Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school need to get a grip?

309 replies

Tyrozet · 25/03/2022 10:21

Just had a text from my son informing me of a letter he is bringing home from school about a trip abroad next year.

The cost of the trip alone is nearly £1000 - it is a skiing trip so on top of the basic cost of the trip, special clothes need to be purchased, passports paid for and of course spending money - I'd say all in it will be at least £1500.

It's a state school in a town with many deprived areas.

I know you can just say "no" if it's not affordable but AIBU to think the school shouldn't be putting on trips like this at a time when many families are having to choose between which basic essentials they can afford?

Things are shit enough as it is for alot of people without having the added kick in the teeth that this is completely unreachable at the moment.

OP posts:
NeedAHoliday2021 · 25/03/2022 13:17

My daughter’s school is doing this and there are 40 spaces so most dc won’t be going. My daughter is going and so are her close friends. We can’t afford to go skiing as a family of 5 but the experience will be amazing for her in year 10. In 3 years my twins will want to go so that’ll be double and we’ll plan for it. Many families can afford these trips but they’re not mandatory and most dc won’t be going.

2bazookas · 25/03/2022 13:16

So, have I got this right, you think working class parents should not provide their children with any of the opportunities, skills, or advantages the parents never experienced ?

What a dismally limiting outlook.

superram · 25/03/2022 13:16

To be fully inclusive the trip would have to be free-trips in term time have to be accessible. My school ran a ski trip, my parents couldn’t afford to send me, I lived.

Change123today · 25/03/2022 13:15

Our daughter state school covers a massive area (including deprived areas) year in take - 240, is planning a ski trip they gave us well over a year notice (nearly 18 months! It’s not in term time) it’s £1k - We as a family could never afford to go sking but we put her name down for this - birthday/Christmas will be presents from family for the ski trip - things she will need. Yes I will have to manage my money and we paying by instalments.

I wasn’t sure whether it would be popular …out of 240 kids 145 applied to go.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 25/03/2022 13:15

@superram

I run a ski trip, of course I’ve thought about the expense and I’d like to think I’m not tone deaf. We have a fund to support some low income families. About 45% of ONE year group apply and I take about 33%. If I opened it to the whole school I could fill it many, many times over. It is in the school holidays, I don’t get paid for going or for organising it (I think I’m probably on 500 hours?!) but I do it as I think it’s a great opportunity. I teach in a mixed area, parents know about it from when they join the school. Some kids can afford to go on all the trips, some none. My kids will be somewhere between the two but would have to put birthday/Christmas money into the pot. If you think running a trip for almost 100 kids is a jolly then you are sadly mistaken. I do open it to all staff but can only take 8.
So do your staff and you pay for your own trips, equipment, skiing passes etc @superram? Because I really don't see why you would do it if its as awful as you describe. Who do you think it's a good opportunity for?

Do you not see that low income families have enough to deal with, without having to compete for a place in your poverty fund?

Loopyloulou007 · 25/03/2022 13:14

Have you had a chat with the school. They do subsidise for some. My daughter had to miss out on all school trips as we couldn't afford it, but was a straight A student and I was upset, that yet again we could not afford it. I wrote to the school and they asked what I could afford and paid that, they chipped in the rest. They do have funds put aside, for things like this.

PruGnu · 25/03/2022 13:14

YABU. We couldn't afford to take DC on a trip like that as a family, just not doable. But I could just about afford to send the DC on that trip with school, which would be a great experience.

My parents could never afford such a trip for me and I never went on them. No hard feelings, I worked hard at school, got a decent job and paid for myself to go on holidays in my 20s.

Kolani · 25/03/2022 13:13

@LittleGwyneth

I think it's pretty tone deaf honestly. But then I don't really think it's on the school to provide ski trips. Odd form of enrichment.
But it’s not “Tone deaf” because they’re not forcing you to go.
aliloandabanana · 25/03/2022 13:13

I completely agree with you OP.

I find this attitude that everyone should have the opportunity to experience skiing, or that skiing is something a school should be encouraging, very odd. It's a ridiculously expensive winter sport that can't easily be continued in this country, should the children enjoy it.

If this sort of expensive pastime is so important, why do schools never take pupils scuba diving in the Maldives?!

I'm guessing there's a teacher who enjoys skiing enough to put up with dealing with the children for the sake of a free holiday, who's willing to organise it.

pixie5121 · 25/03/2022 13:13

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 25/03/2022 13:13

@GivenchyDahhling

I actually think the opposite to your last post OP - if state schools, especially ones in poorer areas, DIDN’T offer these trips I think that would be divisive - because the trips, and skiing as a sport, would go back to being the preserve of private schools and the super rich.
It already is, @GivenchyDahhling - I don't know a single person on a low income that goes skiing, the equipment hire alone is more than their daily budget for fun and food.
Onlyforcake · 25/03/2022 13:11

I want my child to get an education at school, an academic one. Not a lesson in elitism.

superram · 25/03/2022 13:11

I run a ski trip, of course I’ve thought about the expense and I’d like to think I’m not tone deaf. We have a fund to support some low income families. About 45% of ONE year group apply and I take about 33%. If I opened it to the whole school I could fill it many, many times over. It is in the school holidays, I don’t get paid for going or for organising it (I think I’m probably on 500 hours?!) but I do it as I think it’s a great opportunity. I teach in a mixed area, parents know about it from when they join the school. Some kids can afford to go on all the trips, some none. My kids will be somewhere between the two but would have to put birthday/Christmas money into the pot. If you think running a trip for almost 100 kids is a jolly then you are sadly mistaken. I do open it to all staff but can only take 8.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 25/03/2022 13:11

I completely agree with you @Tyrozet - I was the poor kid whose parents had no money for our school skiing trip, it was hard enough to afford the days out and we never had foreign holidays as a family. The school focused so hard on the "equality" aspect of us all having (expensive) school uniform, but then created situations like this to divide the haves and have nots.

What I found was that it also disrupted existing friendships across the rich/poor divide - the kids who could afford it all bonded on these trips, made new friends and left the rest of us behind. Skiing is particularly unnecessary as a school holiday - at least foreign exchanges allow you to learn languages and culture which are directly transferable for most jobs. Even when I worked in a shop after school my French and German was used for visitors.

Harlequin1088 · 25/03/2022 13:11

When I was a kid, I used to bin the ski trip letters they sent home every year. Never took them home to show my parents. I knew money was tight when we were kids. Parents were divorced so two lots of household expenditure to consider not just one and even as a kid I was wise enough to realise we had more going out than we had coming in, and I didn’t want my folks feeling pressured into trying to find the funds to send me on a ski trip that had no educational value. A trip to a museum with the history class - fine. Ski trip for a week to goof off - not financially justifiable.

nokidshere · 25/03/2022 13:09

I don't think any state school should organise trips like this.

But then you are excluding even more people? We definitely could never afford a skiing trip for the 4 of us as a family. DS2 only got the opportunity to do one because it was a school trip and someone else would be taking him.

So you think it's fair that because you can't go we shouldn't go either? Bizarre logic.

Onlyforcake · 25/03/2022 13:09

These are the sort of trips state school shouldn't be pushing. It's all for a few pictures to make it look wonderfully good at offering exciting opportunities to prospective parents, attract the sort of people that want their child to go on skiing trips etc. But it's an exclusive opportunity, trips through school should be inclusive, it's a state school - with delusions.

GivenchyDahhling · 25/03/2022 13:09

I actually think the opposite to your last post OP - if state schools, especially ones in poorer areas, DIDN’T offer these trips I think that would be divisive - because the trips, and skiing as a sport, would go back to being the preserve of private schools and the super rich.

mam0918 · 25/03/2022 13:09

@Snoozer11

Some people can't afford a £300 trip. Would the school be unreasonable to continue to organise those?

What about school lunches? Some parents can only afford a packed lunch for their kids. Should the school enforce packed lunches for all?

It is not the fault of the school if your child can't understand that their parents can't afford a £1500 ski trip or you are unable to tell them "no".

Where have you been?

School meals are the subsidized and free option... its pack lunches people cant afford.

Snoozer11 · 25/03/2022 13:08

@LadyHonoriaDedlock

Crass and tone deaf. Our school is doing a residential in this country that costs £120 and they're letting us pay it off over a year because that's how life is right now. Who the heck can afford over a grand?
Lots of people can afford it.
Snoozer11 · 25/03/2022 13:08

@Tyrozet

I think alot of people have missed my point, or maybe I haven't explained it too well.

I actually think that in a school environment, this sort of trip is divisive and discriminates against people who are from poorer backgrounds.

I understand that not everyone will be able to afford every trip, but this isn't necessary or educational, it's a holiday being facilitated by the school which blatantly excludes a large number of pupils because of their background.

Well-off families who can summon up £200 by next week to enter the lottery for a place will be fine, but others who can't come up with that sum of money with no notice wont get a look in - even if we could afford to save the installments for the rest of the trip.

No, we understand your point perfectly.
pixie5121 · 25/03/2022 13:06

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

SockFluffInTheBath · 25/03/2022 13:06

@Whatalovelydaffodil

I don't think any state school should organise trips like this.
So only private school kids should get the chance? That is divisive. If 20 kids from a school of 1,000 go on the ski trip then that’s hardly marginalising or highlighting the ones who don’t go.
Whatalovelydaffodil · 25/03/2022 13:04

I don't think any state school should organise trips like this.

montysma1 · 25/03/2022 13:04

You think it's inclusive😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread