Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this pissed me off about my booking appointment ?

555 replies

chattycaterpillar · 24/03/2022 22:18

I had a pregnancy booking appointment recently, and was talking to a friend about this yesterday, and she agreed this equally pissed her off about her's too, ( she had hers 12 months ago in the same NHS trust).

The actual medical questions were almost skimmed over, ( I wasn't asked if I had any medication allergies, even though I have a serious allergy to doxycycline). But the amount of nosy, social questions asked to "judge," your suitability to parent was ridiculous.

Examples on the proforma list included:

  • How long have you been with your partner ? ( Yes, it is a long-term relationship so wasn't an issue for me, but my friend's child was conceived after a short fling and she didn't want to be answering exactly how long it was).
  • What is your highest level qualification/ are you educated to degree level ? ( I'm educated to degree level, but interested in the medical relevance of this. Imagine getting asked that at any other medical appointment ...)
  • Are you employed ? Is it full time work, what do you do for work ? What does your partner do for work ? ( Why on earth is it medically relevant what my partner does as his job ? )
  • Does your partner have any other children ? ( No, but again, not medically relevant...)
  • Do you own or rent your property ? ( Why, do you want to take a look at my mortgage deeds....)

Seemed to be a lot more interested in asking a list of nosy, intrusive questions than either a) a serious physical health condition I have that could impact the birth, or b) my medication allergies.

I'm just trying to work out in what other medical scenario this would be appropriate...

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 11:06

Apologies for typos, typing quickly on phone - how I would love MN to introduce an edit button).

RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 11:01

Where would that have put me then? Dropped out of uni after a term, did a secretarial course then spent a year in Europe. By 20 I had a job in the City, by 26 I was selling Eurobonds, and earning large sums of money. Burnt out at 34 but hardly one of life's failures. My professional qualifications came later when my DC started school and I started carving my 2nd career.

Further I suspect I have mild ADHD and dd was diagnosed aged 17 with ADD variant (never picked up because she was always high performing) after a hellish 18 months of depression, anxiety and self harm for which there was no support whatsoever on the NHS. She got a diagnosis and got well again because we could afford to pay privately via a combination of BUPA and our funds for the bit BUPA didn't cover (more than £500 on therapy and anything linked to neuro diversity). DD graduated from Cambridge this summer with a very high 2:1 presently working as a TA in a school for autistic and ADHD young people, considering whether to do a masters in speech therapy first or a PGCE or vice versa. 30 years ago she would have been under no pressure whatsoever to go to university or get high grades and wouldn't have felt a failure for never feeling she had reached her potential.

In a world where HE is contracting and apprenticeship routes growing there's a great deal of catch up required. 28 years ago when my first was born University for my generation (the boomers - a group much abused on MNet because they had all the "wins") was not the norm. There still is a vast gap between well educated and well qualified and sadly many well qualified people today are not at all well educated.

A generation before us, MIL went to teacher training college, mother to the Royal Ballet School. Neither degree educated. Was that a big red flag - because neither had a degree? Of course not. Both however were in stable employment and had husband's who were too. A far better signifier and whilst I accept their are outliers who abuse from professional/wealthy families if one looked at the proportion of women affected by domestic abuse and compared it to the proportion affected in demographically lower social groups I am sure there is evidence to say it is vanishingly insignificant.

I do recall a professional family with several disabled twins whose mother killed them. The pressures were such that she had become mentally unwell. In Wandsworth she got enough NHS and social care to cope; when the family moved to Kingston the support vanished because there were lower provisions. That family were known to the NHS and other agencies for legitimate reasons - the state knew the support needed and didn't provide it. It couldn't have been more obvious.

If the state fails people in those circumstances (as in a far more miniscule way it failed my dd) then I have less than zero time for intrusive and too often exceptionally rude comme to, combined with subordination the mother who is a key and equal stakeholder. A little common sense and sensitivity wouldn't go amiss.

flipflopjump · 26/03/2022 10:56

It's very disheartening to think that so many of my patients might believe I am asking them these kind of questions just because I'm nosy.

If you want to know why I am asking a particular question, just ask me and I'll explain. Because there will be a reason.

