Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate doing minutes of a meeting

141 replies

CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 10:55

Last week, due to the absence of a person who usually does the minutes, I was asked two minutes for before a meeting started to do minutes.

I hate doing minutes. I can't keep an accurate record of a meeting and participate in it at the same time. People also talk too quickly for me to take notes of all that was said. The end result is that I always end up with scores of complaints any time I have taken minutes. It also takes me a really long time to write them up afterwards and if things are busy with my main responsibilities people keep pestering me for them when I really have no time to write it all out and share them.

These days I make sure that minutes are not part of my job repsonsibilities anymore and I refuse to even consider a job where that is a requirement.

I told the person who asked that I am no good at doing minutes, that I never end up with anything useful and that I only jot down a few things for myself. Despite my telling him this, he came back later and asked me what I got. I got all of two lines of the two hours meeting. I hope his own notes were more useful, but I never agreed to do them.

So was I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 19:41

@EinsteinaGogo

In my career experience, I've worked on programmes where minutes of meetings were either :

A: legally required and and enormously important record and agreed actions
B: not legally required but still an enormously important record and action list
C: taken because the leader or function thinks they should be, they are never agreed, no one cares and they're never looked at again

A and B are very skilled jobs that require agility, knowledge of the topics, acronyms and business language.

C is a job that these days, typically indicates an inefficient workplace where it's no-ones real responsibility and generally falls to the junior, the unlucky or the female.

My workplace is let's say not very "formal". When I joined a few years ago we were even more poorly staffed than we are today. Shortly after I joined a few very experienced and talented people walked out due to being frequently ignored by management.

I was only there a few weeks before it became pretty clear to me that they more than half the team had one foot out the door already and I rang alarm bells with HR. Some people they were not able to keep.

Things have improved and they have expanded. But many times I still fly by the seat of my pants and make things happen however I can. I work well that way. I am good at improvising in less structured environments. I am also to quick to learn the technical aspects of most jobs.

But I have als noticed that I don't do as well in more formal settings, if I am forced to work within rules and systems where no one can even explain to me why they are in place, when people waste time following ineffecient procedures, I structure. I can't concentrate and I lose motivation. This is what seems to be happening with this project. I can't get out of the meetings, but since they are remote I listen in with half an ear and try work work on my primary responsibilities as well.

I agree that I should have been more clear, but I also told the coworker who asked that I sometimes have to take calls as we cannot afford to lose a whole morning of our department not being reachable by phone. That was obviously not a clear enough 'no', but it wasn't a yes either.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 26/03/2022 19:41

@TheFoldOx

As *@godmum56* has said, if you control the minutes, you control the meeting. Most people do not remember what was said in a meeting (that's why we have minutes, after all). Most people "remember" what they wish they had said, whether they did or not. So by producing the minutes, you can ensure that the outcome of the meeting is as beneficial t you/your tea/your allies as you wish.

On a more prosaic level, I never write detailed notes. I sketch out the agenda before the meeting, note any major disagreements expressed, and what the meeting decides. Minutes will read "the meeting noted paper x. In discussion, the following points were raised: x, y, z. It was agreed that ". At the end I add a table showing action, due date, and person responsible. For a two hour meeting I'd expect to type up three sides at most.

Finally, and going back to the first point, always remember Sir Humphrey Appleby's advice:

It is characteristic of all committee discussions and decisions that every member has a vivid recollection of them and that every member's recollection of them differs violently from every other member's recollection. Consequently we accept the convention that the official decisions are those and only those which have officially recorded in the minutes by the officials, from which it emerges with an elegant inevitability that any decision which has been officially reached will have been officially recorded in the minutes by the officials and any decision which is not recorded in the minutes has not been officially reached even if one or more members believe they can recollect it, so in this particular case if the decision had been officially reached it would have been officially recorded in the minutes by the officials. And it isn't so it wasn't.

yup....and if you do it subtly people thnk you are SUCH a team player too! Grin
CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 19:21

@Needcoffeecoffeecoffee

I had never agreed to do them. There are no repercussions. It was a coworker who asked me to do them, not my boss. It's not public sector and I avoid taking roles with these kind of admin duties, because I know I am no good at them.

I like the suggestion of just recording the meeting next time. Then I can do my notes as usual and just share the recording and people can use that.

OP posts:
TheFoldOx · 26/03/2022 19:19

As @godmum56 has said, if you control the minutes, you control the meeting. Most people do not remember what was said in a meeting (that's why we have minutes, after all). Most people "remember" what they wish they had said, whether they did or not. So by producing the minutes, you can ensure that the outcome of the meeting is as beneficial t you/your tea/your allies as you wish.

On a more prosaic level, I never write detailed notes. I sketch out the agenda before the meeting, note any major disagreements expressed, and what the meeting decides. Minutes will read "the meeting noted paper x. In discussion, the following points were raised: x, y, z. It was agreed that ". At the end I add a table showing action, due date, and person responsible. For a two hour meeting I'd expect to type up three sides at most.

Finally, and going back to the first point, always remember Sir Humphrey Appleby's advice:

It is characteristic of all committee discussions and decisions that every member has a vivid recollection of them and that every member's recollection of them differs violently from every other member's recollection. Consequently we accept the convention that the official decisions are those and only those which have officially recorded in the minutes by the officials, from which it emerges with an elegant inevitability that any decision which has been officially reached will have been officially recorded in the minutes by the officials and any decision which is not recorded in the minutes has not been officially reached even if one or more members believe they can recollect it, so in this particular case if the decision had been officially reached it would have been officially recorded in the minutes by the officials. And it isn't so it wasn't.

CaptSkippy · 26/03/2022 19:11

[quote HalfShrunkMoreToGo]techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/microsoft-teams-blog/live-transcription-with-speaker-attribution-now-available-in/ba-p/2228817[/quote]
I have tried that before. It really doesn't work very well and it also gives you all the ahs and uhms and incomplete sentences that are not usefull at all.

OP posts:
ExMachinaDeus · 26/03/2022 19:02

I am only 1 of two women in my department

Why am I not surprised ...

Papayamya · 26/03/2022 18:24

I used to take loads of minutes (we had to keep them on file as they formed part of the documentation we had to retain), it's just finding something that works for you. I just scribbled down pertinent decision or action points and didn't bother to include stuff on the slide pack aside from perhaps referencing it ie slide 3 of x pack. It's a different issue if you're being asked just as you're a woman- we had a rota of sorts and would cycle through so everyone did them at some point.

PigletJohn · 26/03/2022 18:19

Whoever is chairing the meeting (if anyone) should at least pause and say, "OK, so Harry will chop down the oak tree by Friday 10th Jan"
(Or whatever other actions have been agreed) and "So it is decided that the new Whizzog will be painted green" (or whatever other decisions have been made) and write them down herself.

The chair should also note down the names of participants, apologies, and AWOLs.

How can a competent chair not do that?

Chair's notes will have to do if nobody is doing minutes.

A spiteful chair like myself will also note "Anastasia spoke from 10.00 to 11.15 about the colour of the new wallpaper. No decisions made"

RockaLock · 26/03/2022 17:34

Thanks, @OstrichFeathers that's helpful Smile

PuppyMonkey · 26/03/2022 17:28

You say you never agreed to do it, so Random Man who asked you due no doubt to you being female will have to try and survive without the Minutes.

I find Minute taking ok, but my background is in newspaper reporting so that probably helps.

You could have always just done it like this:

“Two pointless hours were spent discussing x project.
It was agreed we would all do it again in a fortnight.”

Ionlydomassiveones · 26/03/2022 17:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

dipdye · 26/03/2022 17:15

Was this meeting online or in person?

lightand · 26/03/2022 16:47

I have managed to avoid taking minutes my whole life.
I am always surprised when people step forward to do them.

Gotajobthrunepotism · 26/03/2022 16:43

Why on earth did he ask you to take the minutes? If he wants minutes: he writes them. Cheeky fucker

LemonDrizzles · 26/03/2022 15:40

Next time suggests the host types up.minutes as you go along

EinsteinaGogo · 26/03/2022 15:39

In my career experience, I've worked on programmes where minutes of meetings were either :

A: legally required and and enormously important record and agreed actions
B: not legally required but still an enormously important record and action list
C: taken because the leader or function thinks they should be, they are never agreed, no one cares and they're never looked at again

A and B are very skilled jobs that require agility, knowledge of the topics, acronyms and business language.

C is a job that these days, typically indicates an inefficient workplace where it's no-ones real responsibility and generally falls to the junior, the unlucky or the female.

