Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog owner angry because i walked away from his dog

181 replies

Mooo111 · 26/03/2022 10:26

I admit I'm a little nervous of certain dogs, I just think 'never say never'.
Anyway just before I was walking in the street and a pitbull type dog was off its lead walking past me. I moved to the other side of the pavement to let them past.
The owner (a young man) took great offence at this snapping, 'He's friendly, he wouldn't be off the lead if he wasn't, Jesus Christ!" Then walked off muttering obscenities.

I didn't respond just carried on walking. Has anyone else met this sort of situation? I'm within my rights to move out of the way of the dog if I want to. Of course owners will always say he/she is friendly but it can be intimidating when a dog you don't know runs up to you.

OP posts:
katepilar · 26/03/2022 14:16

@Porthia

YADNBU - I had a similar albeit more polite version when I was heavily pregnant and walking with my 2 year old to nursery.

Now, I am scared of dogs. I used to be properly phobic but I have worked hard to overcome it and now I would say I am cautious around dogs but no longer fully terrified. The reasons behind my phobia are likely many but it was fuelled by 2 dog related incidents when I was a child, one involving a Doberman when I was about 5 and one involving 2 German Shepherds when I was about 10. In the latter incident I ended up being bitten on the leg.

ANYHOO, my point is that no one just walking along with their dog knows any of this. So when a young off lead German Shepherd was running towards me down the pavement and I was encumbered by a very pregnant belly and a toddler I found it absolutely terrifying. This was on the pavement by the side of a relatively busy road - not off in the woods.

The dog was, it turns out, very well trained and the owner just whistled and he turned without breaking stride and returned to him. But I did ask the owner why he doesn’t please use a lead and he said - much like the bloke you spoke to - “if I needed a lead I would use one”

I have since seen them walking around quite a lot, never with a lead and, to be fair, the dog is always under control, but to someone like me it literally feels like seeing an enormous man eating tiger wandering down the road next to me and my toddler. And I’m trusting in the training of a stranger and the unpredictable nature of a dog I don’t know that nothing bad will happen.

Is that irrational? Yes, probably my fear is still irrational and I get that the man has probably put in lots of time and effort training his dog. But, I still think people should come first and that means dogs should be on the lead when on a road!

Sorry for the essay - but I think it’s important for people to understand how it can feel to see a dog off lead (and obviously it’s different in a field or dog park or something).

I agree with you. You never know the dog owner and the dog are like. Not all of them are well managed like this. It would be great that these blokes realized world doesnt run just by his standards. as in not all dogs are well trained as his and not all people are fine having a dog running towards them even if the dog is later called back.
WonderfulYou · 26/03/2022 14:05

Trying to get noticed in the Daily Fail how pathetic 🙄

Stop posting multiple threads and trying to create drama when there isn’t any.

SamphiretheStickerist · 26/03/2022 14:05

@Allergictoironing

Yes that is true, if that dog was of a breed that was classed as illegal then that child wouldn't have died. Unless the parents had bought a different large adult dog, of a different breed, that wasn't yet on the banned list e.g. a German Shepherd, or a Husky/Mamlute, or a Chow cross, or a standard English Bulldog, which may or may not have attacked the child.

I wasn't trying to suppress you at all - I asked a simple question about what breeds YOU considered dangerous and should be banned.

The problem is, any large & most medium breeds of dog have the potential to cause death if they attack. There have even been cases of babies & small children being killed by small terrier breeds in the UK.

Though I can find no records of any deaths caused by Bull Terriers - the breed owned by @SamphiretheStickerist, the dog you state is "bound to cause a serious or fatal injury ".

There are none, as far as I can tell. I don't think I found any serious injuries either (unless it was from a dog stolen and used for fighting). Other smaller terriers, including a Lakeland have killed, though.

Most people who own bull terriers spend inordinate amounts of time learning their dog's levels of 'bounciness' and refocusing it. They aren't aggressive dogs but their immense capacity for over exuberance can be an issue for people who don't know the breed or judge them on their head shape. No Bullie owner is ignorant of that fact.

Badbaddog · 26/03/2022 14:04

@Porthia

YADNBU - I had a similar albeit more polite version when I was heavily pregnant and walking with my 2 year old to nursery.

Now, I am scared of dogs. I used to be properly phobic but I have worked hard to overcome it and now I would say I am cautious around dogs but no longer fully terrified. The reasons behind my phobia are likely many but it was fuelled by 2 dog related incidents when I was a child, one involving a Doberman when I was about 5 and one involving 2 German Shepherds when I was about 10. In the latter incident I ended up being bitten on the leg.

