Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- Can't afford to work

385 replies

MissRja · 25/03/2022 09:45

Just trying to work out a return to work after having a baby In December ( also have a 4 year old in full time school ) unfortunately, my original plans for childcare have fell through, which now means we are looking at paid childcare. My current job have declined My flexible working request , which means I am looking for another job. Due to school pick up/ drops offs I am looking returning on reduced hours over 5 days or term time only. Have worked our I will be bringing home roughly £1200 after tax per month. Nursery fees will be £1100 for a four week month, or £1375 for a 5 week month. This does not include before / after school club fees. If I was to use my wages alone to pay childcare fees I would actually be losing money to work , especially when factoring in petrol , work clothes etc. Surely this can't be right. How in this day and age can I not afford to go to work !! Its ridiculous. The whole reason I am going back is because we can't afford to live off DP wages alone , but it doesn't seem like it will make a difference if i do go back to work. Am i missing something here ? What does everyone else do to work around this ? Would love to hear your experiences / advice !!

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 26/03/2022 00:46

I didn’t say that it wasn’t possible to want things that don’t personally benefit you, for the greater good (I assume that is what ‘busy about grabbing something for yourself’ means).

And, what I said isn’t nonsense. Read any of the wide selection of threads on Mumsnet complaining that childcare is too expensive and should be subsidised or free like in Europe. Or any of the threads moaning about income tax being too high.

95% of the people with children who are calling for childcare subsidies also say, without a hint of irony, that they can’t possibly pay more in tax, because they can’t afford it, but that other people should pay for them to have free childcare.

If you aren’t willing to pay more tax personally, how can you expect everyone else to?

A similar group want the NHS to be better and for nurses to get a 20% pay rise, without any tax increase. Or for all care of elderly people to be free so that they can inherit their parents’ house without it being sold to fund care. Or for the state pension age to be moved back to 60. Who’s paying for that? Anyone except them, is what quickly emerges on those threads.

Thoosa · 26/03/2022 00:16

@Iamthewombat

The people who want free taxpayer-funded childcare for themselves are the same people complaining that they themselves can’t possibly pay more tax. No, everyone else can pay more. But not them.
Well that’s nonsense. I’ll never need childcare again but I think heftily subsidised early years care is a good idea. I won’t benefit from it directly, but I will indirectly.

It’s possible to have a view that isn’t busy about grabbing something for yourself.

Iamthewombat · 26/03/2022 00:05

The people who want free taxpayer-funded childcare for themselves are the same people complaining that they themselves can’t possibly pay more tax. No, everyone else can pay more. But not them.

MabelsApron · 25/03/2022 23:59

People don’t want to pay more tax to pay for their own nursing care. If they don’t care about their own individual experience, you’re gonna struggle to convince them to pay more tax to pay for the societal benefit everyone else’s childcare.

I’m not saying that this is right - I’d prefer to pay more tax for better public services (including ones that don’t directly benefit me), but the UK is generally very selfish.

Thoosa · 25/03/2022 22:21

@LabelMaker

Someone has to pay for the childcare, if it was really cheap it would be really crap. You are trusting these people with tour child's life.
It’s heavily - and I mean HEAVILY- subsidised across Scandinavia and in European countries like Germany and France and it is of absolutely superb quality. Those countries also have better early years outcomes and sex equality statistics. Obviously slightly different systems in each country, but we are really lagging behind the most successful countries in this area.

Do my answer would be that the tax payer should pay, because it is a profound social and economic good to support early learning and support the workforce in that way.

LabelMaker · 25/03/2022 22:14

Someone has to pay for the childcare, if it was really cheap it would be really crap. You are trusting these people with tour child's life.

Darbs76 · 25/03/2022 22:11

It is difficult paying childcare but you have to remember it’s not forever. You’ll get some assistance at certain ages plus eventually your kids don’t need childcare. Might seem a long way off but time flies. If you give up your job remember you’re giving up years of pension contributions and it’s harder for women who take time out to get back to earning decent salaries. I just decided to suck it up and it was very expensive but glad I did as once both kids are in school it reduced a lot. Now we allow many of our staff to go and collect school aged children on a late lunch break and finish off at home for another hour or two. That saves them on childcare and on their office days they can do that too as long as they do their 40% over the month

Iamthewombat · 25/03/2022 21:45

@PatientlyWaiting21

It’s shit, we have a childcare crisis and yet again it was ignored in the spring budget. How many times did Sunak say he wanted to support hard working families? Families can’t work without childcare, so who exactly is our government supporting? They want to look at how Canada, Sweden and Germany are running things!
Whilst I can’t get behind the spring budget statement, there’s no way we’re having free or subsidised childcare unless we’re all prepared to pay more in tax. Much more. In a time of rising food prices and energy bills, do you think that would have been a popular policy, if the chancellor had announced it?
ThreeLocusts · 25/03/2022 21:16

I believe that you are experiencing a dilemma that is the daily bread of single mothers. Unless you can get well-paid full-time work with predictable hours, you easily end up in a situation where you pay more in childcare than you earn if your children are pre-school age. That's why the denigration of un- or underemployed single parents as 'shirkers' etc is so disgusting.

I had a friend who persisted in working for about 5 years despite losing money through it (two children in paid childcare, at about 800 GBP/month/child) then, finally, she got a job that paid more than the childcare fees, based on the experience she had accumulated in the worse-paying job. She could afford to do this because her husband was well paid.

So it really depends on whether you can afford to make this kind of investment in the future, and how invested you are in having a career. And yes it really shouldn't be like this.

Ontobetterthings · 25/03/2022 21:14

@BulletTrain

I've just done 2 years paying £500 (minus 20% tax free) to earn about £800 (minus commuting costs). Completely worth it. Now DS is 3 we pay £110 a month and I have been promoted.
Definitely keep working. I was in a relatively low paid office job, roll on 5 years working with my young son and I earn more than double that salary due to 2 promotions and now a high earner and in a senior job.
PatientlyWaiting21 · 25/03/2022 21:09

It’s shit, we have a childcare crisis and yet again it was ignored in the spring budget. How many times did Sunak say he wanted to support hard working families? Families can’t work without childcare, so who exactly is our government supporting? They want to look at how Canada, Sweden and Germany are running things!

Tiredalwaystired · 25/03/2022 20:57

Laser? Older!

Tiredalwaystired · 25/03/2022 20:57

Mine are laser now but I definitely worked for negative money for 15 months until eldest was in school. It was the only way I could stay on track with my career (plus the kids enjoyed it and thrived there socially). I only worked three days a week and they were in nursery for two full days and it still took more than every penny. They’re secondary age now and those days are thankfully far behind us. It’s shocking how much it costs and risks losing so many women from the workplace

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 25/03/2022 20:46

Everyone needs to shout about it @TheNameOfTheRoses

Although a lot of women want to be the main carer / leave work / go part time.

It probably won't ever happen but I personally believe things would be better if it did.

HisHX · 25/03/2022 20:43

@TiddleyWink

So depressing how it’s always the man who is the higher earner with travel etc so couldn’t POSSIBLY commit to school runs etc. Strange how women manage not to be in those completely inflexible positions when they decide to have children, yet men apparently can’t. Why don’t men think about this before they have kids and why don’t women make them? Where would we be if all these jobs actually were as inflexible as we’re told they are? Because neither men nor women would be able to properly parent their children so most adults couldn’t work.

Something just doesn’t add up.

Not trying to have a go at you OP - it’s a society thing - but it’s just so depressing to read the same scenario over and over again.

Women taking the hit, over and over again.

Not always the case at all. I earn 5x what my DH earns and he has all of the flexibility. My job is flexible too, but he is self employed and completely manages his own time.
RetireReady · 25/03/2022 20:40

@OnlyFoolsanMothers are you not UK based? Since 2019 all companies have to contribute minimum 3% unless you earn a vv low wage. If you earn more than UC level then even more reason for you to keep paying in an cut back other areas

HisHX · 25/03/2022 20:38

Not everyone gets tax free childcare though, so they? I think it depends on DH salary? I understand should consider childcare as a 50/50 cost but as a basic calculation, the cost of childcare can easily exceed a wage. Which is insanity, I think.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 25/03/2022 20:36

[quote Getyourarseofffthequattro]@TiddleyWink I don't think it's necessarily the man not being arsed, employers seem to be a lot less flexible with men and don't expect them to need to change hours or take any kind of leave. We need a massive societal shift![/quote]
On the other side, the reason why women got more flexibility etc.. is because they carry on asking instead if throwing the towel and say ‘they don’t want to’.

So yes we need some societal shift but it’s not going to happen if men don’t start asking for it. As in loudly asking and demanding as men can be when they want to.

LabelMaker · 25/03/2022 20:32

It's the gap in employment that makes it harder. Any gap.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 25/03/2022 20:30

[quote RetireReady]@getyourarseoffthequattro No. Men say their employers are less flexible.[/quote]
Maybe the men you know! When dp put in a flexible working request it was declined and his line manager asked why he would possibly need to do the school runs when I was there. Wanker.

RetireReady · 25/03/2022 20:28

@getyourarseoffthequattro No. Men say their employers are less flexible.

MabelsApron · 25/03/2022 20:04

@TiddleyWink I agree. I work in a department that’s primarily women and they all say that their husbands jobs are soooo inflexible so they just have to do both school runs themselves, so if any meetings get scheduled then oh dear no can do, Mabel will have to step in. Some of them have husbands working for the same organisation! IME a lot of men just aren’t bothered and are happy to not rock the boat with their employer. It’s really annoying though and makes me want to work in a department full of men instead!

Iamthewombat · 25/03/2022 20:00

[quote HappyMeal564]@Labelmaker just because you stop working when your children are young doesn't mean you instantly become incapable of getting a job/lose any qualifications or skills you have if your husband runs off. As a single parent you can claim child maintenance from the child's father and there are benefits that help those who are struggling. I'd hate to live life thinking, oh must live like this and make it harder on us just in case my husband bails. I'd just deal with that at the time.[/quote]
The husband running off or not running off isn’t relevant. What makes the difference to a woman’s career prospects and future wealth is the years out of the workplace.

You don’t ‘instantly become incapable of getting a job’ or lose your qualifications when you become a SAHM but you impair your desirability as an employee. You’re on the B list behind people with no gaps in their CV.

Several posters have acknowledged this on the thread: one said that she effectively went back to entry level after having been a SAHM. You try getting a decent finance job if you’ve been out of the workplace for even one year: everyone wants very recent experience.

The OP may not care about that, though.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 25/03/2022 19:59

@TiddleyWink I don't think it's necessarily the man not being arsed, employers seem to be a lot less flexible with men and don't expect them to need to change hours or take any kind of leave. We need a massive societal shift!

ancientgran · 25/03/2022 19:43

@TiddleyWink

So depressing how it’s always the man who is the higher earner with travel etc so couldn’t POSSIBLY commit to school runs etc. Strange how women manage not to be in those completely inflexible positions when they decide to have children, yet men apparently can’t. Why don’t men think about this before they have kids and why don’t women make them? Where would we be if all these jobs actually were as inflexible as we’re told they are? Because neither men nor women would be able to properly parent their children so most adults couldn’t work.

Something just doesn’t add up.

Not trying to have a go at you OP - it’s a society thing - but it’s just so depressing to read the same scenario over and over again.

Women taking the hit, over and over again.

My DIL is the higher earner, my son works funny hours so he is there for all pick ups and some drops offs so it isn't always the man who is the higher earner.
Swipe left for the next trending thread