ReachersDaughter · 26/03/2022 15:38

@toomanydogsandcats

Surely an admin would be present. Why would participants need to do that? It's a menial task
Wrong, another governance professional here (ICSA too!). Minutes are not a menial task!!!
NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/03/2022 15:34

@BoredZelda

What jobs do you people do??? I am a manager and lead leadership meetings, that is an admin job not an executive one.

😂 “leadership meetings” which train people that admin tasks are beneath them 😂

Yeah, we’ve all worked for those “leaders” before.

And also unaware of something known as a Governance Professional, who can be the person whose works determines whether the manager is promoted or reported to the Police.

Of course, it can be useful to be viewed as nothing more than a glorified typist, as it's then possible to document discussions where illegal actions are being attempted - how would a mere typist know that what you've just said is proof you're committing an offence, after all? - but it's a skilled professional role with professional standards the person is legally obliged to keep to.

Competent managers are aware of this. Incompetent ones, not so much.

courgettigreensadwater · 26/03/2022 15:31

Urgh. I HATE doing minutes. Like you said I would not apply for a job with it listed. I started a new job in Jan 2020 after 15 years in the same team. Two weeks later I was asked to do minutes for a meeting with 32 people the names of whom I did not know. I was a wreck. Had to make little cardboard things with the participants initials and was also part of the meeting - difficult to concentrate and write things down. It was horrendous. They made me do it a couple more times despite me saying I wouldn't have gone for for job if I'd know. In the end I said if I continue having to do them I will start proactively looking for a new job! They transferred the minute taking to someone who was actually an admin person and had experience of writing minutes.

BoredZelda · 26/03/2022 15:25

What jobs do you people do??? I am a manager and lead leadership meetings, that is an admin job not an executive one.

😂 “leadership meetings” which train people that admin tasks are beneath them 😂

Yeah, we’ve all worked for those “leaders” before.

DiamondBright · 26/03/2022 15:20

@toomanydogsandcats

What jobs do you people do??? I am a manager and lead leadership meetings, that is an admin job not an executive one.
It's a senior admin job, it requires training and experience to do well. I check minutes for a meeting I attend and even with an experience minute taker who's recognised as being pretty good I make at least small amendments every month where she's not quite understood something technically or included something that wasn't particularly relevant. You need a good chair and good supporting papers as well as a competent experienced minute taker for good minutes, ours get referenced in papers for other meetings and audited. Action notes for an informal meeting are different.
jeremyjamjam · 26/03/2022 15:20

I've always been terrible at taking minutes, but I have an ADHD diagnosis so thankfully not having to do them is one of my reasonable adjustments. In my team minute taking is rotated through the whole team, not just purely an administrator task. It's one of those things that some people seem to be able to do without even trying whereas for me I'd get maybe two legibly lines down, like the OP, then pages of incoherent scrawl!

BoredZelda · 26/03/2022 15:19

I don't love doing them but they're not hard.

It's minutes not a transcript, it just needs to capture the talking points and agreed actions so my basic format is

For you. They aren’t hard for you. There are plenty of bits of my job that are really easy that you wouldn’t be able to do as well as I can if you aren’t doing it all the time.

The point is, it’s not OP’s job and it shouldn’t fall to her to take the minutes. People used to try it on me, usually because I was the only woman in the room and I always said no, not doing them, it’s not my job.

The person who chairs the meeting should do the minutes, unless they have an assistant who does it for them.

RubiesandRose · 26/03/2022 15:17

It's also worth mentioning that the requirement for Minutes can vary depending on the business, but as a PP said in an industry that is required to demonstrate governance and compliance the need for accurate Minutes and recording of events/actions/approvals etc as a legal requirement is very different to keeping a record of a team meeting in another industry sector.

In the first example it is a skilled and well paid role and certainly not menial!

user1496146479 · 26/03/2022 15:16

@okletsdothis

Teams has a transcription tool so if you set it up it will transcribe everything said by everyone and the provide it at the end

Have you ever actually used this though? Maybe it's just the accents (our team is made up of scottish, irish and welsh accents) but the transcription that came out of our last meeting was hilarious, and would have been absolutely no use if you were relying on it for minutes. 'Clear and concise' for example, somehow became 'thieves in the night' Confused

But yes, I hate minute taking with a passion, and dread every meeting.

Yes we are the same! Hilarious read back, but not a reflection of our actual meeting! Grin