Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know that mumsnetters are very concerned and horrified about the war in Ukraine.

159 replies

BookkeeperBobby · 25/03/2022 23:38

AIBU to ask them to read this article which ime is a fairly accurate account of the impact it has had on Russians? And indeed a fairly accurate account of the impact Putin has had on Russians, at a time when UK/EU/USA governments bolstered him?

www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/03/28/the-russians-fleeing-putins-wartime-crackdown

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/03/2022 04:58

@Thebestwaytoscareatorynot sure what your point is. Do u think there should be no sanctions against Russia for the attack on Ukraine? I didn’t agree with the war in Iraq same as many in the U.K. but as I am based in the U.K. I am hardly going to want to sanction myself!

Then you're a hypocrite. Either it is wrong to invade a county on nonsensical grounds, or it isn't. In fact, I would argue there is more justification for the Russian invasion of Ukraine, given that they are next door neighbours and Ukraine has Russian supporting regions within it, than for the West to invade a country 1000s of miles away because a Saudi national and his international terrorist cell (that was initially founded, funded, and trained by the west) may have been hiding in the border regions of said country.

@Thebestwaytoscareatory- Ukraine was first invaded six years ago and Russian supported violence has been going on since that time. Uncontrolled violence in 2018 though? Who makes those claims?

particularly in the occupied regions there were issues. But generally civil society was improving despite the attacks.

I literally said in that post. Amnesty International, Freedom House, and Human Rights Watch made the claims. The UN women's organisation also raised concerns after a study in 2017 (I think) by them found that 75+% of women with partners had experienced physical or sexual violence in the previous 12 months. Ukraine was and is not some golden paradise it western ideals.

Also "Russia supported violence" is a fairly recent take on the euromaiden movement and subsequent "Revolution of Dignity". Until very recently the narrative was split and documentaries like Ukraine on Fire were being praised for telling the story of those in the Donbas regions as they tried to fight for their right to self determination. Funny how quickly narratives change when those in power decide they should.

Lucymay2113 · 26/03/2022 04:56

This isn't the place to discuss things like this. Post will probably be taken down

Turningpurple · 26/03/2022 04:52

You responded to my comment and I did not moan that mumsnetters didn't do something 20 years ago. I mentioned that because of an incident in 2001 we saw fit to decimate an entire region for 20+ years. At no point in that time did anyone call for sanctions on us for our actions. Even now we are still involved in fucking up that region (selling arms, expertise, and support to various belligerents, or in the case of America taking direct military action) but there's still no call to sanction anyone.

Yes you did. Your post specifications talked about MNers reactions. Your post said there was ZERO outcry from the good posters mumsnet as the West lay waste

How is that not moaning the MNers didn't do something 20 years ago? And that's particular part is the part I responded to. Which is why I quoted it.

But I was talking about the situation in general, you read "Saudi terror attack" and decided I was speaking solely about 2001. I wasn't.

Again you mentioned a specific incident. I asked did you mean 9/11? You said because a single terrorist organisation with links to the region carried out an attack on the good old US of A. You said an attack. As in one.

Again, the part I was commenting on was the part I quoted in my first post.

No of course not, but in the same vein I don't think people should call for sanctions against other countries if they're not willing to have them imposed on themselves for the same actions. If you think Russia should be sanctioned for invading Ukraine then you should think the UK should be sanctioned for invading...well everywhere. If you're argument against that is "Russia are doing it now though" then fine, but you should be calling for the UK to pursue a strictly defensive military strategy from now on and do away with any offensive capability

No one is willing to have sanctions imposed on themselves. Sanctions impact normal people trying to live their lives. Even when people disagree with their governments decisions, they aren't going to push to have themsel3vs pushed into poverty. Or even ask for it.

I absolutely think we were wrong. I think we should have faced sanctions. Because that's how, it apparently, works. Again, I commented on the specific bit I quoted. That you can not compare a forums recatoon 20 years ago to its reactions today, when it's alot more popular and mainstream and there's been a huge turnover of posters.

No, your interpretation was ridiculous. As mentioned I was not talking about a specific event 20 years ago, I was talking about the entirety of the past 20+ years. And again, I still don't see anyone arguing that we should pay for what we did during that time.

Again, your position of 'mn thought this 20 years ago with completely different posters' is ridiculous. I quoted the part I was commenting on that specifically mentioned MNers and a specific incident.

Not an original no, but near and no people have not changed really. There is, and always has been, the presumption that the western way of life is the ideal and that any other way is various degrees of wrong, ranging from the tolerable to the "that shouldn't be allowed". Why do you think Russia are perpetually painted as the "bad guys"? It's quite simply because they do not embrace the western ideal of "freedom" (lol) and "democracy" (double lol), same reason China, Iran, Iraq, Syria, etc are considered baddies

That doesn't even address what I said, which you went to the effort of copying and pasting. Which said you haven't noticed people have come and gone? You haven't noticed there are new posters, new people.

Theres people who were kids 20 years ago who now post. You are seriously suggesting that this site, has all the same people.

You may think attitudes are the same. I disagree because you say people didn't talk about how sanctions would have happened if we were anyone else. But you can't honestly think its the same posters for 20 years.

overnightangel · 26/03/2022 04:42

@noblegiraffe

How would you prefer that the appalling invasion of Ukraine by Russian forces is bought to a halt?

Boots on the ground by NATO allies?
Sanctions on Russia meaning they can't afford to run the war?

Or perhaps you think the invasion is justified and should just be allowed to go ahead?

Which is it?

That’s called “whataboutery”, and it just diminishes your argument I’m afraid
Carpy899 · 26/03/2022 04:40

So many edgelords on here

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/03/2022 04:36

The comment I responded to moaned that 20 years ago MNers didn't do something. The comment specifically mentioned a certain period in time.

You responded to my comment and I did not moan that mumsnetters didn't do something 20 years ago. I mentioned that because of an incident in 2001 we saw fit to decimate an entire region for 20+ years. At no point in that time did anyone call for sanctions on us for our actions. Even now we are still involved in fucking up that region (selling arms, expertise, and support to various belligerents, or in the case of America taking direct military action) but there's still no call to sanction anyone.

I didn't talk about the situation in general. I replied to a comment about MN and posters reactions at a specific time.

But I was talking about the situation in general, you read "Saudi terror attack" and decided I was speaking solely about 2001. I wasn't.

Woild you expect people to lobby their own MP, to get another country to put sanctions on us?

No of course not, but in the same vein I don't think people should call for sanctions against other countries if they're not willing to have them imposed on themselves for the same actions. If you think Russia should be sanctioned for invading Ukraine then you should think the UK should be sanctioned for invading...well everywhere. If you're argument against that is "Russia are doing it now though" then fine, but you should be calling for the UK to pursue a strictly defensive military strategy from now on and do away with any offensive capability.

It was a ridiculous comment. It was incorrect and failed to take into account that MNers, in the main, will be a totally different group of individuals to 20 years ago or even 10 years ago. Or that the ones that are the same, will have changed. Matured. View the world in an entirely different way, to what they did 20 years ago.

No, your interpretation was ridiculous. As mentioned I was not talking about a specific event 20 years ago, I was talking about the entirety of the past 20+ years. And again, I still don't see anyone arguing that we should pay for what we did during that time.

I take it that you were an original MNer. Joined the site right at the start? You havent noticed people have changed? That posters have come and gone.

Not an original no, but near and no people have not changed really. There is, and always has been, the presumption that the western way of life is the ideal and that any other way is various degrees of wrong, ranging from the tolerable to the "that shouldn't be allowed". Why do you think Russia are perpetually painted as the "bad guys"? It's quite simply because they do not embrace the western ideal of "freedom" (lol) and "democracy" (double lol), same reason China, Iran, Iraq, Syria, etc are considered baddies.

MusicMan65 · 26/03/2022 04:30

I have been very clear in previous posts that some of our compassion and sympathy should also be with ordinary Russian people and Russian soldiers, all of whom are lied to or sent to die or made to suffer due to their brutal murderous dictatorship of a government.

However, the fact remains that Russian citizens are not being bombed and murdered whereas Ukrainian citizens are. The fact also remains that, even if they are conscripts, Russian soldiers are armed combatants invading another country, and therefore legitimate targets for the Ukrainian military. Russian soldiers do have the option, if their consciences start to bother them, of surrendering or defecting or changing sides.

Most of them do not do this, of course, because their families in Russia would be in harm's way from the Russian government. The same thing applies to Russian public figures who refuse to publicly condemn the Russian government for the same perfectly understandable reason.

