting and participate in it at the same time. People also talk too quickly for me to take notes of all that was said. The end result is that I always end up with scores of complaints any time I have taken minutes. It also takes me a really long time to write them up afterwards and if things are busy with my main responsibilities people keep pestering me for them when I really have no time to write it all out and share them.

These days I make sure that minutes are not part of my job repsonsibilities anymore and I refuse to even consider a job where that is a requirement.

I told the person who asked that I am no good at doing minutes, that I never end up with anything useful and that I only jot down a few things for myself. Despite my telling him this, he came back later and asked me what I got. I got all of two lines of the two hours meeting. I hope his own notes were more useful, but I never agreed to do them.

So was I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
user1496146479 · 26/03/2022 15:12

@Hercisback

I'd argue if there was only 2 lines in a 2 hour meeting then was it worth your time being there?

If you were asked because you're a woman that puts a whole different spin on things.

This!!
NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/03/2022 15:09

@toomanydogsandcats

Surely an admin would be present. Why would participants need to do that? It's a menial task
Really? Menial?

They can form the basis of a criminal prosecution. Get them wrong and potentially somebody dies or goes to prison, depending upon what it is that is being minuted. That's not menial by any stretch of the imagination.

EBearhug · 26/03/2022 15:09

I take minutes several times a week and I enjoy it. What you need to remember, is that as the person taking the minutes you control the narrative and direction of the meeting.

This. I'm good at it, and depending on the audience may add sarcastic or exaggerated comments (there's never actually been fisticuffs in any meeting I've been in, but my minutes may have suggested otherwise, after a contentious discussion...) I've even had feedback that people enjoyed reading my minutes, which must be a rare thing indeed. (I was quite surprised they actually read them!)

It is important to catch decisions and actions, which is the main point of it. Even if I'm not minuting the meeting, I will often note those points anyway, at least for projects I care about.

However as much as I'm good at doing it, and often don't mind, no one is daft enough to ask me to do it often, because I am usually the only woman there, and most of them will have previously been subject to me pointing out sexist assumptions around who should do certain tasks etc.

EinsteinaGogo · 26/03/2022 15:04

@suzyscat

Isn't it standard office sexism to expect a woman, however senior or irrelevant her role, to pick up this shit, or book a table for a company dinner. I've seen countless w of senior business women being given as hoc menial tasks, not in their job description, instead asking male office juniours/ interns, or men doing it themselves.

YANBU he isn't your boss, it's not your job and you didn't agree to do it.

Absolutely, @suzyscat

I facilitated an off-site recently. Old-skool style with flip charts, pens and post its. Bloody lovely!

Attendees were 50/50 men and women. Genuinely enlightened forward thinkers. At the end of the day, when it came to taking stuff off walls etc, no word of a lie, the men went to the bar and the women starting clearing.

I said "you are kidding me" and one of the women - more senior than the men - actually ran out and got them back in.

They were sheepish but it was still instinctive.

EinsteinaGogo · 26/03/2022 14:54

I'm not surprised you hate doing minutes, it's not your job, and the fact that you were one of only two women in the group, and a woman was asked, leans highly toward sexism.

if you're asked again, politely say "why have you asked me?.

Back in the day when I did feel obliged to take minutes, I got the feedback "Einstein's minutes seem to say what she would liked to have been said, rather than what actually was". 🥳

LatteLady · 26/03/2022 14:51

I take minutes several times a week and I enjoy it. What you need to remember, is that as the person taking the minutes you control the narrative and direction of the meeting.

OP, you were asked to minute the meeting, from your post it is not clear that you actually refused and said, "No." From this you tell us you managed two lines in two hours... even on a personal note taking scale that is pretty poor. If you have deliberately done this so you are never asked again, then understandable but not professional. I suggest that next time you are asked, you tell your colleages you do not have the capacity to take and turn around minutes, because currently you are going to be the only one being embarrassed.

SwedishEdith · 26/03/2022 14:45

@toomanydogsandcats

What jobs do you people do??? I am a manager and lead leadership meetings, that is an admin job not an executive one.
Lots of work areas don't have any admin staff. Admin staff have been cut and their work absorbed by everyone else.
suzyscat · 26/03/2022 14:44

Isn't it standard office sexism to expect a woman, however senior or irrelevant her role, to pick up this shit, or book a table for a company dinner. I've seen countless w of senior business women being given as hoc menial tasks, not in their job description, instead asking male office juniours/ interns, or men doing it themselves.

YANBU he isn't your boss, it's not your job and you didn't agree to do it.

toomanydogsandcats · 26/03/2022 14:41

What jobs do you people do??? I am a manager and lead leadership meetings, that is an admin job not an executive one.

phishy · 26/03/2022 14:40

I don’t take minutes but I do note down key points and actions from important meetings.

Otherwise things just get forgotten.

It’s a skill like any other, you get better the more you do it.

ButterfliesAndPancakes · 26/03/2022 14:35

I have to do it once a month and I loathe it. Luckily two of the agenda items are always guest speakers so I can just write ‘XX gave an interesting talk on XX. PowerPoint to follow’.

