Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is there such a thing as overstimulation (kids)

61 replies

Toyrus · 25/03/2022 11:03

DD 4.5 is very social and loves activities/nursery. She is going to nursery 4 half days and one full day a week. 3 other afternoons she is doing classes. I should add that she is the one asking for all these additional activities, if it was for me I'd keep her home for the afternoon or just take her to the local playground. On top of this we manage to squeeze about 3 play dates a week, sometimes 4, as she has a lot of friends who want to see her.

Lately she's becoming a bit withdrawn, her speech has regressed a bit and she finds it harder to form long sentences. I have some concerns about her behaviour too, seems a bit odd the way she interacts with her friends.

DH thinks this is because she is too tired and over stimulated. But I know he says that partly because we are always out and he feels a bit lonely and neglected (he works from home). Is there such a thing as overstimulatiom having a negative impact on children? I mean she doesn't do much academic stuff, it's mainly play...and classes are sports and drama.

OP posts:
Parkedthespaceshiponthelanding · 26/03/2022 06:55

A 4.5 year old at school would be doing 5 full days and certainly wouldn't be unusual to have a couple of play dates and clubs after school. Unless she is getting upset going, then I don't think she is doing much.

Is it a nursery attached to a school? If not, it could be many children her age are moving in preparation for school and she's playing with younger children. Or maybe playing with younger children regardless.

It could be she's seen younger children get more attention and she wants to play baby or/and be babied.

I'd probably just 'I didn't understand that, can you say it again?' when she's saying words she knows how to say incorrectly. Suspect it will pass when she starts school at the latest.

Toyrus · 25/03/2022 16:20

@Burgoo I'm sure a lot of it is true. It's not something that I have given much thought to before, like I said I followed her lead. But I'm glad to read all these responses, it does make me put things into perspective.

OP posts:
Barrawarra · 25/03/2022 16:11

I know I get overstimulated when I’ve too much on, so why wouldn’t kids?!

Toyrus · 25/03/2022 16:08

@PinkSyCo oh no, my DD loves her friends too and is always up for a play date. I would never push her into any of it. If I'm completely honest I don't really enjoy play dates, I'm an introvert and I much rather go to a playground and let her do her own thing. It's just that some of her friends don't have so many other friends or classes like her and so request a few play dates a week, which is not something that we can possibly do. I rarely arrange anything tbh. because we simply don't have any time left.

We had play dates every day of the week this week and had one scheduled today between pre school and her class which thankfully got cancelled. Then I'm going to cancel another proposal for Sunday, just need a quiet Mother's day.

I didn't believe the boy did anything because I didn't see it and it would be completely unusual for him. He is very well behaved and likes her a lot and if he really did anything serious she'd have reacted differently. I think she probably just needed some time out but didn't know how to express it.

OP posts:
SmellyOldOwls · 25/03/2022 15:42

@Poppy92r

Have you asked her if there's anything bothering her? In a quiet place, just the two of you?

I don't necessarily think that 4 half days and 1 full day at nursery with some extra activities outside that is too much. It could be too much for some children - absolutely - but I'd be expecting a different behaviour if that were the case and I'd be expecting that behaviour to be linked to the days activities.

Red flags for me OP

  • Regression with speech that isn't linked to being tired at the end of the day
  • Unusual behaviour with friends (possibly even making things up?)
  • Becoming withdrawn
  • Sleeping more than normal

I'm also gleaning that while she's social and quietly confident, she's also maybe slightly introverted around adults as part of her nature?

You say she told you her friend did something, but you suspect she made it up - what did he do? why didn't you believe her?

4yr olds when they're tired and over stimulated- it's usually really obvious (highly fussy/tantruming etc) and you can see the link to where you are in the day.

You describe a subtle but also significant behavioural change. Significant enough that it brought you here to ask for help because you can feel in your gut something is wrong? Is that fair to say?

So I'd be approaching this two fold

  • one is a clinical route - book a non-urgent appointment with the GP. Wait times are usually 3 weeks and during that time I'd be keeping a note on things like the speech, sleeping etc. If it comes to nothing, she has a bit of downtime, and she goes back to normal and it really is just a case of over tiredness you can always cancel the appointment
  • the 2nd is psychological and safeguarding. Take some time with her, remind her she's not to keep secrets from Mummy and try and get her to open up a little bit. I'm not saying jump to the worst possible conclusion but I would be wondering if something in her little world is making her anxious?
I absolutely agree with this I'm afraid. I don't think she's necessarily doing too much, my 4 year old goes to school all day, a class on a Monday, play dates or park after school on lots of days, out most Saturdays and visiting family on Sundays. I know they're l different but it's just to give you an idea OP.

Regression in speech and change in behavior should be checked by a doctor.

Burgoo · 25/03/2022 15:31

This isn't related to your daughter specifically but just my take on over-stimulation in general.

I believe that there is such thing as over-stimulation when it comes to children and I have a strong suspicion that this has been one of the key drivers of anxiety and depression in teenagers. Hold your horses before jumping on me though!

There is a large amount of data that shows over the past 10-15 years the amount of time which children and adolescents are "on" has increased massively. From computer games and social media to groups and social functions, children do more now than at any point in history (except being stuck up chimneys but I'm not advocating for that!) I don't think it is a coincidence that teens have been more miserable and anxious since this time. Why? Because when do children just "be"? If we get our children to "do" all of the time, then they can't sit with emotions, thoughts and their experience without needing a distraction.

Mindfulness has seen a big drive over the past decade and rightfully too. People in general have to be distracted, often because they can't tolerate feeling or thinking. The problem is that over time this stops us being able to anticipate problems and deal with them in advance - leading to higher anxiety when problems crop up.

If you look at the following, I would suggest a middle ground would be much healthier for ALL people, not just kids:

Being Doing

Being is just being in the moment. Not thinking about the future or the past. Just noticing where we are, what we feel and our experiences.

Doing is being actively engaged in "things" - occupation, education, activity, social etc. We are often on auto-pilot at these times.

I do have hope though as mindfulness and other types of grounding are being widely taught in schools now so I hope the next generation will do more "being".

Anyway I am unsure if I have answered the question but I hope you get what I mean!

PinkSyCo · 25/03/2022 15:22

I think your DD is doing too much and in doing so she has missed out on learning to play alone, which is a very important skill. I’ve noticed you’ve said a couple of times in your posts that you arrange play dates because the other children/child love your DD, which seems rather strange to me. Where do your DD’s thoughts/wants come into this? Is she being pushed into these play dates? And why didn’t you believe her when she said the boy did something to her? Maybe try slowing it down and actually listening to your DD so that hopefully you will be able to get to the bottom of her rather worrying change of behaviour.

YoYoYoYoSup · 25/03/2022 15:02

Why are you limiting tv so much? Couple of hours a day won't hurt her and might give her the unwind time she needs.

LadyMacduff · 25/03/2022 15:00

I agree that children need to learn to play by themselves which will be harder if they've been brought up being entertained all the time. My son is 4 as well and is very happy to play with his trains or build lego by himself. He plays out scenarios and does voices for the characters. He goes round the garden looking for bugs or messing about with the gravel and the watering can.

pawcontrol · 25/03/2022 14:38

Impressive on the Tv, i think most kids have double this ( 2 hours) or a lot have much much more ( despite what the hairy handed on here say about their child having 10 minutes once a fortnight.)

Do you feel the play has changed from alongside to more interactive games? It maybe either the kids are behind her and she's loosing interest. Her being an older in the school year child. Or she's not so interested in their games and prefers playing alongside. I wouldn't jump to a special need, but worth keeping an eye on her health. So many bugs around but if it goes on too long definitely a doctor visit. A multivitamin daily is a good support of you don't already.

Poppy92r · 25/03/2022 14:07

Have you asked her if there's anything bothering her? In a quiet place, just the two of you?

I don't necessarily think that 4 half days and 1 full day at nursery with some extra activities outside that is too much. It could be too much for some children - absolutely - but I'd be expecting a different behaviour if that were the case and I'd be expecting that behaviour to be linked to the days activities.

Red flags for me OP

  • Regression with speech that isn't linked to being tired at the end of the day
  • Unusual behaviour with friends (possibly even making things up?)
  • Becoming withdrawn
  • Sleeping more than normal

I'm also gleaning that while she's social and quietly confident, she's also maybe slightly introverted around adults as part of her nature?

You say she told you her friend did something, but you suspect she made it up - what did he do? why didn't you believe her?

4yr olds when they're tired and over stimulated- it's usually really obvious (highly fussy/tantruming etc) and you can see the link to where you are in the day.

You describe a subtle but also significant behavioural change. Significant enough that it brought you here to ask for help because you can feel in your gut something is wrong? Is that fair to say?

So I'd be approaching this two fold

  • one is a clinical route - book a non-urgent appointment with the GP. Wait times are usually 3 weeks and during that time I'd be keeping a note on things like the speech, sleeping etc. If it comes to nothing, she has a bit of downtime, and she goes back to normal and it really is just a case of over tiredness you can always cancel the appointment
  • the 2nd is psychological and safeguarding. Take some time with her, remind her she's not to keep secrets from Mummy and try and get her to open up a little bit. I'm not saying jump to the worst possible conclusion but I would be wondering if something in her little world is making her anxious?
Toyrus · 25/03/2022 13:48

@pawcontrol she does enjoy watching TV, but we keep it to 45 mins a day, max 1 hour.

OP posts:
pawcontrol · 25/03/2022 12:59

My kids (5 & 2) are like this they get so tired but won't just play or do an activity by themselves for even 2 seconds. So I have to be the entertainer or tell them what to get out or manage it. That is exhausting too. So it's easy to try to fill the time.

They love TV 📺 will she sit and chill out watching something?

CanYouRowRow · 25/03/2022 12:50

She's used to being stimulated, so time at home will probably feel quite "boring". This doesn't mean this isn't what she needs.

TabbyMcTatBuskersCat · 25/03/2022 12:45

You have to let kids be bored and learn how to entertain themselves. That's part of their learning development.

Toyrus · 25/03/2022 12:24

Just collected her from nursery now and she says she is so bored. She has a class at 4 and can't wait to go.

OP posts:
Toyrus · 25/03/2022 12:22

She's not very good at playing alone, so we have to entertain her if we stay home. Being out is the easier option most of the time. Plus when she does classes I have some time to myself.

OP posts:
Toyrus · 25/03/2022 12:15

@Poppy92r I'll ask nursery at the next parents meeting end of Apr. I don't expect they noticed much as she is not very vocal at nursery. She is quietly confident and only recently they told me they were really pleasantly surprised at how articulate and confident she was when talking to her class about her half term trip to the sea side. They probably haven't heard much from her before.

On Tue she was having a play date with her friend from gymnastics, a boy who loves her and can't wait to see her every week. He is bright and very well behaved. She pulled away from him in the playground and didn't play with him until he left at 4 pm. She said he did something which I didn't see and I suspect she made it up and found an excuse to ignore him. That's never happened before as she does like him a lot too. Also did the same with another friend a few days before, after begging me to arrange a play date with her.

With the speaking, it's at different times of the day, morning, afternoon etc.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 25/03/2022 12:13

I think it’s important to teach kids to have down time as much as having opportunity for lots of activities. Kids really benefit from being bored, making their own play and simply resting - it gives them space to process everything they’re learning at that age. Cut back a bit, have some down time at home and see how she gets on.

JesusSufferingFuck22 · 25/03/2022 12:12

Yes! My dd wanted to do ALL the activities and ALL the play dates. She was completely over scheduled. She was a lot happier when we seriously cut back on activities and just hung out at home for a good chunk of time.

Poppy92r · 25/03/2022 11:41

Have you asked her nursery if they've noticed anything?
With the speaking - is it all the time? Even in the mornings or later on in the day?
What do you mean odd behaviour with friends? Can you give an example?

SummerInSun · 25/03/2022 11:39

At 4, she may know what she wants, but not what she needs. It's great that she embraces new activities and friends and wants to do them, but she's too little to understand the cumulative effect on her.

My 9 year old DS can have a weekend full of activities that he loves and have a brilliant time, but then on Sunday evening he'll complain he didn't have any quiet time at home to just play. But a 4 year old doesn't have that self awareness.

Howareyouflower · 25/03/2022 11:39

I do think children need some time just to be. To sit and watch TV or look at books, to nap or have a cuddle. Time to indulge in some imaginative play. Time to learn how to entertain themselves. You are filling her time with organised activity, including playdates. I'd cut down to just nursery and one playdate every couple of weeks. You can always re-evaluate it after a month or so.

Toyrus · 25/03/2022 11:36

@Aroundtheworldin80moves yes, for instance on Tue she goes to preschool until 11:45, then lunch, then 1:45 gymnastics for 45 mins and after that she has a play date with a friend from gymnastics until 4 pm. Obviously this is not every day. Mon she has no classes so we have just a play date for 1.5 hrs.

OP posts:
Aroundtheworldin80moves · 25/03/2022 11:31

Is she doing nursery, class and playdate in one day? It is a lot.

I'd aim for one quiet day a week with no plans as a minimum. Especially with school in a few months, she will need a weekend day to relax.