Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- Can't afford to work

385 replies

MissRja · 25/03/2022 09:45

Just trying to work out a return to work after having a baby In December ( also have a 4 year old in full time school ) unfortunately, my original plans for childcare have fell through, which now means we are looking at paid childcare. My current job have declined My flexible working request , which means I am looking for another job. Due to school pick up/ drops offs I am looking returning on reduced hours over 5 days or term time only. Have worked our I will be bringing home roughly £1200 after tax per month. Nursery fees will be £1100 for a four week month, or £1375 for a 5 week month. This does not include before / after school club fees. If I was to use my wages alone to pay childcare fees I would actually be losing money to work , especially when factoring in petrol , work clothes etc. Surely this can't be right. How in this day and age can I not afford to go to work !! Its ridiculous. The whole reason I am going back is because we can't afford to live off DP wages alone , but it doesn't seem like it will make a difference if i do go back to work. Am i missing something here ? What does everyone else do to work around this ? Would love to hear your experiences / advice !!

OP posts:
Leftleg · 25/03/2022 12:36

If you're just going to be working school hours so you can do drop off / pick up then I would use a childminder instead of nursery. I found childminders much cheaper and was able to just use the childminder for the school day ir hours required. Nursery was either full day or AM/PM so wouldn't suit for school hours. Once your child is 2 they should be able to attend pre-school which you'll have to pay for but will be much cheaper than nursery.
Also you can claim childcare allowance.

Donra · 25/03/2022 12:32

I see the usual idiots who can’t do basic maths are making the usual stupid comments that childcare is a shared expense. IT DOESN’T MATTER WHO PAYS IT, THE TOTAL COST IS THE SAME. Childcare costs £1100 regardless. If one person only earns £900 for example, the family is £200 out of pocket. It’s irrelevant whether you think of it as one person paying £1100 or two people paying £550 each, the maths works out the same.

OP, yes it’s very common for childcare to exceed the salary of a low earner. It’s very common for one parent to be forced to stay at home until free childcare kicks in. I was in the same situation and I couldn’t work for years because we as a family would have been worse off financially if I did.

Notanotherwindow · 25/03/2022 12:29

It doesn't really matter whose salary it comes out if though does it?

The bottom line is that the maximum amount brought in by OP working is 1200 and the childcare to allow her to work is more like 1300. Whatever way you look at it, the household is down by approx 100. If they are already struggling on the husbands salary then they can't afford to be down another 100 for the sake of pension contributions and the like.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 25/03/2022 12:29

We had the same situation (200 left of my salary after childcare costs) but I wanted to make sure I could get a better paid position, which was more likely if I stayed in employment. So we scrambled around on little cash for 3.5 years. Things improved once I got a promotion. Are you likely to get one if you stay in your position?

The other option is to look for a position where you can work from home with some in-home help for a few hours a day. It could work our cheaper. I am able to do my work at night after everyone has gone to bed, which is how I manage.

HumptySumptious · 25/03/2022 12:29

@WaterBottle123

You can't afford not to work, never be financially dependent on a man.

Claim the childcare help and make sure your husband pays half the fees and does half the pick ups

Yes, this is a narrative that a lot of women fall into without considering properly.
Wellthisiscrapeh · 25/03/2022 12:25

@WombatChocolate

IT isn't worth working for everyone.

As others point out, if you have a basic job with few benefits and no real career progression, the gains of remaining in work can be few.

Lots of people have jobs not careers. Their pension contribution from the employer is the minimum and they can't afford to make their own contribution (especially with childcare costs). Lots of jobs give basically zero sick pay for early sickness. Lots of people will be earning the same in 10 years and won't see any career progression and being in the job longer won't confer any benefits in terms of pay. Lots are on zero hours contracts so actually their work is irregular and they can be paying for childcare without even knowing how many hours they will be earning for.

People forget that large proportions of the population don't have a career. They aren't on a trajectory to promotion and personal fulfilment in the workplace. They do jobs they hate and which treat them poorly and give them limited security.

