Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school need to get a grip?

309 replies

Tyrozet · 25/03/2022 10:21

Just had a text from my son informing me of a letter he is bringing home from school about a trip abroad next year.

The cost of the trip alone is nearly £1000 - it is a skiing trip so on top of the basic cost of the trip, special clothes need to be purchased, passports paid for and of course spending money - I'd say all in it will be at least £1500.

It's a state school in a town with many deprived areas.

I know you can just say "no" if it's not affordable but AIBU to think the school shouldn't be putting on trips like this at a time when many families are having to choose between which basic essentials they can afford?

Things are shit enough as it is for alot of people without having the added kick in the teeth that this is completely unreachable at the moment.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AngelsWithSilverWings · 31/03/2022 13:20

@BlackeyedSusan my primary school used to offer a cruse trip on the SS Uganda. That was also called up for service in the Falklands so probably the same ship. My parents couldn't afford it but I did go on a Norfolk Broads holiday with school which ,although not quite as exciting, I still remember for being such a great experience.

I've just registered my DS for his school ski trip and am now waiting to see if he was lucky enough to be one of the first 110 to register. We had three devices all primed to make sure he registered quickly. It is ridiculously popular.

Hawkins001 · 31/03/2022 01:50

@Tyrozet

I think alot of people have missed my point, or maybe I haven't explained it too well.

I actually think that in a school environment, this sort of trip is divisive and discriminates against people who are from poorer backgrounds.

I understand that not everyone will be able to afford every trip, but this isn't necessary or educational, it's a holiday being facilitated by the school which blatantly excludes a large number of pupils because of their background.

Well-off families who can summon up £200 by next week to enter the lottery for a place will be fine, but others who can't come up with that sum of money with no notice wont get a look in - even if we could afford to save the installments for the rest of the trip.

As people can guess that trips will happen at some point, surely then as and when possible if various people put a savings fund together for their children, so when trips do come up, they are already have some or all the cost covered ?
Hawkins001 · 31/03/2022 01:47

@Tyrozet

Just had a text from my son informing me of a letter he is bringing home from school about a trip abroad next year.

The cost of the trip alone is nearly £1000 - it is a skiing trip so on top of the basic cost of the trip, special clothes need to be purchased, passports paid for and of course spending money - I'd say all in it will be at least £1500.

It's a state school in a town with many deprived areas.

I know you can just say "no" if it's not affordable but AIBU to think the school shouldn't be putting on trips like this at a time when many families are having to choose between which basic essentials they can afford?

Things are shit enough as it is for alot of people without having the added kick in the teeth that this is completely unreachable at the moment.

With all due respect, their will always be one situation or another that will mean not all can cover the £, so when should they do the trips ?
BlackeyedSusan · 31/03/2022 01:45

it does have merit for that quite well off but not well off enough to go skiing as a familyincome band of kids. if there are several sorts of trips at different budgets then it is possible for families to send kids to something that is just out of reach as a family but just in reach via school.

but yeah, not great timing as more families are into the heating or eating band.

BlackeyedSusan · 31/03/2022 01:42

we were offered a cruise on a ship that cost a couple of thousand quid.

It got cancelled as the ship was required in the south atlantic as a refitted troop ship for the Falklands war.

GrandTheftWalrus · 31/03/2022 01:33

If my financial situation stays the same for 10 years then my dc won't be going.

I remember at primary school in the 90s my parents couldn't afford to send me to a residential thing. It never bothered me to miss out. I still had to go to school while my class were away and I enjoyed it.

DdraigGoch · 29/03/2022 20:33

[quote GrandTheftWalrus]@DdraigGoch I wouldn't spend 6k on a family holiday either. We are going on a family holiday abroad later in the year for just over 1k. But we've been paying it off for over a year. There is no way we'd be able to afford a 1.5k skiing trip for 1 dc in term time.

However I'm talking about this as though it was imminent. My dc are 5 and 10 months so in 10 years or whenever it would be when trips like this come up I would hope our financial situation would be improved.

But as far as I know the high school they'll be going to doesn't do trips like that as we are a deprived area.[/quote]
That's the point though, most families don't have £6k to splash out on a ski holiday for the whole family. Many will however have £1.5k to let the eldest child go skiing, followed by another £1.5k a couple of years later for the youngest. Especially if (as for many posters upthread) the child recognises the sacrifice involved and opts out of Christmas/birthday presents from their parents, asking grandparents for clothing and spending money.

