Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I enter the NHS as a trainee nurse if I am gender critical?

142 replies

Balicious · 25/03/2022 14:17

I have been offered a place on a nursing degree apprenticeship within a GP surgery. Since I applied I have watched YouTube videos that GP nurses have posted in relation to the trans healthcare they have to provide. It appears the NHS is pro-trans and since the scandal came out about the rape on a NHS ward and the gaslighting of a patient following this assault, I am rethinking entering the NHS at all. Please help! I am deeply concerned about gender ideology and the effects it is having on women and children. I must admit I would struggle to treat anyone under the age of 18 with hormone blockers/hormonal injections. Will I struggle in the NHS with these views? Am I nursing material or should I reconsider? Honest opinions will be greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
QuebecBagnet · 25/03/2022 18:19

@Crystalvas I work as a university lecturer. We have a nursing apprenticeship programme which is separate to the normal nursing degree. There are also midwifery apprenticeship courses now.

Crystalvas · 25/03/2022 18:18

[quote anotherbrewplease]@Crystalvas

There are apprenticeship pathways to being a staff nurse in the NHS Trust I work in.[/quote]
Is that not nurse axilleries.

Crystalvas · 25/03/2022 18:10

@QuebecBagnet

That’s incorrect. Nursing apprenticeship are definitely a thing and are a split between uni and work. They’ve been brought back.
As far as im aware the training placements are part if the uni degree. No such thing as a nursing apprentiship.
godmum56 · 25/03/2022 17:59

@acrimoniousone

Ex-nurse, first post. Nerve touched.

I worked in ICU (fun fact - it's brilliant for newly qualified nurses but they are frequently scared off) and had a patient who attempted suicide. Although they survived it wasn't a cry for help and they suffered devastating injuries. The patient was no longer able to live with their immediate family's rejection of their chosen gender identity.

This led to a bizzare situation where some staff supported the patients' choice and others sympathised with the parents views - this person was over eighteen but still at home. It led to stupidity such as the patient's name above their bed being changed with the shift.

I thought it was fucking disgusting and advocated for the patient. This young adult had horrific trauma both physical and mental - this wasn't attention-seeking but a miraculous survival. I had sympathy for the parents but their principles mattered more than the child desperately reaching out to them. To see this supported by a majority of staff - well, I didn't work there much longer.

They made a reasonable recovery but it was life changing injuries. It is hard - in ICU your patients are, on the whole, asleep or out of it so the main interaction is with the family and of course you build a connection.

But it is never the place of a nurse to make value judgements when it is related to a patient. They should always advocate for their patient and respect their choices. This was a few years ago and hopefully it may have improved now but I will never forget it.

I also won't forget the rampant bullying from both staff and patients, the appalling starving of the NHS over many years and the abysmal care I have both observed and received. And it wasn't that long ago.

You will notice I don't mention my own views on transgender issues. Because it doesn't (or shouldn't) fucking matter. If you can't stow your opinions you shouldn't be even thinking about nursing, it's no different to views on abortion.

Not just nursing but any NHS clinical post. I am shocked by @acrimoniousone's post, that any patient should experience such appalling treatment. Its not the same but round me the isssue used to be fox hunting. I live in a BIG bloodsports area and many of the homes I used to visit would show (to me) gruesome evidence of this. While I did judge in my head, I never showed a hint of this by my behaviour and anybody who can't do the same doesn't belong in clinical care whether NHS or private.
CoraggioCara · 25/03/2022 17:56

@acrimoniousone thank you for your post. I found it very insightful. I hope things got better for your patient.

LeftFootForward · 25/03/2022 17:56

@acrimoniousone

Ex-nurse, first post. Nerve touched.

I worked in ICU (fun fact - it's brilliant for newly qualified nurses but they are frequently scared off) and had a patient who attempted suicide. Although they survived it wasn't a cry for help and they suffered devastating injuries. The patient was no longer able to live with their immediate family's rejection of their chosen gender identity.

This led to a bizzare situation where some staff supported the patients' choice and others sympathised with the parents views - this person was over eighteen but still at home. It led to stupidity such as the patient's name above their bed being changed with the shift.

I thought it was fucking disgusting and advocated for the patient. This young adult had horrific trauma both physical and mental - this wasn't attention-seeking but a miraculous survival. I had sympathy for the parents but their principles mattered more than the child desperately reaching out to them. To see this supported by a majority of staff - well, I didn't work there much longer.

They made a reasonable recovery but it was life changing injuries. It is hard - in ICU your patients are, on the whole, asleep or out of it so the main interaction is with the family and of course you build a connection.

But it is never the place of a nurse to make value judgements when it is related to a patient. They should always advocate for their patient and respect their choices. This was a few years ago and hopefully it may have improved now but I will never forget it.

I also won't forget the rampant bullying from both staff and patients, the appalling starving of the NHS over many years and the abysmal care I have both observed and received. And it wasn't that long ago.

You will notice I don't mention my own views on transgender issues. Because it doesn't (or shouldn't) fucking matter. If you can't stow your opinions you shouldn't be even thinking about nursing, it's no different to views on abortion.

An excellent post.

I am also an ex-nurse and I will second how important it is to be able to leave your own views about all sorts of things from vaccination to abortion to drug use etc at the door.

During my time in nursing I cared for criminals, drug addicts and dealers, a child sex abuser and numerous prostitutes. I probably cared for many more people who had done things that I didn't agree with as well but never knew. You just have to try not to judge.

Some patients weren't very nice people but you have to see beyond that and do your job regardless. It can be very tough.

wristwrangle · 25/03/2022 17:55

@SpaceFarce

If you can't stow your opinions you shouldn't be even thinking about nursing, it's no different to views on abortion.

Very much this.

Agree. I've treated paedophiles, abusers, drug addicts, people who are very unpleasant to you, people who make very unwise decisions about their own care / life styles etc - we treat everyone the same regardless of all of that. That's what being in healthcare means.
Cuck00soup · 25/03/2022 17:54

Will I struggle in the NHS with these views?
No. The thing about trained health professionals is that they know a thing or two about biology.
You might not be able to be as open as you wish but please don't think the NHS is full of believers.
Am I nursing material or should I reconsider?
Could you care for someone who is trans or is questioning their identity with respect and dignity, taking into account that they may have had a complex history?
Most trans people aren't angry activists, and most want to draw as little attention to themselves as possible. The rape was appalling, as were the lies told afterwards but don't allow yourself to think this rare assault is a regular occurrence.

Boscoforever · 25/03/2022 17:49

We do Open University in our trust, where staff can train as a nurse whilst working as an auxiliary in their own ward/dept. So I would say it is definitely a thing.
OP, you will learn all about how to understand and deal with this stuff in your training. Do it!! Best job in the world.

KneadingKitty · 25/03/2022 17:45

If you can remain neutral with your opinions and treatment yes. If you can't, then no. You've already suggested you'd feel uncomfortable treating a patient in a way that clashes with your opinions, so I'm dubious.
You will see FAR more stuff that concerns you and that you potentially disagree with than this particular topic so you need to question your ability to practice against your beliefs on more than just gender.

SpaceFarce · 25/03/2022 17:43

If you can't stow your opinions you shouldn't be even thinking about nursing, it's no different to views on abortion.

Very much this.

anotherbrewplease · 25/03/2022 17:39

@Crystalvas

There are apprenticeship pathways to being a staff nurse in the NHS Trust I work in.

QuebecBagnet · 25/03/2022 17:39

That’s incorrect. Nursing apprenticeship are definitely a thing and are a split between uni and work. They’ve been brought back.

anotherbrewplease · 25/03/2022 17:38

Your job as a nurse is to care for people - not to judge them.

Crystalvas · 25/03/2022 17:35

@FabFitFifties

Something fishy about this thread.
Hang on I think your are right. As far as I know to train as a nurse in the UK you must do a degree at uni. Apprentiships discontinued years ago. After your degree you specialise in other areas including working ina GP practice. OP is talking crap. You’v been rumbled OP. 🤣
QuebecBagnet · 25/03/2022 17:34

@acrimoniousone

Ex-nurse, first post. Nerve touched.

I worked in ICU (fun fact - it's brilliant for newly qualified nurses but they are frequently scared off) and had a patient who attempted suicide. Although they survived it wasn't a cry for help and they suffered devastating injuries. The patient was no longer able to live with their immediate family's rejection of their chosen gender identity.

This led to a bizzare situation where some staff supported the patients' choice and others sympathised with the parents views - this person was over eighteen but still at home. It led to stupidity such as the patient's name above their bed being changed with the shift.

I thought it was fucking disgusting and advocated for the patient. This young adult had horrific trauma both physical and mental - this wasn't attention-seeking but a miraculous survival. I had sympathy for the parents but their principles mattered more than the child desperately reaching out to them. To see this supported by a majority of staff - well, I didn't work there much longer.

