Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this online coach/ life coach stuff is very irritating?

65 replies

Cheerios12 · 24/03/2022 22:47

Posting vague general captions or posting about their tough life but turned it around and so can you. Is it me or does anyone else find this online coaching culture annoying. Most have no training.

I've just listened to one saying OCD is a self sabotaging behaviour and you need to just snap out of this behaviour cycle.
Well no actually OCD is a mental illness that needs alot of DBT or CBT work that you can't just snap out of. How damaging are some of these peoples words.

I'm in the psychology profession, have trained so hard. Yet these online coach cowboys pray on people and tell them to stop making excuses or you can have whatever you want if you follow my advice

OP posts:
Mmmmmmbop90 · 25/03/2022 19:03

Coming back - with a hard hat!

I did my training with the coaching academy in London. I do 4 cpd days a year with a variety of providers.

Life coaches don’t give advice, and therefore don’t need to know better than you - in fact that’s the number one thing about a coach. They won’t tell you what to do, they won’t give advice as it would be unethical and dangerous to do so. Imagine the insurance claims!

Professional coaches will have completed a diploma in coaching, been assessed over a period of time, have regular supervision, be insured etc

Re the mental health issues point. I think I worded it badly, I won’t work with anyone on their mental health. So if someone came to me who was diagnosed with depression and wanted to work on ‘being happier’ etc I would decline and signpost to appropriate services. If they wanted to work on a business plan then that would of course be fine.

At no point does coaching stray into counselling. I dabbled in counselling training years ago before deciding it wasn’t for me, and coaching is a completely different skill set with different objectives.

It pains me that coaches apparently get such a bad rep! I would never claim to transform someone’s life, but I do have the skills to help them progress in their chosen path (be it work, relationships etc)

coffeeisthebest · 25/03/2022 18:06

[quote OMG12]@coffeeisthebest couldn’t agree more with you (and Ruby). I use a system for my own development (on different levels) which states you should undertake at least a years worth of therapy before starting. I think life coaches, or any work which might expose shadows/mental health issues/past traumas/issues should recommend something similar. It would make people less vulnerable and most likely they wouldn’t need the use of a random on Facebook, and if they wanted decent life coaching they would be in a better position to reap the benefits. You can have mental health issues and be in a position that enables really good growth rather than leaving you vulnerable,[/quote]
Yep. If you haven't stared in the face of your own shit you are not in a position to go anywhere near anyone else's. For me, a therapist is a companion as you work through your own stuff, a life coach infers that someone else 'knows better' which is bonkers in itself as there are no authority figures on how to live. We all just have to learn to navigate our own way, otherwise we will live as eternal children looking for someone to tell us what to do.

topcat2014 · 25/03/2022 16:56

What is a 'qualified life coach'.

Who gives out the qualifications.

Is there a professional learned body you join?

Speaking as someone who sat exams for years for my chartered qualification. And who pays ongoing subs and CPD to maintain it.

ZaraSizeMedium · 25/03/2022 16:52

I know 2 life coaches and knowing what I do of their own lives I wouldnt take the most basic advice or coaching from them even if they were giving it away for free.

It’s a completely unregulated industry so the “qualifications” around coaching mean jack shit as far as I’m concerned, not worth the paper they’re printed on.

I also know a “coach the coaches” coach and yes I agree it’s yet another MLM.

OMG12 · 25/03/2022 16:44

@coffeeisthebest couldn’t agree more with you (and Ruby). I use a system for my own development (on different levels) which states you should undertake at least a years worth of therapy before starting. I think life coaches, or any work which might expose shadows/mental health issues/past traumas/issues should recommend something similar. It would make people less vulnerable and most likely they wouldn’t need the use of a random on Facebook, and if they wanted decent life coaching they would be in a better position to reap the benefits. You can have mental health issues and be in a position that enables really good growth rather than leaving you vulnerable,

OMG12 · 25/03/2022 16:18

[quote Cheerios12]@omg12 completely agree with you.

Surely though they would realise a qualified person charges between 50-100 per hour. Therefore 1000s would seem crazy to pay?

Mental health is definitely in a crisis with the huge wait lists. These type of people are take advantage of this and unfortunately it could make it worse. When surprisingly the coaches advice/guidance doesn't work[/quote]
Absolutely and I think some kind of regulation is called for. Unfortunately any work on mental health takes a lot of very hard work and often painful realisation. We’re used to an immediate gratification society. Others doing the dirty work. We’re so used to healthcare being free people often forget it can be accessed privately and there is an element of the more expensive the better.
We’ve lost many of the support systems, religion, extended family, life long friends and work colleagues - I suspect many are basically paying these people to have a friend they can control.
I 100% agree that using “alternative” methods whilst having unresolved mental health issues makes you extremely vulnerable. I’ve seen it a lot with esp young men with unresolved issues becoming entwined with conspiracy theories, drugs, anger issues, dissociation, masking etc by untrained people offering these “therapies”. Covid really opened my eyes to exactly who was in my yoga class😂

This of course is different to people who offer say a sounding board for organising your life etc.

coffeeisthebest · 25/03/2022 16:16

@Mmmmmmbop90

Im a coach so going to defend us a bit here…

I did a two year course to become one, passed multiple practical assessments etc. My clients seem to get a lot out of a course of sessions and I charge £75 an hour.

I would never coach someone with a mental health condition and make that clear in my ts&cs and code of ethics. I (and most other trained coaches) make it clear that we are not therapists or psychologists and don’t look back at the past, that’s outside our remit.

I’m sure there are lots of charlatans, but there are also some great coaches who help people take steps in their lives that they’ve been too afraid/unsure/unmotivated/don’t know where to start about before.

I have heard before that you won't work with those with a mental health condition. Can you describe to me exactly how you ascertain if someone is mentally ill? Surely not everyone has a diagnosis but may be incredibly vulnerable non the less. I found this really difficult to get my head round when I heard this, and also did not like the inference that those with mental illness were not 'workable' with, under the life coach framework, as though it is some kind of elite gang. Ruby Wax said years ago that most of us are mentally ill in one way or another, I think this is a more real view.
Cheerios12 · 25/03/2022 15:56

@omg12 completely agree with you.

Surely though they would realise a qualified person charges between 50-100 per hour. Therefore 1000s would seem crazy to pay?

Mental health is definitely in a crisis with the huge wait lists. These type of people are take advantage of this and unfortunately it could make it worse. When surprisingly the coaches advice/guidance doesn't work

OP posts:
Littleelffriend · 25/03/2022 15:26

My sil claims to be a life coach. She’s never had a successful relationship, doesn’t have a successful career, jumps between obsessing about various hobbies then dumping them and is generally quite unhappy. I have no idea why she thinks she’s qualified to call herself a life coach.

OMG12 · 25/03/2022 13:37

@TheWayOfTheWorld

It's beyond irritating. It's also beyond me how people are suckered in by it and shell out £££. But they do Hmm
I think there are lots of people out there who peddle this stuff, they invariably have a large collection of crystals and think sticking the word “ceremony” after various class A drugs makes it ok.

Why do people do it? More and more people are struggling, access to proper help is difficult. Try accessing mental health help and you end up with long waiting lists etc. in a time where lots of relationships are superficial suddenly someone is “interested” in you (or your wallet).

Having spent years in various forms of therapy, there’s a lot of bad therapists and incomplete/inappropriate treatments offered within a profession who often ignore both somatic and spiritual aspects of therapies. It takes a lot of effort to find good ones and it usually helps to have supplementary therapy involving physical and spiritual release. There’s not always a lot out there, there’s minimal joining up with each part usually criticising the others. One of the best books on this is The Body Keeps the score. But the point is where a gap is left someone will always fill it with big promises and big fees. The psychology profession needs to widen its treatment to close these gaps.

Don’t get me started on “The Secret” it’s a version of a tiny part of various very complex systems which actually do help in a wholistic way but they need lots of work over decades (and I would be suspicious of people charging for this as most of these systems link into one that specifically state probono help) and often a long period of psychotherapy/psychoanalysis is undertaken first.

People want quick fixes to life long problems ideally with minimal effort from themselves. It’s why therapy often fails people want the therapist to do the work and wave a wand. It’s entwined with a lot of the new age philosophies.

Mummy1608 · 25/03/2022 13:02

Yanbu at all op.

But fair play to them, if they can find rich silly people who will give them thousands for some trite slogans... As dire straits would say, that ain't working, that's the way you do it, money for nothing.

I also, like some pp, have a friend who has failed at various jobs and been unemployed for a while before self styling as a life coach, no qualifications as far as i know, she would have mentioned. I kind of feel sorry for her husband who has to be the breadwinner while being "supportive of her business". I don't think I could respect my DH if he did that

Margaretmatcher · 25/03/2022 09:49

I guess if you have the balls to believe you can drastically change someone life you will have the balls to charge thousands of pounds
And if you are looking for a lifestyle change you would probably think that the higher the fee the more professional the coach will be

Cheerios12 · 25/03/2022 09:30

@Margaretmatcher

My ex wanted to improve his business so went to something like a life coach. Cost him a few thousand he put the motivational cd on in the car. It was the exact wording from the book THE SECRET but the guy had just made it into a cd with his voice. The cd was in a plastic bag no hard cover. And no it did not improve his business. Fyi I had the book it cost me£11.
Wow. I can't believe he paid thousands for that. I also can't believe the person charged that much. Where do they pluck these prices from? Thin air?
OP posts:
Margaretmatcher · 25/03/2022 09:21

My ex wanted to improve his business so went to something like a life coach. Cost him a few thousand he put the motivational cd on in the car. It was the exact wording from the book THE SECRET but the guy had just made it into a cd with his voice. The cd was in a plastic bag no hard cover. And no it did not improve his business. Fyi I had the book it cost me£11.

Echobelly · 25/03/2022 09:13

YANBU, there's a lot of bollocks out there. When it's not misleading or wrong, it is just saying very obvious stuff.

I'm sure there is a place for life coaching, but from people who know what they are doing, but it seems like a lot don't.

TwoBigNoisyBoys · 25/03/2022 09:11

@Mmmmmmbop90 agree with PP’s…I don’t think OP is talking about genuine, properly qualified people like you. I do feel for you.

But I have to agree with OP. I’m not currently on Facebook, but this used to do my nut in! One particular user was advertising her life coach and mindfulness teaching/online life counselling sessions …now, I know her off Facebook and I’m genuinely not being horrible, but her own life is a bit chaotic, so I’d be reluctant to accept life coaching from her? I also asked her what her relevant qualifications were…2 short courses from a free online provider. I’m not knocking her for taking these course and trying to improver her life, but it seems bizarre that she now considers herself expert enough to impart advice and guidance to others 🤷🏼‍♀️

I dunno, maybe I’m just am old gimmer 🤷🏼‍♀️ I do however speak as someone with qualifications in advice and guidance, counselling, am due to complete a degree in mental health next year and I have a background in mindfulness spanning many years now…yet I still wouldn’t consider myself qualified enough to set myself up as a life/mindfulness coach.

Mmmmmmbop90 · 25/03/2022 08:56

Just to add - life coaches don’t give advice. That’s one of the benefits of a life coach! So anyone giving people advice and claiming to be a coach is a liar.

I’m actually getting cross reading these because they in no way reflect what a qualified life coach is meant to do!

SingToTheSky · 25/03/2022 07:41

Absolutely YANBU

Cheerios12 · 25/03/2022 07:20

Without*

OP posts:
Cheerios12 · 25/03/2022 07:19

@Lennon80

It’s a load of old bollocks - I have three people on my Facebook who have started doing it - They are just people who have had depression in the past no other ‘qualifications’ as such. I wouldn’t want life advice from any of them frankly or anyone who wasn’t a multimillionaire from scratch. All this ‘best life’ bollocks.
Agree, I get if you want to help people because you've been in that situation. But to preach and say damaging things.

You can't just give psychological advice with proper qualifications.

OP posts:
Lennon80 · 24/03/2022 23:27

It’s a load of old bollocks - I have three people on my Facebook who have started doing it - They are just people who have had depression in the past no other ‘qualifications’ as such. I wouldn’t want life advice from any of them frankly or anyone who wasn’t a multimillionaire from scratch. All this ‘best life’ bollocks.

Cheerios12 · 24/03/2022 23:26

@Mmmmmmbop90

Im a coach so going to defend us a bit here…

I did a two year course to become one, passed multiple practical assessments etc. My clients seem to get a lot out of a course of sessions and I charge £75 an hour.

I would never coach someone with a mental health condition and make that clear in my ts&cs and code of ethics. I (and most other trained coaches) make it clear that we are not therapists or psychologists and don’t look back at the past, that’s outside our remit.

I’m sure there are lots of charlatans, but there are also some great coaches who help people take steps in their lives that they’ve been too afraid/unsure/unmotivated/don’t know where to start about before.

As I said most don't have qualifications but you do which is good. You also state you don't help mental health conditions which is also good. I'm not saying all but it seems most unfortunately on the likes on Instagram and tiktok feel they call pull people from depressions, tell a person with adhd inattentive to stop being lazy etc. That kind of stuff grinds my gears. Especially as I'm in the depths of training in a NHS psychological field.
OP posts:
Whitefire · 24/03/2022 23:26

@Mmmmmmbop90

Im a coach so going to defend us a bit here…

I did a two year course to become one, passed multiple practical assessments etc. My clients seem to get a lot out of a course of sessions and I charge £75 an hour.

I would never coach someone with a mental health condition and make that clear in my ts&cs and code of ethics. I (and most other trained coaches) make it clear that we are not therapists or psychologists and don’t look back at the past, that’s outside our remit.

I’m sure there are lots of charlatans, but there are also some great coaches who help people take steps in their lives that they’ve been too afraid/unsure/unmotivated/don’t know where to start about before.

I actually feel for coaches like you who are committed and dedicated to the role, however unfortunately many have seen it as a quick, easy way to make a buck. The wisdom generally involves buying a happiness planner from them.

The MLM turned life coach are doing you an incredible disservice.

Cheerios12 · 24/03/2022 23:23

@Whitefire

A lot of them were 'respected" within the MLM and aspired to. They appear to have done good (financially) so it is an honour to be able to get a nugget of their knowledge. If one can do what they did then one will also be rich.

Though the charge is less money and more selling their soul to the devil.

Narcissistic springs to mind there
OP posts:
Mmmmmmbop90 · 24/03/2022 23:23

Im a coach so going to defend us a bit here…

I did a two year course to become one, passed multiple practical assessments etc. My clients seem to get a lot out of a course of sessions and I charge £75 an hour.

I would never coach someone with a mental health condition and make that clear in my ts&cs and code of ethics. I (and most other trained coaches) make it clear that we are not therapists or psychologists and don’t look back at the past, that’s outside our remit.

I’m sure there are lots of charlatans, but there are also some great coaches who help people take steps in their lives that they’ve been too afraid/unsure/unmotivated/don’t know where to start about before.

Swipe left for the next trending thread