Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I enter the NHS as a trainee nurse if I am gender critical?

142 replies

Balicious · 25/03/2022 14:17

I have been offered a place on a nursing degree apprenticeship within a GP surgery. Since I applied I have watched YouTube videos that GP nurses have posted in relation to the trans healthcare they have to provide. It appears the NHS is pro-trans and since the scandal came out about the rape on a NHS ward and the gaslighting of a patient following this assault, I am rethinking entering the NHS at all. Please help! I am deeply concerned about gender ideology and the effects it is having on women and children. I must admit I would struggle to treat anyone under the age of 18 with hormone blockers/hormonal injections. Will I struggle in the NHS with these views? Am I nursing material or should I reconsider? Honest opinions will be greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LibrariesGiveUsPower · 03/04/2022 10:22

Would you treat a trans patient any different to any other patient? If yes then it’s the wrong profession for you.

Many doctors and nurses treat people in ways that go against their personal ideals and beliefs, but they can separate personal ideals from professional behaviour. Anyone who works for the nhs should accept people as they are - but we all know that doesn’t always happen.

Camillasmummy · 03/04/2022 10:12

Please read the NMC end RCNs current work on supporting transgender patients.

Disclosing a patients gender identity is a breach of confidentiality and in some cases can be criminally prosecuted.

www.rcn.org.uk/-/media/royal-college-of-nursing/documents/publications/2020/november/009-430.pdf?la=en

Nurses can only object to partaking in treatment of patients in two areas: abortion and IVF.

www.nmc.org.uk/standards/code/conscientious-objection-by-nurses-and-midwives/

Camillasmummy · 03/04/2022 09:43

@Balicious I read them all

Balicious · 03/04/2022 08:29

I can only assume you haven't read any of my responses. Please read the thread before commenting next time, thanks.

OP posts:
Camillasmummy · 31/03/2022 18:47

Hi OP. I am a registered Nurse.

To be a nurse you have to treat people with dignity and respect irrelevant of their gender, sexuality, race, religion, social status, job, criminal past, anything….

I have nursed convicted paedophiles. Does this mean I agree with what they’ve done? Of course not!!!!!!!!! But it is not my place to judge.

It is not your place as a nurse to judge either.

Please read the NMC code of conduct and if you don’t think you can work in accordance with it then consider another career.

Balicious · 30/03/2022 22:01

@Cuck00soup

Will I struggle in the NHS with these views? No. The thing about trained health professionals is that they know a thing or two about biology. You might not be able to be as open as you wish but please don't think the NHS is full of believers. Am I nursing material or should I reconsider? Could you care for someone who is trans or is questioning their identity with respect and dignity, taking into account that they may have had a complex history? Most trans people aren't angry activists, and most want to draw as little attention to themselves as possible. The rape was appalling, as were the lies told afterwards but don't allow yourself to think this rare assault is a regular occurrence.
Thank you. Sometimes when you read lots of negative news stories you do start to wonder why you applied for the job in the first place! But then I think of my own experiences of working within the NHS to date and they don't mirror the scandals that I read about in the papers. I treat all patients with respect and dignity - my poorly worded question wasn't about individuals but really but how how the NHS operates as a whole on the issue. Think I've been spending too much time on online recently and I think it's maybe knocked my confidence in the NHS a bit. It is so nice to be reassured that my positive working experience might be the rule as opposed to the exception. Smile
OP posts:
Balicious · 30/03/2022 21:44

@Boscoforever

We do Open University in our trust, where staff can train as a nurse whilst working as an auxiliary in their own ward/dept. So I would say it is definitely a thing. OP, you will learn all about how to understand and deal with this stuff in your training. Do it!! Best job in the world.
Thank you xx
OP posts:
Balicious · 30/03/2022 21:39

@TheGreatATuin

Interesting responses. The OP didn't say she didn't want to treat trans people or implied anything about not treating them with dignity, yet somehow that's what's been leapt on.

There are serious considerations here for NHS staff and there have been a large number of incidents where staff have been put in a very difficult position.

Take the many whistleblowers at the Tavistock. I think that's 35 resignations now?
Someone upthread mentioned that it would be 'unkind' to refuse treatment to a trans teenager.
What if that teenager was the one who had said that 'my mum wants this more than me', or one of those who came out as trans after being bullied for a lesbian and that mum was one of the openly homophobic parents mentioned in the review?
There's nothing kind about giving irreversible medical treatment to a teenager who doesn't want it and is only agreeing because of homophobia from their peers and parents.
Or if you're one of those clinicians who were told not to raise concerns with the safeguarding lead?

