Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school need to get a grip?

309 replies

Tyrozet · 25/03/2022 10:21

Just had a text from my son informing me of a letter he is bringing home from school about a trip abroad next year.

The cost of the trip alone is nearly £1000 - it is a skiing trip so on top of the basic cost of the trip, special clothes need to be purchased, passports paid for and of course spending money - I'd say all in it will be at least £1500.

It's a state school in a town with many deprived areas.

I know you can just say "no" if it's not affordable but AIBU to think the school shouldn't be putting on trips like this at a time when many families are having to choose between which basic essentials they can afford?

Things are shit enough as it is for alot of people without having the added kick in the teeth that this is completely unreachable at the moment.

OP posts:
daisyjgrey · 26/03/2022 12:30

@LoopyGremlin

But as a PP says, where does it stop? £1000 is unaffordable for most, £500 is unaffordable for many, £100 is unaffordable for some, £10 is unaffordable for a few. Therefore, in the interest of fairness, we shouldn’t have any trips that cost more than £5? That’s the approach my school seem to be going for and it’s pretty miserable. Nothing residential, nothing that costs money, nothing that’s outwith the local area. So all you are left with is a trip to the museum on public transport. Is that what we want?

Exactly. I can't afford to take us both skiing, it's an interesting thing to do that isn't just lying by a pool and eating at an all inclusive which a lot of family holidays seem to be. So I'll try and find the money so she can experience it.

It seems a bit of a shit argument that skiing is just going off on a jolly and has no value. The independence, experience of travelling (especially on coach where you stop through different countries), food, language, people etc are all valid learning experiences.

Cocomarine · 26/03/2022 11:05

@EatSleepRantRepeat but the £1000 isn’t subsided- cancelling doesn’t create money for a cheaper trip.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 26/03/2022 11:01

@LoopyGremlin

But as a PP says, where does it stop? £1000 is unaffordable for most, £500 is unaffordable for many, £100 is unaffordable for some, £10 is unaffordable for a few. Therefore, in the interest of fairness, we shouldn’t have any trips that cost more than £5? That’s the approach my school seem to be going for and it’s pretty miserable. Nothing residential, nothing that costs money, nothing that’s outwith the local area. So all you are left with is a trip to the museum on public transport. Is that what we want?
It stops at the point where the school can easily afford to subsidise all children who want to go but can't afford it. 5 x more kids could be taken on a £200 week youth hostelling or orienteering with the subsidy money from a £1000 skiing trip, especially if it was by coach.
EatSleepRantRepeat · 26/03/2022 10:58

Interestingly the people who are saying suck it up can all afford these trips - precisely, @stillherenow. Even the ones saying "we sacrificed X to send our child" either aren't that poor or have no idea about money management. If my parents could have saved £1000 over the course of a year it would have gone towards a damp course or heating bills for our freezing old house to benefit the whole family, not a one-off week skiing. Ski trip time at school was the first time at school I felt that the relative wealth of my classmates was being rubbed in my face, thankfully I had a close knit group of other poor kids who couldn't go either, but not everyone does.

DaffodilDandilion · 26/03/2022 10:46

Our school funds or significantly reduces the cost of trips for students receiving free school meals/ families who need extra help which means all kids can manage to go on the £100 residentials.

LoopyGremlin · 26/03/2022 10:27

But as a PP says, where does it stop? £1000 is unaffordable for most, £500 is unaffordable for many, £100 is unaffordable for some, £10 is unaffordable for a few. Therefore, in the interest of fairness, we shouldn’t have any trips that cost more than £5? That’s the approach my school seem to be going for and it’s pretty miserable. Nothing residential, nothing that costs money, nothing that’s outwith the local area. So all you are left with is a trip to the museum on public transport. Is that what we want?

courgettigreensadwater · 26/03/2022 09:57

C'est La vie.

stillherenow · 26/03/2022 09:00

@ragwort school is not the place for that lesson.

Believe me, dd gets it. But it should not be something that extends into the school life.

Interestingly the people who are saying suck it up can all afford these trips !

GnomeDePlume · 26/03/2022 08:16

My DCs' school eventually gave up on the school ski trip because it was so out of line with local affordability that even with opening it up to all years there was insufficient take up. But that still took several years of dwindling interest.

What is the obsession with offering a ski trip? Why skiing?

Ragwort · 26/03/2022 07:59

It is not 'immoral' to offer these opportunities - some mumsnetters really need to look up the meaning of the word 'moral'.

I think it's a valuable lesson in life that not all things are affordable ... you frequently see on here all the handwringing and angst when grown women need to decline an invitation to a hen party weekend or a 'destination' wedding ... we need to be able to say 'I can't afford it' without getting upset and embarrassed.

Yes, I could afford a ski trip for my DS but there are lots of other things in life I can't afford that many people seem to spend money on .... it's not 'unfair' ... it's life.

stillherenow · 26/03/2022 07:54

And this is a working trip - so dd will miss out on an educational trip that some others will get .
The whole point of uniforms is to even things out at school and make it less obvious who is rich and who is 'normal'. There should be a cap on trips of well under £1k

stillherenow · 26/03/2022 07:51

It'd make me mad too. No chance id fork out that much for a school trip. DD's already excited as one of her teachers said they might have a trip to Iceland next year and I'm certain I won't be able to afford it - even a 3 day UK residential is £500!

They shouldn't offer expensive trips, it's unfair and creates division . I don't want dd to feel 'poor'. We're ok financially but I'm a lone parents and can't even afford a holiday for the two of us this year

CelestiaNoctis · 26/03/2022 01:19

My daughters school is going to the zoo and want £15. They're allowing that to be paid in 3 instalments of £5. They said they understand how tight things are these days. Your kids school sounds wildly out of touch. I expect the trip won't go ahead as not many will sign up for it.

GrandTheftWalrus · 25/03/2022 23:46

If its a choice of a family holiday for 1500 or 1 dc to go for same price then I'm sorry family holiday trumps it.

What if you've kids in different school years? Potentially 3k on 2 trips?

No chance.

DockOTheBay · 25/03/2022 23:35

@Dontcallmebabylalala

It’s immoral for the school to do that. And I’m usually very supportive to schools, even biased. There’s zero reason for them to push such an expensive trip and yes yes yes you can deny. But it absolutely WILL make children sad if they can’t come. It’s a ridiculously expensive trip.
"Immoral" Hmm pull the other one

What a shame to make a 15 year old sad. Some of the rich kids who can afford it will be sad too if the trip is oversubscribed and they don't get picked. If being sad for 5 minutes, because a small number of your classmates get to do something, is the worst thing that happens then I can't get worked up about it.

DockOTheBay · 25/03/2022 23:30

[quote toomuchfruit]@JudgeRindersMinder

You surely don't believe this school trip is inclusive ? An inclusive school trip would be one that both poor and rich kids can afford to go on.[/quote]
There's no such thing then, is there. Unless they can go somewhere totally free there will always be someone who can't afford it.

Might as well ban all school trips. While you're at it, ban music lessons, pencil cases and sports which require any equipment - not everyone can afford those. Better also ban packed lunchboxes with anything other than bread and jam, ban leather school shoes and disband any cycling to school programmes - not everyone can afford a bike you know.

Bananabutter · 25/03/2022 22:13

YABU. Just because you can’t afford it doesn’t mean others should miss out.

DdraigGoch · 25/03/2022 22:10

The fact that they want a very large deposit to even be put on the list for a place is excluding people - nobody can have time to organise fundraisers or apply for grants with such a short turnaround.

I remember similar with "World Challenge" where they wanted a deposit at really short notice.

Bad organisation like that needs to be sorted out, but that's not a reason to abandon ski trips entirely.

DdraigGoch · 25/03/2022 22:09

@Dontcallmebabylalala

It’s immoral for the school to do that. And I’m usually very supportive to schools, even biased. There’s zero reason for them to push such an expensive trip and yes yes yes you can deny. But it absolutely WILL make children sad if they can’t come. It’s a ridiculously expensive trip.
You can't have everything in life, sometimes you will be "sad". Tough.
DdraigGoch · 25/03/2022 21:48

@theleafandnotthetree

I really don't get this whole 'opportunity to go skiing' argument as if it is some fundamental thing that everyone should ideally get to do. You might as well bemoan the lack of opportunities to go on a sailing holiday or a weeks horseriding. All are expensive and actually quite dangerous hobbies and are just that - hobbies. No one is missing out hugely in life by not doing ANY of these things, they are just other additions to the never ending list of things some very priveliged people see as they and their childrens due. And yes, the fact that you can pay for your child to go on one of these trips does make you pretty privileged.
I went sailing on a square-rigged ship twice as a teen (not through school, through a youth organisation). The first trip was funded by someone who had been part of the same organisation in his youth. I'd argue that anyone who hasn't done similar HAS missed out on a fantastic experience. Perhaps more schools should partner up with the likes of the Jubilee Sailing Trust.

Do you not realise that it's these sorts of experiences that sets the "privileged people" you mention apart from the crowd? Most private schools are no mere exam factories, they recognise that these sorts of pursuits come with cultural capital, the same as visits to museums and exchange trips to France. It also feeds into the mindset of "can do anything, go anywhere" that makes someone walk into an interview with confidence. It's soft skills that gives private school pupils the edge.

Darbs76 · 25/03/2022 21:44

I think you’re being unreasonable. Some people will be able to afford it, some people might not be able to but might have saved up for years or have grandparents willing to pay. Our school has a variety of trips at various costs, some affordable to me, some not. At secondary level kids are old enough to understand that

Adeleskirts · 25/03/2022 21:42

It's not a case of "if I can't have it for my child then nobody else should". There's a big difference between not having the means to fund expensive trips or hobbies on a private/individual level - but the school shouldn't be facilitating something that basically divides and excludes large groups of children based on what their parents earn

I struggle with this, it really does sound like if I can’t have it foe my child no one else should. No way round that really, that’s what you’re saying. May as well own it.

daisyjgrey · 25/03/2022 21:08

Ours is in school time, it's two weeks before the Feb half term. It's not a hill I can be bothered to die on.

Lennybenny · 25/03/2022 20:58

DS school trips were Vietnam and New York...it worked out at £100 a month for 18 months and that was just the trip without clothes and spending money etc. It was an expensive jolly which the rich parents would send their dc and us poor parents couldn't.

nokidshere · 25/03/2022 20:45

To all the posters who have said it's fine as it's not in school time, I've just read the letter which explicitly says this trip will take place during term time.

Highly unusual to do it in term time. What yr group is it?