Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know that mumsnetters are very concerned and horrified about the war in Ukraine.

159 replies

BookkeeperBobby · 25/03/2022 23:38

AIBU to ask them to read this article which ime is a fairly accurate account of the impact it has had on Russians? And indeed a fairly accurate account of the impact Putin has had on Russians, at a time when UK/EU/USA governments bolstered him?

www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/03/28/the-russians-fleeing-putins-wartime-crackdown

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
2Gen · 26/03/2022 18:30

@BookkeeperBobby

But actually what we all need to do - but never will - is support our fellow small person whether Russian or Ukrainian or whatever. This war is the same as all wars, waged to secure power for people who already have power. Your average Ukrainian will be no better off at the end of it. They weren't very well off to begin with given they lived in a country ruled by an oligarch. Your average Russian ditto. No good will come of it. Loads of people will die and it's all completely pointless. The only thing any of us bystanders can do is hear the stories of people caught in it and pressure our governments to do better.
Yes, I agree. It's always the little people who suffer in war, whilst the rich and powerful make their grabs. It's also said that extremely wealthy entities financed both sides of most of the wars of the last 100 years and have made huge profits from these wars, which wouldn't surprise me. Putin is a member of the WEF, along with people like Trudeau and NZ's Jacinda Aderne, which is something to think about too. I fell sorry for all the little people caught up in this, especially the children and I pray for peace. I can't help believe it has all been planned and orchestrated by very powerful and nefarious entities that stand to gain even more power and wealth, regardless of who wins. They will win and the all the little people, Ukranian, Russian and us in the West because of rabid inflation and shortages, will loose. God help us.
CailleachGranda · 26/03/2022 16:25

@TooBigForMyBoots

But the monolithic partisanship of the msm across radio, television and paper inthiscountry is still upsetting and frankly quite alarming.

What do you mean? Where are you?

Which country?

India?
South Africa?

TooBigForMyBoots · 26/03/2022 16:22

But the monolithic partisanship of the msm across radio, television and paper inthiscountry is still upsetting and frankly quite alarming.

What do you mean? Where are you?

SuperSocks · 26/03/2022 16:10

The Russian state treats its people most cruelly. And of course Russians know this. Of course they do. You would have to be a fool or a moron to think otherwise and Russians are neither. They know.

Why on earth do they keep having children then?

CailleachGranda · 26/03/2022 16:07

@BookkeeperBobby

Putin invaded Ukraine in 2014. Nobody gave a crap about it until Zelenskiy got enough bent money behind him that he was able to sweet talk NATO.
Seriously?

Transparent.

Notonthestairs · 26/03/2022 15:40

Rod Atkinson has produced an interesting segment on the Azoz influence (or lack thereof)

9 mins on the untruths and distortions that Russia is spreading about 'Nazis' in Ukraine - including about the role of the Azov regiment of Ukraine’s National Guard. Produced by Mary Fuller, Michael Cox, Priyanka Deladia

twitter.com/bbcrosatkins/status/1506988213637890048?s=21

DysonSphere · 26/03/2022 15:26

[quote TooBigForMyBoots]@DysonSphere, if you are worried about media partisanship, expand your media sources.[/quote]
Oh believe me I do, I watch news coverage from across the world and across political spheres of interest. You absolutely have to these days, even if it means sometimes watching coverage from outlets whose perspective you usually strongly dislike or disagree with. In Britain there are still a few news outlets you can consume that give a nod to being objective and fact driven.

But the monolithic partisanship of the msm across radio, television and paper in this country is still upsetting and frankly quite alarming.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 26/03/2022 15:17

I'm sure we'll all summon up tons of support and admiration for the Russian people when they get off their arses and sort their country out. But as for now, as their soliders rape and murder innocent women and children with impunity, they can jog on.

Polyanthus2 · 26/03/2022 15:10

I heard on the radio that Russia earns a billion dollars a day from it's oil and gas exports.
So again - why the need to invade other countries. Just sort your own country.

AnakinthePadawhine · 26/03/2022 14:51

Your "poor" Russian soldiers are using rape tactics, firing on civilians and kidnapping them. Unless they start fragging their officers, I will have no pity for them.
I wish for Ukraine to have vast sunflower fields after this war.
Ordinary Russians are vastly in favor of Putin. Maybe because they are misinformed, maybe because they are bought shills like you. Let them feel the hunger and pain of the sanctions, it is only a fraction of what they are gleefully letting Ukrainians suffer.

lljkk · 26/03/2022 14:22

I wish I can remember where... last week i heard a whole summary on the Azov battalion. Their history, their present, their far right links. Historically Excellent fighters that are a small % of whole UA, their reputation as excellent militia attracted people of all views, a tiny % of Azov members hold extremist views.

Too bad Russians are bad at dealing with their native-grown far right extremists.

Meanwhile, Putin gets high approval ratings in Russia.

TooBigForMyBoots · 26/03/2022 14:14

@DysonSphere, if you are worried about media partisanship, expand your media sources.

DysonSphere · 26/03/2022 14:05

Do you truly believe people don't understand the nuances until you've explained them

Casually reading the thread I would say the answer is yes.

Thank you OP for starting this thread and for the ensuing debate. I have been troubled by the partisanship media coverage since the beginning of the war.

maddening · 26/03/2022 13:51

The Russians have not been bravely fighting neo nazis for 8 years at all. The Russians imported to Ukraine after the Russians starved Ukraine under Stalin have been funded and equipped by Russia to cause civil war, the Ukranians have been defending their own land from Russian backed separatists for 8 years.

lighterskies · 26/03/2022 12:53

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

However when your leader invades a next door neighbor in Europe you can't be surprised if the rest of your neighbors react strongly.

Sanctions seem like the least worst option to express strong disapproval.

Ah ok, it is the proximaty that is the issue. If Putin had decided to invade Kenya or Chile we wouldn't give a fuck. Just like when we decimated Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, etc. They're not our neighbours so they don't count as people, no need for sanctions if your killing people outside of Europe, after all we're the only people that matter.

I think it would be unrealistic to imagine that proximity isn't an issue. Because self interest is always going to be part of any political intervention.

If Putin was invading Chile there would be a much stronger involvement from other countries in that region. Who you will notice have not been particularly involved in this European crisis.

This isn't about the inherent worthiness of any group of individuals simply political reality.

Furries · 26/03/2022 12:43

@Nietzschethehiker

Wow I mean I find some of the arrogance on MN surprising but this is absolutely breathtaking. I'm sorry OP are you honestly arrogant or ignorant enough to believe any of this is new information?

Do you truly believe people don't understand the nuances until you've explained them and that anyone has missed your agenda skewed "information"?

I have no problem with different views or opinions. Any war is nuanced. I doubt very much anyone truly believes either side is perfect but there is no avoiding that what Putin has done is abhorrent this time. The whole of human history has behaviours each country has that are not "clean" it doesn't make their further actions automatically without merit.

There has been very little anti Russian sentiment but a plethora of anti putin sentiment , as well as recognition that many leaders have not behaved well.

Truthfully either you are pushing an agenda and not bright enough to do it cleverly, or you are beyond arrogant and genuinely think you are the only one that can think critically. Actually this thread suggests your critical analysis abilities are far lower than you think they are.

Shockingly the actual information is not new. Many people know this. I hate to burst the bubble but you are not more informed or ground breaking.

This x 100.
noblegiraffe · 26/03/2022 12:27

Do you think what you are posting is more akin to what the Russians being paid to spread Russian propaganda are posting, or the Russians who risk being sentenced to hard labour are posting?

TooBigForMyBoots · 26/03/2022 12:18

@BookkeeperBobby

What are you FFS--ing about?

I'm sorry that the world isn't conveniently divided into goodies and baddies for you but at least you're not dying because of this shit.

Thanks for the apology @BookkeeperBobby. Lots of people are dying and will continue to die as long as Putin continues with his war.

Putin is a cunt and he looks like Envy.

MarshmallowSwede · 26/03/2022 12:16

Typo.. it should say it’s on them how people view Russia. *

MarshmallowSwede · 26/03/2022 12:14

So you want us to support Russians? And not be anti Russian?

I would say there’s a huge amount of distrust for Russians in Scandinavia so I doubt we are going to change our viewpoint on Russia any time soon.

Do we hate Russians? Yes some Scandinavians do hate Russians. Some Scandinavians don’t hate Russians. The same as anywhere. A lot of us distrust and take anything coming out of Russia or anything pro Russian with a grain of salt. So I for one won’t be on board with pulling out a tiny violin for “ordinary” Russians.

It’s for them to oust Putin and if they don’t then it’s in them how their nation is viewed and how people grow Russia. I’m not saying people should attack anyone on the street, but don’t expect people to “oh those poor Russians” when that’s not what we feel. I certainly don’t feel that way. And I think you would be hard pressed to find any pro Russian sentiment anywhere in Scandinavia for sure. I can’t speak for the UK, but we haven’t been a fan of Russia for centuries and I don’t see this changing.

workisnotawolf · 26/03/2022 12:13

I read that article and I have many Russian friends and also spent quite a bit of time in Russia in the late 1990s-mid 2000s. The article is a bit of a cliche too though - the intelligentsia has always been against the powers to be in Russia. Russia has had imperialism in different forms for centuries. The Russian people are now well educated and were not badly off as a whole in the last 15 years. There is too much of a culture of what will be will be and too much Mother Russia suffers brainwashing at the deepest levels. Of course Putin is a dictator, but the Russian people also need to wake up from being slaves to dictators for centuries. They are well educated with amazing talents and natural resources and need to free themselves from the shackles of the users at the top.

BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 12:11

@Usou agree there must be a strategic international reason for NATO to have encouraged Putin to step up the war into outright invasion and then condemn him. Maybe he had outgrown his usefulness and got too problematic with the whole gas supply thing. After all it must have been a blow for de pfeffel to have his erstwhile Brexit buddy have such a hold on fiscal policies via energy prices.

OP posts:
BookkeeperBobby · 26/03/2022 12:06

Ok that's great. I must be imagining people who are arguing against what I'm saying then. It's all good.

OP posts:
Usou · 26/03/2022 12:05

Personally, I think the Ukrainian war is a disaster for both Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine will be a wasteland and Russia's international standing will be damaged for decades - unless they can get rid of Poot. Think of all the parents on both sides finding out that their only son is dead. I travelled across Russia about 5 years ago, and found Russians to be decent enough people.

I think your use of the Azov battalion as an excuse to brand Ukrainians as neo-nazis is very weak. A motorized battalion is likely to consist of no more than 1500 people, and probably less than 1000 - a fraction of Ukrainian forces. One could justifiably use the presence of Wagner Group personnel and Chechens to call the Russians Nazis. Militarily they are very effective, not unlike the SS in WW2: highly politically motivated forces are like that.

Personally, I would love to see a future in which Russia and "the west" cooperate to meet the many challenges facing the world, not least climate change, but I expect that will be off the table for a few years - right when it matters.

I also wonder if there are major global powers waiting quietly in the wings for the Russians to dash their state on the rocks of the Ukrainian war, so they can get unrestricted access to all those lovely resources..

Nietzschethehiker · 26/03/2022 12:04

Wow I mean I find some of the arrogance on MN surprising but this is absolutely breathtaking. I'm sorry OP are you honestly arrogant or ignorant enough to believe any of this is new information?

Do you truly believe people don't understand the nuances until you've explained them and that anyone has missed your agenda skewed "information"?

I have no problem with different views or opinions. Any war is nuanced. I doubt very much anyone truly believes either side is perfect but there is no avoiding that what Putin has done is abhorrent this time. The whole of human history has behaviours each country has that are not "clean" it doesn't make their further actions automatically without merit.

There has been very little anti Russian sentiment but a plethora of anti putin sentiment , as well as recognition that many leaders have not behaved well.

Truthfully either you are pushing an agenda and not bright enough to do it cleverly, or you are beyond arrogant and genuinely think you are the only one that can think critically. Actually this thread suggests your critical analysis abilities are far lower than you think they are.

Shockingly the actual information is not new. Many people know this. I hate to burst the bubble but you are not more informed or ground breaking.