Or take the recent case of a woman who was raped on a single sex ward and told that it couldn't have happened because there were 'no men' on the ward? If you're the nurse who is expected to tell a woman she wasn't raped because NHS policy said it couldn't have happened?

I would find it very difficult to turn a blind eye to any of those scenarios, all of which have actually happened.

This isn't about refusing treatment to trans people or refusing to treat them with dignity. It's about medical professionals being put in a position where they have to go directly against their medical judgment.

Another analogy is a nurse working in one of the hospitals overseas that perform FGM on girls. Is she supposed to say 'it's my job' and wash her hands of it because she was respectful and kind to the girl on the post-op ward?

This isn't about the OP not being kind or not wanting to treat trans people. It's about being worried about having to go ahead with treatment that is clearly bad for the patient and having to enforce policies that go against safeguarding.

OP, it's difficult to tell someone else what to do with something like this, but I do know that the NHS needs nurses who will genuinely put their patients first and not look the other way in cases of medical malpractice or safeguarding concerns.

Wow, thank you so much! I've only just read your response and I think you are one of the very few who understood what I meant in my original post! I realise I worded my question very poorly, so thank you for expressing my thoughts far more eloquently!

I've already responded to others with my thoughts on the responses so I won't repeat myself but just wanted to thank you for expressing these legitimate concerns.

I have an ominous suspicion that the integration of the transgender ideology within the NHS will be the final nail in the coffin for this much loved institution. How many more scandals can the NHS take? The Stafford Hospital scandal, The Redfern Report and now today the Ockenden maternity report. We are already seeing evidence of legal action being taken against the NHS owing to the Tavistock and assaults against women on supposedly female only wards. The recent Cass Review was damning.

The principle of 'do no harm' is being put at risk in the NHS; in the past it has been linked to cost saving measures or neglect, but this is the first time it is under threat owing to an ideology.

OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 22:30

@KELLOGSspeck

Have you got any type of support work or care experience OP?

If not I would do this BEFORE applying for nursing it's a bloody hard slog! There's lots of unusual things you will see as a nurse.... but you have to put it aside.

I do yes lots. I am under no illusion as to how demanding the role will be. Smile
OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 22:25

@MrsOvertonsWindow

I'm as GC as they come but it shouldn't matter in terms of patients and the care you deliver. I am nothing but respectful and supportive of teenagers I work with who believe they're the wrong sex - I know they need compassionate adults who focus on the whole child and their needs, not activists virtue signalling or imposing their own political views on them. To my mind, the challenges will be just as in schools, ensuring that all the Stonewall flag flyers don't drown out all the rational balanced adults delivering our roles - be it medicine or education. It's good to think critically and it's scary out there at the moment if you believe in safeguarding children as a priority. However, the interim report from the Cass Review demonstrating the appalling standards of unevidenced medical care offered to such vulnerable children will result in changes quite quickly. Medicine needs critical intelligent thinkers, able to prioritise patent needs, not lobby group demands. Good luck.
Thank you for your balanced and thoughtful reply. I hope you're right regarding the effects the Cass Review will have on patient care in the future!
OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 22:20

@hazelnutlatte

I am GC and I am a nurse in a GP practice. It's not an issue. We have some trans patients, I treat them with respect, the same as I would treat any patient. I use preferred pronouns etc because it would be rude and disrespectful not to. If you feel you can't do this then nursing is not the career for you. If however, you are just concerned about providing treatment specifically for gender transition then all you need to do is not work in a specialist gender transition service. GP practices do not provide this treatment. We do have a few patients with 'shared care' agreements - this means they have their blood tests with us, to save them from traveling long distances to the gender identity clinic, but the hormone treatments are provided by the specialists.
Thanks for this. I had watched youtube videos posted by nurses and I was under the impression that hormone injections would need to be administered by GP nurses. I must admit I'm relieved. As per my other responses, it's the treatment for under 18s and the lying to vulnerable patients I am most concerned about.
OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 22:14

@KohlaParasaurus

I am GC and work in health care, am open about the fact that I don't believe humans can change sex, and it has never been a problem. Provided you treat everyone with respect and professionalism you are likely to be fine. Dilemmas like transwomen on female inpatient wards are uncommon.