They made a reasonable recovery but it was life changing injuries. It is hard - in ICU your patients are, on the whole, asleep or out of it so the main interaction is with the family and of course you build a connection.

But it is never the place of a nurse to make value judgements when it is related to a patient. They should always advocate for their patient and respect their choices. This was a few years ago and hopefully it may have improved now but I will never forget it.

I also won't forget the rampant bullying from both staff and patients, the appalling starving of the NHS over many years and the abysmal care I have both observed and received. And it wasn't that long ago.

You will notice I don't mention my own views on transgender issues. Because it doesn't (or shouldn't) fucking matter. If you can't stow your opinions you shouldn't be even thinking about nursing, it's no different to views on abortion.

This totally. I’m gender critical in my private life and a midwife at work. The main thing about being a nurse or midwife is that you provide individualised care. So I would have no problem at all supporting or advocating or treating a trans person.
tkwal · 25/03/2022 17:32

Why wouldn't you enter training. The NHS supports trans people , it doesn't mean you have to change your feelings or beliefs. Just treat your patients as individuals and with compassion

FabFitFifties · 25/03/2022 17:28

Something fishy about this thread.

Crystalvas · 25/03/2022 17:22

@Byrnealicious

I have been offered a place on a nursing degree apprenticeship within a GP surgery. Since I applied I have watched YouTube videos that GP nurses have posted in relation to the trans healthcare they have to provide. It appears the NHS is pro-trans and since the scandal came out about the rape on a NHS ward and the gaslighting of a patient following this assault, I am rethinking entering the NHS at all. Please help! I am deeply concerned about gender ideology and the effects it is having on women and children. I must admit I would struggle to treat anyone under the age of 18 with hormone blockers/hormonal injections. Will I struggle in the NHS with these views? Am I nursing material or should I reconsider? Honest opinions will be greatly appreciated.
Look up what unconditional positive regards means. Then start your course and see if its for you. You’ll quickly know if its not.
TheGreatATuin · 25/03/2022 17:17

Also adding the terrible story of supposedly GC staff mistreating the trans teenager upthread is from yet another new poster who has only posted once and that is on this thread.

Katypyee · 25/03/2022 17:14

Sounds like nursing is not the career for you if you are not in support of it being Pro-Trans. Dear God!

Notjustabrunette · 25/03/2022 17:14

If you think your opinion on how someone lives their life is more important then the how the individual wants to lead their life, then no you should probably stay away from a nursing.

TheGreatATuin · 25/03/2022 17:13

Interesting responses. The OP didn't say she didn't want to treat trans people or implied anything about not treating them with dignity, yet somehow that's what's been leapt on.

There are serious considerations here for NHS staff and there have been a large number of incidents where staff have been put in a very difficult position.

Take the many whistleblowers at the Tavistock. I think that's 35 resignations now?
Someone upthread mentioned that it would be 'unkind' to refuse treatment to a trans teenager.
What if that teenager was the one who had said that 'my mum wants this more than me', or one of those who came out as trans after being bullied for a lesbian and that mum was one of the openly homophobic parents mentioned in the review?
There's nothing kind about giving irreversible medical treatment to a teenager who doesn't want it and is only agreeing because of homophobia from their peers and parents.
Or if you're one of those clinicians who were told not to raise concerns with the safeguarding lead?

Or take the recent case of a woman who was raped on a single sex ward and told that it couldn't have happened because there were 'no men' on the ward? If you're the nurse who is expected to tell a woman she wasn't raped because NHS policy said it couldn't have happened?

I would find it very difficult to turn a blind eye to any of those scenarios, all of which have actually happened.

This isn't about refusing treatment to trans people or refusing to treat them with dignity. It's about medical professionals being put in a position where they have to go directly against their medical judgment.

Another analogy is a nurse working in one of the hospitals overseas that perform FGM on girls. Is she supposed to say 'it's my job' and wash her hands of it because she was respectful and kind to the girl on the post-op ward?

This isn't about the OP not being kind or not wanting to treat trans people. It's about being worried about having to go ahead with treatment that is clearly bad for the patient and having to enforce policies that go against safeguarding.

OP, it's difficult to tell someone else what to do with something like this, but I do know that the NHS needs nurses who will genuinely put their patients first and not look the other way in cases of medical malpractice or safeguarding concerns.

maddening · 25/03/2022 17:10

Ps I don't think anyone would suggest not treating a trans person, I am thinking more of the trans agenda within the nhs