Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- Can't afford to work

385 replies

MissRja · 25/03/2022 09:45

Just trying to work out a return to work after having a baby In December ( also have a 4 year old in full time school ) unfortunately, my original plans for childcare have fell through, which now means we are looking at paid childcare. My current job have declined My flexible working request , which means I am looking for another job. Due to school pick up/ drops offs I am looking returning on reduced hours over 5 days or term time only. Have worked our I will be bringing home roughly £1200 after tax per month. Nursery fees will be £1100 for a four week month, or £1375 for a 5 week month. This does not include before / after school club fees. If I was to use my wages alone to pay childcare fees I would actually be losing money to work , especially when factoring in petrol , work clothes etc. Surely this can't be right. How in this day and age can I not afford to go to work !! Its ridiculous. The whole reason I am going back is because we can't afford to live off DP wages alone , but it doesn't seem like it will make a difference if i do go back to work. Am i missing something here ? What does everyone else do to work around this ? Would love to hear your experiences / advice !!

OP posts:
Sswhinesthebest · 27/03/2022 11:20

Some ridiculous posts from some people.

It says something when two working adults can’t afford an average family in this day and age. At £700 your housing costs aren’t even on the high side compared to some rents.

It’s wrong op.

fuckfuckfuck2021 · 27/03/2022 11:05

Op you may not qualify for UC payments but you may qualify for childcare help. Have you done the entitled to calculator with the childcare costs included. You may be surprised!

Ayabbadabbado · 27/03/2022 10:27

www.turn2us.org.uk/Get-Support,

OP you can use this site to calculate all entitlements including childcare etc. If you look at the different scenarios it will help you work out if there is any support you didn't know about and also make it clearer what is best for your family situation. Good luck!

Nothing7 · 27/03/2022 09:24

I’m really sorry it’s such a struggle must be really challenging.
I would echo what the others are saying about looking into childminders - I’ve had mine now since my eldest was 9 months and she’s still looking after them now in school holidays and he’s 9! She’s ofstead outstanding too and they have former fab friendships there.
And definitely look into tax free childcare as it’s an option for you both to save on tax. Even if you could find another job a couple of days or evenings per week it may be good for you just to have your own space and time, plus you’ll be contributing to NI and the kids will benefit from being socialised.
We definitely felt the pinch when we had 2 in childcare and that was only 3 days a week. It was a huge relief when we started getting the 3 year old childcare funding.
I’m sure there is something about lower earners being able to do something with their tax so that the other half can benefit - not sure how it works though if he’s self employed and think you need to be married

thirdistheonewiththehairychest · 27/03/2022 08:25

Sorry I haven't read all of the replies but you asked what everyone else did to get around this dilemma so here's what we did:

The childcare costs didn't come out of my wages alone. We opened a joint account and started budgeting according to our total income.

We worked out what our bottom-line would be in terms of necessary outgoings (i.e. took all unneccessary things out of our budget - haircuts, holidays, meals out...)

We worked out the minimum I would have to work to cover our bottom line, also factoring in that DH would have to reduce his hours to cover those days.

So we spent 3 years with me working 1 day per week and DH working 4 days per week. So zero childcare costs. We lived very frugally during this time but it worked and it was actually a really happy time for us. I got to be (mostly) at home when the DC were little, DH got some time to himself with them too, and I also kept a foot in the door at work.

Over time we were able to increase due to payrises and the 30 hours free when they turned 3. Now (11 years after having our first dc) DH worked 5 days per week and I work 2.5 days.

Now that our youngest is about to start school, I'm looking to retrain so that I can work in a job that fits more easily into school hours (working from home) so that I can maximise my earnings.

SparklyShoesandTutus · 27/03/2022 08:25

I haven't read the full thread so sorry if I am repeating previous advice.
Have you looked at childminders they are often cheaper than nurseries.
Could you possibly work fewer longer days, say 3x 8-6 shifts which would be the equivalent of 9-3 5 days.
You could find a childminder who drops of and picks up from your eldest school.
If they went for an hour before and 3 hours after and your youngest was there 30 hours a week at £6/hour that would work out at around £1000 a month. Not ideal but once your youngest is 3 they would be entitled to the 30 hours a week funding. We used this with our childminder spread across the year rather than term time so they got about 21 hours a week.

Faevern · 27/03/2022 08:13

@MissRja
Of course UC won’t always pay 80% childcare, it is a sliding scale. I appreciate you have used an example but using that scenario. A family with 2 children one earner with 2k a month net and one SAHP, no mortgage would be entitled to almost £200 a month UC. If the other parent earned £1200 a month with your childcare costs then they would be entitled to over £600 a month UC.

So not 80% but more than £400 is 30% and more than tax free childcare (you can’t claim both) The cut off is high with childcare costs even a joint net income of 4K would attract a small amount of UC.

NeverForgetYourDreams · 27/03/2022 08:07

One of you drop off and the other pick up. After school club usually runs for 2 hours after school and nursery is usually open till 6pm so why don't you go to work early and then you do the pick ups. Husband can do the drop offs in the morning

ChoiceMummy · 27/03/2022 07:59

@MissRja

I think some people are getting a bit rude about this ... at no point did I say I wanted subsidies or anything like that to pay for my childcare. I asked how other people manage when childcare costs more than the take home pay. I understand for a lot of people career progression is a really important Factor. For my family, having enough money to cover everything and to live on is our priorty. There are also a lot of people who clearly do not understand how UC works. They don't just pay 70 or 80% of childcare. And I have done a calculator we are not entitled to any help. My DP is not a high earner but not on minimum wage. He earns an average wage, but this just not stretch far enough to cover everything. For example, take home pay : 2000 Mortgage : 700 Council tax:200 Gas/ Electricity: 200 Water: 45 DP Van ( for work so essential ) 150 per month DP Petrol: 200- 250 per month Food: 320 per month Insurances: 50 per month This leaves us with 85 per month spare money

These costs also do not include petrol for my car which I need for school run , shopping etc. I also can't walk to school as its too far away.

All clothing / items for the children comes from the child benefit money. We survive at the moment because I receive smp but when this ends I clearly need to work as we need the additonal money. But if this is taken up by childcare we are in deficit so am trying to work away around this. And with UC we are not entitled to any support on these figures as not classed as low earners.

Sorry for the long reply but I'm getting annoyed at people stipulating that I'm loaded and just don't want to pay!

Thank-you so much to those of you who are giving practical advice and sharing what you do ,it's really helpful

I've not read any other replies, so apologies if always said.

Your ohs business expenses should be coming directly out of the business, not your income. If they're not then it would be worth reviewing how the business is setup with an expert and what he is or isn't claiming etc.

With an income of 31k gross, approx, I'd apply for uc regardless of the calculators. They may well award as the thresholds have changed and some people get childcare paid with a nil/low payment. I wouldn't right this off entirely until I'd tried as you have a number of children this increases the likelihood of your eligibility.

Autumn42 · 27/03/2022 07:36

@MissRja

I think some people are getting a bit rude about this ... at no point did I say I wanted subsidies or anything like that to pay for my childcare. I asked how other people manage when childcare costs more than the take home pay. I understand for a lot of people career progression is a really important Factor. For my family, having enough money to cover everything and to live on is our priorty. There are also a lot of people who clearly do not understand how UC works. They don't just pay 70 or 80% of childcare. And I have done a calculator we are not entitled to any help. My DP is not a high earner but not on minimum wage. He earns an average wage, but this just not stretch far enough to cover everything. For example, take home pay : 2000 Mortgage : 700 Council tax:200 Gas/ Electricity: 200 Water: 45 DP Van ( for work so essential ) 150 per month DP Petrol: 200- 250 per month Food: 320 per month Insurances: 50 per month This leaves us with 85 per month spare money

These costs also do not include petrol for my car which I need for school run , shopping etc. I also can't walk to school as its too far away.

All clothing / items for the children comes from the child benefit money. We survive at the moment because I receive smp but when this ends I clearly need to work as we need the additonal money. But if this is taken up by childcare we are in deficit so am trying to work away around this. And with UC we are not entitled to any support on these figures as not classed as low earners.

Sorry for the long reply but I'm getting annoyed at people stipulating that I'm loaded and just don't want to pay!

Thank-you so much to those of you who are giving practical advice and sharing what you do ,it's really helpful

It’s not any assumption that your loaded at all, when I was a SAHM we didn’t even have £85 a month after bills and food and that’s including the child benefit. However it’s kind of what we expected when found out pregnant as obviously our children needed to be taken care of snd funded hours don’t kick in till 3 plus we had a mortgage, which is a privilege and investment do not eligible for the same help as rent. It did seem very unfair to me at the time the idea bandied about that implied that only dual income couples should be entitled to extra support (childcare) and even though we’re in that boat now I still very much stand by that opinion. When I started did a bit of work in the evenings and weekends while hubby was home that helped and not sure why more people don’t consider that? There is also the marriage allowance worth £260 and can still claim if earning almost to the tax threshold. Are you sure your not entitled to anything as when I looked on entitled.com a couple on net 2k a month with 2 children were entitled to £235 universal credit a month (plus child benefit on top) plus a loan to help towards your mortgage if you wanted too. If you would be entitled to that you would be entitled to childcare help too, although yes of course you can’t expect 85% of costs paid if hubby bringing in 2k plus whatever you would bring in. It’s about you having enough to live and afford the odd day out, modest birthday presents etc like the rest of us with young children, not necessarily having the lifestyle you had before.
HotChoc10 · 27/03/2022 07:11

@LoisLane66

Don't have children you can't afford.
This attitude is so shitty, there are all sorts of structural factors impacting people's wealth. I'm from South Africa and when I was growing up, white people were generally wealthy and black people were generally poor. It's not much better now. Ridiculous and offensive to say only those with money should be allowed children.
Leontine · 27/03/2022 02:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ as it quotes a deleted post. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

merrymelodies · 27/03/2022 02:21

I fell into a trap when my DC were toddlers. The children's father (now my XH) pointed out that if I went back to work, childcare would cost more than I could earn. So he convinced me to be a SAHM.

Once the DC were old enough for school, however, I still couldn't go back to work because someone had to drive them to school in the morning, pick them up and bring them home for lunch, drive them back to school an hour later and then pick them up after school and supervise their homework. This went on for years. I bitterly regretted not insisting on going back to work, no matter what the cost in childcare.

Granted this was about 18 years ago and we were living in Switzerland.

Dovecare · 27/03/2022 00:52

Why go back to work just to lose money? Enjoy your time with young children and perhaps top up with a Saturday job or do car boots etc? Once they are both at school you can get back to work and the daily slog.

theo12 · 27/03/2022 00:12

@Rebornagain

I'm reading this and surely the most important thing here is spending time with the children.

Women have been sold a pup about being able to have a career, family etc something has to give.

All this talk about the father going out to work freely etc it's not free choice is it , he is paying for the family to live.

I completely agree with this and somewhat surprised by some of the comments. It's a weigh up between what's affordable and what's ultimately best for your children. I chose to take the cut and spend time as a SAHM and then up my hours at age 3 when more childcare was affordable. I don't regret this and each to there own, at the time unfortunately my job at a charity did not pay enough for it being practical and cutting my husbands hours or pay wasn't financially practical. We we're a team and his pay was the main family income. That was before the cost of living like now is even more ridiculous!! i
2pinkginsplease · 26/03/2022 23:54

I think it really depends on whether you have a job or a career that’s difficult to go back into if you were to take a career break while your children are younger.

We managed it by me changing jobs. I went from full time retail management to part time in hospitality. It meant I was still working but was there during the day and dh was there evenings and weekend. Did it for 18 years and only recently retrained and went back into full time employment.

So we paid no childcare costs at all.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 26/03/2022 23:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ as it quotes a deleted post. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 26/03/2022 23:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ as it quotes a deleted post. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

LoisLane66 · 26/03/2022 23:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

LoisLane66 · 26/03/2022 23:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MissRja · 26/03/2022 23:45

Priority **

OP posts:
MissRja · 26/03/2022 23:44

I think some people are getting a bit rude about this ... at no point did I say I wanted subsidies or anything like that to pay for my childcare. I asked how other people manage when childcare costs more than the take home pay. I understand for a lot of people career progression is a really important Factor. For my family, having enough money to cover everything and to live on is our priorty.
There are also a lot of people who clearly do not understand how UC works. They don't just pay 70 or 80% of childcare. And I have done a calculator we are not entitled to any help. My DP is not a high earner but not on minimum wage. He earns an average wage, but this just not stretch far enough to cover everything.
For example, take home pay : 2000
Mortgage : 700
Council tax:200
Gas/ Electricity: 200
Water: 45
DP Van ( for work so essential ) 150 per month
DP Petrol: 200- 250 per month
Food: 320 per month
Insurances: 50 per month
This leaves us with 85 per month spare money

These costs also do not include petrol for my car which I need for school run , shopping etc. I also can't walk to school as its too far away.

All clothing / items for the children comes from the child benefit money. We survive at the moment because I receive smp but when this ends I clearly need to work as we need the additonal money. But if this is taken up by childcare we are in deficit so am trying to work away around this. And with UC we are not entitled to any support on these figures as not classed as low earners.

Sorry for the long reply but I'm getting annoyed at people stipulating that I'm loaded and just don't want to pay!

Thank-you so much to those of you who are giving practical advice and sharing what you do ,it's really helpful

OP posts:
LoisLane66 · 26/03/2022 23:43

What about dad or dads...?

Bmh54 · 26/03/2022 22:48

I worked weekends & also collected another mums children from school & had them during school holidays to give me that extra money I needed. I was probably better off than working full-time and paying a shed load out in childcare. Another alternative would be to work part time and a friend do the same & help each other out with childcare.
Plus I was told if you are in receipt of family allowance, then your NI contributions due are zero, the year will count towards your pension. It's called Home Responsibility Protection. So no need to worry about state pension contributions.
You could do office cleaning in the evenings when hubbie gets in from work, until you have children at school. ?

Autumn42 · 26/03/2022 22:31

[quote Getyourarseofffthequattro]@Autumn42 nobody is saying their time is less valuable. You're coming at this from a bizarre angle. Quitting work shouldn't be essentially forced. It affects women more as well, presumably you're not a feminist?[/quote]
Well why not give parents it as a cash benefit or tax break to spend on childcare or making up for the loss of earnings if this isn’t the ideology behind such demands for more ‘affordable’ childcare.

There are plenty of people on here who claimed to have been forced to quit work when actually what they meant was they weren’t as better off working as they wanted to be. If you include the extra childcare paid over the summer then we were actually net income worse off me working for the 18 months until I got flexible hours. We’re actually still paying off the money had to borrow for childcare from last summer. However it was our choice to both continue working and pay for a nursery to give us that option. If my husband had insisted that he wouldn’t drop his hours or cover the excess funding to enable me to work if my salary hadn’t covered childcare then I could of left him and then would be entitled to universal credit and have done what I liked, so either way no one would of been forcing me to not work.

I totally get the OP being angry about the flexible hours, as I said before this is such a small concession on the employers part for what is a huge gain for the OP and doesn’t require everyone’s taxes to be put up but I don’t understand her expecting everyone else to further fund their childcare more than the current system already does

Swipe left for the next trending thread