People in the west are very naive about what living in a dictatorship actually means. Any speech or gesture that here would be viewed as mainstream can cause severe problems in a dictatorship, not just for the person themselves but also for their families.

This may surprise people, but I am not in favour of sacking individuals just because they refuse to publicly condemn Putin. Neither am I in favour of banning RT. If our case is strong enough it can easily withstand the drivel pumped out by RT, which can (if it isn't banned) be seen for the propaganda that it is. "Lord Haw Haw" broadcast to the UK from Nazi Germany throughout WW2 and was not jammed, precisely because the effect was exactly the opposite of what the Nazis intended.

Finally, since Russia has denied free speech to its own citizens, I do not blame Ukraine for shutting down Kremlin mouthpieces within Ukraine, in fact I'm surprised that they didn't do it before. This is a fight to the death with no quarter given, and so everyone in Ukraine (and, I would argue, everywhere else) now has to choose a side. In these circumstances sitting on the fence is no longer an option.

Was Ukraine perfect? Far from it. However, if this is now a choice between two evils, I am very clear myself about which evil is the lesser one of the two.

Villagewaspbyke · 26/03/2022 04:16

@Thebestwaytoscareatory - Ukraine was first invaded six years ago and Russian supported violence has been going on since that time. Uncontrolled violence in 2018 though? Who makes those claims?

particularly in the occupied regions there were issues. But generally civil society was improving despite the attacks.

Villagewaspbyke · 26/03/2022 04:07

@BookkeeperBobby you can’t possibly say that not one single person in Russia believes Putin. Even it it were true (it’s not) what evidence could you have for that.

I don’t think the war is popular in Russia but many do believe and support Putin.

@Thebestwaytoscareatory not sure what your point is. Do u think there should be no sanctions against Russia for the attack on Ukraine? I didn’t agree with the war in Iraq same as many in the U.K. but as I am based in the U.K. I am hardly going to want to sanction myself!

In respect of WW2, we never really confronted the atrocities committed by Russia and the Soviet Union because they did help us win the war. Certainly they never had to confront their past as the Germans did. And they did some awful things since from Stalinism to Chechnya to Afghanistan.

Poland and many other Eastern European countries have welcomed refugees from Ukraine because they suffered so long from Russian control and atrocities committed in and to their countries. Stalin probably murdered more civilians in deliberate acts than hitler, yet hitler is still the archetypal baddie.

Ultimately Ukraine should have the right to self determination and the vicious invasion by Russia must be stopped. The nonsense from Putin about nazis etc should be treated with the contempt it deserves.

Turningpurple · 26/03/2022 04:05

All I know is, if I felt strongly enough to start a thread on a really important situation, then I wouldn’t start it so late at night - I’d want maximum potential footfall on the thread.

But not everyone posts for maximum footfall. They post their thoughts at a time that works for them.

Turningpurple · 26/03/2022 04:04

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

Do you mean 9/11? That happened in 2001?

Hadn't mumset only been founded a year before? How popular were the forums in the first few years? And I am pretty sure there's not that many posters who were posting here in 2001/2002 and still here. You are talking about a group of people, where the individuals have changed. There's no comparison.

There will have been thousands and thousands of people come and gone in that time. Lots of people posting now would have been children in 2001.

When I started posting here in 2009,it was often talked about and Condemned. There was lots of people concerned and unhappy about that war. And there were lots of people actively opposed to it and had attended protests etc.

We've been laying waste to the Middle East for over a century (centuries if you count pre-industrial rampages). 2001-2021 was just the latest in a long line of Western attempts at dominating the region. However, focusing on that specific period, I don't recall a single time anyone on mumsnet, or elsewhere for that matter, suggested that sanctions against the UK and/or the West should be imposed for their actions in the region. Imagine what would have happened if China, Russia, Argentina, Mexico, France, etc tried to impose sanctions on the UK and US. At a minimum it would have been vetoed and if that didn’t work ww3 would have been and gone by now. Plenty of people in Russia have attended protests against Putin et al, that hasn't stop the West from fucking them over.

Well mumsnet hasn't been around for centuries.

The comment I responded to moaned that 20 years ago MNers didn't do something. The comment specifically mentioned a certain period in time.

I think plenty did oppose it and talk about it and were concerned about it AND the vast majority of todays MNers were not here at that time.

And yes, actually, lots of people did talk about how if it was other countries there would be sanctions and consequences for their actions. But No one actively seeks out sanctions against their own countries. Woild you expect people to lobby their own MP, to get another country to put sanctions on us?

I didn't talk about the situation in general. I replied to a comment about MN and posters reactions at a specific time.

It was a ridiculous comment. It was incorrect and failed to take into account that MNers, in the main, will be a totally different group of individuals to 20 years ago or even 10 years ago. Or that the ones that are the same, will have changed. Matured. View the world in an entirely different way, to what they did 20 years ago.

I take it that you were an original MNer. Joined the site right at the start? You havent noticed people have changed? That posters have come and gone.

Furries · 26/03/2022 03:56

@EleonorBronte

Im sorry but i dont think the op is a bot because many disagree, i think all points of view have a right to be heard when someone presents their thoughts respectfully.

I dont like the bullying attitude on this website whenever anyone questions a status quo.

I might not agree with someone but they have a right to speak.
Trying to attack and humiliate them is childish and pretty much reveals your own insecurities of belief.

There are many good points in this thread. We should be able to hear details about this war without such black and white thinking and policing.

To berate and as suspicious questions of the op for 'being up late' - get a fucking grip, what the hell are YOU dong up late, acting the bloodhound on a message board?

Ok, I’ll accept that as my failing.

All I know is, if I felt strongly enough to start a thread on a really important situation, then I wouldn’t start it so late at night - I’d want maximum potential footfall on the thread.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/03/2022 03:51

Ukraine has also come along well the past few years, while less than perfect improvements were being made.

So well that Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Freedom House warned that "Ukraine is sinking into a chaos of uncontrolled violence posed by radical groups and their total impunity" after government ties to several far right groups including C14, National Militia, Right Sector, and Karpatska Sich were revealed in 2018 (not long after which C14 launced attacks across the country against international women's day).

Turningpurple · 26/03/2022 03:49

I dont sleep well. Even worse lately. Mum died, i cant sleep much. I slept from 10am until 2.30am.

During this time my mind wonders and I do most of my serious thinking, when the house is quiet.

I dont often start threads on MN. But I am more likely do it at this time. Come 6am, i am and ds is up and i have less time. I didn't realise there were certain hours that are more acceptable than others, to post. Certainly didn't realise that after 13 years of posting, that judgements were placed on me due to that.

LaurenKelsey · 26/03/2022 03:46

@PastMyBestBeforeDate

It's important to distinguish the actions of a state from its people. In any country there are people who disagree with the government. In a democracy they should be able to say that freely. Russia is not a democracy and blaming all Russians is unfair. Western governments are acting against the Russian state.
Very well stated. Your username is brilliant! ☺️
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/03/2022 03:40

Do you mean 9/11? That happened in 2001?

Hadn't mumset only been founded a year before? How popular were the forums in the first few years? And I am pretty sure there's not that many posters who were posting here in 2001/2002 and still here. You are talking about a group of people, where the individuals have changed. There's no comparison.

There will have been thousands and thousands of people come and gone in that time. Lots of people posting now would have been children in 2001.

When I started posting here in 2009,it was often talked about and Condemned. There was lots of people concerned and unhappy about that war. And there were lots of people actively opposed to it and had attended protests etc.

We've been laying waste to the Middle East for over a century (centuries if you count pre-industrial rampages). 2001-2021 was just the latest in a long line of Western attempts at dominating the region. However, focusing on that specific period, I don't recall a single time anyone on mumsnet, or elsewhere for that matter, suggested that sanctions against the UK and/or the West should be imposed for their actions in the region. Imagine what would have happened if China, Russia, Argentina, Mexico, France, etc tried to impose sanctions on the UK and US. At a minimum it would have been vetoed and if that didn’t work ww3 would have been and gone by now. Plenty of people in Russia have attended protests against Putin et al, that hasn't stop the West from fucking them over.

EleonorBronte · 26/03/2022 03:38

DONG Grin

EleonorBronte · 26/03/2022 03:37

Im sorry but i dont think the op is a bot because many disagree, i think all points of view have a right to be heard when someone presents their thoughts respectfully.

I dont like the bullying attitude on this website whenever anyone questions a status quo.

I might not agree with someone but they have a right to speak.
Trying to attack and humiliate them is childish and pretty much reveals your own insecurities of belief.

