Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- Can't afford to work

385 replies

MissRja · 25/03/2022 09:45

Just trying to work out a return to work after having a baby In December ( also have a 4 year old in full time school ) unfortunately, my original plans for childcare have fell through, which now means we are looking at paid childcare. My current job have declined My flexible working request , which means I am looking for another job. Due to school pick up/ drops offs I am looking returning on reduced hours over 5 days or term time only. Have worked our I will be bringing home roughly £1200 after tax per month. Nursery fees will be £1100 for a four week month, or £1375 for a 5 week month. This does not include before / after school club fees. If I was to use my wages alone to pay childcare fees I would actually be losing money to work , especially when factoring in petrol , work clothes etc. Surely this can't be right. How in this day and age can I not afford to go to work !! Its ridiculous. The whole reason I am going back is because we can't afford to live off DP wages alone , but it doesn't seem like it will make a difference if i do go back to work. Am i missing something here ? What does everyone else do to work around this ? Would love to hear your experiences / advice !!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EllieJos · 30/03/2022 17:31

It is quite simple. Unless you can work when your partner is home or you can cover your childcare costs it is not worth working. I did but I also had gp help for the first couple of years and DH covered some of the costs and care even though he was a student. I also worked ft over 4 days and still use childcare vouchers (replaced by tax free childcare) which also helps.

Mumofboys0 · 30/03/2022 11:19

Have you looked into Universal credit? My partner and I both work ( me 20 hours) him full time and we are entitled to 85% of childcare costs as long as they are ofsted registered.

Crikeyalmighty · 29/03/2022 19:02

I would say OP having been in that position— ‘if’ you are in a career with progression and want to remain in it—look for something ideally that’s 2 days a week , your earnings and childcare costs will balance out- although be aware your childcare costs are high because your little one is still classed as a baby— those costs will come down but not for a good while — you can always then look at maybe a bit of evening work a couple of nights a week on days you don’t work in the day — maybe a bar/ waitressing etc— it will get you out and bring in extra money without childcare needs provided you don’t gave a partner doing shifts. If that’s not possible I would accept for first 2 years you won’t gain extra income — so may as well do 2 days a week and 2 days childcare just to keep your hand in— ‘if’ your job isn’t really a career and you aren’t fussed what you do, and he doesn’t work shifts/weekends then look at evening or weekend jobs a few nights a week and your partner will have to step up to the plate— that way you can quite easily make £500 a month extra , no childcare costs.

321user123 · 29/03/2022 18:19

@User112

Did you not do this match before planning kids? We delayed having 2nd child for seven years for the same reason, but we ended up with twins! After paying for childcare, I hardly had anything left. But it’s better now. It’s hard for a few years, but finances can improve significantly once the youngest starts school. Also by then you’ll hopefully get some pay rises/ promotions.
That’s just rude. Thought about it or not it doesn’t change the fact that she’s in this situation now.

However, OP clearly stated in her initial post that she had childcare plans that have fallen through and as a result of that, now she can’t afford to go back to work. Just read.

By reading in between the lines it seems she had a family/friend arrangement and things changed.

321user123 · 29/03/2022 18:16

Simply because they need higher earner’s income to survive.
They also need income above that to make ends meet as OP said.

321user123 · 29/03/2022 18:08

Yes you do…

dfendyr · 29/03/2022 18:02

@ancientgran yes if you claim Child Benefit

ancientgran · 29/03/2022 17:05

@VapeVamp12

If you were working you’d be paying NI towards your ‘old age’ pension though, and would you be paying towards a private pension too ?

My great uncle hasn't worked a day in his life and his state pension is the same as my Dad's who still isn't retired at 70.

Don't you still get credits for your NI if you have young children?
ancientgran · 29/03/2022 17:04

@thebigpurpleone

Why is all the onus on you to be finding flexible solutions?
Because he's the higher earner and they need the money.
dfendyr · 29/03/2022 16:18

@VapeVamp12

If you were working you’d be paying NI towards your ‘old age’ pension though, and would you be paying towards a private pension too ?

My great uncle hasn't worked a day in his life and his state pension is the same as my Dad's who still isn't retired at 70.

Does your dad have a private pension through work though?

To get Basic State Pension, you need to have paid enough national insurance contributions or received enough national insurance credits.

If you haven’t paid enough national insurance contributions yourself, you may still have some entitlement. Check our Basic State Pension – What if I don’t qualify? page to find out more.

The maximum Basic State Pension is £137.60 per week if you are under 80 years old and £137.85 per week after you turn 80.

You are entitled to the maximum amount of Basic State Pension if you paid enough national insurance contributions or received national insurance credits for a total of 30 years.

For each year that is missing from your national insurance record, your entitlement is reduced by one thirtieth.

Some people may still be entitled to additional amounts from old schemes:

State Second Pension (phased out from 6 April 2016)
Increase for a husband, wife or civil partner (phased out from 6 April 2010)
Increase for children (phased out from 6 April 2003)
State Earnings Related Pension Scheme (phased out from 6 April 2002)
Graduated Retirement Benefit (phased out from 6 April 1975).

VapeVamp12 · 29/03/2022 15:46

If you were working you’d be paying NI towards your ‘old age’ pension though, and would you be paying towards a private pension too ?

My great uncle hasn't worked a day in his life and his state pension is the same as my Dad's who still isn't retired at 70.

dfendyr · 29/03/2022 14:52

[quote HappyMeal564]@Labelmaker just because you stop working when your children are young doesn't mean you instantly become incapable of getting a job/lose any qualifications or skills you have if your husband runs off. As a single parent you can claim child maintenance from the child's father and there are benefits that help those who are struggling. I'd hate to live life thinking, oh must live like this and make it harder on us just in case my husband bails. I'd just deal with that at the time.[/quote]
but its sooo much harder to get back in to the workforce, or continue a career if you take time out

No its not great, yes it is sexist, but i wouldnt stop working just because it wasn't making a difference to the household income as long term the pain will be worth it

thebigpurpleone · 28/03/2022 20:56

Why is all the onus on you to be finding flexible solutions?

littledrummergirl · 28/03/2022 18:11

When my dc were small I stayed home for a few years, then got a job working evenings and weekends. Family life was shit.
We then altered our lives, dh worked nights, he would sleep from 7 until 1 and I would work from 09:30 until 18:00.
I'd sort the dc in the morning, dh would collect from school and do dinner.
We had more family time as a result which was the most important thing to us.

Autumn42 · 28/03/2022 17:51

@Dixiechickonhols

Op is in a good position as she has a car and a partner to mind the children evenings or weekends. I bet if you look around you’ll be surprised how many opportunities there are. I’ve worked in factories as a student that ran twilight shifts. If you’ve got office skills something like this might suit. uk.indeed.com/m/viewjob?jk=c4c0b0d3dd1786b9&from=serp A lot of employers realise they can get better candidates for NMW if the offer the right hours.
Absolutely, I used to work a couple of evenings on a zero hours contract, Dh salary almost covered the mortgage and bills (we weren’t entitled to UC) and so my earnings generally topped it up and gave us a small amount for kids birthday presents etc. obviously some months didn’t get as much work but other months got a bit of weekend work too. Just a bit tiring at times as didn’t get to bed till 2-3am on those nights but would try and get an hour kip when Dh got home and once got the funded hours at 3 could go back to bed for a couple hours if on morning went to nursery.
Autumn42 · 28/03/2022 17:43

P.s. if they’re both working 26 hours at minimum wage then they would most certainly be entitled to UC as well

Autumn42 · 28/03/2022 17:39

[quote BulletTrain]@Autumn42 I know we've all had to do it, but you get a lot of suggestions on these threads like "Why don't you both work 26 hours a week" and the chances of both finding something part-time with minimal crossover hours is very very slim! Compressed hours for one or both can be easier.[/quote]
The 26 hours is just an example of what could both work at minimum wage and bring in, it didn’t say no childcare would be needed (unless your lucky enough to both find a job with no cross over) it said minimal. So if I take the combined example of myself and friends and family it might typically involve one working Sunday and Monday day/night shifts in a care home (24 hours) a week earning £1040 take home and the other working part time has to work Mondays, Wednesdays, Thursdays and Fridays 8-6 (36 hours with an unpaid break) earning £1700 per month take home so the take home is £2640 and they spend £225 a month on the day at nursery and breakfast and after-school club for the Monday when they need childcare cover leaving them with £2515 plus the £150 child benefit so £2665 a month after childcare. This is a typical example of a lot of families I know and they seem to manage quite fine on this and both get the opportunity to work

Dixiechickonhols · 28/03/2022 16:43

Op is in a good position as she has a car and a partner to mind the children evenings or weekends. I bet if you look around you’ll be surprised how many opportunities there are. I’ve worked in factories as a student that ran twilight shifts.
If you’ve got office skills something like this might suit.
uk.indeed.com/m/viewjob?jk=c4c0b0d3dd1786b9&from=serp
A lot of employers realise they can get better candidates for NMW if the offer the right hours.

BulletTrain · 28/03/2022 16:28

@Autumn42 I know we've all had to do it, but you get a lot of suggestions on these threads like "Why don't you both work 26 hours a week" and the chances of both finding something part-time with minimal crossover hours is very very slim! Compressed hours for one or both can be easier.

RegardingMary · 28/03/2022 16:19

You're not going to get a job that's in school hours and term time only.
I suggest you look at ways between you to increase flexibility. 1 cover pick ups, the other drop offs. Look into shift work, most early shifts finish before school pick up. Nights would mean you could do both pick up and drop off.

It may mean a career change.

Autumn42 · 28/03/2022 16:13

@BulletTrain

I don't think many people understand how difficult it is to find part-time work that doesn't require a particular type of experience and is fixed days/hours around childcare. Retail is on a rota. Call-centres are on a rota. School positions are usually 5 days a week termtime. I did strike gold and find one, but for example next week I am having to do an extra day to do some exams and training so paying for extra nursery.
I don’t think it’s that people don’t understand but it’s what we’ve all had to go through. That’s not to say that the government shouldn’t be making it easier for future generations of parents by promoting more flexibility, obviously it won’t be possible for all positions to accommodate this but for example in the field I work in there was absolutely no flexibility for years and then with combination of labour shortages and the government promoting public sector flexible working myself and colleagues have now been able to work set days which has slashed our childcare bills as we’re not having to pay for full time childcare just in case we get rostered a particular day as we know e.g that we’ll only be working e.g. Mondays, Tuesdays and Fridays not any 3 days our of 7. There was no really good reason why this couldn’t have been done before except an employer policy that just didn’t want to give up the flexibility it gave them should they ever need it, but the difference this no cost solution to parents and others in the workplace is absolutely huge. In terms of minimum wage work most people will find is they spend a little while looking they will find something to fit, loads of friends have been able to and my older children have all found work which fitted around college days etc. If it’s a particular field your interested in it’s sometimes worth doing it even if your not going to be immediately financially better off. When I started my current job there were months when we paid more in childcare than I earned and I really wasn’t expecting there to be any flexibility so assumed that would be the case until we got the funded hours but both my job and after school care for older child become more flexible so we’re much better off now and not long either until we get the funded hours so long term it’s worked out really well. However I love my job, if didn’t would of just opted to enjoy the time at home with little one and look at trim back home expenses to a bare minimum like many of my SAHM friends do
Dixiechickonhols · 28/03/2022 15:49

If you don’t want to stay in your current role long term/no prospects I’d look for a role evenings or weekends. Supermarket, care, hospitality. Even if it’s NMW you’ll be better off as no childcare.
Or be a student now not later (you mentioned re training at Uni) and you’d get student loan and childcare assistance.

BulletTrain · 28/03/2022 15:38

I don't think many people understand how difficult it is to find part-time work that doesn't require a particular type of experience and is fixed days/hours around childcare. Retail is on a rota. Call-centres are on a rota. School positions are usually 5 days a week termtime. I did strike gold and find one, but for example next week I am having to do an extra day to do some exams and training so paying for extra nursery.

Autumn42 · 28/03/2022 15:23

@321user123

I might have expressed the 50-50 situation wrong and being married maybe I’m misunderstanding the issue.

My (and many others) point is, if DP is earning
£2,000 and OP is earning 1,200 that totals £3,200 at the end of the month.
If the current expenses are £2,200 the current DP waged don't cover that, the existing expenses.
If the new expenses after OP returns to work are now £3,450, it does not change the fact the total income is £3,200 a month.

I only understand the 50-50 situation if there is disposable income left at the end of the month from Salary 1. If there isn’t the conversation makes no sense because however you do the math it still totals the same.

OP has expressed that due to their situation and the type of professions is not possible for DP/DH to be more flexible. (He’s a trade/construction worker).
OP is not in a position where there is career progression.

She has also expressed that currently feeding her family takes priority over NI contributions and other stuff.

So really PT work along the lines of what was mentioned above may be the only route.

I understand people’s suggestions about she not being a single parent, I do, but not everyone is in a flexible work environment or the same situation.
I believe that if she was the high earner in the couple, her work would be prioritised over DH, but has OP stated that is not the case and it sucks even more that both of their employments are not flexible.

They’ve got far more options than a single parent who has no childcare support. If she is particularly eager to work but her salary does not cover the cost of childcare then they could both work part time e.g. if they both worked 26 hours a week each, even at the minimum wage they would bring in £2100 pcm between them and he wouldn’t necessarily need to be in a job where he needs such an expensive van and fuel costs and they would still be entitled to their child benefit and an amount of UC and even childcare help if they needed it. Either could work full time and one of them part time, they could both work full time staggering their days and thus needing less childcare. There are lots of options to they don’t seem to have considered and they need to remember full time childcare is proportionally more expensive as you only get a maximum TFC supplement of 2k per year per child, which e.g. in our area means you only get the discount on the first 3.5-4 days of childcare. Tax and national insurance wise too, a couple both working part time receive 25k total free in tax and NI allowance whereas a single earner household with earnings of 25k receives only a a 12.5k allowance so pays a good amount of that on tax/NI, potentially extra in student loan repayments etc too, which wouldn’t be payable with 2 people who both earn 12.5k. If she stayed at home she said she had £85 a month plus £150 pcm child benefit after essential bills and food so that’s £235 a month for clothes, savings, occasional treats etc, given the figures she gave she would also be entitled to £235 UC so that’s actually nearly £500 disposable income, a lot more than many families have. There is extra financial and childcare support for them anyway if her figures are accurate and even if they are both desperate to work there are so many different ways they could without the country taxing everyone to high hilt to pay for all new parents childcare
321user123 · 28/03/2022 14:36

I might have expressed the 50-50 situation wrong and being married maybe I’m misunderstanding the issue.

My (and many others) point is, if DP is earning
£2,000 and OP is earning 1,200 that totals £3,200 at the end of the month.
If the current expenses are £2,200 the current DP waged don't cover that, the existing expenses.
If the new expenses after OP returns to work are now £3,450, it does not change the fact the total income is £3,200 a month.

I only understand the 50-50 situation if there is disposable income left at the end of the month from Salary 1. If there isn’t the conversation makes no sense because however you do the math it still totals the same.

OP has expressed that due to their situation and the type of professions is not possible for DP/DH to be more flexible. (He’s a trade/construction worker).
OP is not in a position where there is career progression.

She has also expressed that currently feeding her family takes priority over NI contributions and other stuff.

So really PT work along the lines of what was mentioned above may be the only route.

I understand people’s suggestions about she not being a single parent, I do, but not everyone is in a flexible work environment or the same situation.
I believe that if she was the high earner in the couple, her work would be prioritised over DH, but has OP stated that is not the case and it sucks even more that both of their employments are not flexible.