Kennykenkencat · 26/03/2022 10:51

@Elisheva

It isn’t that the mother is just thick or preferred to go out and party rather than study to gain a degree I don’t think that anybody is saying it is? The OP wanted to know why the midwife asked about her level of education, and I am explaining that there is a correlation between maternal education and different outcomes for the child. Educational outcomes may not be as relevant for a midwife, but likelihood of a low birthweight, good maternal diet, and things like use of alcohol/smoking are. It’s just an indicator of things that the midwife might need to be aware of.
Then ask about smoking, alcohol, diet because having a degree doesn’t automatically mean women know about folic acid, drinking and smoking during pregnancy. It isn’t automatically the ones that aren’t degree educated who are the walking red flag. I know someone who both her and her Dh by these questions would have looked perfectly good parents. Both degree educated, their own home, good careers. An informal conversation would have shown the cracks with a multitude of red flags sticking through. These are the people being missed.
FourLittleStars · 26/03/2022 10:30

@Kennykenkencat

FourLittleStars Being functionally illiterate doesn’t mean you don’t want to know how to do things.

Not everything is written down to wade through if you struggle with literacy

YouTube etc can be referred to if you don’t know stuff or just want to see what alternative ways there are of doing anything.

I failed Functional English but can still read and write and have a wide knowledge of a variety of random stuff. I know I struggle with a lot of written instructions sometimes so when I get to a bit where I just don’t get then YouTube/Pinterest etc does help
Ds has struggled and failed to get an. English qualification and only has one GCSE
In the past year he has gained an almost encyclopaedic knowledge of camper van prices and how to renovate the interior
Learned Spanish for 14 hours per day for 6 weeks
Learned about Bitcoin and stock trading and had now decided to try forex and currency trading which he is finding complicated.
Learned how to build a computer and done a stint as a manager of a large carpark

Just because you struggle academically and have a learning difficulty doesn’t mean that you don’t have a thirst for knowledge.

Not wanting to learn new things isn’t the preserve of those who are functionally illiterate. I have come across many many highly educated people who have not a clue about anything outside their own lives.

Of course it doesn't. But I'm talking about my DHs family. Who are all low level education, with absolutely no thirst for knowledge or desire to learn anything past what they need.

Same for the area I grew up in. Multi generational poverty and deprivation. School was an authority figure to be tolerated until you could leave, social services were evil and to be feared, don't engage with anything beyond the bare minimum so you don't get reported.

Struggling with how schools teach and expect you to learn and perform is no indicator of intelligence. But if you've grown up with no support in learning or education at home, then it's harder. I had an ex who went to sixth form and his dad would actively put him down "you think you're so fucking clever, college boy, don't think I'm paying your bus fare" because he was so insecure about his own level of education, he was frightened that his son would think he was better than him if he educated himself.

hugr · 26/03/2022 10:29

Haven't read the full thread but have seen a few people speculate why the degree question is there. It's because lower educational level is a risk factor for poor pregnancy and birth outcomes.

Twizbe · 26/03/2022 10:24

If those questions bother you, be glad you didn't need fertility treatment. Then you need to complete a welfare of the child form.

toomuchlaundry · 26/03/2022 10:24

If you have depression, why do you think you just need to get over it. That isn’t usually how depression works.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 26/03/2022 10:23

What should be happening is that the MW is treating/looking after the person in front of them.
Adding some layers of ‘this person is educated/not educated therefore will require more/less support’ is a lazy way of looking after patients. It stops them from seeing the person in front of them and concentrate only on ‘red flags’ that might or might not be relevant to that particular woman.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 26/03/2022 10:21

@Elisheva

The mother’s education level is the biggest predictor of a child’s educational success. It also has an measurable impact on a child’s cognitive skills, health and well-being. For example, children whose mothers have a low education level are more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD.
But that has no relation with the pregnancy itself. That would be good information for a HV, sure start centre (so they still even exist?) etc…

