Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I enter the NHS as a trainee nurse if I am gender critical?

142 replies

Balicious · 25/03/2022 14:17

I have been offered a place on a nursing degree apprenticeship within a GP surgery. Since I applied I have watched YouTube videos that GP nurses have posted in relation to the trans healthcare they have to provide. It appears the NHS is pro-trans and since the scandal came out about the rape on a NHS ward and the gaslighting of a patient following this assault, I am rethinking entering the NHS at all. Please help! I am deeply concerned about gender ideology and the effects it is having on women and children. I must admit I would struggle to treat anyone under the age of 18 with hormone blockers/hormonal injections. Will I struggle in the NHS with these views? Am I nursing material or should I reconsider? Honest opinions will be greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
Millicent2022 · 25/03/2022 17:10

Please don’t

Blossomtoes · 25/03/2022 17:09

Absolutely brilliant post @acrimoniousone. The perfect summary of the bottom line.

maddening · 25/03/2022 17:03

The more gc people in there the better!

Tortabella · 25/03/2022 16:51

I dont think the trans narrative will keep its grip for the amount of years you'd spend in the profession tbh.

This is a good point. I don't see the next wave of primary school kids being so readily swayed, they are already different.

housemaus · 25/03/2022 16:50

If you think you won't be able to treat patients due to broader ideological differences then no, I don't think nursing is for you. You will treat plenty of people whose politics are different to yours, who have committed crimes, who are racist or sexist or homophobic or misogynist.

If it's that you can't handle treating a person with the medical care prescribed to them by a doctor because you think their treatment should be different, then I suggest perhaps you go to medical school and become a doctor and make care decisions in order with your own views, or perhaps find a way onto the General Medical Council to make your views known. Otherwise, your job is to treat the patient as their doctor has prescribed*, not to pass judgement on whether or not you personally would treat them that way.

*I know nurses have clinical decisions to make, too, but that isn't relevant in this specific scenario.

cushioncovers · 25/03/2022 16:50

Plenty of nhs staff have their own personal views on all sorts of things. You just leave it at home and act in a professional manner at work.

KELLOGSspeck · 25/03/2022 16:46

@Elsiebear90

I am clinical in the NHS (not a nurse) trust me someone being trans will be the least of your worries, you will have to treat rapists and murderers, people who are that rude and aggressive you’re scared they’re going to attack you (and some do), people who verbally abuse you, make disgusting sexual comments about you etc. You need to be able to put your opinions about that person to one side and offer the same standard of care you would to any patient, if you can’t do that then a patient facing role isn’t for you.
Well put. I was thinking the exact same line.... after a 13hour shift .... least of your worries!
FabFitFifties · 25/03/2022 16:44

Are you doing child or adult nursing OP? Would you feel more comfortable in adult nursing, with regards to informed consent etc? If you feel you still couldn't provide prescribed treatment, then maybe you do need to think again. It points to putting your own beliefs and feelings before your patient's. There maybe other scenarios where you feel the same, but don't know it yet. You will, at some point in your career, have to provide care with compassion and respect, to people who have very different beliefs, or who have done truly hideous things.

Elsiebear90 · 25/03/2022 16:40

I am clinical in the NHS (not a nurse) trust me someone being trans will be the least of your worries, you will have to treat rapists and murderers, people who are that rude and aggressive you’re scared they’re going to attack you (and some do), people who verbally abuse you, make disgusting sexual comments about you etc. You need to be able to put your opinions about that person to one side and offer the same standard of care you would to any patient, if you can’t do that then a patient facing role isn’t for you.

DamnUserName21 · 25/03/2022 16:40

Don't people get the hormones once they've been prescribed through their GP and perhaps sometimes need help?

Hormone injections to trans persons are administered at the practice I work so yep.

SolasAnla · 25/03/2022 16:38

acrimoniousone that behaviour was disgraceful everybody deserves the simple recognition of being called their name. If a HCP cant be minimally professional how could they obtain consent (when possible) of their patient.

OP nursing is a dont bring your full self to work job. So if you are going into a profession such as nursing you need to be able to treat the person in front of you in accordance with its professional ethics.
If you are unable to do that then nursing is not the profession for you.

If you are unsure, if your personal ethics align with the professional nursing ethics you need to do your research first.
If you are conscious objector its up to you to find out what guidance must you follow to ensure that your choices as a nurse is not detriment to the paitent care.
If your objection is to a specific cource of treatments is ethical and allowed within nursing you would need to discuss this with your training orginisation and the GPs you will be working in, if they wish to facilitate your limits and provide cover that their choice.
But IMO a GP is a little like A&E in that the HCP ends up having to deal with whoever comes through the door. However unlike A&E in the GPs the doctor is the first point of contact and is directing any treatments. Nevertheless the paitent deserves to be treated professionally if you feel your personal ethics do not allow that then nursing is not the profession for you.

Pyewhacket · 25/03/2022 16:36

I work in the NHS and unless you work in that particular area I doubt you’ll even be involved other than that you treat all patients the same, you won’t have time to do otherwise.

SomePosters · 25/03/2022 16:27

Depends if you can leave your personal opinions at home to do the job properly

Medical care isn’t something you get to be a bigot about from treating enemy soldiers on the front lines to providing abortion healthcare it doesn’t matter what you think of the individual and their life choices, it matters that you can do your job anyway

Darkstar4855 · 25/03/2022 16:26

If you can’t leave your personal beliefs at the door and treat patients accordingly then no, it’s not for you.

DelurkingLawyer · 25/03/2022 16:21

I quite agree that one should leave one’s politics and personal opinions at the door and treat all patients with respect irrespective of their views.

Here’s how the LGBTQ+ staff network of a major London trust approached that important matter: “no TERFS allowed.” It was not clear whether this referred to staff, or patients, or both.

The Trust’s response was that it treated all patients with dignity and respect (good) but implied that the earlier tweet was somehow justified because it “followed a previous instance of online abuse directed at our LGBTQ+ network.“ So much for leaving politics at the door.

twitter.com/NoXYinXXprisons/status/1505262848515223552?s=20&t=h91-UIQ9sJwlbK9uJ7JD8Q

Should I enter the NHS as a trainee nurse if I am gender critical?
DaffTheDoggo · 25/03/2022 16:20

@Nousernameforme

Trainee nurse is it bollocks it's a troll looking for screen shots
I wondered about this as well, especially using the term "pro-trans", as if GC equals anti-trans.
Crispyturtle · 25/03/2022 16:18

I you think your personal beliefs should interfere with another persons access to healthcare, then no, you are not nursing material.

Fluffycloudland77 · 25/03/2022 16:18

The sensible thing to do with a nursing degree is train to do botox and fillers afterwards & work self employed doing that.

Branleuse · 25/03/2022 16:14

Im gender critical and i dont think this would even be relevent in your day to day life unless you specialised in that area. On a day to day basis you would treat everybody with dignity and respect whether you agree with them or not. No matter who they are, what theyve done or what they believe. If you dont think you could manage that then dont go into nursing.

Georgeskitchen · 25/03/2022 16:14

In the 80s I had a Catholic GP who refused to prescribe the pill!!

Verv · 25/03/2022 16:12

I dont think the trans narrative will keep its grip for the amount of years you'd spend in the profession tbh.

I think go for it, you dont have to drink the Kool Aid, you just have to treat all patients with due care and respect, regardless of personal opinion.
Most people in customer facing jobs have to do the same thing.

iolaus · 25/03/2022 16:09

If it is only under 18s that you would think you would have a problem with treating then if you were an adult nurse that shouldnt come into it at all, and even paediatric nurses I believe it would be those who had specialised (though during training you may have time on that speciality - unlikely though)

And in fairness it seems like it's actually conducting care directly relating to transitioning rather than caring for someone who has transitioned/is transitioning - ie someone who is trans but has broken their leg I'm assuming you wouldn't have an issue with treating the broken leg - to me this is no different that those who opt out of abortion care - they can't object to caring for someone who has had an abortion, or is going to have an abortion - but they can object to being the person who is directly involved (ie give the medication to)

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 25/03/2022 16:08

If you've been accepted onto a degree course apprenticeship then I assume you've already been recruited in line with the values of the NHS constitution.

TabithaTittlemouse · 25/03/2022 16:02

@acrimoniousone

Ex-nurse, first post. Nerve touched.

I worked in ICU (fun fact - it's brilliant for newly qualified nurses but they are frequently scared off) and had a patient who attempted suicide. Although they survived it wasn't a cry for help and they suffered devastating injuries. The patient was no longer able to live with their immediate family's rejection of their chosen gender identity.

This led to a bizzare situation where some staff supported the patients' choice and others sympathised with the parents views - this person was over eighteen but still at home. It led to stupidity such as the patient's name above their bed being changed with the shift.

I thought it was fucking disgusting and advocated for the patient. This young adult had horrific trauma both physical and mental - this wasn't attention-seeking but a miraculous survival. I had sympathy for the parents but their principles mattered more than the child desperately reaching out to them. To see this supported by a majority of staff - well, I didn't work there much longer.

They made a reasonable recovery but it was life changing injuries. It is hard - in ICU your patients are, on the whole, asleep or out of it so the main interaction is with the family and of course you build a connection.

But it is never the place of a nurse to make value judgements when it is related to a patient. They should always advocate for their patient and respect their choices. This was a few years ago and hopefully it may have improved now but I will never forget it.

I also won't forget the rampant bullying from both staff and patients, the appalling starving of the NHS over many years and the abysmal care I have both observed and received. And it wasn't that long ago.

You will notice I don't mention my own views on transgender issues. Because it doesn't (or shouldn't) fucking matter. If you can't stow your opinions you shouldn't be even thinking about nursing, it's no different to views on abortion.

Excellent post.

(Also a nurse)

Nousernameforme · 25/03/2022 15:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.