Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this pissed me off about my booking appointment ?

555 replies

chattycaterpillar · 24/03/2022 22:18

I had a pregnancy booking appointment recently, and was talking to a friend about this yesterday, and she agreed this equally pissed her off about her's too, ( she had hers 12 months ago in the same NHS trust).

The actual medical questions were almost skimmed over, ( I wasn't asked if I had any medication allergies, even though I have a serious allergy to doxycycline). But the amount of nosy, social questions asked to "judge," your suitability to parent was ridiculous.

Examples on the proforma list included:

  • How long have you been with your partner ? ( Yes, it is a long-term relationship so wasn't an issue for me, but my friend's child was conceived after a short fling and she didn't want to be answering exactly how long it was).
  • What is your highest level qualification/ are you educated to degree level ? ( I'm educated to degree level, but interested in the medical relevance of this. Imagine getting asked that at any other medical appointment ...)
  • Are you employed ? Is it full time work, what do you do for work ? What does your partner do for work ? ( Why on earth is it medically relevant what my partner does as his job ? )
  • Does your partner have any other children ? ( No, but again, not medically relevant...)
  • Do you own or rent your property ? ( Why, do you want to take a look at my mortgage deeds....)

Seemed to be a lot more interested in asking a list of nosy, intrusive questions than either a) a serious physical health condition I have that could impact the birth, or b) my medication allergies.

I'm just trying to work out in what other medical scenario this would be appropriate...

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 26/03/2022 08:08

My parents left school with no formal qualifications - they've been the best and most loving parents a child could wish for. My cousins dad had a degree and ran his own company - didn't stop him from hitting her mum.
Now I know you are going to say plural of anecdote isn't data but if these questions are being asked to individuals on the grounds that they can target said individuals for additional help, then maybe the wrong questions are being asked.

ImAvingOops · 26/03/2022 08:04

Agreeed are you saying that if you can't afford to opt out, then you aren't entitled to tact and politeness from your HCP? That you aren't entitled to give informed consent?
And if these questions are so bloody important, being rich shouldn't exempt you from answering them. There are plenty of wealthy women in domestically violent relationships - money, or lack of it, isn't always a key factor in why a woman doesn't leave these relationships. Rich people can abuse kids too - having a degree doesn't = better life.

Annette objecting to the approach used by these HCP really isn't about being the sort of women the HCP are attempting to target - that's a lazy and reductive pov. I did not meet any of their 'red flag' situations. However the approach from my hv made me feel judged in my own home and really uncomfortable, at a time when my hormones were all over the place. The stupid woman could have actually triggered PND with her clunky questioning and general rudeness. I'd never have another hv based on that experience. So they are, in effect, causing the opposite of what they want by being so bad at their jobs.

Another thing to keep in mind is that seeing a hv is a service offered, not an obligation. If you were married to an abuser he'd probably just stop you seeing one. Since it isn't obligatory what could social services do - they aren't going to swoop in and investigate a family turning down something they aren't obliged to use, since plenty of people don't need a hv for a variety of reasons, that don't have anything to do with hiding worrisome behaviour.

EishetChayil · 26/03/2022 07:49

What has having a degree got to do with raising a child and being a good parent. What do they take from it if you say you haven’t got any qualifications. Are they going to pass your details on to the local college for some free courses so you can get a degree or does it mean they will look at you and raise a red flag that you are not qualified to look after a child.

Can you honestly not see the potentially very different needs between a degree-educated professional and a woman who left school with three GCSEs? It isn't a value judgment. It's just fact.

Annette32123 · 26/03/2022 07:40

@Phineyj

I actually tried the 'pay for it yourself and avoid it' option in desperation, as my local trust kept appearing on lists of worst maternity providers in the UK, the local papers were full of horror stories and the way they handled the prenatal appointments was threatening my job. It's not actually possible to opt out unless you've got squillions. The NHS dominates the whole of the system.
It does. And sadly most of the UK population cannot grasp how exceptional the NHS is and are determined to moan and moan until it is destroyed.

When it’s gone, nobody will complain about council tax bills any more - medical insurance costs will dwarf that. At the moment the NHS subsidises everything including supposedly ‘private’ healthcare. The moment anything goes wrong or patients become seriously unwell in the private sector they can be (and are) transferred into NHS hospitals where the expensive part is picked up by the taxpayer.

Pregnant women and their children are at huge risk of abuse by the men in the mothers life. It is the job of those caring for her to at least attempt to detect those at highest risk and provide them with information that might save their or their children’s lives. Many of the women at risk do not believe they are at risk. Asking women if there are any issues won’t reveal much because more are either in denial or genuinely can’t see the situation they are in for what it is. But there is plenty of data from many many previous women that tells midwives what the red flags are and they ask questions to get to that information. If you are so sure you aren’t at risk then just answer the questions and move on.

However methinks the ladies doth protest too much here and so I imagine many who are railing against the system are the very people the midwives are trying to identify; the women who are in denial or cannot acknowledge their situation despite clear red flags.

Dinoteeth · 26/03/2022 07:22

Not sure on the degree question but they'll be some logic, probably something to do with not being in poverty. Your ability to be independent and raise the baby.
The same reasons lots of employers want people with degrees but aren't fussed what the degree is in.

Those questions are all about looking out for the baby potentially 'at risk'. Some baby's are never allowed to go home with the mother.

The booking appointment is at 3 mths, so 6 mths to go, if the mother is in a violent relationship and flags are waved at that appointment it gives time to try and get mother out of that relationship.

The home owner question is probably related to if you own its a different set of issues to being able to walk away from a dodgy relationship in a rental.

Phineyj · 26/03/2022 07:19

I actually tried the 'pay for it yourself and avoid it' option in desperation, as my local trust kept appearing on lists of worst maternity providers in the UK, the local papers were full of horror stories and the way they handled the prenatal appointments was threatening my job. It's not actually possible to opt out unless you've got squillions. The NHS dominates the whole of the system.

Kennykenkencat · 26/03/2022 01:57

Whilst many on here are putting the argument that identifying issues helps to refer the woman on to get help.
And whilst I haven’t RTWT what I have read. Is some have said that it helped them when they have asked for help, but more have said there wasn’t any help.

I think there does need to be some acknowledgment that the questions themselves put peoples backs up and are quite condescending to some and to others who might need help if it was available could see the questions as saying you aren’t suitable to have a child and then are not giving honest answers because they fear being judged or getting SS involvement.

What has having a degree got to do with raising a child and being a good parent. What do they take from it if you say you haven’t got any qualifications. Are they going to pass your details on to the local college for some free courses so you can get a degree or does it mean they will look at you and raise a red flag that you are not qualified to look after a child.

RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 00:57

But the problem is CWB that many HCPs don't twig the cues. There's a huge difference between a 17 year old young woman wearing no rings, whose next of kin is her mother, and clearly cannot be post graduate or professionally qualified and a professional woman in her mid 30s, who reports two previous miscarriages and whose next of kin is her husband. It doesn't take a lot of nouse to quickly weigh up and adjust tone so it is sensitive to different people with different circumstances. Isn't that something that post graduate professionals should be capable of?

NumberTheory · 26/03/2022 00:56

@Agreeeeed

Also, if nhs care is so rude and intrusive, And you don’t like the quick questions they use to filter out those in need, then there is always the option to pay for yourself and avoid it.

Asking have you any housing difficulties may not prompt some people to identify they don’t have stable accommodation.
The questions have to be clear and not open to misinterpretations.
Going through every possiblity is more time consuming. Which as I’ve said nhs practitioners don’t have.
Again brings me back to my point if you don’t like the care provided you can refuse to answer.
Or pay private.
But don’t suggest these questions should be removed, when there are women and babies who rely on their circumstances being picked up by a time poor hcp.

It’s pretty telling how judgmental the whole system is if there is no obligation on private providers to do this. You only have to put up with being “safeguarded” if you aren’t prepared to shell out again to go private.
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 26/03/2022 00:34

I think your way of wording things are more likely to make women in precisely the situations they need to know about, clam up more, out of embarrassment and possibly shame. Asking in the way that has clearly got your back up might be a way to open the conversation.

Imagine a 17 year old being asked if they rent or own - no, I live with my mum. Are you in a long-term relationship - sort of, my boyfriend and I have been together for a year. What's your boyfriend's DOB - he turns 45 this year.

I think YABU and need some perspective. You're coming at this from the privilege of a woman who has a stable relationship, stable housing, stable employment and everything else.

RosesAndHellebores · 25/03/2022 23:46

@Agreeeeed certainly people can chose to pay privately, which actually means they pay twice. They have already paid the NHS which is free only at the point of delivery and is funded by the people for the people. There is as yet no tax rebate on private healthcare payments and neither can one opt out of the NHS.

All too often those who run the NHS seem to forget it is not free and expect all its users to be grateful supplicants for care which is all too often suboptimal.

Agreeeeed · 25/03/2022 23:00

Also, if nhs care is so rude and intrusive,
And you don’t like the quick questions they use to filter out those in need, then there is always the option to pay for yourself and avoid it.

Asking have you any housing difficulties may not prompt some people to identify they don’t have stable accommodation.
The questions have to be clear and not open to misinterpretations.
Going through every possiblity is more time consuming. Which as I’ve said nhs practitioners don’t have.
Again brings me back to my point if you don’t like the care provided you can refuse to answer.
Or pay private.
But don’t suggest these questions should be removed, when there are women and babies who rely on their circumstances being picked up by a time poor hcp.

chattycaterpillar · 25/03/2022 22:50

Just to clarify some points:

  1. I didn't have any personal problem with the midwife and I wasn't trying to find fault. I understand that she was reading through a set list of, ( rude and intrusive !) questions, and it would have been the same whoever asked/ whatever midwife was allocated.

  2. If some of the questions, ( e.g. degree status), were part of a public health survey, then they should ask consent for you to voluntarily answer questions for a public health survey. I'd have probably happily said yes and assisted, but, you shouldn't really survey people for public health research without their informed consent.

  3. I think it would be a courtesy and put vulnerable people at ease if they asked what they meant to ask/ explained the "support" on offer, ( although my friend, who was struggling in difficult social circumstances), was adamant that any actual practical, useful or meaningful support was not offered ).

E.G " Do you have a degree ?" is going to put people's backs up/ make them feel judged. Why not ask, " We can provide extra support with reading documents related to the pregnancy if you have difficulties with reading. Do you have dyslexia or other associated difficulties that would mean you'd like to take us up on that ?"

Instead of do you rent or own, " are there any housing difficulties, e.g. overcrowding, accom. in disrepair you'd like us to refer you to Citizen's Advice for Housing support for ? Local council's have a legal duty to provide suitable accom.for pregnant women and their babies, so if homelessness is an issue, do you need the contact details for housing options ?"

Surely that might put people more at ease....clearly transparency and explaining clearly and honestly why you are asking might make people feel more at ease.

And I definitely do not lead a charmed life. I have my own issues, ( BMI of 28 so in the overweight category, worried about having to disclose previous antidepressant use), and I can assure stuff like this does make you feel judged.

OP posts:
Agreeeeed · 25/03/2022 22:50

People on this thread have explained why information is sought.
If a midwife was to say, we ask these questions because some people, sadly, aren’t in a position in life where they are stable, and they and their babies are at risk of harm and abuse, would this change things? Would it encourage people to speak up? Would it calm the moaners and whiners about having to say their partners name dob and whether they have stable accommodation?

Probably not.

Is there anything stopping you asking if you want to know why a question is asked? Absolutely not.
And you can always refuse to answer.

But when children have lost their lives and lack of professional curiosity has been blamed as a contributing factor, I can’t understand why anyone objects.
Even if you personally have had unhelpful experiences, it’s not actually about you (even though I’m sorry for people who had bad experiences). It’s about new born babies and vulnerable new mums who may need help and if asking questions like this helps identify people why complain?

BoredZelda · 25/03/2022 22:42

Covid has led to many more women dying from domestic abuse than pre-covid.

How many more?

Because according to the ONS the number in England and Wales was the same for Apr19 to mar 20 as it was from Apr 20 to Mar 21. And the number was lower in Scotland for last year than the year before. I know it’s common to want to pretend there we’re all these ills that came from lockdown, but statistics don’t bear that out.

RosesAndHellebores · 25/03/2022 22:22

Indeed ImAving and mine were born almost 28 years ago. Even then the staff never stopped complaining about how overworked they were. Even when there were more midwives on the post-natal ward tha mothers.

ImAvingOops · 25/03/2022 22:03

Agreeeed I've had 4 children. My experience of tactless and rude midwives and health visitors isn't a one off either.
While I'd agree that these services desperately need more money, it doesn't actually cost a penny to be tactful or to explain why certain information is sought.

NumberTheory · 25/03/2022 21:08

@Papayamya

If it's recorded on your notes it's bound by the same data protection requirements as any other information contained within them, if you're really arsed you could also ask the hospital to explain why.

Some of the information you answer also gets recorded on your child's notes and so it's not treated the same as most information you give to your HCPs.

Only the other day we had the announcement that BPAS had had to advocate for mothers to stop the NHS from instituting policy to routinely record information on how much alcohol a woman says she drinks on her child's medical record. It can still be recorded there, as is other information on the mother, it just won't be routine. Information on medical records, especially children's, gets shared far and wide in some circumstances.

And the NHS's record on privacy and anonymized data and cyber security is far from pristine. In 2018, more than 6 months after the WannaCry attack brought parts of the NHS to its knees, not a single NHS trust passed NHS Digital's cyber security check.

And it isn't all in the past. There were publicised breaches during COVID testing and just 5 weeks ago: Massive NHS patient data breach.

LabelMaker · 25/03/2022 21:06

@RosesAndHellebores

As I've said before there is no point asking anything if they don't listen. At my first post natal visit the community midwife said to me oh lots of support with your parents downstairs. She asked three times and three times I said "no they aren't my parents, they are our neighbours who have popped in to see the baby". When Inlooked at my record she had written lots of support, parents downstairs.

She was so concerned about my physical well being and relationship with my husband that she wanted to discuss pelvic floor exercises and my sex life. When I said I didn't wish to discuss either with a stranger she took her left elbow in her right hand and waved her left hand back and forth telling me that "if I didn't do the pelvic floor exercises that's what sex would feel like for my husband". Not too much concern about women's rights there. I thought "no" was a refusal of consent - one would think a midwife would understand that wouldn't you. My midwife didn't understand no; my husband did and does.

I wonder how much she would have supported a vulnerable mother.
1994.

That sounds awful. Hopefully now 18 years has passed standards have improved but I am sorry you went through that.
RosesAndHellebores · 25/03/2022 20:58

It wasn't my one experience, it was my experience time and time again. Based on my experiences of midwives and health visitors they are the last people on earth I would trust with the wellbeing of my children. Grown up now. Most of them when I asked a question, said they didn't know or weren't an expert.

Agreeeeed · 25/03/2022 20:36

Because I don't want to use the safeguarding services of NHS maternity care. In the same way that some women choose to have unassisted births or choose not to use all of the maternity services offered. I don't know if it would be flagged if you choose not to answer questions - possibly. I don't know fully about how safeguarding in schools works and whether you have to inform the school of your occupation in the same way that you do when registering a birth. I do think we are too reliant on schools to deal with social issues.

^^ I don’t think you understand how safeguarding works.
The questions are screening questions.
From them If a risk is identified then safeguarding processes may be followed.

So by asking everyone they attempt to screen out mums, babies and families at risk.

As far as I’m concerned anyone who objects to these processes, either doesn’t understand how many lives they may save. Or doesn’t think that children and vulnerable people are worth hcps bothering about and trying to identify them and protect them from abuse.

I know some of the questions may seem intrusive but why would anyone whinge and complain about it? if your life is perfectly fine that’s great, but by agreeing to the process it helps midwives screen out the women and babies who may lose their life.
I don’t know what kind of person objects to checks on the most vulnerable in society.

Appreciate all of the people who had hcps that maybe didn’t listen. And that’s not acceptable.
But that was your one experience and it is not a rationale for these questions not to be asked.
If anything it’s a rationale to encourage more vigilance for slap dash staff that don’t listen. And for the government to invest more money, so staff that are overwhelmed and harrassed with their workload can actually spot signs, take on board what their patients are saying and action things.

nitsandwormsdodger · 25/03/2022 20:17

A good % of my students had parents who were blood relatives
Marrying your cousin or second cousin is not unusual there were leaflets in school to spot sighs of diseases that were more common in those communities

RosesAndHellebores · 25/03/2022 20:17

As I've said before there is no point asking anything if they don't listen. At my first post natal visit the community midwife said to me oh lots of support with your parents downstairs. She asked three times and three times I said "no they aren't my parents, they are our neighbours who have popped in to see the baby". When Inlooked at my record she had written lots of support, parents downstairs.

She was so concerned about my physical well being and relationship with my husband that she wanted to discuss pelvic floor exercises and my sex life. When I said I didn't wish to discuss either with a stranger she took her left elbow in her right hand and waved her left hand back and forth telling me that "if I didn't do the pelvic floor exercises that's what sex would feel like for my husband". Not too much concern about women's rights there. I thought "no" was a refusal of consent - one would think a midwife would understand that wouldn't you. My midwife didn't understand no; my husband did and does.

I wonder how much she would have supported a vulnerable mother.
1994.

PurplePansy05 · 25/03/2022 20:13

@SpinningTheSeedsOfLove Which is what good midwives do. If you haven't had that experience then it's regrettable, there are many reasons for this, some not easily solved atm.

T1mumtobe · 25/03/2022 20:11

@OnceuponaRainbow18

Mine asked me if I smoked, I said no. Then they asked me to do a carbon monoxide test!
The carbon monoxide test can also indicate whether you are exposed to a gas leak at home or high levels of pollution where you live or work.
Swipe left for the next trending thread