Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if many people actively enjoy small talk?

135 replies

thatsgotit · 25/03/2022 13:24

Not a journo, long-standing member, just curious. I'm an introvert and can do small talk when it's needed, but oh man, I hate it so much. I do enjoy getting to know people and having conversations that feel to me like they 'go' somewhere, but I just hate the fact that it's not considered socially acceptable to dive into 'meaningful' conversation without the obligatory exchanges about the weather, 'how are you?' (and the obligatory reply of 'very well, thank you' whether that happens to be true or not, rendering the question pointless), etc etc having to be got out of the way first, and as someone who doesn't have kids I'm always forgetting that I'm supposed to ask after other people's, which typically I only remember to do if I actually know the kid in question, or know something significant is going on with them.

If I sound a bit cynical it's just because I find it such a struggle. I accept that small talk serves a purpose in oiling the wheels of communication/breaking the ice etc and it's not that I don't want to find things out about people, I just tend to be more interested in exchanging opinions than facts, I suppose. So I'm curious, do many people actively enjoy small talk?

YABU = 'I enjoy small talk'
YANBU = 'I don't enjoy small talk'

OP posts:
Sharrowgirl · 25/03/2022 15:46

You can control the small talk though so if you don’t like the inane weather chat, simply don’t do it. Steer it to something you find more fulfilling.

‘How are you?’
‘Not bad, could be worse. Felt better watching the new series of Bridgerton, even without the Duke’
Or whatever it is you find more interesting or easy to talk about!!

EishetChayil · 25/03/2022 15:45

Small talk is socially essential as a way of assessing the other person. People say "oh, I hate it" often quite smugly, but it's actually a vital tool.

All of the conversations I've had that have begun with non-small, heavier topics have always been with people who turned out to be either unstable, weird, or downright fucking dangerous.

waterrat · 25/03/2022 15:41

This just seems sad to me. Small Talk just means connecting to the people around you in a friendly way. I absolutely love chatting to anyone friend or stranger...and I am in A job that involves talking to strangers so that is handy !

Talking about the weather or someone's journey etc etc is just building connection ...it makes humans feel part of a wider society. It was something I missed so much in lockdown.

If you don't start with thr small Talk how do you get to big talk ?

We have a loneliness crisis in this country and so many people go days without even a brief hello. Many of my elderly neighbours live day to day for chat with people passing all of it seemingly superficial.

It just seems so snobbish and unkind to dismiss small Talk

Lemonyfuckit · 25/03/2022 15:36

I'm with you OP - I'm naturally quite shy and I get that I need to do 'networking' for my job, go to client drinks and stuff but boy do I find it quite hard work and tiring and it makes me rather nervous. My DH is great at it, he will happily just strike up a conversation with anyone and engage them, I always feel quite boring when I do that.

Mamamia7962 · 25/03/2022 15:30

Love small talk. When out walking the dog I chat to loads of people, have so many acquaintances now that I can pass the time of day with, and some have become friends. If an elderly person stops to speak to me I always chat to be them because I could be the only person they speak to that day.

thatsgotit · 25/03/2022 15:21

Is it because you feel you can be yourself in a meaningful conversation but have to hide bits of yourself when making small talk and that is tiring?

For me it's exactly this, you've put your finger right on it. I feel fake AF a lot of the time when making small talk, because it feels like there are 'right' and 'wrong' answers and these leaves me feeling obliged to give fake answers at times (e.g. if someone asks me how I am, as mentioned upthread, given that I don't feel particularly well a lot of the time.)

OP posts:
Lyricallie · 25/03/2022 15:18

It's fine. It does what it's supposed to do. Light hearted getting to know people, start the conversation off. What is there to like or dislike? If someone immediately jumped into a conversation with me about my thoughts on Ukraine (no matter how close I was to them, and I have been trying to follow along so it's not as if I'm ignorant) I would back right off. That's way too intense without a hello, how have you been. I think a previous poster said it well. It sparks things off that you can use as a topic later.

DoorLion · 25/03/2022 15:16

@TeeBee

Oh god, I hate it! I can see why its useful (for other people). But quite honestly, if I'm going to expend energy interacting with people, let's crack straight on with the important bits and cut out the frilly shite. I can find an in-depth conversation about something meaningful incredibly fulfilling and thought-provoking but I really don't have the need for a 'warm up'. Unsurprising, I'm also an introvert.
I genuinely don't understand how an in-depth conversation is less draining than a lightweight conversation although obviously it is to many people. To me it's like saying you find a three hour exam less draining than a ten minute crossword. Is it because you feel you can be yourself in a meaningful conversation but have to hide bits of yourself when making small talk and that is tiring? (I would also say I'm an introvert in the sense that I need a lot of time alone to recharge and am happy spending time alone, but I'm also a fan of small talk!)
CornedBeef451 · 25/03/2022 15:14

I don't like it but consider it social lubrication. Once you have complied with enough statutory weather talk over a period of time you might actually have an interesting conversation.

OMG12 · 25/03/2022 15:14

I hate small talk, I can do it (but I could also gouge out my own eyes with a teaspoon of absolutely necessary).

Happy to talk with strangers about interesting things though, I love good conversation especially if erudite and challenging.

WellTidy · 25/03/2022 15:14

I love it. Passing the time of day with people makes me feel great! And sometimes people don’t have to amount of interaction with others that they’d like, so I always engage when someone initiates engaging with me

AeroMocha · 25/03/2022 15:11

I don't actively enjoy it - I don't think many people are actually interested in the conversation itself or the answers - and like many people, I do enjoy getting to know someone in more depth or having real conversations. But I know that you can't really do that easily without small talk first - it eases you in, and to an extent, filters who you talk to more deeply and how. So it needs to be done, and yes the questions themselves might be pointless in a literal sense but the literal answer is not their purpose.

Doggydreaming · 25/03/2022 15:08

Nope. I hate it. Total waste of time. Boring. Either don't talk to me at all or tell me the juicy stuff, thanks.

I've heard that in Swedish people don't bother with small talk. I genuinely considered moving there for a while.

TeeBee · 25/03/2022 14:51

Oh god, I hate it! I can see why its useful (for other people). But quite honestly, if I'm going to expend energy interacting with people, let's crack straight on with the important bits and cut out the frilly shite. I can find an in-depth conversation about something meaningful incredibly fulfilling and thought-provoking but I really don't have the need for a 'warm up'. Unsurprising, I'm also an introvert.

GrolliffetheDragon · 25/03/2022 14:40

@blockbustervideo

LOVE small talk. Bump in to a mum in the playground? "Hi, your little one is so sweet, how old? What's their name? Are you on maternity leave or taking time out for now? Are you local to this area? Bla bla bla..." that's how you make friends as an adult/mum, I find anyway.
That's presumably where I'm going wrong then. I'm rubbish at that sort of thing.
cantbecoping · 25/03/2022 14:38

Hate it. Cannot BEAR it. Pointless, draining, unnecessary.

thatsgotit · 25/03/2022 14:32

@TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek

In my opinion YANBU. Even with family members I hate it! I think it is because it makes me feel awkward. Like you say you almost have to ask the obligatory "how are you", then when they almost certainly say "fine" or "good thanks, how are you", should I say "that's good, and I'm fine too thanks", because although it looks OK on paper, I find it really embarrassing - probably because I hate scripts, and I never do actually feel fine or good, I always feel varying shades of crap.

However, I know that strangers don't want to hear about my health and mental health issues, and if I said that to my loved ones all the time it would depress them, and make them feel bad and useless, which I obviously don't want them to do. In fact most of the time I hate getting any sympathy at all. But I do think that I am quite a strange person anyway, so hopefully you will get replies soon from more "normal" people!

On a one to one basis with people I know well, or love, I do like having in depth conversations with them about lots of different things, which can in itself be quite fraught with danger, eg. If I found out that the person I was talking with was into things like fox hunting etc I could no longer be friends with them (is that too much of an extreme reaction - but even if it is, it would be my reaction) and I would immediately start feeling awkward whilst wondering how I could politely extract myself from that situation, as I would no longer want to be friends with them. Unfortunately, my very awkwardness could make me tell them too bluntly what I thought about them and their enjoyment of such a cruel activity - I will never call things like that a sport, as far as I am concerned there is nothing sporting about it at all 😡

Sorry OP, I should probably scrap this reply as I don't think this is the sort of response you were looking for, but when I started this you had not had any other replies, you will have probably had loads now, but I will post it just incase!

You actually sound a lot like me @TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek! Grin In particular your first paragraph. I have ME and a few other chronic health issues, and and agree the 'how are you?' question is an awkward one for people who feel crap a lot of the time.

@raspberrymuffin sorry to hear about your DH. I can definitely see how lighter conversation could be helpful at such a difficult time.

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 25/03/2022 14:29

No, it's horrible & pointless.

MakkaPakkas · 25/03/2022 14:26

I quite enjoy this sort of phatic communication, but I enjoy listening to other people doing it more than I enjoy participating in it.

MrsGHarrison87 · 25/03/2022 14:25

Depends what mood I'm in. Sometimes I don't mind it, sometimes I dislike it if I'm tired and I've got to think of things to say to someone I don't really know. Then it's draining.

Pootles34 · 25/03/2022 14:25

I love it in certain situations - particularly with old ladies on buses. It has to include weather talk.

DoorLion · 25/03/2022 14:25

Its interesting how many people find small talk draining - I would find "a good discussion about Ukraine" with someone I don't know, where I have to articulate and defend my view and challenge someone else's, much much more draining than a fun chat about holidays or TV or books or the horror of the new fried chicken shop that's opening round the corner.
Maybe it's because my day job involves talking to people I don't know about big subjects (journalist) with very little small talk involved (Hello. I'm writing an article about X. What is your view on it?").

raspberrymuffin · 25/03/2022 14:22

I like having done it. I think it's the evolved version of eating ticks off each other's backs - you get to feel a human connection without having had to think too hard about it or talk about things that are really worrying you. How I "am" at the moment is actually a nervous mess due to DH having cancer but I talk about the lovely weather and how much I'm looking forward to getting my potatoes planted out, and I like hearing about other people's nice things too even though maybe they've got similar worries to me.

TitoMojito · 25/03/2022 14:20

Small talk just reminds me of when I worked at a till in a shop. So no not really haha

TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek · 25/03/2022 14:19

probably!