Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if many people actively enjoy small talk?

135 replies

thatsgotit · 25/03/2022 13:24

Not a journo, long-standing member, just curious. I'm an introvert and can do small talk when it's needed, but oh man, I hate it so much. I do enjoy getting to know people and having conversations that feel to me like they 'go' somewhere, but I just hate the fact that it's not considered socially acceptable to dive into 'meaningful' conversation without the obligatory exchanges about the weather, 'how are you?' (and the obligatory reply of 'very well, thank you' whether that happens to be true or not, rendering the question pointless), etc etc having to be got out of the way first, and as someone who doesn't have kids I'm always forgetting that I'm supposed to ask after other people's, which typically I only remember to do if I actually know the kid in question, or know something significant is going on with them.

If I sound a bit cynical it's just because I find it such a struggle. I accept that small talk serves a purpose in oiling the wheels of communication/breaking the ice etc and it's not that I don't want to find things out about people, I just tend to be more interested in exchanging opinions than facts, I suppose. So I'm curious, do many people actively enjoy small talk?

YABU = 'I enjoy small talk'
YANBU = 'I don't enjoy small talk'

OP posts:
WlNDMlLL · 26/03/2022 21:29

OP, I can see I wasn't explicit about this so fair enough, but my comment was a general 'you' to people of the thread (as it was several pages long by this point with lots of contributors), not a load of questions to you specifically. I was trying to understand more about the POV of people who dislike small talk - not sure why that is argumentative. Yes I agree conversations that don't move forward are dull.

nosyupnorth · 26/03/2022 21:27

Oh and the fact you say you get stuck in small talk doesn't mean small talk is bad, it might mean the small talk is serving it's purpose in letting people test the waters and they are deciding they don't want to get into deeper conversation with you - if you are dismissive and half-assed about small talk then that isn't going to leave people coming away with the reaction of 'thatsgotit is an engaging person I'd like to get to know better' they're going to think 'thatsgotit was acting dismissive and uninterested in our conversation clearly they don't want to talk more'.

dephlogisticated · 26/03/2022 21:21

I love a bit of small talk, sometimes it's an important dance where you're really saying to someone 'I'm familiar and safe to approach, are you? Other times it's a way to stop and pay attention and really properly listen to someone.. I guess there isn't such a thing as small talk really, it's the space and the quality of attention that are important and not the words. I love a good chat about nothing or something and I always love listening, you never know how you might help someone by listening to their 'small' stuff, it might be the biggest thing that happened to them all day. And if you hear someone's small stuff, they will come back to your with their big stuff if they need to.

nosyupnorth · 26/03/2022 21:19

YABU

I find people who get very intrusive in early conversation or overshare about details I didn't want to know about their life/opinions very uncomfortable to deal with because they are at best rude and at worse deliberately trying to catch me out in saying something stupid about the very high brow deep talk topic they prefer or share an opinion they don't approve of.

Small talk is a conversational warm up, it lets you test the waters before getting onto deeper talk so that you can avoid wading into dangerous territories like getting into a disagreement with somebody you need to stay on the good side of or tripping into sensitive issues. In small talk you don't have to lie and say 'fine' when asked 'how are you' you just need to meet a causal inquiry with a causal answer - could be better/a bit tired/under the weather/the usual are all fine responses, just not taking it as an invitation to dump all your problems on the asker. Similarly sharing opinions on milder topics lets you feel out the ground for more serious ones, if you launch in with 'I hate XYZ and think everybody who likes it is stupid don't you agree?' it makes for a very awkward conversation if your partner actually doesn't agree but has now been backed into a corner.

thatsgotit · 26/03/2022 21:14

@WlNDMlLL

Surely though if you only enjoy jumping straight into 'meaningful conversations' you only enjoy talking about subjects that are interesting to you? How on earth do you ever find that common ground with people if you don't have any sort of chit chat beforehand? I bet you're equally as put out by people who talk about subjects that don't interest you. And what about people you come into contact with daily but have little time to build a proper relationship with - would you prefer to ignore them? I see someone at work for 1-5 minutes every day but over time I've learnt little snippets about her. It would be bizarre if after several years all we had ever said to each other was hello! We literally don't have time for an in depth discussion though.
You've made some extrapolations here that I find odd and quite argumentatively expressed, tbh. To clarify a few points (obviously I can only speak for myself, not other non-fans of small talk, but this is how things are for me anyway):
  1. I acknowledge that some small talk is necessary in order to identify the points of common ground that might make people want to start an in-depth conversation relatively quickly. It's all the 'How are you?', 'Lovely weather we're having' etc stuff I find difficult because it's hard, for me anyway, to know what to say once these niceties have been exchanged.
  1. Of course I am not 'put out by people who talk about subjects that don't interest' me. It's all part and parcel of general communication. Indeed, it can sometimes be interesting to hear more about things one hasn't previously had an interest in - but small talk can only take people so far along that conversational path. If a person asks to know more about something they're hearing about, the conversation's likely to flow at some point from small talk into a deeper and more specific conversation.
  1. And of course I wouldn't 'prefer to ignore' people I see daily but don't get to talk to in depth. I just talk to people about the things that feel mutually relevant, if that's all that time or personality differences allow. At no point in my OP did I say I was only interested in talking to people if I could have an in-depth conversation.

But as you asked me several questions I'm going to ask you one. Do you find conversations that never go past 'How are you?/Very well thank you, how are you?' 'Isn't the weather lovely?/'Yes, but I heard it's going to rain tomorrow'/'Oh, I hope not!' satisfying and not even a tad superficial in themselves? I wouldn't have thought so. Even small talk needs to go somewhere or else the conversation just peters out, which is one of the things I find difficult about it.

OP posts:
YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 26/03/2022 21:13

@dayswithaY

I'm really good at small talk, it never phases me. It's a fabulous way to get to know people and can lead onto amazing conversations. Small talk makes the world go round, it's a valuable skill too.
I wholeheartedly agree. I meet lots of really interesting people via ‘small talk’. It’s fabulous!

Today I chatted to a random woman at a train station. We discussed dogs, the Highlands, her daughters amazing sounding Grace & Favour home, Zanzibar, flying, foxes, Battersea Park, baby owls, bird watching and flowers. In around 30 mins!

Will either of us be ‘affected’ by the meeting? No. Did both of us walk away from our chat with a spring in our steps? Absolutely.

Small talk is a real skill. Being able to find common ground with whomever you find yourself with is important and oils the wheels.

timeforteaforyouandme · 26/03/2022 21:11

Depends on my mood tbh

cansu · 26/03/2022 21:09

God it is so tedious. I actively find myself wishing I hadn't bothered.

Kanaloa · 26/03/2022 20:57

I think that’s what people meant by small talk being necessary though. Obviously if you’re into ‘deep conversation’ that’s fine but it’s not going to be appropriate in many social situations, which is why it’s good to be well versed in small talk.

thatsgotit · 26/03/2022 20:52

If you did that to me I would feel judged, exposed, and annoyed…that’s probably why it’s socially not acceptable!

But typically for those of us who like deep conversations, they just tend to start naturally if both people are interested in a given topic. If not, the conversation tends to naturally remain on more of a small talk level. In my experience, anyway - I never try to force in-depth conversations on anyone, if they're going to happen they tend to happen organically.

OP posts:
DoorLion · 26/03/2022 08:12

@Twattergy

I really dislike it. Mostly because 'deep talk'(is that the opposite?) is so much more interesting, rewarding and a quicker way to explore who you are talking with. I'd go straight in with a deep question every time if it was socially acceptable!
If you did that to me I would feel judged, exposed, and annoyed…that’s probably why it’s socially not acceptable!
RampantIvy · 26/03/2022 07:38

@cantbecoping

Hate it. Cannot BEAR it. Pointless, draining, unnecessary.
I disagree. It breaks the ice when you first meet someone. If on first meeting someone they dive straight into a serious discussion I would find them too intense and full on.
Snozwanger · 26/03/2022 07:36

I have found small talk very difficult since my first child reached school age. So much so I recently bought a book on it to see if I could improve how I deal with it. Since the pandemic I've had to review how I connect socially as I've felt very isolated. I've realised that although tricky at first, small talk is a necessary way of meeting people you have things in common with and having positive interactions. You can also find out information on things that will benefit you on the long run so although I dislike small talk, I know that if I want to improve my connections as a SAHM and parent then I need to brave those difficult situations in future.

RobotValkyrie · 26/03/2022 07:22

Well, we wouldn't all be having a chat here on this Internet forum if we thoroughly hated small talk, would be?

I kind of like small talk... On my terms.
I small talk lots with people I know. Real chatterbox. It's light meaningless talk, but no topic is off limits. Sticking to the weather is boring. Though I can chat about that too, off course. Lovely blue sky right now. May well go to the beach. The kids love it. My youngest will collect buckets of shells. Do you have little ones in your life? Blah. Blah. Blah.

With people I don't know... Depends.
Internet forums? That's the whole point of being there, so let's!
Other contexts? Well... I'm pretty goal driven... So unless there's a greater goal (e.g. getting to know a new colleague, because we'll be working together in the future), I'm not that motivated. I also like my peace and quiet, and getting on with my own business. Packed schedule and all that. Random lady discussing the weather over a bunch of carrot in the vegetable aisle is tolerable for about 50 seconds, but then I've got places to be, and I hate being held back.
I don't hate random strangers, I will happily hold the door for them and give them directions. But I hate people getting in my way. And I've got much more patience for slow-walkers (we can't all be young and fit, and if that luggage looks heavy, or that pushchair needs carrying up the stairs, I'll be glad to help) than small-talkers. Sorry not sorry.

dayswithaY · 26/03/2022 07:18

I'm really good at small talk, it never phases me. It's a fabulous way to get to know people and can lead onto amazing conversations. Small talk makes the world go round, it's a valuable skill too.

Vampirethriller · 26/03/2022 06:59

I like it. If not for small talk I wouldn't have had a conversation for days on end when my daughter was a baby.

Parfait · 26/03/2022 06:58

Another beautiful day !

Kanaloa · 26/03/2022 06:54

Also for example when you’re in hospital - it would be so uncomfortable for the people to jump in with ‘deep conversation’ but some light talk is necessary to put the patient at ease and make them feel comfortable and as if they’re being treated as a person. Even in shops etc. So many situations where ‘deep and meaningful’ conversation would just come across as socially inappropriate.

OfstedOffred · 26/03/2022 06:53

It's rare to find a decent genuine friend these days. Especially in the school playground

Maybe that's just you. I've found lots among the school crowd. But then I am a taking part type - I am happy to volunteer on parent committee, attend a fundraiser event etc.

Kanaloa · 26/03/2022 06:52

@Twattergy

I really dislike it. Mostly because 'deep talk'(is that the opposite?) is so much more interesting, rewarding and a quicker way to explore who you are talking with. I'd go straight in with a deep question every time if it was socially acceptable!
Realistically that’s inappropriate in lots of situations though. For example in my workplace when I’ve worked in childcare it’s necessary to be friendly and build relationships with colleagues and parents but I would see it as inappropriate and odd to share ‘deep’ or personal things in that setting.

A lot of people say they dislike small talk, and I don’t particularly enjoy it, but it does serve a purpose. It builds appropriate relationships for communication. There is a time and place for ‘deep’ conversation, and a time and place for polite small talk.

OfstedOffred · 26/03/2022 06:51

I told once as part of a feedback thing at work that although some peers were technically stronger than me in our specialist field, I was consistently more sought after on a project teams because I am considered "open", "warm" and "engaging". I like a little bit of chat. I get along with most people, and I like hearing about their families or latest holidays. It's how you build relationships with people, people do far more for each other when they have strong relationships.

WlNDMlLL · 26/03/2022 06:47

Surely though if you only enjoy jumping straight into 'meaningful conversations' you only enjoy talking about subjects that are interesting to you? How on earth do you ever find that common ground with people if you don't have any sort of chit chat beforehand? I bet you're equally as put out by people who talk about subjects that don't interest you. And what about people you come into contact with daily but have little time to build a proper relationship with - would you prefer to ignore them? I see someone at work for 1-5 minutes every day but over time I've learnt little snippets about her. It would be bizarre if after several years all we had ever said to each other was hello! We literally don't have time for an in depth discussion though.

Twattergy · 26/03/2022 06:46

I really dislike it. Mostly because 'deep talk'(is that the opposite?) is so much more interesting, rewarding and a quicker way to explore who you are talking with. I'd go straight in with a deep question every time if it was socially acceptable!

Whattodoniw · 26/03/2022 06:41

@blockbustervideo

LOVE small talk. Bump in to a mum in the playground? "Hi, your little one is so sweet, how old? What's their name? Are you on maternity leave or taking time out for now? Are you local to this area? Bla bla bla..." that's how you make friends as an adult/mum, I find anyway.
See this fucks me off.

Horses for courses and all that but I loathe this intrusive kind of shit.

Nine out of ten friendships made in the playground are purely superficial.

It's rare to find a decent genuine friend these days. Especially in the school playground.

StrongerOrWeaker · 26/03/2022 06:33

I find it so pointless and unnecessary. I'd rather stand in what people call 'awkward silence '. To me this is bliss.