Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this pissed me off about my booking appointment ?

555 replies

chattycaterpillar · 24/03/2022 22:18

I had a pregnancy booking appointment recently, and was talking to a friend about this yesterday, and she agreed this equally pissed her off about her's too, ( she had hers 12 months ago in the same NHS trust).

The actual medical questions were almost skimmed over, ( I wasn't asked if I had any medication allergies, even though I have a serious allergy to doxycycline). But the amount of nosy, social questions asked to "judge," your suitability to parent was ridiculous.

Examples on the proforma list included:

  • How long have you been with your partner ? ( Yes, it is a long-term relationship so wasn't an issue for me, but my friend's child was conceived after a short fling and she didn't want to be answering exactly how long it was).
  • What is your highest level qualification/ are you educated to degree level ? ( I'm educated to degree level, but interested in the medical relevance of this. Imagine getting asked that at any other medical appointment ...)
  • Are you employed ? Is it full time work, what do you do for work ? What does your partner do for work ? ( Why on earth is it medically relevant what my partner does as his job ? )
  • Does your partner have any other children ? ( No, but again, not medically relevant...)
  • Do you own or rent your property ? ( Why, do you want to take a look at my mortgage deeds....)

Seemed to be a lot more interested in asking a list of nosy, intrusive questions than either a) a serious physical health condition I have that could impact the birth, or b) my medication allergies.

I'm just trying to work out in what other medical scenario this would be appropriate...

OP posts:
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 27/03/2022 18:40

Are you being deliberately obtuse or just ridiculously hormonal tonight?

And tbe prize for the most patronising post on Mumsnet goes to…. @PurplePansy05

MonteStory · 27/03/2022 17:17

@C8H10N4O2

these questions aren’t for judging you and nobody has ever suggested they should be

Oh come on, have you met any health professionals? Of course they judge - they would need to be inhuman to avoid it. We hope they manage to mostly put it to one side - some do, not all manage it.

The nhs is trying to care for the population and find areas of need. If you don’t like being part of that population then don’t engage with the nhs. God forbid your experiences of health care might lead to its improvement and benefit someone else

I find your faith in how some of this data is used very touching but its misplaced. Ask your midwife where the data goes, ask why its collected in some areas and not others, ask why the data captured is not reliably used to help the individual whose appointment time is being used for a data capture exercise. The likelihood of them being able to give you accurate answers is near as dammit zero.

There is nothing wrong with doing demographic studies and research (although a bit more coordination would save a lot of wasted time and money).

The problem here is the lack of informed consent and the reassignment of patient appt time (which as we are told a million times a day is utter gold dust) to gather that data.

Emotional blackmail along the lines of "you don't care about other people" is frankly emotional blackmail and should be treated as such.

I am a health professional and am married to one so yes I have met a few.

I said the questions aren’t FOR judging, I didn’t say midwives don’t judge. But asking what level of education a person has is completely different to asking if they smoke or if their partner has children they don’t see. No midwife is sitting there thinking “only 1 a level, well you’re obviously thick”. If you say you’re smoking and don’t plan to cut down then yeah, they might judge you. I would.

Do I think a midwife would know where this data goes? No, because they aren’t told. It’s a huge leap to assume this means it ISNT used, or isn’t used usefully. Do you know where it goes? I would be, genuinely, interested to hear if this is an area you work in.

Informed consent is a fair point, if people object to the nhs doing research then yes I guess they should be able to shave 90seconds off their appointment time by not answering the questions directly relevant.

Which would they be? What is your level of education would need to be replaced by “do you have any difficulty with reading and writing English?” because this is important. ‘Do you rent or own’ could go, but would that risk women of NFA or who live in hostels going unsupported?

C8H10N4O2 · 27/03/2022 14:14

these questions aren’t for judging you and nobody has ever suggested they should be

Oh come on, have you met any health professionals? Of course they judge - they would need to be inhuman to avoid it. We hope they manage to mostly put it to one side - some do, not all manage it.

The nhs is trying to care for the population and find areas of need. If you don’t like being part of that population then don’t engage with the nhs. God forbid your experiences of health care might lead to its improvement and benefit someone else

I find your faith in how some of this data is used very touching but its misplaced. Ask your midwife where the data goes, ask why its collected in some areas and not others, ask why the data captured is not reliably used to help the individual whose appointment time is being used for a data capture exercise. The likelihood of them being able to give you accurate answers is near as dammit zero.

There is nothing wrong with doing demographic studies and research (although a bit more coordination would save a lot of wasted time and money).

The problem here is the lack of informed consent and the reassignment of patient appt time (which as we are told a million times a day is utter gold dust) to gather that data.

Emotional blackmail along the lines of "you don't care about other people" is frankly emotional blackmail and should be treated as such.

MonteStory · 27/03/2022 13:38

@RosesAndHellebores

If it's all about data capture could complete the answers through an app with midwives picking up only those who have not responded. It shouldn't be difficult in the 21st Century.
Absolutely. The fact maternity notes are paper based (mine are at least, currently 33 weeks) is ridiculous. But let’s remember the NHS was working with windows XP until fairly recently Angry. Tech is massively behind in the nhs and, as you rightly point out, improvement would save massive amounts of time and money.
RosesAndHellebores · 27/03/2022 13:32

If it's all about data capture could complete the answers through an app with midwives picking up only those who have not responded. It shouldn't be difficult in the 21st Century.

Member869894 · 27/03/2022 13:21

13:14MyDcAreMarvel

@Papayamya it’s not paranoia it’s just unnecessary. Abusive parents will be abusive regardless putting unnecessary stress on regular families is in no way helpful.

'Regular families' . I can only think you are really, really stupid to make that comment...regular families abuse their children ...Work in child protection and you will quickly realise that horrible things happen to children in 'regular' families. Shocking ignorance .

MonteStory · 27/03/2022 13:18

I don’t get what’s so difficult to understand about this.

People are studied at population/demographic level all the time. Your education status has no direct bearing on any specific part of your pregnancy/parenting (apart from for those who do not speak English or are functionally illiterate). But it allows you to be grouped.

If the NHS wants to promote breastfeeding, reduce traumatic births, combat childhood obesity or whatever it will put a plan in place and then evaluate the impact. If the amount of women reporting traumatic births goes down that’s great, but what if it only seems to be benefiting women with degrees or Asian women? It would be negligent of the nhs to ignore those women who are not seeing benefit and to not question why.

It’s also important when it comes to randomising further studies. Middle class, university educated women are more likely to breastfeed. But they may also have better outcomes in other ways. When studying the impact of breastfeeding, if all the respondents are university educated, it doesn’t highlight the impact specifically of breastfeeding.

Black women are found to have worse infant and mother mortality rates. When looking at this you need a range of black women so you aren’t confusing a race issue with an education or geographic area issue.

TLDR; these questions aren’t for judging you and nobody has ever suggested they should be. The nhs is trying to care for the population and find areas of need. If you don’t like being part of that population then don’t engage with the nhs. God forbid your experiences of health care might lead to its improvement and benefit someone else.

MyDcAreMarvel · 27/03/2022 13:14

@Papayamya it’s not paranoia it’s just unnecessary. Abusive parents will be abusive regardless putting unnecessary stress on regular families is in no way helpful.

C8H10N4O2 · 27/03/2022 13:11

How much time do you think there is for these appointments confusedconfusedconfused if someone did ask I'd have explained by the way, but it would have meant staying at the end of the day to catch up- if everyone did everyday would be putting shedloads of unpaid overtime in, so no thanks, sorry

If there isn't enough time in the precious appointment slot to ask for consent then frankly why are you wasting it asking a series of detailed questions which are not there for the benefit of the new mother?

The factors described do not require the level of detail specified in the questions which are for a data capture exercise. The factors relevant to the mother could be identified with much more personalised questions for the woman in the room which also gives you more chance of helping her.

C8H10N4O2 · 27/03/2022 13:05

It does. And sadly most of the UK population cannot grasp how exceptional the NHS is and are determined to moan and moan until it is destroyed.

40 years ago you would have had a point. Now - you need to look around at other state backed health care systems and see how far behind we are. Its not just about money either - its about how the system is organised and operates and the whole "national religion" vibe expecting patients to be grateful as if its some kind of charity.

As someone who has voted at every opportunity to pay taxes to support health care I think its time to look at other models of state backed health care which actually deliver timely care with a view to learning where we can improve. Currently the mindset in too many of the NHS fiefdoms is that they can't even learn from other trusts and practices, let alone foreign models.

SmudgeButt · 27/03/2022 12:58

I'd understand them asking about your job - i.e. physical or sedentary but the only reason they might need to know about your partner's job is if he'd been subjected to massive amounts of something that might affect him genetically (working at a nuclear power plant or with chemicals) or if it was something that took him away from home a lot (long distance truck driver with regular runs to the middle east or something)

Papayamya · 27/03/2022 12:54

@hugr

*So having no degree is a risk factor?

Or having a degree is a risk factor?

There is only 2 answers and one of them you are saying indicates a risk factor*

Yeah, I said in my previous post, having lower educational attainment (whether that be GCSE, A Level, Degree etc) is a risk factor. For example, women of lower educational attainment are more likely to give birth to smaller babies, have premature babies, or have babies who need respiratory support after birth.

Yes there has been research into this and there is a correlation between level of educational attainment and certain risk factors. I guess by collating more data they can look into ways to try and mitigate this, it seems to be largely a global trend so personally I don't mind my data being used to bring about positive change.
Member869894 · 27/03/2022 12:46

I work in child protection and go to court to get orders to remove children from their parents at birth if necessary. Thank god for these questions without which so many children would come to harm. Astonishing naivety and entitlement on this thread

hugr · 27/03/2022 12:01

So what is the intervention offered when a mother’s educational level indicates a risk of a poorer outcome?

I don't know. I'm not a midwife.

hugr · 27/03/2022 12:00

*So having no degree is a risk factor?

Or having a degree is a risk factor?

There is only 2 answers and one of them you are saying indicates a risk factor*

Yeah, I said in my previous post, having lower educational attainment (whether that be GCSE, A Level, Degree etc) is a risk factor. For example, women of lower educational attainment are more likely to give birth to smaller babies, have premature babies, or have babies who need respiratory support after birth.

Kennykenkencat · 27/03/2022 09:00

@hugr

I suppose you believe that higher educational levels = no risk factors

@Kennykenkencat

I don't think anything regarding educational level. I was simply stating that the purpose of the question is to identify known risk factors. A person can have multiple risk factors, or none at all. It's an exercise to identify those with multiple risk factors and thus a high risk pregnancy and birth.

So having no degree is a risk factor?

Or having a degree is a risk factor?

There is only 2 answers and one of them you are saying indicates a risk factor

Papayamya · 27/03/2022 08:47

[quote MyDcAreMarvel]**@toomuchlaundry* you do realise when your DC is at school there will be things written about them on the school safeguarding database, some of which may seem trivial* I home educate , shocking how many people are willing to allow such state involvement with their own children even before they are born.[/quote]
I'd suspect most people don't have an over inflated sense of paranoia about what the 'state' will do with routine information about their child, it's not a low bar to have. If you required help from the state I'm sure you'd happily take it.

RidingMyBike · 27/03/2022 08:35

@seven201 I was told my area didn't offer the antenatal home visit from a MW or HV any more (this was pre-Covid)! It was listed on the appts I should expect antenatally though which was why I queried it.

Im sorry about your mum. I disclosed that we had 3 dead parents between us and the one remaining was in poor health and lived hours away but that didn't produce any acknowledgment we had no support!

NumberTheory · 27/03/2022 02:54

@hugr

I suppose you believe that higher educational levels = no risk factors

@Kennykenkencat

I don't think anything regarding educational level. I was simply stating that the purpose of the question is to identify known risk factors. A person can have multiple risk factors, or none at all. It's an exercise to identify those with multiple risk factors and thus a high risk pregnancy and birth.

So what is the intervention offered when a mother’s educational level indicates a risk of a poorer outcome?
hugr · 26/03/2022 23:22

I suppose you believe that higher educational levels = no risk factors

@Kennykenkencat

I don't think anything regarding educational level. I was simply stating that the purpose of the question is to identify known risk factors. A person can have multiple risk factors, or none at all. It's an exercise to identify those with multiple risk factors and thus a high risk pregnancy and birth.

BoredZelda · 26/03/2022 23:21

that’s a very low bar to have.

It really isn’t.

Ireallymustgetup · 26/03/2022 22:51

I was more annoyed at how the midwife assumed my answers to questions like alcohol use, drug use, domestic abuse, etc. Lots of comments like ‘that will be no” and and “I can tell that isn’t a problem” the first time I’d met her. While I didn’t have any drug or alcohol dependency issues I was in a horrible relationship, which got worse while I was pregnant and when baby was small. If she had given me half a moment to consider my response she might have picked up on something instead of shutting me down.

toomuchlaundry · 26/03/2022 22:49

@MyDcAreMarvel do you think schools shouldn’t note safeguarding concerns? Schools worry when certain children go off role because they know their parents want their children off the radar for the wrong reasons

seven201 · 26/03/2022 22:18

I do think it's a worthwhile thing to do as it will pick up on some women who need extra support. I thought everyone in my area had a cigarette breathalyser test thing at their booking in, I found out 2 years later that none of my local mum friends had had that - I've never smoked in my life, but she must have decided I was lying about being a non-smoker.

My dm died 2 years before I had my child. This meant a hv came to my house pre birth (again, I assumed everyone had this locally) and questioned me at length about how I feel about not having a mum. I wasn't expecting it and it was awful and not done in the best way. However, I do think it could pick up on people who would otherwise slip through the net.

MissMaple82 · 26/03/2022 22:14

Why are you taking it some personally, its an essential part in determining support fore those that may require it!