(Our local obstetrics and gynaecology unit is called Women's Outpatients. This makes me ridiculously happy.)

That's good to hear, thanks Smile
OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 22:10

@DdraigGoch

Unless you actually get a job at the Tavistock, you're unlikely to end up doing any 'care' which would prickle your conscience in that way.

What's more concerning is the prospect of being ordered to lie to patients about who is in the next bed. Putting patients at risk but being unable to speak out would trouble me greatly. The NHS is a very dysfunctional organisation and reacts to whistleblowers particularly badly.

Precisely!

I simply wouldn't be able to lie to patients. I plan to treat every patient the same way I would care for a member of my own family, (that sounds trite but I think it's a good way to measure whether you're delivering acceptable treatment or not). I wouldn't lie to my Mum about being on a mix-sex ward so why should I lie to someone else's Mother?

OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 21:58

@Spaghettipie1

I'm an NHS nurse with similar views, I treat everyone with the same respect and am happy to call people by whatever name they choose and refer to them he/she/they as preferred. other than that it just depends where you work, unless planning on working in specialist areas dealing with trans gender issues/treatment specifically it has never involved more than that for me. It's about treating everyone as an individual, not being pro/anti anything in my experience. You might also have to treat people with criminal pasts, murderers/rapists, people who are nasty/abusive. that's way more difficult to accept and look past. Many challenges but a great job.
Thanks for your reply. It's not about the individual. I'm sure the majority of trans-identifying individuals are lovely. I understand the importance of person-centred care and would never judge an individual patient for their choices. If I felt prejudice towards any single group of people, I would never have considered nursing as a career, that's for sure! My question was regarding the NHS and how severely the organisation has been affected by this ideology in terms of their treatment of vulnerable children and women. The cross-sex hormone treatments for under 18s (that GP nurses are expected to administer according to nurses on youtube), and wards becoming increasingly mix-sex. I guess my worry is, that there will be a huge backlash one day when patients such as Kiera Bell, and the poor victims of the recent assaults that have taken place on wards, seek compensation for their treatment. Will the doctors and nurses that were treating these patients be held accountable for the possible harm caused? I don't want to be involved in experimental treatment with no solid evidence base. It's a concern that honestly worries me.
OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 21:39

@Nutellaonall

I work for the nhs. I don’t think it massively affects our day to day working lives anymore than it does any other profession.
That's a relief, thank you.
OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 21:36

@RebeccaCloud9

Sometimes you just have to keep your opinions to yourself. I'm a teacher and gender critical and (although I post on Mon) I wouldn't share my views on Twitter or FB or it would affect my job. In the same way I wouldn't swear or post drunken pictures etc. I haven't ever come across a child or parent irl who is trans. If I did, I would treat them with respect. I would vocally disagree with certain things eg putting pronouns on name badges (not necessary, I'm Mrs anyway) or not being allowed to use gendered terms eg boys and girls. But beyond that, my gender critical views are separate from my job.
Thanks for your reply. Surely you can't compare being concerned about treating under 18s with cross-sex hormones (available from the age of 16 in the UK), to swearing or posting drunk photos? This isn't a silly opinion I share with my friends in private.

I am considering training to become a healthcare professional that has a duty of care to patients.
I have genuine, evidence based concerns, (e.g. Cass report), about the effects this ideology is having on both women and young children. The first rule of medicine is do no harm but we don't have enough data on the long term effects of this treatment to know we aren't harming people.
It goes without saying I would treat patients with respect and I certainly wouldn't, nor would I want to, deny any adult hormone treatment, (you can only hope they have researched the risks (of which there are many), and made an educated decision. I am concerned about under 18s and also allowing males on female only wards with extremely vulnerable women.

OP posts:
Mouldyfeet · 29/03/2022 21:17

I'm GC and work in a GP practice. I treat the person and their symptoms and not their ideology. No different that treating religious people really even though all the medicalisation etc really winds me up. You keep schtum, it's fine plus this craze will be out of fashion in a few years.

Balicious · 29/03/2022 21:13

Sorry, the above message was meant to be a reply to someone...I'm new to mumsnet so still learning Smile

OP posts:
Balicious · 29/03/2022 21:06

Yes, nurses are expected to administer hormone injections to transgender patients. That's what I found out through watching youtube videos - that's the main reason for the post really. Is don't mind injecting adults, I take it they understand the risk, but under 18s? No, I don't think I would be able to. Cross-sex hormones can be prescribed from age 16.

