Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this pissed me off about my booking appointment ?

555 replies

chattycaterpillar · 24/03/2022 22:18

I had a pregnancy booking appointment recently, and was talking to a friend about this yesterday, and she agreed this equally pissed her off about her's too, ( she had hers 12 months ago in the same NHS trust).

The actual medical questions were almost skimmed over, ( I wasn't asked if I had any medication allergies, even though I have a serious allergy to doxycycline). But the amount of nosy, social questions asked to "judge," your suitability to parent was ridiculous.

Examples on the proforma list included:

  • How long have you been with your partner ? ( Yes, it is a long-term relationship so wasn't an issue for me, but my friend's child was conceived after a short fling and she didn't want to be answering exactly how long it was).
  • What is your highest level qualification/ are you educated to degree level ? ( I'm educated to degree level, but interested in the medical relevance of this. Imagine getting asked that at any other medical appointment ...)
  • Are you employed ? Is it full time work, what do you do for work ? What does your partner do for work ? ( Why on earth is it medically relevant what my partner does as his job ? )
  • Does your partner have any other children ? ( No, but again, not medically relevant...)
  • Do you own or rent your property ? ( Why, do you want to take a look at my mortgage deeds....)

Seemed to be a lot more interested in asking a list of nosy, intrusive questions than either a) a serious physical health condition I have that could impact the birth, or b) my medication allergies.

I'm just trying to work out in what other medical scenario this would be appropriate...

OP posts:
Sweepingeyelashes · 25/03/2022 04:37

Not in the UK I should say and it was 20 years ago. But I was asked by the anaesthetist in front of my husband whether I had had an abortion when we were there to discuss the epidural. I could truthfully say no but I imagine some women may never have told their partner if they had and could be put on the spot. I don't know why I didn't complain at the time - I was only there because another anaesthetist had nearly killed me when having my first child and there were things that they could do to stop a recurrence and I wanted to make sure they were done. Other anaesthetists I asked later were a bit horrified and couldn't think of a reason why she would ask that.

FarangGirl · 25/03/2022 04:08

@Laniania

I think it is inappropriate too OP but honestly good luck getting anyone to agree on here. Most people seem happy to accept any level of state nosiness, judgement and interference in the interest of preventing abuses that said state mostly subsequently fails to prevent anyway.
Or we understand how statistics work, that people have the option to opt out adn that there are strict data protection rules.

It's not nosiness, you're not allowed to just ask question that you feel like for statistical purposes, you have to show it has policy relevance, i.e. that the data will be used for the benefit of society.

KELLOGSspeck · 25/03/2022 04:01

@PurplePansy05

YABU. They are asked to check your support network and future environment for your baby. Professionals have a duty of care and if you were finding yourself in difficult circumstances they'd refer/signpost you accordingly.
I disagree. After giving birth you hardly see your midwife.

Issues like income isn't relevant and how long someone has been dating... its impersonal.

NewtoHolland · 25/03/2022 04:00

I get that it can feel nosey ..but surely the reason behind most of these questions is clear as explained by many midwives on this post.
Maybe Mumsnet could do an article explaining and reassuring about these questions? As I guess if it catches you off guard it can be a negative start to your maternity care.
Pregnancy is a gateway time for accessing health services and an extremely vulnerable time for domestic violence which often starts in pregnancy, new mental health conditions or exacerbated mental health symptoms, and then first year of baby's life where they are at their most vulnerable to harm.
The are you related question is about likelihood of genetic conditions, cousin marriages are reasonably common in the UK and so something worth asking about as the baby may need extra screening.

Dryshampooandcoffee · 25/03/2022 03:54

Wouldn’t bat an eyelid regarding a 29 year old with a 60 year old. What I would be very concerned about would be the 16 year old that comes into my clinic and tells me with a big grin on her face that her boyfriend was born in the early 80s! Or the woman who says her partner was 29 at booking and then obviously brings a man who is in his 40s into the delivery room claiming he’s the dad. Or the women who are in a ‘stable relationship’ but can’t remember what month their partners birthday is in, let alone what year they were born in. These questions do seem nosey but for each question you’ve listed I can think of a handful of social concerns that have been picked up due to the answers that I’ve been given in the past. I completely agree though that the medical questions such as your allergy status should have also been asked.

OfstedOffred · 25/03/2022 03:43

The questions are not "judging" Hmm. Its about identifying people who need support, ensuring you are accessing any/all help you which you may be entitled and about protecting the child.

NumberTheory · 25/03/2022 03:27

I think this is all part of the lack of respect the medical profession has for mothers.

These questions have a purpose, but that purpose isn’t what you were anticipating. The booking in appointment is superficially sold to women as a physical medical appointment, not an emotional support or social services one. And the paucity of resources available to help build up social or emotional reserves makes that aspect a fairly judgmental process with, at the end of it, the threat of losing your child. That threat is tiny, and necessary, but it’s there without being really acknowledged.

The treatment is patronizing and frequently disingenuous. It treats women as vessels for the child more than people in their own right who have devoted significant biological resources to nurturing new life and are demonstrably, on average, more concerned for their child than anyone else. It is manifest in the disregard for consent that is so frequently discussed on these boards when discussing child birth and it continues after birth with health visitors and, later, schools.

Lhddujvf · 25/03/2022 03:23

@Laniania

I think it is inappropriate too OP but honestly good luck getting anyone to agree on here. Most people seem happy to accept any level of state nosiness, judgement and interference in the interest of preventing abuses that said state mostly subsequently fails to prevent anyway.
Completely agree with this.
Lhddujvf · 25/03/2022 03:22

YANBU to feel how you do. I would feel the same OP. I had a private midwife for many reasons. It's overly intrusive in parts.

SpringRainbow · 25/03/2022 03:02

This is just the first set, in a long line of questioning you are going to receive when it comes to your child.

Welcome to parenting and the attempts various professionals and services will go to in order to safeguard you and your family.

RoseGoldEagle · 25/03/2022 02:50

I thought you sounded naive at first not understanding why they ask these questions, but so many posters have explained why, and you’re still annoyed about it, why? Do you not understand the explanations? That not everyone is in your privileged position of needing no additional social support?

Tidlo · 25/03/2022 02:30

Post above re. Why you're asked if you are related to the father.

Tidlo · 25/03/2022 02:30

I was asked this and asked why it was one of the questions. They told me that in some communities there is a much higher incidence of cousins marrying which then leads to a much higher incidence of miscarriages, birth defects, genetic conditions, etc. They need to understand if you are at need of different types of testing and support because of this.

This is a standardised question - if they ask it due to one community group they have to ask it of all. Or would you prefer nurses only ask it of people that look a bit Asian?!

SeasonFinale · 25/03/2022 02:29

The questions aren't to judge or to categorise you but to assess the situation a baby is being born into. The questions regarding your health and c sections and birth plans come later.

The fact that you don't understand why these questions are being asked will, I am sure, have been picked up on.

newyorker74 · 25/03/2022 02:19

I have an injection every 8 weeks. Every fourth time I go, they ask me all sorts of questions about if my home is safe, do I have any thoughts of self harm, do I feel safe in my life and relationship. I'm not pregnant, don't have children and the treatment I'm getting is for a gastro issue. But I'm glad they ask these questions because if it helps one person access support to leave an abusive situation, it will have been worth it in terms of my time. Answer the questions OP and consider yourself lucky that you get to think they are ridiculous and not appropriate to you.

Laniania · 25/03/2022 02:16

I think it is inappropriate too OP but honestly good luck getting anyone to agree on here. Most people seem happy to accept any level of state nosiness, judgement and interference in the interest of preventing abuses that said state mostly subsequently fails to prevent anyway.

SubParbanMum · 25/03/2022 02:10

You’ll be asked throughout your pregnancy whether you feel safe at home. The health visitor will also ask you.

If you had been at an in person appointment you would see they’re just reeling through the questions that appear on the screen.

Think yourself lucky you have a lovely support network and think these questions are nosey and irrelevant. For some people; this is the first chance they get in pregnancy to get some support.

Blueberryflavour · 25/03/2022 02:10

The actual support they can offer you is real, they don’t just ask out of nosiness. Mums who might have had previous babies removed by SW’s will often move to a new area for the next pregnancy in the hope they are not identified, midwives are the first line of defence for these at risk babies. Asking questions about the dad is vital in helping identify cases of abuse, trafficked women, sex workers or addicts. Our local SW service has a special Pre-birth Team and midwives are the gateway to refer pregnant mums who they feel need extra support to the team. These SW’s can provide a huge range of supports including parenting classes to inexperienced mums without partner or family support, they can offer help with applying for housing or benefits, they can help mums who have been coerced into a pregnancy by an abusive partner and who now want to break free. They can refer struggling mums/couples/families to local charities for things for the baby or clothes for mum while pregnant or food banks to ensure mum eats well during pregnancy. They can help a single mum who has no one to mind her other children when she goes into labour. You may not need any of this help but there are many mums who do, would you rather midwives just take one look at how mums present and make assumptions about how the mums are doing?

Weatherwax13 · 25/03/2022 01:29

Get in the habit of asking questions.
The best medical professionals around you won't always proffer explanations before saying/doing things.
Don't come away from appointments cross or confused. Just ask "what does that mean? Why is that needed?" etc
It's really important to ask questions when you don't understand so you can make informed decisions around your pregnancy/birth.
For a start I'd be asking how the medical condition you mention might affect your birth choices and who to speak to about that?
Don't be passive. Nothing wrong with asking a midwife/obstetrician why they need x or y from you.
It'll also stand you in really good stead for the postnatal period and when you have a child to advocate for.

Feather12 · 25/03/2022 01:26

The actual medical questions were almost skimmed over,
Medically at this stage there is not a lot they can do. They can’t stop you having a miscarriage. The medical care increases as the pregnancy progresses, but at this stage the social care is far more important.

waterbill · 25/03/2022 01:23

The irony is that I did have a child in need. I needed help and support .
I didn't get any. Looking back , my child should have been assigned a social worker, probably from birth. They never got one. I lost out on child benefit and disability benefits my child was entitled to. There were no helpful NHS staff members signposting the way.

DropYourSword · 25/03/2022 01:21

[quote babywalker56]@DropYourSword and what's that?[/quote]
See, this is precisely why midwives should just ask questions without having to explain the relevance of each question. Because then when you explain why you're asking, you then have to explain what each condition is. It would take forever!! It's only relevant when it's relevant. Hence the screening questions.

BFPDec21 · 25/03/2022 01:19

If a partner has children he doesn't see, maybe there's SS involvement and that's something that needs to be looked into and flagged. It would have implications for both as the new baby may be subject to SS intervention. It's basic safeguarding.

A DOB for your partner is to verify identity and can assist with the above and also if anyone tries to advocate on your behalf if you're not well enough, they'll have your partner's details and ask for a DOB which can be cross referenced.

They do seem odd questions but they're to look into whether you're at risk. You might need MH support, extra testing, benefits advice or social services' support.

You will need to get used to it. A good one with no obvious purpose is: 'Is this your first child?' That one is a real cracking one and will probably be wheeled out most of the time you see a GP for your child. Not entirely sure that has a purpose other than to determine if they should take you seriously or not but that one always perplexes me.

Allaboutthatvase · 25/03/2022 01:19

Can you imagine if they never bother to ask about domestic violence etc because they assumed people would be honest?!

Allaboutthatvase · 25/03/2022 01:16

@Kennykenkencat
The midwives themselves might not do much but can refer to other teams including high risk midwives, children's service and signpost towards benefit support etc

My sister was rehoused after her accommodation (which she'd been on about to the council) was picked up in a screening like this, her health visitor got her in touch with a charity and put her weight behind supporting the application. I've no doubt without them she'd still be in that accommodation

Swipe left for the next trending thread