I also think it creates a blind spot when it comes to new mums.
I had bad PND and I’d say I was actually a risk to my baby at one point. But neither the GP nor the HV made any effort around that. I’m well educated, intelligent whatever so I suspect they all assumed I would do the right thing because I had all the knowledge. This was wrong.
I had no idea what PND was. I learnt about it months after. I didn’t dare asking for more help out of fear that my baby would be taken away (Yep very similar ideas than some so called less educated women could have). I had no support around me, Incl DH. Because despite being degree educated, he also had no idea what PND was. And the word depression just made think i needed to just get over it.
And you know what? The same thing happened again when I had AND with my second…. Same doctor, same reaction and no support what so ever.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 26/03/2022 10:18

If the reason the father doesn't see his other children is because he's abusive then it's very relevant

Elisheva · 26/03/2022 10:16

I failed Functional English
Ds has struggled and failed to get an English qualification and only has one GCSE

I’m not saying I necessarily agree with the questions, the OP said that she doesn’t see the relevance, I’m just pointing out how the question could possibly be relevant.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 26/03/2022 10:12

but likelihood of a low birthweight, good maternal diet, and things like use of alcohol/smoking are.

In that case you ask about alcohol use, diet etc… not of the person is degree educated.
It just smacks of uneducated people are thick and will do stupid things whereas degree educated women are sensible and unlikely to harm their child.
Right oh… that might actually be the best way to miss problems just because mum is well educated…..

Oblomov22 · 26/03/2022 09:58

Bet we'd get red flagged if we refused to answer. I really resent being asked such questions and want to tell them to bog off.

ImAvingOops · 26/03/2022 09:55

Asking about smoking, drinking, diet is completely reasonable. These are health questions which have a direct impact on that particular woman and her baby. Whether she owns a dishwasher, not so much.

Kennykenkencat · 26/03/2022 09:54

FourLittleStars
Being functionally illiterate doesn’t mean you don’t want to know how to do things.

Not everything is written down to wade through if you struggle with literacy

YouTube etc can be referred to if you don’t know stuff or just want to see what alternative ways there are of doing anything.

I failed Functional English but can still read and write and have a wide knowledge of a variety of random stuff. I know I struggle with a lot of written instructions sometimes so when I get to a bit where I just don’t get then YouTube/Pinterest etc does help
Ds has struggled and failed to get an. English qualification and only has one GCSE
In the past year he has gained an almost encyclopaedic knowledge of camper van prices and how to renovate the interior
Learned Spanish for 14 hours per day for 6 weeks
Learned about Bitcoin and stock trading and had now decided to try forex and currency trading which he is finding complicated.
Learned how to build a computer and done a stint as a manager of a large carpark

Just because you struggle academically and have a learning difficulty doesn’t mean that you don’t have a thirst for knowledge.

Not wanting to learn new things isn’t the preserve of those who are functionally illiterate. I have come across many many highly educated people who have not a clue about anything outside their own lives.

Elisheva · 26/03/2022 09:45

It isn’t that the mother is just thick or preferred to go out and party rather than study to gain a degree
I don’t think that anybody is saying it is?
The OP wanted to know why the midwife asked about her level of education, and I am explaining that there is a correlation between maternal education and different outcomes for the child.
Educational outcomes may not be as relevant for a midwife, but likelihood of a low birthweight, good maternal diet, and things like use of alcohol/smoking are.
It’s just an indicator of things that the midwife might need to be aware of.

Kennykenkencat · 26/03/2022 09:08

@Elisheva

The mother’s education level is the biggest predictor of a child’s educational success. It also has an measurable impact on a child’s cognitive skills, health and well-being. For example, children whose mothers have a low education level are more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD.
This is exactly what I mean. You actually think that for every academically low achieving mother that gets flagged there is an ADHD test for their child..

Take a look on the SEN board and you will find getting a test for dyslexia/dysgraphia/ADHD etc either needs a NT mother with a degree or to be very very lucky that they come across a teacher who knows the signs and the school are willing to refer them to be tested

You do realise that the reason behind ADHD in most cases is genetic.
It isn’t that the mother is just thick or preferred to go out and party rather than study to gain a degree but more to do with the fact the mother also has undiagnosed ADHD/dyslexia etc themselves and their mother was the same etc etc

I was diagnosed last year with ADHD. Looking back I see ADHD in every generation of my family. Even the ones who were dead long before I was born but were spoken about frequently

FourLittleStars · 26/03/2022 08:55

The asking about education level might seem weird or intrusive, but literacy levels vary so hugely.

My dh (early 40s) left school at 14 or so with no qualifications and is, at best, functionally literate. He has friends who cannot read and write. Most of his family have the same level of education. They can navigate Facebook but wouldn't research anything beyond that. If he was a pregnant woman, he'd have relied on his family's advice about baby rearing, safe sleep, weaning etc, which would have been out of date and probably dangerous.

The general consensus is "mum knows best", even when that involves a child not strapped into a car seat properly, cot bumpers and teddies in with a newborn to sleep, put down on the front, and personalised dummy cords bought off ebay that are basically a fancy noose.

Offering £400 NCT classes would be daft, pamphlets would be pointless, but a couple of free sessions in the hospital or at a sure start would suit and not be stressful.

My cousin was flagged up as being a DV victim and received extra HV care. She wasn't signed off until her partner had decided that crying babies weren't his thing and moved out at about 7w PP.

I know a lady who is married to her first cousin and has buried five of her babies as a result of a genetic mutation.

Just because something doesn't pertain to you personally, doesn't mean It not useful.

ThinWomansBrain · 26/03/2022 08:55

@chattycaterpillar

Oh and they also wanted to know my partner's date of birth. Why ?! I've been for surgery before under anesthetic and they've never asked that. My partner and I are the same age, (29), but my friend sad it's for them to have a nosy at unsuitable age gaps.....but if i'd have said my partner was 60, what would they actually be able to do ?!
aren't some medical conditions higher risk for children of geriatric parents?
ImAvingOops · 26/03/2022 08:49

If you are educated, then you value education and want that for your own children. It's your 'norm'.
Equally, if you are not educated but are intelligent, then you also want a good education for your children, since education offers opportunities. It might be that you don't have the means to access it though.

Education tends to equal more money, so I'm not surprised that it results in better wellbeing. It's the difference between being able to buy good food or supplement your child's education with private tuition and not.
And I'd assume that educated women are in careers rather than jobs and therefore have fewer children, since children do disturb career progression and good childcare is expensive.
Being a good parent is about attitude and prioritising your children's needs with the money you have. I'm not totally convinced these questions identify attitude, only financial status. I think they need refining, personally.

Elisheva · 26/03/2022 08:46

Yes, maternal education is a really important indicator of loads of things. A mother with poor education is more likely to have a baby with a low birth-weight for example.
It is only an indicator or course, but it’s one of the really important questions that a midwife asks.

Dinoteeth · 26/03/2022 08:33

@Elisheva wow I didn't know that.

I knew mother's education level played a part in reducing the number of children she would have on average. The higher educated the less children.

Elisheva · 26/03/2022 08:29

The mother’s education level is the biggest predictor of a child’s educational success. It also has an measurable impact on a child’s cognitive skills, health and well-being. For example, children whose mothers have a low education level are more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD.

Agreeeeed · 26/03/2022 08:21

I think I’ve been more than clear with my point of view. I know how important the questions are.
That’s why I think that they should be asked.
If people don’t want to answer then they can pay privately.
Or they can tell their midwife they refuse to answer.
That’s my view.
And I totally agree that rich women are at risk too. But if they want to pay and go private or if some people want to refuse to answer them that is up to them.
What I find distasteful is adult women moaning ans whinging about questions that are there to identify the most vulnerable. They are there to build a full picture.
Of course one question alone about qualifications or housing alone won’t indicate someone is vulnerable. Like that same question won’t confirm they will be a good parent. But knowing information about someone helps build a picture that may indicate they need more support.

What I disagree with is people moaning about questions that can help other people.
Your options are answer and accept that even if it won’t help you it helps them identify people who are at risk - which may be you. Perhaps you don’t recognise the signs yourself
Tell your midwife you don’t want to answer.
Or go private.

As for the tact and politeness, my midwife was always polite even if usually running late. She always apologised for it.
If she wasn’t polite I wouldn’t have raised that as a seperate issue.
Not moaned about being asked questions that as I have repeatedly said save lives.