DiamondBright · 26/03/2022 14:25

I would have refused to take minutes, that's a specific skill I'm not trained to do. It would have been better to record the meeting for someone to minute later.

I would take informal notes at a push but thankfully in the male dominated world I work in no one would dare ask me to take notes, I've had male executive directors offer to take notes rather than ask me and risk appearing sexist. My female line manager is the only one who would ask me, but only notes never formal minutes.

Kite22 · 26/03/2022 14:24

YANBU to hate doing them, but YABVU to be asked, and then to only record 2 lines of a 2 hour meeting.

You need to be assertive.

We don't have any administrative assistance - in our Team we take turns to keep minutes. Before we move to next item on the agenda, the person whose turn it is will often say "Hold on a minute - just for the minutes - what do you want recording about {topic just discussed}". Or "For the minutes - this is what I've put {read out} does that cover everything?".

Just sitting there with the meeting having asked you to take them, and then not doing them, is unreasonable.

SwedishEdith · 26/03/2022 14:23

Just take action points. That's all people look at minutes for - what has been dumped on them to sort out.

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 26/03/2022 14:19

@SafelySoftly

I just can’t imagine just saying oh no I can’t do it. Everything I’m asked to do at work I give 100% and try my hardest. 2 points from a 2 hour meeting isn’t that. Is this public sector?!? Because I’d be looking at a disciplinary in private sector for this, at least a performance improvement plan! It’s not the hard!!
Why would you assume its public sector?? Because theres more cuts so people have to pick up work? Or because you assume in the public sector people arent working? OP hasnt mentioned anything about the repercussions of not taking adequate minutes (that arent her job) whether there are some or not
toomanydogsandcats · 26/03/2022 14:18

Surely an admin would be present. Why would participants need to do that? It's a menial task

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 26/03/2022 14:17

[quote user1471457751]@Spongebobfrillypants except the OP can't say she wasn't aware she was given the role as she was explicitly asked and didn't say no. And she clearly hasn't done her bit as she decided not to take the minutes, just without telling the person who asked her.

While it often is sexism that leads to the woman in the room taking the minutes, in this case it could just be because the OP had almost nothing to contribute to the meeting (she says so herself) so was best placed to be able to take the minutes.[/quote]
I was going to say that. Perhaps it had been recognised the difficulty of taking minutes and participating which is why op was asked

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 26/03/2022 14:15

I found if you took the minutes you could not really participate in the discussions.

Athena51 · 26/03/2022 14:11

@ComtesseDeSpair

Accurate minute taking is a skill, and I think it’s both unfair and remiss of a manager or project leader to ask it of somebody who doesn’t have that skill / hasn’t had the opportunity to develop the experience.

I’m a company secretary. I love taking minutes and the whole process which follows. I get paid an awful lot of money to do it. It isn’t just taking notes of what happened in the meeting, but I suspect that that view of it is what leads some managers to ask it of people who don’t know how to do it and hate doing it.

Same, I'm ICSA qualified with a background in governance. I only do the high level board/council meetings now but I pride myself on being able to minute any meeting. It's a real skill, not a menial task to be foisted onto someone without the skills to do it properly.

Officering meetings is very important and it can lead to a very interesting and well-paid career in governance.

Useranon1 · 26/03/2022 14:00

OP next time, just record the meeting.

user1471457751 · 26/03/2022 13:59

@Spongebobfrillypants except the OP can't say she wasn't aware she was given the role as she was explicitly asked and didn't say no. And she clearly hasn't done her bit as she decided not to take the minutes, just without telling the person who asked her.

While it often is sexism that leads to the woman in the room taking the minutes, in this case it could just be because the OP had almost nothing to contribute to the meeting (she says so herself) so was best placed to be able to take the minutes.

SevenWaystoLeave · 26/03/2022 13:59

You shouldn't be expected to be participating and taking minutes, one or the other

SafelySoftly · 26/03/2022 13:57

I just can’t imagine just saying oh no I can’t do it. Everything I’m asked to do at work I give 100% and try my hardest. 2 points from a 2 hour meeting isn’t that. Is this public sector?!? Because I’d be looking at a disciplinary in private sector for this, at least a performance improvement plan! It’s not the hard!!

Loopzy · 26/03/2022 13:45

We take it in turns to do the minutes and like you, I feel I can't participate and keep an accurate record. As our meetings are on Teams, we have started recording them, but still make some brief notes. We have noticed our meetings are shorter and there is no general chit-chat. It also means if anyone is absent, they can view the meeting if there are any actions for them. We always ask if everyone consents to the recording, but not sure if this is necessary or not.

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 26/03/2022 13:43

I would say "I cant do full minutes but can not a few action notes"
I would have also said at the end could people just confirm their actions for the notes. I attended a similar meeting and still managed more than 2 sentences though!!
Minute taking is an under appreciated skill.
However if at the next meeting you are asked I would say that you did it last time and isny it better to rotate responsibility.

Swipe left for the next trending thread