Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog owner angry because i walked away from his dog

181 replies

Mooo111 · 26/03/2022 10:26

I admit I'm a little nervous of certain dogs, I just think 'never say never'.
Anyway just before I was walking in the street and a pitbull type dog was off its lead walking past me. I moved to the other side of the pavement to let them past.
The owner (a young man) took great offence at this snapping, 'He's friendly, he wouldn't be off the lead if he wasn't, Jesus Christ!" Then walked off muttering obscenities.

I didn't respond just carried on walking. Has anyone else met this sort of situation? I'm within my rights to move out of the way of the dog if I want to. Of course owners will always say he/she is friendly but it can be intimidating when a dog you don't know runs up to you.

OP posts:
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 26/03/2022 12:17

[quote StrawberryPot]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

5 houses is hardly much of a walk! The only people who I see walking their dogs any distance off lead fit the description of the man in the op. So yes, I do question their training methods.

But I stand by my belief that no dog should be off lead in a street. Even the most obedient dog can forget itself and suddenly give chase - into a road causing an accident. [/quote]
We live in a quiet cul de sac. He's still off lead on a street. He is only ever on a lead to walk down to the main road to go to the local field. Then he's off.

BobbinHood · 26/03/2022 12:15

YADNBU and I’d have done the same. Especially when with DD, we give off lead dogs as wide a berth as possible because they’re inevitably not off lead for good behaviour but because their owners are shit.

StScholastica · 26/03/2022 12:15

Our dog comes straight back to us to have his lead put on if he sees people approaching. It wasn't easy to get him to do this and took a mountain of dog treats.
We still encounter people who are dog phobic and cross over, I completely understand this, you wouldn't expect someone with a fear of heights to climb a ladder.
Our dog is a tiny Shitzhu cross.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 26/03/2022 12:15

@Philisophigal

When I'm supreme leader, people found walking their dogs off a lead in a public place are banned for life from owning dogs.
Haha. Ridiculous
Thumpkin · 26/03/2022 12:09

YANBU. I’m a dog owner - a responsible one, with two dogs that I’ve taken to dog training classes since they were puppies.

Dogs should be under full control in public places. That means that if a dog is on a pavement, walking close to pedestrians, it should be on a lead unless 1) it is trained not to approach other dogs or people; 2) it has immaculate recall. By that, I mean it can be recalled away from real temptations such as food on the floor. If it can’t do either of those things, it has no business being on a street off lead near joggers, cars, toddlers, cyclists, shops, people eating food or whatever other distractions there may be. The owner doesn’t get to dictate that other people should be okay with their dog approaching them, uninvited.

Unfortunately, lots of dog owners treat dogs as a hobby rather than a responsibility and find it easier to walk around with their dog off lead. ‘He’s friendly’ means ‘I’ve not trained him not to approach people and I don’t really care if people want my dog going up to them or not.’

funinthesun19 · 26/03/2022 12:09

If an owner is actually offended that someone moved away from their dog, then there’s a red flag right there.

limitedperiodonly · 26/03/2022 12:09

Of course YANBU for avoiding the dog. Most dog owners are not like this man and I am sure you know that. I expect it was a Staffie but it always sounds more dramatic when people describe them as a pitbull type.

Goldbar · 26/03/2022 12:06

The problem is that lots of people have skewed judgement when it comes to their dogs. They then get offended when strangers don't trust their judgement.

I would put anyone who lets their dog approach or run up to passers-by into that category, especially if they shout "It's all right, he/she is friendly!" No, it's not all right. Lots of people don't like dogs and, even if the dog in question is unlikely to savage them, they should not have to deal with them and should be able to live a relatively dog-free life without being accosted by other people's dogs.

EthelTheAardvark · 26/03/2022 12:04

@CandidaAlbicans2

YANBU. However, my first thoughts are that he may have got sick of people judging him and his dog negatively and become very touchy about it. Your reaction may have been the straw that broke the camel's back. But all we can do is make instant judgements, it's what helps keep us safe and is a natural human instinct, so if you felt uncomfortable you felt uncomfortable. Shame he reacted the way he did though.
You may be right, but when anyone gets a pitbull type of dog, they have to realise it comes with the territory, especially if they want to exercise them off lead. If they can't cope with people's reactions, maybe they need to rethink their choices.
FingersofFish · 26/03/2022 12:04

YANBU dogs shouldn't be off leads. It still puzzles me that on my local field, on which there is a primary school that people are exercising dogs off lead at school drop off. No matter how friendly accidents can happen and I've been knocked over by a bounding dog dropping my kids off. He didn't mean me any harm but I'm a 40 year old who was no match for an excited large dog after his ball so what hope do nursery kids have 🤷🏼‍♀️

Booklover3 · 26/03/2022 12:03

I have a Labrador and I can’t blame anyone who crosses away. She’s still in training and doesn’t walk to heel yet. I would also never, ever let her off lead unless it’s a secure field we’ve hired.

Yet.

But even when we get to the stage where she walks nicely and I trust her recall. I would never let her walk to heel on a street. Too many variables that can’t be controlled in my opinion. Too many dangers… but I do live in a very busy town.

isittheholidaysyet · 26/03/2022 12:02

I get you OP.
I was once in a Travelodge. I walked though reception into the bedroom corridor and found the receptionist talking to a man with a dog.
I immediately stepped back to allow them to finish their conversation and the dog and it's owner to return to their room.

Receptionist immediately turned to me and said 'Don't worry it's a service dog.'

So? Did I ask? Does that make a difference? Did I speak? Did I question it?
No, so crack on and I'll return to my room when I am happy.
I'm not going to squeeze past 2 people and a dog.

Comedycook · 26/03/2022 12:02

You can walk anywhere you want for any reason or no reason without anyone commenting

FrancescaContini · 26/03/2022 11:58

Ah, the righteous outrage directed by dog owners towards people who, very sensibly, get out of the way of savage-looking dogs. I’ve come across this before. They’re being defensive because they know their dog looks terrifying (and should definitely be on a lead).

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 11:56

@CandidaAlbicans2
You’re right. It’s actually a very healthy reaction to avoid dangerous dogs, we have the instinct of fear for a reason. I couldn’t care less about the feelings of a dog owner. They knew what breed they chose as a pet. They knew these dogs can cause fatal injuries to people if decide to attack. Then we somehow owe love to their dogs.

Unsure33 · 26/03/2022 11:54

@EvilPea

I accidentally ended up with a “status” breed, I will trot out the “softest dog you’ve ever met” and he was. It used to make me so sad people would judge it and cross the road after one look at him. Fair enough if you don’t like dogs, he wasn’t going to jump up at you anyway. But the immediate judgement made me sad. He had a soft coloured harness to look friendlier.

I have to admit I go out of my way with status breeds now to say hello, as I know the judgement they get

To be honest I would do the same cross the road because
  1. I ended up in hospital after being bitten by a status breed
  2. I don’t know your dog
  3. I don’t know how my dog would react if I was tense myself
  4. I would not be worried about offending your dog or his feelings.
Philisophigal · 26/03/2022 11:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 11:53

@IVFConfusion
It doesn’t matter if that’s a reflection of the owner or not. I’m not a fortune teller to say if someone’s is a responsible dog owner or not, if the dog is trained or not. The truth is some dogs are much more likely to cause fatal injuries and some dogs aren’t . This is the risk not worth taking.

Longblues · 26/03/2022 11:52

Yanbu I am nervous arround dogs and can't stand the owners who are dismissive of this or take personal offence.

Namelessnancy · 26/03/2022 11:51

Even for 5 doors away it's really not too much hassle to pop a lead on. I've seen too many times through my work the consequences of a well trained, lovely dog being momentarily distracted near traffic. I promise it can and does happen and leads to such pain and heartache. There is also the issue of legal liability for an accident caused.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 26/03/2022 11:50

@Ownedbymycats

We need laws specifying that in public streets etc dogs should be on leads. I was in a park recently with a 1 yr old niece.A staffy came hurtling towards us from at least 200metres away. The owner shouted and whistled but couldn't get it back. The speed it had built up when it did get to me was enormous, it hit me with such impact that it was like a rugby collision. The dog was beautiful and I'm used to the breed but it's an accident waiting to happen and it's the dogs who suffer.
It's already the law that dogs should be on leads on public roads.

But the issue is, off-lead doesn't automatically mean danger and on-lead doesn't automatically mean safe.

For example, yesterday I was walking three dogs at heel along the road - all on leads. A man on the other side of the road had two boxer-type dogs on leads. One snarled and lunged towards me and my dogs - it nearly got itself hit by a car as it pulled the man so strongly he ended up on the road.

Lurking9to5 · 26/03/2022 11:49

@Mischance

Dogs are a British obsession ... no-one dare complain about them, and if you do not love them there is something wrong with you apparently. Makes me sick.
Same in Ireland. I actually had to unfollow a few people on facebook who were obsessed with rescue dogs but stood in judgement of people and compounded their distress with judgement, silent treatments, ostracisation etc If you do a fundraiser for 1) rescue dogs and 2) women's aid, the dogs will raise more money.
Cyw2018 · 26/03/2022 11:49

YANBU.
One of my neighbours has a young adult intact male English bull terrier, I avoid it, and I'm not the only experienced dog owner in the area that tries to avoid it.

Roussette · 26/03/2022 11:49

I generally like most dogs but some owners are just ridiculous about their dogs!

There's this woman who walks her terrier type dog the same time as I walk unfortunately
The first time I saw her, the dog lunged for me, teeth bared and snarling. I jumped out my skin as it was out the blue and I wasn't expecting it. And as usual the owner said 'he's very friendly you know' !! I ignored her and carried on walking, despite wanting to say NO HE'S NOT!

He would've gone for me if she hadn't managed to pull him away a split second before he did!

Now... every morning, she gives me the evils, glaring at me. No idea what I'm supposed to have done! Her dog still snarls and yaps when I walk by. I don't look at her or her dog. Weird dog owner.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 26/03/2022 11:48

YANBU. However, my first thoughts are that he may have got sick of people judging him and his dog negatively and become very touchy about it. Your reaction may have been the straw that broke the camel's back. But all we can do is make instant judgements, it's what helps keep us safe and is a natural human instinct, so if you felt uncomfortable you felt uncomfortable. Shame he reacted the way he did though.