Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if many people actively enjoy small talk?

135 replies

thatsgotit · 25/03/2022 13:24

Not a journo, long-standing member, just curious. I'm an introvert and can do small talk when it's needed, but oh man, I hate it so much. I do enjoy getting to know people and having conversations that feel to me like they 'go' somewhere, but I just hate the fact that it's not considered socially acceptable to dive into 'meaningful' conversation without the obligatory exchanges about the weather, 'how are you?' (and the obligatory reply of 'very well, thank you' whether that happens to be true or not, rendering the question pointless), etc etc having to be got out of the way first, and as someone who doesn't have kids I'm always forgetting that I'm supposed to ask after other people's, which typically I only remember to do if I actually know the kid in question, or know something significant is going on with them.

If I sound a bit cynical it's just because I find it such a struggle. I accept that small talk serves a purpose in oiling the wheels of communication/breaking the ice etc and it's not that I don't want to find things out about people, I just tend to be more interested in exchanging opinions than facts, I suppose. So I'm curious, do many people actively enjoy small talk?

YABU = 'I enjoy small talk'
YANBU = 'I don't enjoy small talk'

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 27/03/2022 23:22

Thank you @Kanaloa. I think I put it quite clumsily, so I'm glad you know what I meant.

Kanaloa · 27/03/2022 23:07

@RampantIvy

There is a danger of those who disparage small talk sounding as if they think they are intellectually superior because they will only engage in deep, meaningful and intellectual discussions.
Yep. They think saying ‘I don’t like meaningless chat about other people’s kids, I can’t even remember their names. I like deep talk about literature and art,’ makes them sound intelligent. Actually it’s the opposite. The most impressive intelligence (in my opinion) is the ability to modify yourself to communicate with a wide variety of people and in all different situations. The most intelligent people I’ve met can chat about their colleagues kids and build good relationships and can have great conversations about classic novels.
SpringHasSprungYay · 27/03/2022 22:47

@GreenNewDealNow

Small talk is fine when you first meet someone as an icebreaker but if it never progresses past that I find it completely boring and draining.
This! It has to go somewhere doesn't it or it can get a bit excruciating.
underneaththeash · 27/03/2022 22:44

I'm an optometrist and I could honestly make small talk with a bin...it's very useful in health care situations to make people feel at ease and a lot of the time I actually enjoy it too.
Most people have something interesting to share about their lives.

I have a large store of interesting facts!

RampantIvy · 27/03/2022 22:39

There is a danger of those who disparage small talk sounding as if they think they are intellectually superior because they will only engage in deep, meaningful and intellectual discussions.

Ohyesiam · 27/03/2022 22:35

Some posts on here talk about small talk as a social lubricant, but today I experienced it more as social constipation.
I was bored by a series of people talking about the routes they take from A to B , telling apocryphal-sounding anecdotes that showed themselves in a good light, and remarking repeatedly about the food we were eating.
None of it felt like communication, more like jaw exercise for people who enjoy holding court.
God I was glad to get home. Small talk is the pits.

Veryverycalmnow · 26/03/2022 23:08

YANBU

HardbackWriter · 26/03/2022 22:47

@Rinatinabina

I hate it, but I’m socially awkward. I’d love it if someone started with “did you watch question time?” Why yes interesting stranger yes I did!
That is small talk, though, surely?
grapewines · 26/03/2022 22:45

I don’t like small talk, but I find that most people like talking about themselves so I ask questions. I sort of sit back and watch what they say unfold.

This is me. When I have to, I can do it well enough. But I often just let people talk.

FreezyFreezy · 26/03/2022 22:42

Yes, but I don't think I ever have anything other than small talk conversations because I find the deep and meaningful ones rather boring. I am not a very deep person though. I enjoy passing the time of day with people, whether I know them or not. I'm introverted and shy but don't mind swapping pleasantries.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 26/03/2022 22:42

Honestly it really depends on how much the other person gives back. If they give as good as they get then it can be quite fun and even easy. If not its like drawing blood oit of a stone.

Ohyesiam · 26/03/2022 22:39

I don’t like small talk, but I find that most people like talking about themselves so I ask questions. I sort of sit back and watch what they say unfold.
Actually I’m happy to do small talk in a professional capacity, such as when I collect a client I can put them at ease by making appropriate small talk on the way to the consultation room.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 26/03/2022 22:29

I like "passing" small talk - "Morning, lovely day we're having!" type exchanges which last less than a minute, with people I know by sight but not by name. It's friendly and pleasant. When you get caught in those conversations, though, it's pretty horrifying.

I hate the routine "how are you / how's work / how's X?" kind of conversations - they're boring, people don't want or give real answers and there's only so many lighthearted responses you can use. I'd rather cut straight to the real conversation, whether that's a chat about fun and interesting stuff we've done lately, actual problems, current affairs or special interest topics. I love listening to people talk about things they're passionate about if they know stuff I don't, or have an interesting perspective. Most people have something interesting to say, but you don't hear them when you're too busy offering paired responses about how your day's been.

thatsgotit · 26/03/2022 22:26

@YellowAndGreenToBeSeen I actually found your post quite thought-provoking as I enjoy conversations such as the one you described as well. I guess I tend to see 'small talk' as meaning the very limited weather/'how are you' type stuff which possibly isn't what everyone means by small talk. Grin

Quite a few responses on here have mentioned 'deep' conversations, but although I enjoy those in the right circumstances, I don't necessarily see the opposite of small talk as being about always having deep discussions - possibly I've expressed myself a bit inaccurately. Put it this way, I'd certainly never want anyone to feel scrutinised in a conversation with me (I'm prone to self-consciousness myself so would never want to make someone else feel that way), and I don't tend to ask people many questions for that exact reason, unless I know I'm on the same page as that person.

OP posts:
Rinatinabina · 26/03/2022 22:16

@FatOaf

I'd love it if someone started with “did you watch question time?”

Curious. My reply to that question would be a rant about how pointless Question Time is, and how insulting I found the suggestion that I might watch it. But I guess I just don't like people talking to me about anything, really.

Out of (feigned) interest, why do you enjoy listening to liars talking shit on television?

So I can shout at the TV. I actually stopped watching it out of irritation buuuuuut the general point still stands.
museumum · 26/03/2022 22:16

I wfh and love the little human interactions I get in the way to/from school or at the shops.
Obviously I would be missing out if these were my only interactions with people but I can’t spend time with my genuine friends every day and although I live my family I also like speaking to acquaintances or strangers.

RampantIvy · 26/03/2022 22:12

Small talk leads to deep and meaningful discussion though.

I recently joined a book group. We didn't just dive straight into a highbrow literary discussion straight away. We introduced ourselves first, then started talking about the book we had just read.

Mojoj · 26/03/2022 22:09

Being able to participate in small talk is a vastly underrated skill. It's very obvious when someone can't do it and I feel very sorry for them because they miss out on so much social interaction. Not every conversation has to be deep and meaningful. Sometimes it's just nice to shoot the breeze😀

Kanaloa · 26/03/2022 22:07

And then sometimes I’ll meet a colleague equally interested in literature which is lovely. How do I find out? Well they ask ‘any weekend plans’ and I say ‘yeah uni assignment haha’ and then it comes out they’re also interested in literature. Small talk, which leads to big talk. And sometimes it doesn’t but it certainly puts me in a good position with my colleagues because I’ve made the effort to build good relations with them.

thatsgotit · 26/03/2022 22:05

@nosyupnorth

Oh and the fact you say you get stuck in small talk doesn't mean small talk is bad, it might mean the small talk is serving it's purpose in letting people test the waters and they are deciding they don't want to get into deeper conversation with you - if you are dismissive and half-assed about small talk then that isn't going to leave people coming away with the reaction of 'thatsgotit is an engaging person I'd like to get to know better' they're going to think 'thatsgotit was acting dismissive and uninterested in our conversation clearly they don't want to talk more'.
Yes, it would convey that impression if I was dismissive or half-assed. But I wouldn't be, because I'm polite and do enjoy meeting people. "Dislikes small talk" doesn't automatically equal "rude and dismissive".
OP posts:
Kanaloa · 26/03/2022 22:05

@IJustLovePirates

I hate it too. I’ve had to train myself at work to discuss what people are having for lunch (a topic of seemingly endless fascination to everyone else) and I can never remember the details of my colleagues children, and what sporting event they’ve participated in. I’m also an introvert but love discussing books and language, and music. Things that I find meaningful.
I find people who say this so better-than. Oh I simply can’t be bothered to engage in trivial talk like everyone else and couldn’t imagine remembering the trivia of other people’s lives. Only the Donna Tartt like deep conversations of literature interest me.

It takes effort to remember the things important to others. Hardly any of us are fascinated in other people’s kids. But we remember to show we take an interest in others. Would I rather talk about African diasporic literature than Shelley’s little girl’s dance recital? Yeah, I would. But will that show her that I’m taking an active interest in her? No. So I join a book group and talk about literature there.

thatsgotit · 26/03/2022 22:01

@nosyupnorth

YABU

I find people who get very intrusive in early conversation or overshare about details I didn't want to know about their life/opinions very uncomfortable to deal with because they are at best rude and at worse deliberately trying to catch me out in saying something stupid about the very high brow deep talk topic they prefer or share an opinion they don't approve of.

Small talk is a conversational warm up, it lets you test the waters before getting onto deeper talk so that you can avoid wading into dangerous territories like getting into a disagreement with somebody you need to stay on the good side of or tripping into sensitive issues. In small talk you don't have to lie and say 'fine' when asked 'how are you' you just need to meet a causal inquiry with a causal answer - could be better/a bit tired/under the weather/the usual are all fine responses, just not taking it as an invitation to dump all your problems on the asker. Similarly sharing opinions on milder topics lets you feel out the ground for more serious ones, if you launch in with 'I hate XYZ and think everybody who likes it is stupid don't you agree?' it makes for a very awkward conversation if your partner actually doesn't agree but has now been backed into a corner.

I wasn't talking about being intrusive, rude or highbrow, though. I'm certainly none of those things myself.
OP posts:
Unicorndreams24 · 26/03/2022 21:49

I hate that awkwardness after :

" hi you ok?"

" yeh you"

" yeh fine "

It makes me cringe 😂😂

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 26/03/2022 21:47

I see I may have misunderstood - OP, you’re someone who loves to get invested and deep in conversation. Well, sure but when someone does that to me, I feel scrutinised, spot light and less inclined.

Small talk allows for common ground to be found without offence. It’s often the space where disagreement and humour meet.

IJustLovePirates · 26/03/2022 21:37

I hate it too. I’ve had to train myself at work to discuss what people are having for lunch (a topic of seemingly endless fascination to everyone else) and I can never remember the details of my colleagues children, and what sporting event they’ve participated in. I’m also an introvert but love discussing books and language, and music. Things that I find meaningful.