Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know that mumsnetters are very concerned and horrified about the war in Ukraine.

159 replies

BookkeeperBobby · 25/03/2022 23:38

AIBU to ask them to read this article which ime is a fairly accurate account of the impact it has had on Russians? And indeed a fairly accurate account of the impact Putin has had on Russians, at a time when UK/EU/USA governments bolstered him?

www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/03/28/the-russians-fleeing-putins-wartime-crackdown

OP posts:
BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 11:58

Some Russians are yes. Ordinary Russians are banned from it now though and can face four years' hard labour if caught. There are reports of people receiving threatening WhatsApp messages from the police this last month. That's why they are leaving. Because Putin is not a nice man and the Russian state doesn't give you notice before it knocks on your door.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 26/03/2022 11:53

@BookkeeperBobby

Quite amused that I'm seen as a Russian bot tho. Lol cheers for that. I'm not Russian but the arms of the state are long in Russia and let's just say Russians are facing four years hard labour for going on social media rn so I'm not about to disclose my Russian connections.
Russians are also paid to go on social media and spread Russian propaganda, aren't they?
IncompleteSenten · 26/03/2022 11:52

You know, it is possible for both leaders to be absolute arseholes and it still be unacceptable to invade. Is it important that Putin = bad and zelenskiy = good? Or can we agree that what matters is what is happening, not the characters of the leaders?

CPL593H · 26/03/2022 11:50

[quote BookkeeperBobby]@grannysbay yes when people get too big for their boots Putin hammers them. Zelenskiy is just one more. We're paying more attention to him because of how he's positioned himself. He was stupid enough to think that meant we'd give him a no fly zone. Against a nuclear power? Give me a break. The man's a fool.[/quote]
I think the first line of this is extremely telling.

BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 11:48

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches middle class Russians haven't done great under Putin. Middle class Brits on the other hand have done very well indeed : "Ooh, my house has gone up in value by £100,000 since I bought it, ooh isn't it just crazy? I can't work out what's going on with the property market."

OP posts:
LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 26/03/2022 11:46

@BookkeeperBobby

Yes it is v like Ireland which makes all the bellyaching about it from our government worse. Zelenskiy has been quite content for his little band of neo Nazis to wreak absolute havoc on the border really up to all sorts displacing and killing and torturing it has been really bad for eight years. And you can argue that Russians shouldn't have been there but would you likewise argue that English shouldn't have been in the six counties. See it is not so straightforward.
Isn't it difficult to be accepted by neo-Nazis if your family is Jewish? I'd heard that there is something of a divide.

With his Jewish heritage, how would Zelenskiy be allowed to lead such a 'band'?

Are you a Putin-bot BookkeeperBobby?

BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 11:41

@Flyingteaspoon I've already given you a link to a report on the Azov battalion which is the official neo Nazi arm of the Ukrainian state forces. It was written during the time when the UK media were still fairly critical of the Ukrainian government. Here it is again. And to reiterate, Ukraine is the only country in the world that has a neo Nazi battalion. Not the only country that has neo Nazis of course, but the only one that has them as legitimate actors in state conflicts. Two countries have exercised a veto from the UN resolution against state utilisation of neo Nazis: Ukraine and the USA.

static.guim.co.uk/images/favicon-32x32.ico

Of course this does not mean that Zelenskiy is a Nazi or that all Ukrainians are Nazis. This is a very specific battalion tasked in a specific region. But they are state neo Nazis. Sticking your fingers in your ears and chanting about Zelenskiy being Jewish does nothing to alter that fact and Putin is busily capitalising on it all the time that commentators fail to address it.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 26/03/2022 11:30

Talking about Zelensky 'sucking Trump's cock' when Trump was impeached for trying to get Zelensky to investigate Hunter Biden is a bit odd.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 26/03/2022 11:28

But it's clear what the OP of this thread is about. None of it good.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 26/03/2022 11:26

I don't think all Russian shoulder the blame but likewise It's far too simplistic to say this is all down to Putin. Many Russians, and I'm not talking about the oligarch class but rather the affluent middle classes, have done very well out of Putin's Russia over the years and have been happy to turn a blind eye to his crimes against their own people.

IncompleteSenten · 26/03/2022 11:07

@Flyingteaspoon

I totally agree that an entire nation shouldn’t be demonised for the actions of its government though. We would have to right off the whole of Israel, Afghanistan, North Korea, China which would be ridiculous as the majority of the citizens of these countries are just going about their lives without wishing harm on anyone, while their governments wreak chaos and misery.
Exactly. And through history - the Germans, the British (the British empire was fucking brutal globally. How many people did we kill? How many people were proud of being British. Sun never sets. Rule Britannia. Blah blah blah) etc. We shouldn't as you say demonise entire populations. Nor should we cast the first stone when it comes to ordinary people not marching to their leaders, breaking down doors and booting them out when they commit atrocities or simply being apathetic letting wrongs go unchallenged. Or picking a powerless group and blaming them for the country's problems instead of looking to where the actual problem is.

Putin needs to be got rid of. He's dangerous. But it's his generals that have the chance to do it, not some poor bastard in Omsk just trying to make ends meet and feeling utterly powerless or believing the narrative they're being fed.

Villagewaspbyke · 26/03/2022 11:02

I doubt anyone thinks all Russian people are bad or at fault anyway though. Of course they are not.

Villagewaspbyke · 26/03/2022 10:58

@BookkeeperBobby your suggestion that Ukraine is like Ireland and Zelensky is a neo Nazi are pretty detached from reality. There is a debate to be had but a major tactic of Putin is disinformation and whataboutery (comes from Soviet Union originally). People are suffering horrendously in Ukraine and it’s a key fight for the self determination of Eastern Europeans. We should be wary of conspiracy theories and nonsense. That’s not debate.

Flyingteaspoon · 26/03/2022 10:51

I totally agree that an entire nation shouldn’t be demonised for the actions of its government though. We would have to right off the whole of Israel, Afghanistan, North Korea, China which would be ridiculous as the majority of the citizens of these countries are just going about their lives without wishing harm on anyone, while their governments wreak chaos and misery.

Flyingteaspoon · 26/03/2022 10:46

So a Jewish Ukraine president is supporting a neo-nazi force

This his me baffled too. Zelensky is Jewish. His family were killed in the Holocaust. How or why would you think he is a neo-Nazi OP?

Villagewaspbyke · 26/03/2022 10:44

@FrecklesMalone absolutely. Stalin did his absolute best to destroy Poland. They were no liberators.

Villagewaspbyke · 26/03/2022 10:42

@Thebestwaytoscareatory - yeah I’m a hypocrite for saying it would be perfectly fair for other countries to sanction us to stop the Iraq war but not suggesting it myself. Or I’m self interested and don’t want to starve.

If HRW, Amnesty and Freedom House really all said (apparently exactly the same thing) about all of Ukraine sliding into lawless violence in 2018, please post links. I was there in that time and certainly not anything like my experience of the country.

FrecklesMalone · 26/03/2022 10:41

[quote BookkeeperBobby]@FrecklesMalone Russians also lost vast numbers of people in WWII ofc. 27 million approximately although the true number will never be known. Those deaths stopped Hitler. Not plucky little Britain with its alcoholic faded grandiose PM who turned the troops on the workers. It was Russian boys' bodies piling up in the snow that put an end to the third Reich while Russian citizens dropped dead of starvation in the streets of st Petersburg. Without that, Britain would have been completely fucked.[/quote]
I'm not really British so don't hold nostalgic illusions about Britain. You have to ask why so many poor Russians died? The blame lies fairly equally between the horrific policies of the German third Reich and a Russian government who didn't care about the lives of their poorly equipped and trained soldiers. They used them as cannon fodder. However the idea that Russia was the liberator of Poland is a fucking joke as anyone that then had to live behind the Russian controlled iron curtains knows.

TheKeatingFive · 26/03/2022 08:02

No matter which way the war goes from there on, ordinary Russian people should be under no illusion that the rest of the world will neither forgive nor forget who the aggressor was in that story. And how popular Putin was back home. "Democratically" elected and all that.

Quite

RobotValkyrie · 26/03/2022 07:58

I'm sure ordinary German citizens were also suffering badly during WW2. More so than Russian people today, in fact.
Didn't excuse the camps.

And ordinary Russian suffering pales in comparison to the atrocities committed in Ukraine today, especially in Mariupol. This place has "crime against humanity" written all over it.
No matter which way the war goes from there on, ordinary Russian people should be under no illusion that the rest of the world will neither forgive nor forget who the aggressor was in that story. And how popular Putin was back home. "Democratically" elected and all that.

Theluggage15 · 26/03/2022 07:53

You’re just a sad little Russian shill OP. Just go away and kiss your poster of Putin.

Tombero · 26/03/2022 07:46

@BookkeeperBobby

Also: the complete mindless irony of people in the UK - a country that voted for fucking Brexit and a Tory PM who told them "we're all in this together" FOR FUCKS SAKE - jawing on about brainwashed Russians ... nobody in Russia believes their politicians, not one single person. They are more than wise to them. Could do with a bit more of that here.
So you share an article (which was interesting to read so thanks at least for that) in order for us to understand that Russia is a nuanced country. To explain that there is dissent, people know what their leaders are, that it is not a one dimensional story. Something I hope most of us understand and I’m sure most of us feel concern and compassion for the Russian people too.

Then, in direct contradiction to what you’re asking us to understand about Russians, you categorise the whole of the UK as “mindless” Brexit voting Tory voters? When everyone knows how divisive both of those are in reality and that this too is nuanced. But you can happily lump us together as a country with shared thought?

And I’m not even going to dignify some of your other, more extreme comments with repeating them.

baroqueandblue · 26/03/2022 07:39

And you can argue that Russians shouldn't have been there

... and consequently show your OP up for the drivel it was.

Grow up Hmm

FarangGirl · 26/03/2022 07:23

@IncompleteSenten

He does? Where does that info come from? Is it actual support or "I don't want to vanish so I'm going to say I support" support?
It might be overestimated but there's no doubt that his support is increasing.

www.levada.ru/en/ratings/

Polyanthus2 · 26/03/2022 07:23

@Carpy899

Judging from twitter there seems to be a huge crossover with covid nutters and those who parrot this pro Russian bollocks.
Yes, apparently the QAnon, moved onto vaccine deniers, now they're pro Russia.