ANYHOO, my point is that no one just walking along with their dog knows any of this. So when a young off lead German Shepherd was running towards me down the pavement and I was encumbered by a very pregnant belly and a toddler I found it absolutely terrifying. This was on the pavement by the side of a relatively busy road - not off in the woods.

The dog was, it turns out, very well trained and the owner just whistled and he turned without breaking stride and returned to him. But I did ask the owner why he doesn’t please use a lead and he said - much like the bloke you spoke to - “if I needed a lead I would use one”

I have since seen them walking around quite a lot, never with a lead and, to be fair, the dog is always under control, but to someone like me it literally feels like seeing an enormous man eating tiger wandering down the road next to me and my toddler. And I’m trusting in the training of a stranger and the unpredictable nature of a dog I don’t know that nothing bad will happen.

Is that irrational? Yes, probably my fear is still irrational and I get that the man has probably put in lots of time and effort training his dog. But, I still think people should come first and that means dogs should be on the lead when on a road!

Sorry for the essay - but I think it’s important for people to understand how it can feel to see a dog off lead (and obviously it’s different in a field or dog park or something).

My dog is usually off the lead unless we’re on a busy road with pavements. However I’ve got very good at reading people’s reactions when they see us approaching. A few times I’ve seen people react with utter terror, it’s heart-breaking. I instantly put the dog on a lead abd cross over if I can.

Some men love to tell me how to manage my dog. These are non-phobic busybodies who think they can use her being off the lead as a justification to boss a woman around. They get very short shrift indeed from me.

VetOnCall · 26/03/2022 14:01

If you are talking about allregognised bully breeds, you're including Bull Terriers, Bulldogs, Boston Terriers, Great Danes, French Bulldogs, Bull Mastifs, Pugs etc as well as Staffys. So where do you draw the line - ban Bull Terriers, but keep Frenchies & pugs etc? Ban Boston Terriers but keep Great Danes?

Great Danes and Pugs are not bull breeds. Great Danes were developed originally from molosser/mastiff type dogs for hunting bears and wild boar. Pugs originated in China as companion dogs, akin to the Pekingese. They were brought to Europe via Holland but the 'Dutch Bulldog' moniker is a misnomer, see the screenshot from the American Kennel Club website.

Dog owner angry because i walked away from his dog
zen1 · 26/03/2022 13:50

YANBU. I am phobic of dogs and always avoid them if they are not on a lead.

Allergictoironing · 26/03/2022 13:44

I should add that I voted YANBU, I'm no apologist for badly behaved dogs or badly behaved owners.

Allergictoironing · 26/03/2022 13:42

Yes that is true, if that dog was of a breed that was classed as illegal then that child wouldn't have died. Unless the parents had bought a different large adult dog, of a different breed, that wasn't yet on the banned list e.g. a German Shepherd, or a Husky/Mamlute, or a Chow cross, or a standard English Bulldog, which may or may not have attacked the child.

I wasn't trying to suppress you at all - I asked a simple question about what breeds YOU considered dangerous and should be banned.

The problem is, any large & most medium breeds of dog have the potential to cause death if they attack. There have even been cases of babies & small children being killed by small terrier breeds in the UK.

Though I can find no records of any deaths caused by Bull Terriers - the breed owned by @SamphiretheStickerist, the dog you state is "bound to cause a serious or fatal injury ".

whynotwhatknot · 26/03/2022 13:40

Ridiculous and proves some owners are twats secind thread today like this

MY late dm was petrified of dogs didnt like them near her or off leads no matter what the size and would ave done the same-dnt worry about the twat

LBFseBrom · 26/03/2022 13:40

You were quite right to be cautious and also absolutely right to walk away. Getting into a conversation in that situation would be pointless.

Alexandra2001 · 26/03/2022 13:36

Most people who have these scary looking breeds are lacking elsewhere in their lives.
Zero reason to own a large attack style dog, loads of breeds out there that are soft mouthed and can be managed by their owners.

Trouble is, many dog owners expect random strangers to love their dogs as much as they do and lack any understanding towards those who don't.

There is a reason certain legal breeds are highly sought after for illegal Dog fighting and others are not.

AuntMargo · 26/03/2022 13:33

@Bananabutter

YANBU. Any sane person would walk away from those type of dogs.
thats a judgemental post, my mothers shih tzu, is the nastiest dog I have ever met. I have never met a nasty bull breed !
TooMuchToblerone · 26/03/2022 13:20

Some owners are idiots. I was walking on my own once and a huge dog came up and was booffing me from behind and pushing my hand. I ignored it as I was nervous and the owner yelled out "Never mind dog name, some people aren't very nice"

katepilar · 26/03/2022 13:15

I often have dogs come my way when I am sat on the grass in a park. Sometimes I am eating lunch which I guess makes me even more attractive for them. But generally people either dont even know wheere their dog is and if they do, they seem not to care at all. I dont feel like shouting at them to keep the dog away from me would make it any better so I get up so they dont get into my face or whatever I have in my hands /lunch, crocheting baby stuff, book.../ and hope for the dog to go away .

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 13:12

@Allergictoironing
Please answer to one direct question yourself. Is the recent tragic death of a young toddler girl worth your whataboutery about how it’s never dogs, it’s always owners and your attempts to suppress me with your dog breed quizzes? If it was illegal to own this breed, this girl wouldn’t have died. Period.

Wykid · 26/03/2022 13:12

I love dogs and have had a few over the years

I absolutely can’t stand people that say “don’t worry, my dog’s fine”

You’re not in the wrong here

RIPWalter · 26/03/2022 13:11

@Philisophigal

When I'm supreme leader, people found walking their dogs off a lead in a public place are banned for life from owning dogs.
I totally disagree with you, however, my friend is deputy leader of a county council and also has her own ward to deal with (including a beach), and she jokes that if dogs were banned it would reduce her workload by about 90%.
Velvian · 26/03/2022 13:11

It is completely unacceptable for any dog to be walked along the pavement off the lead. No one else knows or gives a shit at how brilliantly you have trained your dog to walk to heel. They can see a dog is under control if it is on the lead though.

The guy was a dick with a chip on his shoulder.

SamphiretheStickerist · 26/03/2022 13:10

@Frozenlikeablockofmarble

He’s just a man thinking it’s OK to bully and belittle a woman in the street.

I was out with DH last week when we passed a man with a lovely big dog well controlled on a lead. The dog stopped and looked inquiringly at us, in the way dogs do when they want to make friends. The man said to his dog: “They don’t know you. You’re not friends with everybody, you know.”

That’s how it ought to be.

Yep!
oviraptor21 · 26/03/2022 13:10

His reaction demonstrates very clearly why you were right to cross the road. Any reasonable person would have not even batted an eyelid.

Brushteethwashface · 26/03/2022 13:09

@SamphiretheStickerist

Off lead he was unreasonable. But I do get him being pissed off.

I have a "pit bull type" dog. He's a bull terrier. I keep him on a lead unless we are somewhere enclosed that actively encourages off lead dogs.

Every week, sometime every bloody day, someone will say "A pit bull. They're dangerous them dogs. Should be muzzled." etc etc etc.

I get protective. He is, as are most if the breed, walking cuddles, happy to meet people, never aggressive. Don't get me wrong, I don't trust that it rely on that. He's a dog. And dog's and people can be unpredictable. But I do dislike the assumption that he's a "pit bull type" and bound to be aggressive.

Here he is, filthy having had a blast playing with his ball in a dog park. He was drinking, attached to the back of the car, and some bloke walked up to me and started shouting about him being dangerous and out of control! Like the man you met, OP, I took exception and told him to fuck off.

Well he is lovely- used to have an EBT but people are more wary of them because of how they look, get it’s annoying but it’s understandable. I don’t think you can conflate the OP’s situation with the one you describe, she didn’t shout at anyone, she just crossed the road. I have the opposite problem with my dog who looks cute so people approach him, he’s not at all friendly with people he does not know so feel like I’m constantly saying “best not to stroke him/let your tiny child stroke him because he doesn’t like it”
Frozenlikeablockofmarble · 26/03/2022 13:09

He’s just a man thinking it’s OK to bully and belittle a woman in the street.

I was out with DH last week when we passed a man with a lovely big dog well controlled on a lead. The dog stopped and looked inquiringly at us, in the way dogs do when they want to make friends. The man said to his dog: “They don’t know you. You’re not friends with everybody, you know.”

That’s how it ought to be.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 13:08

@Allergictoironing
Prejudice?? I value the relationship you can build with a dog. But I will never, ever put a dog above humans life. My lovely kind fluffy and all excuses…(fill the gap) spaniel I grew up with once gave me a bite when I was a child. I didn’t need stitches but it scared me a lot. Was not my dogs fault but I don’t want to imagine what happens if there was another breed in the place of my dog. Things happen. Some dogs are biologically and anatomically stronger and genetically predisposed to attacks. There is nothing I can say to change your dangerous dog lovers minds.

SamphiretheStickerist · 26/03/2022 13:07

Actually every dog can kill, even the smallest.

What kind of breed do you think mine is? It's not on the dangerous dogs list, never caused a death in the UK, according to the yearly lists.

So...

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 13:03

@Prescottdanni123
Yes, every dog can bite. Not every dog can attack to death and certain types of dogs are very capable. I don’t want to see these dogs anywhere near me and my children. I value my children’s life more than someone’s taste for a certain breed. They are tickling time bombs. Anyone who thinks otherwise is in denial.