OP posts:
MagnoliaXYZ · 26/03/2022 08:12

I'm a nurse in the NHS and would probably be described as gender-critical I guess. I think it's crazy that people can self-identify.

I've met a hanful of patients who have opted to live as the opposite sex. One of them hadn't had surgery or hormones or anything. I was very young and it made me uncomfortable because the person still looked like what they were biologically but had just changed their name. I've since met this person again in work and they are back living as their biological sex. In that setting, I never even mentioned it as it was irrelevant to the care I was providing. I've looked after another patient who had been through hormone surgery and treatment a very long time ago. You honestly couldn't tell that they hadn't been born as that sex. This was relevant to why I was seeing this patient so we did have a bit of a chat about what they'd been through. It was actually quite fascinating and the patient was very open about it all.

I did actually talk to a patient about religion once. It was during a night shift and he couldn't sleep. The rest of the ward was quiet so we just chatted for a bit. He was a jehovahs witness so I asked him about the blood issue. Again, I do not share those views but it was an interesting discussion. I would probably struggle more with someone who was prepared to die than accept a blood transfusion than I would seeing a man in my clinic who wanted me to call him Jane. I wouldn't chose to work somewhere where I was actively involved in the process of gender reassignment. I've been nursing for over 15 years, it is not a big issue in my professional life at all.

MissTrip82 · 26/03/2022 07:42

Will you have much to do with it? You obviously won’t be prescribing or making treatment decisions about this. Would your role largely be checkups and the provision of non-related health care? If so you’d need to be able to provide that safely and professionally no matter what your opinion of the treatment commenced/continued by other health care practitioners.

You would of course need to keep your opinions to yourself, and use the patient’s preferred name and pronouns. If that’s not possible then you won’t be able to work.

Pandypuff · 26/03/2022 07:40

@EIisheva

Why don’t you just self identify as a doctor and give yourself a wee leg up?
😂😂😂
DdraigGoch · 26/03/2022 07:27

[quote anotherbrewplease]@DdraigGoch

Oh right - thanks for enlightening me.

I very much doubt that the OP will be traumatised by the ethical dillemmas you give examples of. Forced to be part of a cover-up? Really? Is that a common occurence?

Maybe it's not about her views. Maybe no one gives a toss what she thinks.[/quote]
It doesn't matter how common it is, though search for "NHS whistleblower" and you will find loads of cases where those who speak out on a variety of issues (medical malpractice, mismanagement, sexual misconduct etc.) have been victimised and bullied.

There is though the potential of a serious ethical dilemma however, where providing services in the way instructed by your superiors will cause harm to either that patient, or to other patients. If a competent adult wishes to take hormones, fine, that's on them. A homosexual teenager who is being bullied into reassignment by their homophobic parents? Would you really press on? A male patient placed in a female bay who later commits an assault, could you lie to the other patients?

In practice, such scenarios will be unusual as you are implying, so I'd suggest that providing that the OP would treat a trans patient with the same respect she'd give any other (and she hasn't said that she wouldn't), she should go ahead and only actually worry about these scenarios if they crop up - many nurses will never have any more interaction with a trans person than a flu jab or changing a dressing. Things are moving fast at the moment and it is likely that the rules will change first anyway. If the OP does ever end up being placed in an impossible position, she could always resign.

bozzabollix · 26/03/2022 06:51

My husband has had to anaesthetise a double murderer hours after he committed the most awful crimes, healthcare is a job where you’ve got to remove your own opinions from what you’re doing. Maybe it’s not the job for you, the healthcare workers I know are immensely compassionate and non judgemental.

Trans people suffer enough prejudice as it is, the last place they need it is a setting where they are at their most vulnerable.

And to the ITU nurse who posted earlier, the behaviour of those nurses was absolutely atrocious. Were any complaints made to the ITU lead? Disgusting behaviour when the patient was so vulnerable.

anotherbrewplease · 26/03/2022 05:24

@DdraigGoch

Oh right - thanks for enlightening me.

I very much doubt that the OP will be traumatised by the ethical dillemmas you give examples of. Forced to be part of a cover-up? Really? Is that a common occurence?

Maybe it's not about her views. Maybe no one gives a toss what she thinks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread