Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if many people actively enjoy small talk?

135 replies

thatsgotit · 25/03/2022 13:24

Not a journo, long-standing member, just curious. I'm an introvert and can do small talk when it's needed, but oh man, I hate it so much. I do enjoy getting to know people and having conversations that feel to me like they 'go' somewhere, but I just hate the fact that it's not considered socially acceptable to dive into 'meaningful' conversation without the obligatory exchanges about the weather, 'how are you?' (and the obligatory reply of 'very well, thank you' whether that happens to be true or not, rendering the question pointless), etc etc having to be got out of the way first, and as someone who doesn't have kids I'm always forgetting that I'm supposed to ask after other people's, which typically I only remember to do if I actually know the kid in question, or know something significant is going on with them.

If I sound a bit cynical it's just because I find it such a struggle. I accept that small talk serves a purpose in oiling the wheels of communication/breaking the ice etc and it's not that I don't want to find things out about people, I just tend to be more interested in exchanging opinions than facts, I suppose. So I'm curious, do many people actively enjoy small talk?

YABU = 'I enjoy small talk'
YANBU = 'I don't enjoy small talk'

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thatsgotit · 03/04/2022 17:05

@Kanaloa

It's a bit of a leap, for example, to think that if people don't enjoy small talk they must want to ask intrusive questions or have intellectual discussions.

Not really, I was responding to what posters have said. Several have said things like ‘I can’t remember the names of colleagues children, I prefer to talk about meaningful things/I only like to talk about art and literature etc.’ You’ll see it in the previous posts. The very arrogance and pretentiousness of it makes me cringe.

Fair comment, I spotted those comments too. Partly why I wanted to point out that I'm not like that myself 😄 and I suspect lots of us non-small-talk-fans aren't either.
OP posts:
Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 02:22

It's a bit of a leap, for example, to think that if people don't enjoy small talk they must want to ask intrusive questions or have intellectual discussions.

Not really, I was responding to what posters have said. Several have said things like ‘I can’t remember the names of colleagues children, I prefer to talk about meaningful things/I only like to talk about art and literature etc.’ You’ll see it in the previous posts. The very arrogance and pretentiousness of it makes me cringe.

toconclude · 02/04/2022 22:21

I don't enjoy it much either but it oils the wheels so I put on a show.
Fortunately most family and friends want to talk about real stuff pretty soon in a conversation

thatsgotit · 02/04/2022 14:34

Only just getting back to this after a tough week, but I just wanted to say that although there are some interesting points here that have got me thinking, to me there are also some odd extrapolations. It's a bit of a leap, for example, to think that if people don't enjoy small talk they must want to ask intrusive questions or have intellectual discussions. The word 'deep' has been used a lot and I personally wasn't really talking about deep conversations, though other posters may have been. I can only guess people are speaking from their own past experiences and I certainly don't recognise myself in some of the remarks pps have made.

It has got me thinking about whether I classify small talk the same way as other people though. To me small talk = the weather, what was on TV last night, what each person did at the weekend, with the conversation not really broadening out from those topics at any point so they naturally peter out. I recognise that's normal in scenarios like the workplace where people often don't have the time or inclination for further talk. But if, on the other hand, that conversation branched out at some point into anecdotes about things the participants had experienced involving weather (e.g. being snowed in or having witnessed a tornado), or the fact that one of us had actually been on TV, or if the small talk about the weekend led to a discovery that I and the other person had a shared hobby, the conversation would probably broaden out into something I would consider more meaningful, not in the sense of 'deep' or intellectual, simply that it would lead to more information being exchanged. And then it would feel easier to maintain the conversation for whatever length of time/in whatever depth was appropriate for both participants. Nothing to do with being intrusive, wanting the conversation to turn into book club, expecting people to bare their souls after five minutes, etc, unless it naturally evolved that way on both sides. That's my take on it anyway.

OP posts:
Hadtocomment · 01/04/2022 16:08

It's interesting to note too how what they call low-level social interaction is increasingly thought to be important for the brain. There may be a lot more importance to small talk and may be far greater individual and societal benefits than people often consider on these threads.

bumblingbovine49 · 29/03/2022 19:59

@WlNDMlLL

Surely though if you only enjoy jumping straight into 'meaningful conversations' you only enjoy talking about subjects that are interesting to you? How on earth do you ever find that common ground with people if you don't have any sort of chit chat beforehand? I bet you're equally as put out by people who talk about subjects that don't interest you. And what about people you come into contact with daily but have little time to build a proper relationship with - would you prefer to ignore them? I see someone at work for 1-5 minutes every day but over time I've learnt little snippets about her. It would be bizarre if after several years all we had ever said to each other was hello! We literally don't have time for an in depth discussion though.
Absolutely this. People who want deep conversations immediately are giving no thought to what the other person might find interesting. Small talk is about getting to know someone and possibly easing into a topic that might be more interesting if things work out that way. Sometimes I manage small talk fine and sometimes it is difficult, mostly depending on my mood. When I am in the mood though, a light-hearted, chat that is genuinely two way can be very energising and cheering .
balalake · 29/03/2022 19:42

Many people talk to very few people in their daily life, around 1 in 5 live alone (last figure I saw) and with more time spent at home, I would guess many value any conversations they can have.

Kanaloa · 29/03/2022 19:37

Obviously it’s a bit different if it’s a stranger on the bus just forcing their conversation on someone who is obviously happy alone. I was referring to small talk amongst people you know but aren’t close with - people at the school gates, colleagues you don’t work closely with etc. Always useful to be an approachable person to these acquaintances and you never know when it will prove useful. I wouldn’t be as keen to engage in small talk with a total stranger when I’m already busy of course!

LazyJayne · 29/03/2022 17:27

The alternative to 'small talk' doesn't have to be 'deep talk' Hmm just keep yer gob shut Grin

DoorLion · 29/03/2022 17:02

If I’m sat on a bus etc I might often use the time to think through issues, thoughts, ideas etc, I’ve got a great conversation going on in my head.

Me too - I spend a lot of time like that and when I worked in an office I used to leg it into town so I could have a lovely solitary lunch in a cafe rather than spend it chatting to my colleagues. However in that case it would be any kind of talk or interaction I would be annoyed by - not just small talk., I would be equally put out by an in-depth conversation! So for me that isn't an argument against small talk, it is an argument against basically talking to me at all a lot of the time Grin. But I think we are basically saying the same thing.

Solosunrise · 29/03/2022 16:59

Totally, @OMG12
I don't like being talked at either. What I was getting at is that it's not the small talk that's the problem, but the failure of people to pick up social cues.

OMG12 · 29/03/2022 16:50

@Solosunrise

It seems there are varying definitions on here for small talk. To me it's an opener - a way of communicating and to find out a bit about people, to show care and to see if there is potential for something more interesting. If I speak to someone and they grunt or body language shows that they don't want to converse, then I don't. I don't often use public transport but if I'm at a social event, it comes with an expectation that people will talk to each other. So the 'small talk' is effectively the warm up. I don't want someone launching at me with political views or boring me with their current favourite topic. So the 'how do you know the host/did you have a nice weekend etc' is gateway to getting a feel for someone and a method for finding some common ground. The way I understand it, the small talk itself is just a means to an end. If someone clearly doesn't want to engage, I move on.

I'm team @RampantIvy, @Kanaloa and co.

And as an opener it’s fine if there is an intent to move onto something a bit more meaningful. I think the trouble arises when the entire conversation is made up of it to basically fill a void because one person is uncomfortable with silence. If that’s the case many would rather be left alone with their own thoughts.

If I’m sat on a bus etc I might often use the time to think through issues, thoughts, ideas etc, I’ve got a great conversation going on in my head. If I was having that conversation with another person no one would plonk themselves down and start going on about how busy town is, the weather etc so I’m irritated if someone does it whilst I’m having a discussion etc in my mind. If I judge someone is lonely etc talking to them then has a purpose. But someone who talks because they don’t appreciate the value of silence can be bloody irritating.

Solosunrise · 29/03/2022 09:02

It seems there are varying definitions on here for small talk. To me it's an opener - a way of communicating and to find out a bit about people, to show care and to see if there is potential for something more interesting.
If I speak to someone and they grunt or body language shows that they don't want to converse, then I don't.
I don't often use public transport but if I'm at a social event, it comes with an expectation that people will talk to each other. So the 'small talk' is effectively the warm up.
I don't want someone launching at me with political views or boring me with their current favourite topic.
So the 'how do you know the host/did you have a nice weekend etc' is gateway to getting a feel for someone and a method for finding some common ground.
The way I understand it, the small talk itself is just a means to an end. If someone clearly doesn't want to engage, I move on.

I'm team @RampantIvy, @Kanaloa and co.

Hadtocomment · 28/03/2022 10:10

So what do you call small talk versus big talk? Some people are brilliantly entertaining. I have one friend who makes me laugh like a drain because she's hilariously funny. The subject isn't big necessarily. But she wraps it up in a very entertaining way? Would that count as small talk? Or do you mean talk which feels a bit constrained so you can't laugh like a drain? Is that the talk or the occasion though? For example there is nothing more excruciating than networking occasions for work or whatever where you feel under pressure and nervous and where perhaps laughing like a drain might not be totally appropriate. Or occasions where you have to be very polite and restrained? I think the thing about small talk is that it's often in situations where people don't know each other and aren't relaxed so maybe it's that which is unpleasant about it. But like others I was amazed how important the odd remark or verbal interaction became for me during the height of the first lockdown. And it was weird how at one point I almost felt I was losing the ability to speak in those situations. Connection to the outside world is so important. It can make a real difference just to break the ice and see people smile and engage and feel part of a friendly environment rather than seeing a lot of closed off faces. Maybe making small talk a bit more fun or entertaining is the way to go.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/03/2022 08:32

I don’t mind it as long as the other person throws the ball back, so to speak. I still remember one ghastly pre Christmas do where I knew nobody but the hosts (who were busy in the kitchen etc.) - I was valiantly trying to make small talk with a couple I didn’t know.

Me: are you going away for Christmas?
Them: No.
Me: Have you finished your Christmas shopping yet?
Them: Yes.
Etc.
Bloody nightmare!

OMG12 · 28/03/2022 08:32

There’s a difference between first meeting someone and exchanging a few niceties before discovering their likes dislikes and then moving to a fulfilling conversation and being trapped on a bus, in the street etc by someone who can fill an entire conversation with variants of “nice weather for the time of year” one has a purpose as a gateway into something potentially good, the other is pointless drivel to fill a beautiful silence.

RampantIvy · 28/03/2022 06:44

How do the small talk haters meet new people or make new friends without some sort of opener conversation?

How do you know whether you can talk about the literary delights of War and Peace with someone without ascertaining that they enjoy reading in the first place?

Surely you need some kind of ice breaker?

ClaryFairchild · 28/03/2022 02:39

Like hell am I trusting someone I either have just met or know on a social level with my in depth thoughts about meaningful topics. My inner thoughts are for me and my loved ones and close friends - everyone else gets the social chit chat until I feel I can trust them, and even then it's a gradual build.

thepeopleversuswork · 28/03/2022 02:00

I agree with @Kanaloa

Small talk opens doors to people. It’s a way to get an angle on someone, to glean some insight into what makes them tick.

People who insist on having some God-given right only to talk about Ukraine or astrophysics or Dostoyevsky right off the bat are often tone deaf, emotionally infantile and lacking in empathy.

Of course if you should find the person you are talking to is also fired up about this stuff you can then go on to have great conversation about these things. But trying to cut small talk out altogether is basically insisting everyone has to always meet you on your own very narrow terms. It’s selfish and needlessly self limiting.

sarah13xx · 28/03/2022 01:23

Hate it! Have only realised in the last year or two just how much I actually hate it. I’ve had to give myself a talking to recently because I go through the same cycle almost every time I see someone in a shop situation for example. It’s so much less hassle just to grab what I want, swerve the aisle they’re on and go. I also hate the fact that if I’ve decided that’s the plan I’m following and then it backfires and they see me I have to do the false shock like I had no idea they were in the shop and I haven’t been watching them from a far trying to avoid them like the plague. I’ve promised myself I’ll stop this because this week I went through the usual discussion with myself in my head when seeing a supermarket checkout woman that I know. She very overly loudly shouted hi to me after I’d been there a while and had pretended not to see her. I felt like she was maybe highlighting that I had seen her but I’m not sure. I wasn’t being rude, I think some people just don’t realise how much some people want to avoid the small talk 🤦🏼‍♀️ desperately trying to stop it! T

Sunnytwobridges · 28/03/2022 01:11

Hate it. I always run out of things to say so then there’s this awkward silence . I just hate it.

I really hate when my coworkers call me and they ask about my weekend, blah blah blah and I’m clenching my teeth trying not to say “please just get to the point!!!” IRS so excruciating 😂

TooManyPJs · 28/03/2022 00:31

I HATE small talk. With a passion. But I have ADHD and that's seems to be very common.

I find it inanely boring but also difficult (the worst combination). As I can never think of what to say or ask and am constantly trying to figure out what's appropriate (eg my answer to "how are you?" Is not naturally "I'm fine"!!). It's also extremely hard to focus on boring conversation which doesn't help matters.

pastypirate · 27/03/2022 23:49

That said I'll tolerate small talk in favour of people complaining at me about something I have no control over. I cannot cannot stand this unless it's dm or the dc.

pastypirate · 27/03/2022 23:42

I find small talk the constant repetition of information the other person already knows.

At work I can small do it to infinity and it's a contracting skill I'm good at. Outside of work I find it very irritating with people I already know well. It's one of a few reasons I ended a recent relationship but not the main reason. Exp constant attempts to have conversations about nothing - the weather and my new plates ffs that's what drove me over the edge.

I find for example the expectation that you repeat the word thank you about 12 times during a single transaction with a cashier very strange.

I am being assessed for adhd currently and dd1 who is v much like me is probably on the spectrum. I know these things are very much related.

Kanaloa · 27/03/2022 23:25

No you put it perfectly. I tried to explain it earlier but couldn’t find the correct words but I agree one hundred percent. Sociability and the ability to get along is a part of intelligence. Great if you’re desperate to discuss Thomas Hardy but unless you’re a literary academic it’s unlikely to be the only thing you need to do and it makes you look a bit small minded/socially unintelligent.