If you remove those opportunities, then skiing (or sailing etc.) becomes a pastime only for the very rich. At least school ski trips widen opportunities a little further.

GrandTheftWalrus · 29/03/2022 17:10

@DdraigGoch I wouldn't spend 6k on a family holiday either. We are going on a family holiday abroad later in the year for just over 1k. But we've been paying it off for over a year. There is no way we'd be able to afford a 1.5k skiing trip for 1 dc in term time.

However I'm talking about this as though it was imminent. My dc are 5 and 10 months so in 10 years or whenever it would be when trips like this come up I would hope our financial situation would be improved.

But as far as I know the high school they'll be going to doesn't do trips like that as we are a deprived area.

WomblingWilma · 29/03/2022 15:22

DS’s school ski trip next year is just over £1k including travel, all food, tuition, lift passes etc. we’ve been given a years notice and can pay it off at £100 a month. We normally wouldn’t be able to afford something like this but older 3 are paying their way now so we can. Older DC (apart from the SN one) did one overseas school trip during secondary each but there weren’t ski trips and were much cheaper.

I’m very pleased DC4 can go as we wouldn’t ever choose a ski holiday as a family with the limited funds we have for one. I’ve always thought of skiing as a rich persons sport so happy at least one of my DC can have a go!

CMZ2018 · 29/03/2022 14:29

Get a grip. If you can’t afford it don’t let him go, but don’t try and deprive others who can.

theleafandnotthetree · 29/03/2022 13:57

@BogRollBOGOF

I'd love DS2 to get a chance for a school skiing trip. I can't see it happening as a family holiday because DS1 has dyspraxia, ASD and sensory issues and is highly likely to find skiing hellish. With their age gap, DS2 would be 17 before it's viable to consider going without DS1.

School trips were my holidays through my teenage years. DM never organised a holiday herself after dad died and without those school trips and occasionally doing things with other people, I'd never have had any kind of holiday anywhere. Her holidays were always ones organised by friends.

It can be more affordable for school to provide experiences with only paying for one child at a time at group rates.

The more extravagent trips will be taken up by a smaller pool of people. The bigger issue of affordability/ inclusion is where it's an activity that the vast majority are expected to take part in. We've got an educational day trip costing about £15 coming up. That can easily be an issue for people.

You speak of 'only' having school trips as holidays as a teenager, that was absolutely the norm in my upbringing, only minus the school trips! I wouldn't consider not having holidays as some sort of indicator of deprivation.
GnomeDePlume · 29/03/2022 11:45

@DdraigGoch Child goes on school ski trip (having used up the family's holiday budget for the year), discovers a passion for skiing but then still can't go again until they are grown up and can pay for it themselves. Wouldn't a trip to the nearest indoor ski dome have the same potential and at the same time be within scope for far more families with the chance of being able to do it again?

BogRollBOGOF · 29/03/2022 09:45

I'd love DS2 to get a chance for a school skiing trip. I can't see it happening as a family holiday because DS1 has dyspraxia, ASD and sensory issues and is highly likely to find skiing hellish. With their age gap, DS2 would be 17 before it's viable to consider going without DS1.

School trips were my holidays through my teenage years. DM never organised a holiday herself after dad died and without those school trips and occasionally doing things with other people, I'd never have had any kind of holiday anywhere. Her holidays were always ones organised by friends.

It can be more affordable for school to provide experiences with only paying for one child at a time at group rates.

The more extravagent trips will be taken up by a smaller pool of people. The bigger issue of affordability/ inclusion is where it's an activity that the vast majority are expected to take part in. We've got an educational day trip costing about £15 coming up. That can easily be an issue for people.

DdraigGoch · 29/03/2022 09:30

@GnomeDePlume

I dont get the argument that this is the only chance that DCs will get to go on exotic trips. It really isnt. The Alps/New York/Wherever will all still exist when the DCs leave school, are earning and can afford to go wherever interests them. It's not Brigadoon.
Did you miss the posts upthread where posters either sent their kids, or went themselves when they were kids, and it opened up their eyes to something they wouldn't have considered doing otherwise?
GnomeDePlume · 29/03/2022 08:28

I dont get the argument that this is the only chance that DCs will get to go on exotic trips. It really isnt. The Alps/New York/Wherever will all still exist when the DCs leave school, are earning and can afford to go wherever interests them. It's not Brigadoon.

whynotwhy · 28/03/2022 18:06

State schools should not offer expensive trips that pupils cant afford.

Heavens we are a country that insists on uniform so children aren't made to fell different or poor, but hey let's have an expensive trip that excludes most pupils.

DdraigGoch · 28/03/2022 14:28

@GrandTheftWalrus

If its a choice of a family holiday for 1500 or 1 dc to go for same price then I'm sorry family holiday trumps it.

What if you've kids in different school years? Potentially 3k on 2 trips?

No chance.

What if it's a choice between a family ski holiday for £6k, or sending the kids at £1.5k each, two years apart? For many families this is the only chance the kids will get.

It's your decision how you spend your own money, but other people should have the opportunity to choose differently.

theleafandnotthetree · 28/03/2022 12:57

@GnomeDePlume

Trips do take up school resources. Letters out, responses back, handling payments will all be using school resources. The teachers who go on the ski trip may feel that their goodwill has been used up for the year and not want to assist other trips.

We are constantly being told that school resources are scarce so why should those scarce resources get frittered on a trip which is out of the financial grasp of the majority of students?

And why skiing? The school ski trip seems so outdated. It seems to hark back to the 70s when skiing was seen as exotic.

All excellent points!
Ragwort · 26/03/2022 19:16

It's not just people who can afford to send their DC on these trips saying they are OK if you take the time to read the thread.

Some posters have said they wouldn't send their DC as it is 'the cost of a family holiday' .... if my DS chose a ski trip I would happily forego a family holiday and he would understand.

Some posters say it's too expensive for families with more than one DC - exactly the reason I chose not to have more than one DC - to be abe to give him opportunities.

Yes, I appreciate that many people have no money at all for family holidays let alone ski trips but in many instances people are making a choice as to how to spend 'spare' money.

Tonya345 · 26/03/2022 15:58

@OfstedOffred

I suspect school staff love to organise these trips as the staff get to go subsidised. It is a huge saving for them to go to skiing in school holidays via school vs paying to go themselves.
Actually this is far from the case. Teachers give up their holidays to do this. I have been on residential school trips as a teacher and it is no holiday. In fact, it's exhausting. You are on call 24/7, dealing with all sorts of unexpected happenings, children falling out with each other, homesickness, throwing up in coaches etc.
MabelsApron · 26/03/2022 15:47

I was able to go on one of these trips, as was my sibling. My parents wouldn’t go skiing and quite frankly relished the idea of getting us out of the house for a few days. We went via coach and had a great time.

The year after my sister went, a bunch of parents campaigned to have the trips cancelled as they couldn’t be afforded by “those with large families”. They put so much pressure on the SLT that the trips were banned for a few years, which struck me as a real shame. Some people had chosen to limit their family size so as to be able to afford trips like this, which then they couldn’t do because others had made different choices and couldn’t bear the consequences of that.

I’m with a PP - some people do seem to believe that having kids should be free.

hedgehogger1 · 26/03/2022 14:30

I used to work in a school that ran one every year. Always the same "in crowd" of teachers that went. A kid always came back with a broken limb. It was about 20 kids max that went

GnomeDePlume · 26/03/2022 13:44

Trips do take up school resources. Letters out, responses back, handling payments will all be using school resources. The teachers who go on the ski trip may feel that their goodwill has been used up for the year and not want to assist other trips.

We are constantly being told that school resources are scarce so why should those scarce resources get frittered on a trip which is out of the financial grasp of the majority of students?

And why skiing? The school ski trip seems so outdated. It seems to hark back to the 70s when skiing was seen as exotic.

LoopyGremlin · 26/03/2022 13:15

@EatSleepRantRepeat
What subsidy?

Sirzy · 26/03/2022 12:47

I wouldn’t be able to afford to send Ds on such a trip but that doesn’t mean I don’t think they should be offered.

It is a way that children can experience things they wouldn’t otherwise. There will be so few going that not going isn’t going to mark someone out as different.

Ds school released a trip abroad last week for 40 pupils out of 400ish children. The ones not going aren’t going to be left behind.