There are many good points in this thread. We should be able to hear details about this war without such black and white thinking and policing.

To berate and as suspicious questions of the op for 'being up late' - get a fucking grip, what the hell are YOU dong up late, acting the bloodhound on a message board?

BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 03:35

Also: the complete mindless irony of people in the UK - a country that voted for fucking Brexit and a Tory PM who told them "we're all in this together" FOR FUCKS SAKE - jawing on about brainwashed Russians ... nobody in Russia believes their politicians, not one single person. They are more than wise to them. Could do with a bit more of that here.

OP posts:
Villagewaspbyke · 26/03/2022 03:33

It’s not my experience that the average Russian generally doesn’t support Putin. Young international journalists such as in the article you posted don’t but ime many average Russians do. Not all of course and that doesn’t mean that all Russian people are the enemy. I opposed the second Iraq war and demonstrated against it but ultimately other countries would have been justified in sanctions against the UK to stop it as it was illegal imo.

It’s true we didn’t care as much about Russian atrocities in other further away countries like Syria, Georgia, etc. But it’s entirely reasonable for an attack on a state on the border of NATO and the EU to be particularly concerning to people in the uK. It has direct consequences for us.

The nonsense you post about Zelensky and neo nazis is complete rubbish and you are either naïve or spreading deliberate propaganda. Zelensky was supported by an oligarth, yes but he is certainly no neo nazi. Ukraine has also come along well the past few years, while less than perfect improvements were being made.

There are a some far right groups in Ukraine but actually much fewer than in Russia (for example). Actually the attitudes to the far right in Ukraine are much less favourable than somewhere like Poland.

Ultimately though Ukraine and the Ukrainian people have made it clear that they want their own self determination and to align themselves with NATO and the EU. That’s their choice.

Putin is perhaps not mad but certainly bad. The speeches he makes about Ukraine not being a real country etc to justify the attacks tell us really why he is attacking. He wants to control Ukraine against the wishes of the Ukrainian people. We must stop him.

Furries · 26/03/2022 03:31

[quote BookkeeperBobby]@Furries I'm sorry but I think you're suspicious because you're posting outside of office hours and therefore I am unable to engage with you.[/quote]
🤣🤣

Fair point, in a way. Guess I’d approach it differently. If I had an important question to ask, I wouldn’t do it late at night - I’d post during the day to hopefully garner more traffic (maybe with a disclaimer that I’m a night owl, so may not respond until later that night).

BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 03:30

@Stopsnowing it is, isn't it. This is the Russia that I know and that was on my feeds till the bastards shut it down. A restless diverse questioning group of people who refuse to be pinned to their state.

OP posts:
Stopsnowing · 26/03/2022 03:26

The New Yorker piece is good.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/03/2022 03:26

How would you prefer that the appalling invasion of Ukraine by Russian forces is bought to a halt?

Boots on the ground by NATO allies?
Sanctions on Russia meaning they can't afford to run the war?

Or perhaps you think the invasion is justified and should just be allowed to go ahead?

Which is it?

I don't know if this was directed at me or the OP but as far as I'm concerned no invasion is justified. What Russia are doing in Ukraine is as bad as what we did in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Korea, South Africa, Australia, India, Pakistan, and so on and so on. The difference is when we do it we expect the world to sit back and pretend what we are doing is OK and/or justified. If a Russia, China, Iran, etc do it then they are monsters and must be stopped.

It's the hypocrisy that gets me, if we are sanctioning Russia for what they are doing in Ukraine then surely we should be sanctioning ourselves for our actions across the globe?

Imagine what would have happened if Russia or China took the view that our actions in the Middle East were appalling and decided to intervene. I very much doubt anyone on mumsnet would have been saying how righteous and justified Iraq or Afghanistan was for standing up against the Western onslaught and that the UK and America should be sanctioned to the hilt for it.

As for what should happen then either we should let Russia and Ukraine get on with it and accept the outcome, or we should lead by example and lay down our own arms and declare that never again will the West get involved in a conflict that does not directly threaten us. However given the fact that the US economy is intrinsically linked to war, and the fact that we are their lap dogs, I can't see that ever happening. As far as the West is concerned war is money war is profit, war is good, and war is vital.

BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 03:26

@Furries I'm sorry but I think you're suspicious because you're posting outside of office hours and therefore I am unable to engage with you.

OP posts: