Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this pissed me off about my booking appointment ?

555 replies

chattycaterpillar · 24/03/2022 22:18

I had a pregnancy booking appointment recently, and was talking to a friend about this yesterday, and she agreed this equally pissed her off about her's too, ( she had hers 12 months ago in the same NHS trust).

The actual medical questions were almost skimmed over, ( I wasn't asked if I had any medication allergies, even though I have a serious allergy to doxycycline). But the amount of nosy, social questions asked to "judge," your suitability to parent was ridiculous.

Examples on the proforma list included:

  • How long have you been with your partner ? ( Yes, it is a long-term relationship so wasn't an issue for me, but my friend's child was conceived after a short fling and she didn't want to be answering exactly how long it was).
  • What is your highest level qualification/ are you educated to degree level ? ( I'm educated to degree level, but interested in the medical relevance of this. Imagine getting asked that at any other medical appointment ...)
  • Are you employed ? Is it full time work, what do you do for work ? What does your partner do for work ? ( Why on earth is it medically relevant what my partner does as his job ? )
  • Does your partner have any other children ? ( No, but again, not medically relevant...)
  • Do you own or rent your property ? ( Why, do you want to take a look at my mortgage deeds....)

Seemed to be a lot more interested in asking a list of nosy, intrusive questions than either a) a serious physical health condition I have that could impact the birth, or b) my medication allergies.

I'm just trying to work out in what other medical scenario this would be appropriate...

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 26/03/2022 14:41

@flipflopjump

I have a job to do. Sometimes this means asking questions a patient will be offended by. As a professional I don't get to skip questions because I assume they are unnecessary for that patient or because I won't like the answer or think they might annoy the patient. I am not there to judge, I am there to provide appropriate care and I need information to do so.

At a National level education levels are known to be correlated with outcomes. We wouldn't know this, or be able to take steps to improve standards, if we didn't collect this data. At an individual level it's a really helpful shortcut to know what level to start pitching information at. I'll then adapt my approach as I go along to suit that patient.

As others have said, a question that may feel irrelevant or intrusive to some, may improve care for others or even save their life.

At the end of day if you are unhappy about what you are being asked tell the person doing the asking or speak to their superior.

If the education question were needed so you could pitch information properly it would be needed in virtually all care settings.

The education question is asked for the sake of researchers, which many women would be fine with. But they are being made research subjects without their consent and at a time when they reasonably expect things to be more focused on their individual needs not the State’s.

Twizbe · 26/03/2022 14:37

@chattycaterpillar you seem to not be hearing what people are saying.

All those questions together draw a picture of who you are and the risks (if any) surrounding your pregnancy.

For my first I was a 32 year old with a masters degree, owned my own home outright in a stable relationship with the baby's father. Our baby was planned and he was supportive of the pregnancy. Neither of us had had any social service support previously - I was low risk for DV or additional support - great. My care focused on health, which I was low risk for too.

That's very different to a 17 year old woman with little formal education, in an unstable relationship currently sofa surfing.

The medical pathway wouldn't change because of these factors, but the 17 year old might be referred to a youth midwife or to the HV team earlier than me so that support can be put in place to give the baby the best start.

I saw your previous posts about disclosing past MH issues and weight and you seem to really fear that the midwives will judge you. They won't.

GreenBlueRedYellow · 26/03/2022 14:35

[quote Blueeyedgirl21]@RosesAndHellebores why are you so obsessed with introducing yourself as ‘Mrs’? It’s cringeworthy are you just dead proud someone agreed to marry you or what??[/quote]
Because that is how she wishes to be addressed, so why shouldn't she be addressed as such ? Other people insist on being addressed in all sorts of diifferent ways and their needs are usually respected.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 26/03/2022 14:31

@RosesAndHellebores why are you so obsessed with introducing yourself as ‘Mrs’? It’s cringeworthy are you just dead proud someone agreed to marry you or what??

flipflopjump · 26/03/2022 14:29

I have never knowing treated any patient disrespectfully. If you have been treated badly, please do complain.

RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 14:18

Well then @flipflopjump if you have to ask questions you know may offend, that is precisely why I introduce myself to HCPs as Mrs Hellebores. Two reasons, firstly it means at the very least you may address me with a modicum of respect whilst asking questions you know may cause offence and keep the relationship professional and boundaried, secondly as all the midwives I met referred to the Consultant as Mr Bloggs, Miss Jones, etc, you may address me as though I am equal to every other stakeholder in my care. I was left with that stance after ds1's birth and the appalling care, both clinical and social that I received from midwives.

FWIW whenever I ask a nurse further questions they usually say "I don't know, you'd have to ask my supervisor, the senior sister or a Dr." It's far better use of my time to go straight to the organ grinder.

flipflopjump · 26/03/2022 14:10

I have a job to do. Sometimes this means asking questions a patient will be offended by. As a professional I don't get to skip questions because I assume they are unnecessary for that patient or because I won't like the answer or think they might annoy the patient. I am not there to judge, I am there to provide appropriate care and I need information to do so.

At a National level education levels are known to be correlated with outcomes. We wouldn't know this, or be able to take steps to improve standards, if we didn't collect this data. At an individual level it's a really helpful shortcut to know what level to start pitching information at. I'll then adapt my approach as I go along to suit that patient.

As others have said, a question that may feel irrelevant or intrusive to some, may improve care for others or even save their life.

At the end of day if you are unhappy about what you are being asked tell the person doing the asking or speak to their superior.

Dryshampooandcoffee · 26/03/2022 14:01

I know in our trust the education question is asked ‘at what age did you finish full time education’ it plays a part in picking up those people who are unable to read, and therefore we would provide information in a different way/format. I do remember your post worrying about telling the midwife about your previous use of antidepressants and having to be measured and weighed. Everyone tried to reassure you that neither of these things would be raised as an issue. I think you can probably rest easy that the midwife isn’t out to get you, rather they want to support you through this journey to motherhood!

RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 13:42

Because if they can't competently perform the clinical aspects of their job, they are hardly likely to be able to form social judgements in relation to red flags and shoukd not be trusted to do so.

As most women have shared care with GPs presumably that's where an holistic relationship is likely to be formed in relation to social support. Not with a midwife a woman may see sporadically over 6 or 7 months.

Papayamya · 26/03/2022 13:28

[quote RosesAndHellebores]@Kennykenkencat - thank you, not something I was aware of.

@flipflopjump to be honest, whenever I saw a midwife I wanted appropriate clinical care tailored to my clinical history, not social care of any sort. It was very disappointing that so often the former wasn't forthcoming.

Examples: pg with ds1 after two late miscarriages in my mid thirties both noted in the referral letter "is it a planned pregnancy?".

Total lack of attention regarding thyroid disease and failure to ensure TSH was monitored- not once but three times.

In early labour with DS failure to diagnose a posterior baby.

Later in labour administered pethidine without my consent.

Even later when I had an epidural said she was going for a sandwich and told my husband to do the same. The heartbeat disappeared and I couldn't reach the alarm button because I had an epidural and shouldn't have been left alone.

She hoisted the belt up and said "oh no worries the belt slipped must be a bit faulty. The third time that happened dh opened the door and yelled "I want a Dr in her right now.

Senior midwife appeared took one look and hit the red button. The room filled - the baby had the cord tightly wrapped around his neck. He was too far out for a section and they cut the cord whilst he was still in the vaginal canal - I was given one more push to get the baby out whilst the registrar got a forceps delivery ready.

I managed to push hard enough for the baby to be born - he was bright blue and took minutes to resuscitate and spent the first night in special care. I had a prolapsed bladder as a result. Fortunately baby was fine.

Post Natally was visited by six midwives. I have noted above how the first was more interested in my sex life than me or the baby and did something very vulgar. At day 9 I expressed concern about feeding and engorgement and was told no problem.

The next morning I had flu symptoms and rang the hospital concerned I could give the baby flu. I was told oh don't worry as you are feeding he'll have antibodies. By almost 6 I was very unwell and phoned my Dr's surgery and was told the Dr's had been non since morning and certainly would not speak to me and to call the emergency Dr. He arrived at about 8.45pm. In those days there was one pharmacy about 5 Miles away in Earl's Court and my DH made a dash for it in a cab.

Would you like to comment again on appropriate tailored care because it wasn't available in 1994 at a major London teaching hospital and that was before midwives were as stretched as nowadays.

Would you also perhaps like to explain why anyone would reasonably have expected me to trust a midwife's judgement ever again?[/quote]
I mean whats that got to do with midwives asking questions at a booking in appointment that do help some women? Confused

chattycaterpillar · 26/03/2022 13:28

@flipflopjump

It's very disheartening to think that so many of my patients might believe I am asking them these kind of questions just because I'm nosy.

If you want to know why I am asking a particular question, just ask me and I'll explain. Because there will be a reason.

Then @flipflopjump, can I ask why it is relevant to ask if I have a degree ?

As a 29 year old woman, will I be put on a different care pathway if I say I left school at 16 to do an apprenticeship in hairdressing, than if I had a master's degree in engineering ?

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 26/03/2022 13:25

@flipflopjump

The starting point is that you are at the appointment because you want appropriate care. I am asking questions to be able to personalise the care I offer to your circumstances. That is it.

I'm not judging you
I'm not being nosy

Is there a difference in care if the mum doesn't work, Dh doesn’t work and neither has a degree

To someone who is degree qualified and both parents have good well paying careers

Who would need the help?

As it happened It was the latter couple i could tell had problems but it was first couple who got red flagged The fact that the husband was between jobs and the wife was going to be a SAHM didn’t seem to matter

RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 13:23

@Kennykenkencat - thank you, not something I was aware of.

@flipflopjump to be honest, whenever I saw a midwife I wanted appropriate clinical care tailored to my clinical history, not social care of any sort. It was very disappointing that so often the former wasn't forthcoming.

Examples: pg with ds1 after two late miscarriages in my mid thirties both noted in the referral letter "is it a planned pregnancy?".

Total lack of attention regarding thyroid disease and failure to ensure TSH was monitored- not once but three times.

In early labour with DS failure to diagnose a posterior baby.

Later in labour administered pethidine without my consent.

Even later when I had an epidural said she was going for a sandwich and told my husband to do the same. The heartbeat disappeared and I couldn't reach the alarm button because I had an epidural and shouldn't have been left alone.

She hoisted the belt up and said "oh no worries the belt slipped must be a bit faulty. The third time that happened dh opened the door and yelled "I want a Dr in her right now.

Senior midwife appeared took one look and hit the red button. The room filled - the baby had the cord tightly wrapped around his neck. He was too far out for a section and they cut the cord whilst he was still in the vaginal canal - I was given one more push to get the baby out whilst the registrar got a forceps delivery ready.

I managed to push hard enough for the baby to be born - he was bright blue and took minutes to resuscitate and spent the first night in special care. I had a prolapsed bladder as a result. Fortunately baby was fine.

Post Natally was visited by six midwives. I have noted above how the first was more interested in my sex life than me or the baby and did something very vulgar. At day 9 I expressed concern about feeding and engorgement and was told no problem.

The next morning I had flu symptoms and rang the hospital concerned I could give the baby flu. I was told oh don't worry as you are feeding he'll have antibodies. By almost 6 I was very unwell and phoned my Dr's surgery and was told the Dr's had been non since morning and certainly would not speak to me and to call the emergency Dr. He arrived at about 8.45pm. In those days there was one pharmacy about 5 Miles away in Earl's Court and my DH made a dash for it in a cab.

Would you like to comment again on appropriate tailored care because it wasn't available in 1994 at a major London teaching hospital and that was before midwives were as stretched as nowadays.

Would you also perhaps like to explain why anyone would reasonably have expected me to trust a midwife's judgement ever again?

flipflopjump · 26/03/2022 12:59

The starting point is that you are at the appointment because you want appropriate care. I am asking questions to be able to personalise the care I offer to your circumstances. That is it.

I'm not judging you
I'm not being nosy

Kennykenkencat · 26/03/2022 12:44

Reading music and professional musicianship rarely go hand in hand with dyslexia, etc., sometimes high functioning autism

In my experience it definitely goes with dyslexia.
I have known a lot of professional musicians over the years who struggled with reading and writing words and who either were diagnosed with dyslexia or probably had dyslexia but when it came to notes on a page they could read them as easily as others can read a newspaper

Wingingthis · 26/03/2022 12:37

Sorry but you’re definitely over reacting and I’m currently pregnant with my 3rd so have had these questions 3 times.
I have absolutely no problem with them, they’re to keep babies safe. Why on earth would the midwife ask them just to be nosy???

toomuchlaundry · 26/03/2022 12:26

For all those posters thinking this is intrusive, you do realise when your DC is at school there will be things written about them on the school safeguarding database, some of which may seem trivial but could add up to a bigger picture of concern. This information can then follow them to their next educational establishment

TheNameOfTheRoses · 26/03/2022 12:23

@flipflopjump

It's very disheartening to think that so many of my patients might believe I am asking them these kind of questions just because I'm nosy.

If you want to know why I am asking a particular question, just ask me and I'll explain. Because there will be a reason.

Great!

Could you explain why these questions are there and what you are doing with it as a MW?

Could you also explain why the questions are just asked with the expectation women should just answer and there is no need to explain why to start with?
As a HCP I never ask questions that could seem unrelated to their issue Wo asking why I’m asking those questions.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 26/03/2022 11:41

"You see whilst I personally would not be in a relationship with somebody who had children they chose not to see, I think it's completely unprofessional for a HCP to be quizzing an expectant mother about why her partner doesn't see his other kids. If he is a shit dad, he should be the one getting stick, not her."

But no one is giving her stick, they're asking a question. The dad could not see his children for any reasons ie it could be court mandated due to risk, so they need to know to safeguard the baby.

RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 11:23

@chattycaterpillar that's just silly. DD got grade 8 voice with distinction pre degree and her boyfriend did an organ scholarship in one of the world's music capitals post degree although now taking Prof quals.

A music degree is not a practical degree it is a highly academic one and often links with mathematics and linguistics. Reading music and professional musicianship rarely go hand in hand with dyslexia, etc., sometimes high functioning autism.

You may be mixing it up with something like musical theatre.

toomuchlaundry · 26/03/2022 11:20

@RosesAndHellebores you are the one who sounds very bitter

RosesAndHellebores · 26/03/2022 11:16

It certainly pissed off more than one midwife/hv who made snarky micro-aggressive comments because we lived in a large and lovely house in an expensive area. In my experience they will snark whatever one's circumstances because ultimately there are a high proportion of women in these occupations who are hard, bitter or thoroughly unpleasant. The HV of a friend of mine walked into her house and disdainful said "don't think your baby's any better than anyone else's just because you have all this". The funny thing is that family gratefully received 2nd hand our cot, high chair, and pram. I rang social services to see if I could donate and was snottily told their families were only provided with new things - 2nd hand more than good enough for investment bankers though. The system beggars belief.

Kennykenkencat · 26/03/2022 11:15

@hugr

Haven't read the full thread but have seen a few people speculate why the degree question is there. It's because lower educational level is a risk factor for poor pregnancy and birth outcomes.
I suppose you believe that higher educational levels = no risk factors
chattycaterpillar · 26/03/2022 11:08

And again, surely just ask what is relevant ? " do you have dyslexia or reading difficulties that mean you would like extra help reading through pregnancy information, would highlight for example, someone who got a degree in a practical subject, ( e.g. music), but still had dyslexia and found reading difficult; without making the majority of people without a degree, ( who have perfectly fine literacy skills), feel inadequate as it is obvious what the "preferred answer" to the question is.

OP posts:
chattycaterpillar · 26/03/2022 11:06

@flipflopjump

It's very disheartening to think that so many of my patients might believe I am asking them these kind of questions just because I'm nosy.

If you want to know why I am asking a particular question, just ask me and I'll explain. Because there will be a reason.

@flipflopjump, but couldn't you pre-empt this by explaining why you were asking potentially intrusive questions r.e. previous pregnancy loss, degree status, parent's employment status, housing status, length of parental relationship etc ?

I think it is the lack of transparency that is getting people's back's up.

Someone may, for example, have dropped out of uni and it be a very sensitive subject to them.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread