Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school need to get a grip?

309 replies

Tyrozet · 25/03/2022 10:21

Just had a text from my son informing me of a letter he is bringing home from school about a trip abroad next year.

The cost of the trip alone is nearly £1000 - it is a skiing trip so on top of the basic cost of the trip, special clothes need to be purchased, passports paid for and of course spending money - I'd say all in it will be at least £1500.

It's a state school in a town with many deprived areas.

I know you can just say "no" if it's not affordable but AIBU to think the school shouldn't be putting on trips like this at a time when many families are having to choose between which basic essentials they can afford?

Things are shit enough as it is for alot of people without having the added kick in the teeth that this is completely unreachable at the moment.

OP posts:
Tyrozet · 25/03/2022 20:43

To all the posters who have said it's fine as it's not in school time, I've just read the letter which explicitly says this trip will take place during term time.

OP posts:
TooManyPJs · 25/03/2022 20:26

Oh I don't know. This is actually a cheap option for a ski trip. Obviously out of reach of low income families but might allow some children from middle income households who couldn't afford for the whole family to go but might be able to afford this.

We can't all do everything but doesn't mean everyone should miss out.

I grew up in a low income household and I couldn't go on all the trips because of this.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 25/03/2022 20:24

DCs school give quite a bit of notice about the ski trip and the payments are in instalments over many months which is what we did for DCs to go. It was a big stretch for us to afford but we wanted to give them the opportunity as it is not something we were likely to do as a family. DGPs gave money towards ski gear and we got them some bits for Christmas.

Hankunamatata · 25/03/2022 20:18

And yes my dc is going on an expensive skiing trip. The sad part is they didn't bring the form home as they thought it was too much money and we couldn't afford it. Normally we couldn't but we have saved from when they were born so they can have opportunities like ski trips as its something we could never afford as a family.

Hankunamatata · 25/03/2022 20:14

Skiing? There's limited places at dc school like 20 so definitely a minority go

Seashor · 25/03/2022 20:12

I actually think it’s you that needs to get a grip. My daughter went on such a trip as Covid broke out and she’s going again next year. It suits us and we can afford it, that’s life.

nokidshere · 25/03/2022 20:04

It’s you who are being ridiculous here. Just like I said, I understand some people can’t afford even the cheapest trip but £1500? Are you kidding me right there? Funny thing is I CAN afford this trip, I just don’t see what’s the school’s business offering this kind of expensive trips. Please give me a local trip any time, camping or similar where my DD and DS could experience building relationships with most the pupils, not only those cash heavy. What a sad world.

It certainly is a very sad world where people want to stop children having or taking opportunities just because not everyone can afford it. If we went down that route no one would have anything. No local football club? Oh sorry we can't have one anymore because poor little Fred can't afford the subs. No local drama club? Cricket club? After school activities? All these things cost money do we need to stop them all? Where do we draw the line?

It is not a school trip. It is not part of the curriculum and it's not funded by the school, and it's not in term time.

KeepYaHeadUp · 25/03/2022 19:49

@reluctantbrit

But I think for a trip oganised by the school I just can't see the need to go all over the top, voluntarily paid and in the holidays or not.

Don't send your kid then? These are during school hols anyway so you can take your children on your holiday and leave other parents to choose to send their children on an entirely optional trip

KeepYaHeadUp · 25/03/2022 19:47

[quote toomuchfruit]@daisyjgrey

No, not completely free but also not a ridiculous amount like £1000. Surely the school can find more reasonably priced holidays so that more children can enjoy them ? It's really not that hard..[/quote]
My son's primary took the kids to the pantomime pre covid. It was £16/ child. A number of children couldn't afford to go. The head said the school would pay. Some other parent's contributed the cost of the ticket again to help the school.

£16 is not affordable to all, just because it might be affordable to some and £32 might be affordable to some too.

So it's free or it's not fair for everyone w

Onionpatch · 25/03/2022 19:47

I think the ski trip is such a minority that go, its doesnt matter to those who cant go. As in they dont stand out for not having the money.
I might be a bit biased because my son went as a young carer so got a big discount and there is no way we coud afford to go as a family and he misses on so many normal experiences. We struggle with going away at all due to his siblungs care needs.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 19:38

@nokidshere
I’m sorry, but a tiny proportion of the school intake can afford that. Those families can go on a trip in their own time/organise themselves.
It’s only makes sense to organise the trip where the majority could come and to collectively help those who can’t afford. Schools are not there to provide random expensive exotic opportunities for those who are lucky to afford it. No, they shouldn’t say the trip is for those earning more than a certain amount. It’s you who are being ridiculous here. Just like I said, I understand some people can’t afford even the cheapest trip but £1500? Are you kidding me right there? Funny thing is I CAN afford this trip, I just don’t see what’s the school’s business offering this kind of expensive trips. Please give me a local trip any time, camping or similar where my DD and DS could experience building relationships with most the pupils, not only those cash heavy. What a sad world.

internetpersonme · 25/03/2022 19:36

That is expensive but not compulsory.

I could afford for my dc to go but not a family ski trip so in that case its not ridiculous and the only way that they'd get to go so its a good thing.

I would pay for dc to go and in summer have a uk holiday!

nokidshere · 25/03/2022 19:32

You’re absolutely right and it’s simply discriminatory if the school does that.

It is not discriminatory to offer something that not everyone might not be able to afford. Don't be ridiculous. It's open to everyone who applies and the same criteria is used for all.

Maybe they should say the trip is only for people who earn under 20k? Or those who earn over 50k? That would be discriminatory.

Sirzy · 25/03/2022 19:31

But it also gives large groups a chance to experience something they wouldn’t otherwise.

My nephew has just signed up for a foreign school holiday next year, his parents couldn’t possibly afford to pay for that for them all but they can manage it for him to go (and siblings a few years down the line)

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 19:26

@Tyrozet
You’re absolutely right and it’s simply discriminatory if the school does that. It’s extremely divisive and yes, some people may not afford a £100 trip, but it’s much easier to fundraise/sponsor the children for £100 trip rather than £1500.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 19:24

It’s immoral for the school to do that. And I’m usually very supportive to schools, even biased. There’s zero reason for them to push such an expensive trip and yes yes yes you can deny. But it absolutely WILL make children sad if they can’t come. It’s a ridiculously expensive trip.

nokidshere · 25/03/2022 19:24

It's not a case of "if I can't have it for my child then nobody else should". There's a big difference between not having the means to fund expensive trips or hobbies on a private/individual level - but the school shouldn't be facilitating something that basically divides and excludes large groups of children based on what their parents earn.

No there isn't because it's not a school trip, it's not on the curriculum, it's not funded by the school and it's not in term time.

If your child's best friend was going to Disney world and the parents offered to take your child with them would you say no but they shouldn't go either because you can't afford it?

What about other trips? My sons are very talented at cricket, the cricket team offered a trip to South Africa to play, my sons didn't go because I didn't have enough money, should I have said it was unfair that the coach was offering to organise this trip and take members of the team with him and they shouldn't go because we couldn't?

The school is simply organising an out of school trip. Which has nothing to do with the curriculum or school life. It's just a trip in the holidays that some people (rich and poor) would let their child go on.

School trips that are in school time and are tied to the curriculum are open to all and some funding is available to help families who need it.

reluctantbrit · 25/03/2022 18:57

@IsabellaDulcie

Europe (mostly Austria or northern Italy) and Canada (no idea why they think Canada when there are great ski areas in Europe).

The snow is about 100X better in Canada, but it is very cold. I went skiing for the 1st time at school, so pleased I got the opportunity. I think schools should try to keep the costs down, but is a really valuable experience.

That may be and friends do go to Canada for skiing on a regular basis.

But I think for a trip oganised by the school I just can't see the need to go all over the top, voluntarily paid and in the holidays or not.

If a family is big into skiing than I would think they all go and enjoy a week in Canada. If one child is good at skiing I would assume they find a ski camp she/he can go to.

A school trip with 30 children and maybe 20 different abilities - over the top.

Tyrozet · 25/03/2022 18:55

The fact that they want a very large deposit to even be put on the list for a place is excluding people - nobody can have time to organise fundraisers or apply for grants with such a short turnaround.

It's not a case of "if I can't have it for my child then nobody else should". There's a big difference between not having the means to fund expensive trips or hobbies on a private/individual level - but the school shouldn't be facilitating something that basically divides and excludes large groups of children based on what their parents earn.

OP posts:
daisyjgrey · 25/03/2022 18:51

[quote toomuchfruit]@daisyjgrey

No, not completely free but also not a ridiculous amount like £1000. Surely the school can find more reasonably priced holidays so that more children can enjoy them ? It's really not that hard..[/quote]

But if a trip is to be able to be affording by absolutely everyone, and therefore totally 'fair', it would have to be free. There will be people who can't afford it whether it's £1000 or £100.

toomuchfruit · 25/03/2022 18:43

@daisyjgrey

No, not completely free but also not a ridiculous amount like £1000. Surely the school can find more reasonably priced holidays so that more children can enjoy them ? It's really not that hard..

CityHigh · 25/03/2022 18:25

They did this at our school too. Huge school and only around 15-20 places each year so only the rich kids went. They offered it to year 8 and 9s and if there were still spaces then it would get extended to the year sevens.

OfstedOffred · 25/03/2022 18:23

I suspect school staff love to organise these trips as the staff get to go subsidised. It is a huge saving for them to go to skiing in school holidays via school vs paying to go themselves.

theleafandnotthetree · 25/03/2022 18:19

[quote RandomThought96]@theleafandnotthetree

Is there a government subsidy to the organisations running the Gaeltacht courses? If not, how do they manage to keep the costs so low?Is it just that the Gaeltacht areas are relatively low cost?[/quote]
I believe the government subsidises the accomodation side of it to the equivelent of something like 10 euro per day per person (which goes to the host families). And yes, costs would be somewhat lower in those areas and this is not fancy accommodation we're talking about.

bumpytrumpy · 25/03/2022 18:05

Is it not like saying schools shouldn't offer football teams because some kids can't run. Or offer higher GCSE papers because some kids can't get over a C (showing my age there!). Or Mandarin because some kids will never go to China.

It's not compulsory, it's out of term time, I don't see the issue.

For what's it's worth I went to a poor secondary school which didn't offer a trip