Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- Can't afford to work

385 replies

MissRja · 25/03/2022 09:45

Just trying to work out a return to work after having a baby In December ( also have a 4 year old in full time school ) unfortunately, my original plans for childcare have fell through, which now means we are looking at paid childcare. My current job have declined My flexible working request , which means I am looking for another job. Due to school pick up/ drops offs I am looking returning on reduced hours over 5 days or term time only. Have worked our I will be bringing home roughly £1200 after tax per month. Nursery fees will be £1100 for a four week month, or £1375 for a 5 week month. This does not include before / after school club fees. If I was to use my wages alone to pay childcare fees I would actually be losing money to work , especially when factoring in petrol , work clothes etc. Surely this can't be right. How in this day and age can I not afford to go to work !! Its ridiculous. The whole reason I am going back is because we can't afford to live off DP wages alone , but it doesn't seem like it will make a difference if i do go back to work. Am i missing something here ? What does everyone else do to work around this ? Would love to hear your experiences / advice !!

OP posts:
RetireReady · 25/03/2022 11:43

@Herja pension contributions are not taken into account for UC so unless you earn over the amount that UC deem is reasonable to live on, pension contributions are always a good thing.

Wellthisiscrapeh · 25/03/2022 11:41

@Herja

Do you have a job, or a career?

I had a job in a role that it is notouriously easy to get - one of the ones people dismissively say 'can't you just work at...' on here when they're out of work. The pay was too shit to afford to pay into a pension from, it had almost no progression, no benefits. Child Benefit gives NI credits (until the child is 12) anyway, so giving up work was the clear and obvious solution, when I realised childcare cost more than my pay. As a family, we would have been paying for me to work, rather than working for pay.

If you have a career, or a hard to get role, it might be worth it to maintain the position, but for many people (like me), working with young children makes your family pot lower than not working, without any of the percieved benefits being suggested here (pension, progression etc).

That’s the position I’m in too. A job in care, not a career, there’s no prospects.
canary1 · 25/03/2022 11:40

Look at childminder if you can’t find a nursery that does shorter days that match your working times more

Wellthisiscrapeh · 25/03/2022 11:39

@NameChChChChanges1

Your calculation is wrong (unless you're a single parent). 50% of childcare costs should come from your salary & 50% from your partner's
I never understand this argument of 50/50.

Fair enough if all your money is separate, but with dh and me, all our earnings go into one account.

Working at the moment would cost me more than I earn in childcare. Even if we said dh was paying half the childcare, it still wouldn’t make a difference as it all goes in the same pot and we’d still be paying out more than I earned.

Dsisproblem · 25/03/2022 11:39

@Herja

Do you have a job, or a career?

I had a job in a role that it is notouriously easy to get - one of the ones people dismissively say 'can't you just work at...' on here when they're out of work. The pay was too shit to afford to pay into a pension from, it had almost no progression, no benefits. Child Benefit gives NI credits (until the child is 12) anyway, so giving up work was the clear and obvious solution, when I realised childcare cost more than my pay. As a family, we would have been paying for me to work, rather than working for pay.

If you have a career, or a hard to get role, it might be worth it to maintain the position, but for many people (like me), working with young children makes your family pot lower than not working, without any of the percieved benefits being suggested here (pension, progression etc).

This is a good point. I'd (foolishly) only thought of it from the perspective of a career. I can see why in some roles it doesn't make sense to work.
RetireReady · 25/03/2022 11:37

@chubbachub is your husband paying into a pension for you or just his own? How do you anticipate equalising the difference in your pensions? If you divorced you would have to go through court to get a sharing order if he decided not to disclose how much is in it or be fair about sharing it. Just things to think about for YOUR future. Even without divorce it would mean that you would have your own financial independence in retirement.

Herja · 25/03/2022 11:36

Do you have a job, or a career?

I had a job in a role that it is notouriously easy to get - one of the ones people dismissively say 'can't you just work at...' on here when they're out of work. The pay was too shit to afford to pay into a pension from, it had almost no progression, no benefits. Child Benefit gives NI credits (until the child is 12) anyway, so giving up work was the clear and obvious solution, when I realised childcare cost more than my pay. As a family, we would have been paying for me to work, rather than working for pay.

If you have a career, or a hard to get role, it might be worth it to maintain the position, but for many people (like me), working with young children makes your family pot lower than not working, without any of the percieved benefits being suggested here (pension, progression etc).

WhyIsEverythingSoHard · 25/03/2022 11:36

@NameChChChChanges1

Your calculation is wrong (unless you're a single parent). 50% of childcare costs should come from your salary & 50% from your partner's
It doesn’t change anything about the fact that, as a family, they will have less disposable income after paying for childcare than if she goes back to work.

There is a question to ask whether your DH can work flexi time for example so you can lessen cost that way. Or any other arrangement he could have (is he wfh for example) that you would have considered.

user1471538283 · 25/03/2022 11:35

Childcare has always been crippling.

Does your employer (or the new one when you find one) offer childcare vouchers as that can save a little bit of the cost.

Going back to work is important though and you may climb the ladder and you will have contributed to your pension. Even after all these years I have never gained the 2 years off I had with my DS.

Wannabegreenfingers · 25/03/2022 11:34

Childcare vouchers through work and a childminder, one that can drop off and collect your older one whilst looking after the baby. I've used mine for 10 years now and couldn't work without her.

GeneLovesJezebel · 25/03/2022 11:33

OP - if you do decide not to go back to work and you have a private pension, I’d encourage your DP to pay into it while you’re off.

Dsisproblem · 25/03/2022 11:31

Also check your calculations with nursery. Ours are a flat fee per month, regardless of number of days in the actual month. There's no fluctuation between say February when its a short month and May when it's a long one.

Dsisproblem · 25/03/2022 11:30

Yes, I'd def look at 2 or 3 long days, rather than 5 short ones. Tends to be more cost effective with nursery.

The points about the cost being shared are good ones. I know it seems not worth it for the first couple of years, but long term it really is. Pay rises help, having two salaries in case one of you loses your job/gets ill, having a backup if your partner fucks off and leaves you. I wouldn't give up a career lightly.

lampygirl · 25/03/2022 11:29

Only if you look at short term and totally forget about things like pensions, financial independence, career progression, ability to get a job later when child care costs decline etc

Is excellent if you are in a place whereby you can suck it up for a few years, in my household we could live on less than one of our current salaries even though it would be harder work than on our 2 salaries, but many other people I appreciate live pay packet to pay packet and so thinking long term is only well and good if they can keep their head above water at the minimum.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2022 11:27

I never saw childcare as my sole cost and saw it as split between me and my husband, if you take the same view you will be 600 odd pounds a month better off by working. I really don’t see why you compare it to just your wages and not solely to his or joint. I’m guessing he’s not doing the same mental arithmetic on his salary?

It's completely immaterial if they share their household money and costs. Putting the same amount of money into different envelopes doesn't actually make it total any more.

working is about so much more than the salary coming in for any given month. So much more

That's true above a certain level, but the low-paid don't have any option but to look at the monthly salary coming in as against the outgoings.

It's the same kind of thinking as asking why on earth anybody would rent when they could get on the housing ladder and reap the multiple benefits of home ownership in the years to come - lovely if it's an option for you, but if it isn't, you have to prioritise the definite-now over the would-be-nice-future.

Tilltheend99 · 25/03/2022 11:25

Have you tried having a meeting with your current bosses and explaining that without flexible hours you won’t be able to continue? There is a chance of coming to some compromise.

Others have made important points about private pensions and the possibility of wage rises if you are able to get a job with clear opportunities for progression.

In terms of NI, as long as you filled out the forms for child benefit you will be making contributions towards the state pension regardless.

cjpark · 25/03/2022 11:25

Can you do evening shifts OP? Maybe work 6-12 or something like that? It would probably need to be less shifts as well as your DH will be childcare so you wont have any outgoings for that and pure income, plus your not tied to term time earnings only.

Darhon · 25/03/2022 11:24

This is a joint cost. Keep working for your career, sense of self, economic protection. It’s vital you do this. It will be hard for a few years but ultimately you are in a much better position if you keep working

ChloeHel · 25/03/2022 11:24

I work one day a week 9-6 which helps pay for the bills whilst DH wages fund everything else. I don’t need to pay for childcare as family take care of DD the one Wednesday a week. I also don’t get taxed on the wages I earn so I actually take home just as much as I would if worked 2 days! I didn’t want to give up my job as I’d have to go through the whole registration scheme with my regulating body! It also lets me keep my knowledge and skills up to date!

So you always have that option if of course you have help for the one day you work :)

Heyahun · 25/03/2022 11:23

the posters saying its 50/50 for childcare - thats fine to say - but the poster just said that they cant afford to live off husbands pay only - so assuming she was just using her paying fully for childcare for context!! it doesn't matter who pays for it - they cant afford it

I think a job working less days rather than shorter days 5 days a week makes more sense

less days at nursery is alwyas helpful moneywise

I work 3 days now and still manage to take home some money each month - if i worked 4 days id be tipped over the edge and we would be paying out more than i earn for childcare!!

its about finding a balance

chubbachub · 25/03/2022 11:22

I'm in the process of deciding whether its worth returning to work after dc3 and find myself in a similar circumstance.

My job is not a "career" and there is no real progression opportunity and although we would have been only around £100-200 better off per month for me going back (including claiming some costs back), I think I have decided not to. At least for now.

Our reasons were two-fold. Dh has retrained and now has a job which is equal to both our salaries together previously so we can still have the same lifestyle but no childcare issues.

Also, My children are still little and all in school/nursery/baby so the likelihood of needing time off at short notice for a sick kid etc is high and my work were never very understanding. There is also then the issue of childcare for 3 in school holidays & we have no family at all to help us. MIL is very ill and I dont have any parents.

So for us, for now, it's best if i am here for the kids full time while dh works and progresses in his new career. When the youngest goes to nursery I will find a job within school hours or possibly return to college and do something new.

No one can really advise on your situation as it's personal to you, and only you know what support you have, and what your outgoings etc are, what are your chances of progression, could any of your jobs at risk in the coming years, do you have anything else to fall back on? Would you claim benefits, do you have any hobbies you can make money from? Can family and friends help with childcare during holidays? What are work policies for short notice absences ? Can you work it out if you alternate drop off/pick ups? Can you go part time or consolidate days to still work the same hours but pay less childcare days? What can you claim back from the government? All things to consider and weigh up?
Hope you figure it out. I think that navigating returning to work is a tricky one due to childcare costing so much.

Noisyneighneigh · 25/03/2022 11:20

If you be a SAHM get married

cptartapp · 25/03/2022 11:19

We 'broke even' for three years after childcare fees when the DC were very young. Fees came out the joint pot we paid proportionally into according to earnings. They're now 19 and 17 and I'm so so glad I returned to work from very early on. My mental health was preserved, as were my career skills and the power balance in our marriage and my pension looks great.
Think long term.

Sally872 · 25/03/2022 11:18

Reduced hours and term time is a really big ask. Your older child will be able to go to holiday clubs during holidays. I would see if I could get 3 full days work and price wrap around childcare for older and 3 full days nursery. Paying 5 full days nursery to get the school hours is really inefficient.

You may find a childminder who is cheaper than nursery and will take both children. I would look at that.

NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 25/03/2022 11:12

Yabu

Because: why is childcare your expense only, and not a joint expense between you and DP?

Because: it’s just a few years, but long term you’ll never much better off

It hurts financially, now, but it’s temporary

I quit work, because “it made sense”, it was pretty hard (impossible) to get back to work 5 yrs later, as by then my childcare and housewife duties were so entrenched in our relationship it was hard to change things…

Both options are tough, imo. Choose your tough Grin