Yes, for those with career prospects it can be worth taking the hit and even being worse off by working for a short time. But that isn't the same as people in essentially dead-end jobs.

Thanks for pointing all that out better than I ever could.

I always feel like shit for not planning my life better or not having the opportunity in life to do anything better than minimum wage, zero prospect work (I know we all have choices, but some of us are dealt some pretty horrible life circumstances from early on and aren’t able to overcome them for a whole host of reasons. I actually went to one of. the best schools in the country and my peers are all doing amazing things, but no school can make up for a poor family situation in some circumstances).

I don’t have financial security of my own, and yeah, if dh left me I’d be screwed but hey, I can always walk back into a care job. But I am doing my best as a SAHP to support and encourage my children so they don’t have the shit life I did and hopefully, won’t end up working low paying jobs they hate.

Franklin12 · 25/03/2022 12:24

I went back to full time work after 6 months with both children. I now have a comfortable pension, good skills and I am now working part time

For my own health and well being I never wanted some 'part time' low paid role. I have a friend who used to live around the corner. She used to make little barbs regarding my full time role and would often call me at 1630 on a Friday and try and tempt me to come for a few drinks - everyone was there, why wasnt I? She also stated many times in front of people she wouldnt do a role like mine (and quite honestly was in no way qualified to do it).

She is now early 60's and is desperately worried about her lack of a real pension, used to do shifts as a school dinner lady but didnt want anything that meant she couldnt be home for the kids (or go to the pub!). She spent everything she earned which wasnt a lot on enjoying life.

She is now saying I have been lucky, full state pension coming, private pension, kids have been privately educated.

She really doesnt get that we all make choices, some are poor choices, some are short term decisions and some are just plan daft.

In no way was I lucky....

HappyMeal564 · 25/03/2022 12:23

The household pot stays the same though. Wether one salary goes on or 50/50 the house is still worse off. I hear you OP, I'm not at work for the same reason

FeloniusGru · 25/03/2022 12:22

Childcare is expensive, probably the biggest outgoing for many families with small children. It’s more than our mortgage for us.

However, we both want to work so we do the best we can. I’m about to return to work after DC2. Mine are almost 4 and 1. One at school, one due to start nursery.
Originally my work wanted me to do 5 shorter days however I have managed to negotiate 4 full days instead. Shorter days made no sense as with travel time, we would still need to pay for full nursery days and before & after school clubs for eldest (plus extra cost of petrol). With a 4 day week, I am able to provide all childcare for one day, cutting the bill. I start work early so DH does drop offs and I do pick ups. We still need before and after school clubs to cover our hours but at least we can work full days to maximise pay and the burden isn’t completely on one of us.

DH has negotiated to work a 4 day week during school holidays so that we only need to find childcare for 3 days a week during these periods. Youngest will stay in nursery and we are lucky that parents have offered to help with the eldest as much as possible. Obviously we will also need to use annual leave and holiday clubs as a last resort as they can be expensive but we put money aside for these each month.

As others have mentioned, obviously take advantage of the tax free childcare scheme. This helps us a lot.

We worked out a budget combining both incomes and then working out all expenditure including childcare fees to see what (if anything) was left. Most months it is very little and with the rising cost of living, it’s worrying. But we’re definitely better off financially and mentally with us both being at work. I would also be anxious about stepping out of the workplace and trying to find a new role in a few years time as the future is quite uncertain at the minute. We have cut out anything not essential and stick to a strict budget for food shopping/ only but new clothes when truly needed, etc. It should get easier when youngest turns 3 and gets some funded hours at nursery.

konasana · 25/03/2022 12:21

Childcare costs are a household expense, not your personal expense. It's in with mortgage and bills, so split between you and your partner, so you are only liable for part of it. There are other major advantages to working, such as building up your pension and maintaining your position in the work force. Nursery bills are only there for a couple of years - then you are eligible for some free hours, and then the child is in school, so this is only a temporary situation. Do not give up work!

WombatChocolate · 25/03/2022 12:15

IT isn't worth working for everyone.

As others point out, if you have a basic job with few benefits and no real career progression, the gains of remaining in work can be few.

Lots of people have jobs not careers. Their pension contribution from the employer is the minimum and they can't afford to make their own contribution (especially with childcare costs). Lots of jobs give basically zero sick pay for early sickness. Lots of people will be earning the same in 10 years and won't see any career progression and being in the job longer won't confer any benefits in terms of pay. Lots are on zero hours contracts so actually their work is irregular and they can be paying for childcare without even knowing how many hours they will be earning for.

People forget that large proportions of the population don't have a career. They aren't on a trajectory to promotion and personal fulfilment in the workplace. They do jobs they hate and which treat them poorly and give them limited security.

Yes, for those with career prospects it can be worth taking the hit and even being worse off by working for a short time. But that isn't the same as people in essentially dead-end jobs.

BulletTrain · 25/03/2022 12:07

I've just done 2 years paying £500 (minus 20% tax free) to earn about £800 (minus commuting costs). Completely worth it. Now DS is 3 we pay £110 a month and I have been promoted.

TwuntyFriend · 25/03/2022 12:06

Not sure of your situation and whether you're single or married?

If single: Claim UC and you can get up to 85% of childcare fees paid back. On UC you will always be better off working than not. I would also look at childminders rather than nurseries as they will be a lot cheaper and (in my opinion) offer better care. You can look at working FT if you can find a CM who will do wraparound care for your child who is at school too.

If in a couple: Look at UC and see if you can still qualify with your partners wages. Childcare costs should be split between you both and not just replied upon you to pay.

Manekinek0 · 25/03/2022 12:04

I decided to screw the career. I worked part time evening and weekends and started a business in our spare room.

You have to way up where you want to be in 10 years time. If the career is important in the field your in then taking the financial hit is worth it.

Palavah · 25/03/2022 12:02

@IncompleteSenten

You're not paying childcare alone though. You're paying half.

Instead of working in out by individual incomes, add them together and work out total expenditure. Is there more or less left after total expenses if you are working?

Then factor in the damage to your career by years not working and decide what value working has to you beyond the money. It may be worth having less now in order to have more later.

This, plus factor on pension contributions and career progression as financial factors, as well as taxfree childcare allowance.
LakieLady · 25/03/2022 12:01

@RedskyThisNight

Part of the issue if you are paying full time nursery but only working part time hours.

You might well find the sums work out better if you work (say) 3 full days and put your 4 year old in before/after school club on those days, but only pay for 3 days of nursery.

Can you/your partner change hours so one of you does drop offs and one does pickups?

Have you looked at childminders? You might find that works out cheaper if you just pay for school hours.

I was going to suggest 3 full days, too. It worked out much better for a friend of mine.

And if you have an expensive commute, it can reduce the travel costs too.

Could your DP do compressed hours? If he could do the same hours over four days, you'd save a full day of childcare costs.

Wellthisiscrapeh · 25/03/2022 12:00

@Kingharoldshairstyle

Even if we said dh was paying half the childcare, it still wouldn’t make a difference as it all goes in the same pot and we’d still be paying out more than I earned

What about what he earns? What about your pension, what about your ability to get a job later, what about financial independence? If when taking all benefits into account you genuinely can’t afford to work at all, then you need to do what you must but the bottom line is working is not just about what you take home at the end of the month and you seldom see a man saying the same thing.

I worked in care. Minimum wage. And I went back to college as an adult to retrain to do that. I couldn’t afford to contribute to a pension when I was working.
Change123today · 25/03/2022 11:56

You need to look at this as a team effort - yes it a pain that it feels like your working to pay nursery fees but like others have said it should be looked at as a 50/50 cost.

Until more fathers step up and support working mothers - employers need to also take note. I work in IT in a heavily male environment with high contractors earning a lot! BUT the majority of the males have requested flexi time (even though annoyingly it felt like they where amazing that aside!) we have fathers working 4 days, some shared maternity leave and most help with drop offs/pick ups.

My husband is one of those with a big fancy job and earns well - but we choose to have children and he does his share which enabled us to take on the fees etc. Without excuses as to why he can’t - we have to be very organised we have a shared diary which enables us both to see what’s needed.

Look at what works and he without expectation should be a shared effort.

For us breakfast club and nursery drop of was husbands - meant I worked earlier and finished earlier to do the pick ups. I worked one long day so we used the afterschool club. (Also meant if he then did have to work away I could pop her in the afterschool club and it wasn’t something she wasn’t used too) This has meant in my own right i have a decent pension, holiday pay! And my children our now 18 and 12 they fine and haven’t been damaged by having a working mum. In turn they have a good relationship with their Dad.

Look at the savings that exist - We used to use vouchers and they can be used for nursery/school clubs & holiday clubs. And the long term - it will be hard for probably the next two years but then free hours kick in and then school. And by then you may have got a new job and can ask for flexi time to do the school pick ups etc

Do what’s right for you, if you’d prefer to be a SAHP then own that and protect yourself from any possible long term issues (pensions etc) maybe look to retrain etc but don’t close the door on YOUR future just because it feels ‘pointless’ working now.

LakieLady · 25/03/2022 11:55

@catsandquails

It's worth looking to see if you might be entitled to UC. They include 80% of childcare costs (up to a certain amount) before deductions for earnings are made. The online calculators are apparently unreliable though so it's best to try to work it out yourself if you can.
I've found entitledto to be pretty accurate for UC. None of them are brilliant for legacy benefits, esp. where disability is involved, because it all gets so much more complex.

I work in welfare rights and we did a little exercise of comparing the results from the specialist software we use (which is brilliantly accurate, even with tax credits) with various of the public access ones, and entitledto came out with the best accuracy rate.

lanthanum · 25/03/2022 11:55

@GeneLovesJezebel

If you were working you’d be paying NI towards your ‘old age’ pension though, and would you be paying towards a private pension too ? Sometimes you have to think about the long term benefits, and I know that’s hard when it seems a long way off. But personally, I was SAHM for a couple of years, then started working the odd shift when DH was home.
The NI argument doesn't hold water. If you are claiming child benefit for a child under 12, you get full NI credits. (Applies even if partner is higher earner and the child benefit is taken back through their tax return.)
Kingharoldshairstyle · 25/03/2022 11:51

Even if we said dh was paying half the childcare, it still wouldn’t make a difference as it all goes in the same pot and we’d still be paying out more than I earned

What about what he earns? What about your pension, what about your ability to get a job later, what about financial independence? If when taking all benefits into account you genuinely can’t afford to work at all, then you need to do what you must but the bottom line is working is not just about what you take home at the end of the month and you seldom see a man saying the same thing.

Babyroobs · 25/03/2022 11:47

Sorry not read all the replies but would you not be entitled to Universal credit childcare element which would pay up to 85% of childcare costs? Or as others have said tax free childcare.
We had four kids and the only way we managed it was to work around each other. DH did 9-5 and I did nights and weekends. It wasn't ideal and I was lucky I was already established in a career that incorporated shift work. It's what lots of people have to do for a few years unfortunately.

Gonnagetgoing · 25/03/2022 11:45

I know people are saying to return to work but if you can't afford to do it now maybe wait.

I heard on TV or radio a woman who was using trains to get to work as petrol was too expensive at the moment.

WaterBottle123 · 25/03/2022 11:43

You can't afford not to work, never be financially dependent on a man.

Claim the childcare help and make sure your husband pays half the fees and does half the pick ups

Gonnagetgoing · 25/03/2022 11:43

Are there any Barnardos nurseries where you are? DNephew goes to one and it's a bit cheaper (and just as good) as a normal nursery.