Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
user3837313202 · 26/03/2022 04:41

@Mickarooni

I got injured by a rather exuberant, over excited staffie cross (not sure what he was crossed with). He didn’t bite but didn’t know his own strength and caused quite a few injuries being “playful”. I am a broad, 5ft 5 not-very-slim adult, wouldn’t have liked to think what might have happened if a child was there. :( It happened so quickly too.
I'm guessing he jumped up and scratched or something? You don't state the nature of the injuries so I'm guessing you didn't break your arm or something serious.

Sounds like an undertrained overfriendly young dog who bore you no ill will. I'd be forgiving if the owners were trying to train the dog not to jump up. Dogs have the mental age of a 3-4 year old child, and there's no child in this world of that age that always behaves impeccably.

The last overexuberant staffy I met managed to inflict a bit of pain - her tail was wagging so furiously it acted rather like a whip when it caught the back of my legs... Ouch, but I couldn't be upset!

CakesOfVersailles · 25/03/2022 23:23

Also I would be wary of mislabeled dogs. A lot of dogs are "lab crosses" who maybe had a Labrador as a great-grandparents. Sometimes this is done for insurance purposes to to get around bans at dogs parks etc, particularly in the United States where pit bulls are legal but often not allowed in local areas.

Even on @EvilGoldfish 's thread about her puppy that turned out to be part pit bull, many posters were telling her to claim it was a lab mix.

Sometimes I see dogs responsible for bites and it's just???

For example, another wee baby was mauled to death in the United States recently. Apparently by a Great Pyrenees (Pyrenean Mountain Dog) mix. Does this look like it's half Great Pyrenees to you?

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
Mickarooni · 25/03/2022 23:08

I got injured by a rather exuberant, over excited staffie cross (not sure what he was crossed with).
He didn’t bite but didn’t know his own strength and caused quite a few injuries being “playful”.
I am a broad, 5ft 5 not-very-slim adult, wouldn’t have liked to think what might have happened if a child was there. :( It happened so quickly too.

Thimblecrumble · 25/03/2022 23:05

Shouldn't be trusted with any kind of dog or gun 🙄

Thimblecrumble · 25/03/2022 23:03

I don't think we can rely on education. Sorry to be blunt but the problem is not people that can be educated. We are talking about people that can't or won't be educated - they know best, "an won't take no shit from no-one".

Speed limits, cameras and fines don't stop some people from speeding but it puts most of us off. If people were just asked nicely not to go above 30 here and 50 there, do you think everyone would abide by that?

You can only trust people to use common sense if they have it in the first place. These people with these dangerous dogs don't have common sense and much like you wouldn't trust them with access to your bank account, they should be trusted with a gun or any kind of dog.

At some point unless something harsher is brought in, we'll all pay by everyone losing the privilege of dog ownership.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 22:07

@WiddlinDiddling
Unfortunately lots of people don’t want to be taught anything. They want a huge toy, status symbol, they want to scare people away. No amount of education will help. There is no reason to have this breed as a pet apart from being impressed of how strong and dangerous it is. But that’s exactly the point. These parents could choose any other breed. I don’t believe they didn’t know that it can attack. They knew exactly that it can and even parental instincts didn’t outweigh their sick determination to look “cool”. You can’t educate them. Education doesn’t hurt but how do you educate children on this exactly? We are teaching to drink responsibly, but we all know it doesn’t exactly help much. We don’t need long term plans, we need urgent ways of dealing with this, education can go along with this.

user3837313202 · 25/03/2022 22:06

@WaspRelatedEmergency

A 3 month old baby was killed this month in a woodland in Lincolnshire. The parents were walking their huskies and one of the dogs got loose and killed her. This happened late at night which seems a strange time to be dog walking. These parents were with their baby and she wasn't safe from the dogs. I can't bear to think what those children went through. Is it naivety, ignorance or denial that makes people think their dog would never hurt someone?
There's lots of different reasons for late night dog walking. Sometimes it will be because someone works odd hours - though that seems less plausible when the whole family have gone out together.

Sometimes it's because they're trying to avoid meeting other people or dogs because they know their dog has issues with them - and that's a responsible course of action when you have such a dog.

I'll absolutely guarantee this wasn't the first time the dog had shown concerning behaviour towards the baby though. It would be interesting to know if they'd done anything to address this.

WiddlinDiddling · 25/03/2022 21:57

Controlling the size/shape/weight of the dogs people can own doesn't work. We know, we've tried that for 30 odd years and the problem has not gone away.

Educating people on safe, sensible dog ownership MIGHT help - educating people on why buying a dog to make loads of money studding it out (thats why the kids dad bought the dog) isn't a smart idea - on why understanding dog behaviour (rather than watching dogs behaving badly or cesar millan and treating dogs badly as a result) is important might help.

Generally getting across to the public that owning a dog is a serious consideration NOT something you do on a whim, because you want your mates to think you're double hard, because you want a money making machine, because you think they're cute etc etc...

But that needs to start young, that sort of education needs to start in secondary school if not earlier - I highly doubt I'd be a behaviour and training consultant now if I hadn't had a lifelong interest in animals and their behaviour from a young age!

It has to start with formal education because it is not something most people (and certainly, nto something ANY of the people involved in dog related deaths) think they need to know, so its not information they will seek out!

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 21:51

[quote Dontcallmebabylalala]@tabulahrasa
This “temperament testing” doesn’t seem as a guarantee of anything and worthless in the long run and valid only at the point of testing. It doesn’t make me feel safe.[/quote]
It’s not a guarantee, but there’s a huge genetic element to behavioural issues. You’d at least weed out any dogs unable to pass whatever testing was put in place from passing on their issues.

If they can domesticate foxes in a few generations without even training them then you can definitely make dogs safer.

CounsellorTroi · 25/03/2022 21:48

Buying a dog over the Internet is madness. If you are buying a puppy you see its parents. If buying or rescuing an adult dog you see it first. Best to get an adult dog from a rescue centre with advice from them.

We’ve had two JRTs. One from a rehoming centre who had been dumped from a car. She was the gentlest little thing. The second we paid £60 for - a relative put us in touch with the owners. She was one of three and just needed to be the only dog. Again she never attacked anyone.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 21:45

@tabulahrasa
This “temperament testing” doesn’t seem as a guarantee of anything and worthless in the long run and valid only at the point of testing. It doesn’t make me feel safe.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 21:33

“Banning/restricting breeds based on weight would be easier to determine than breed type and probably have more impact?”

That’d never pass, the breeds some people think are dangerous are much smaller than labs and labs are way too popular to ban.

Temperament testing before breeding and fines that would cost more than selling a litter and proper licensing for owning dogs with the power to spot check would have a huge impact on dangerous dogs.

Thimblecrumble · 25/03/2022 21:25

tabulahrasa @Dontcallmebabylalala

We did outlaw some breeds, in the 30 years since attacks have risen.

Breeding and ownership should be regulated, not breeds - responsibly bred and owned dogs are never responsible for attacks.

If you ban breeds the people currently trying to make bully breeds larger, stronger and more dangerous will just move on to other breeds and try to make them larger, stronger and more dangerous.

Then what do you suggest? We have a Rottweiler, a beautiful dog that adores us but another Rottweiler could a loaded gun in someone else's hands whereas a toy poodle, corgi, Westie etc etc is not physically capable of the damage that large guarding/some herding and bull breeds can do.

If something radical isn't done and maybe that's accepting banning scores of dog breeds 'devastating' lots of people, maybe EVERY dog breed will be made high on impossible to own. Which is the better choice?I genuinely would love to hear exactly what people think could work better than a straight up ban on a lot of dog breeds or heavy fines if you're found to own a larger dog with children, something I would be very sad to see.

tabulahrasa and *Dontcallmebabylalala

We did outlaw some breeds, in the 30 years since attacks have risen.*

*Breeding and ownership should be regulated, not breeds - responsibly bred and owned dogs are never responsible for attacks.

If you ban breeds the people currently trying to make bully breeds larger, stronger and more dangerous will just move on to other breeds and try to make them larger, stronger and more dangerous*

The only responsible way to ensure these dogs don't attack children is to never let them near children full stop.

If banning more breeds isn't the solution, what breeding and ownership regulation do you suggest? We have a Rottweiler, a beautiful dog that adores us but another Rottweiler could a loaded gun in someone else's hands whereas a toy poodle, corgi, Westie etc etc whilst capable of biting, is not physically capable of the damage that large guarding/some herding and bull breeds can do.

Regulation/Legislation needs to be far more black and white and extensive than the current flawed DDA. Anything over 20lbs in weight needs an expensive licence and compulsory training for the owner? Not allowed to be homed with children? Banning/restricting breeds based on weight would be easier to determine than breed type and probably have more impact?

I'd be very sad to see breeds being banned but I would genuinely love to know what people think could be put into practice that would actually work.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 21:24

“Yet there are countless people on the road who drive with no license, insurance, tax or MOT.
They know they are breaking the law, and they don't care.
The same will apply to dogs too.
The normal law abiding folk will stick the rules, and the ones who don't give shit, wont.”

And there are lots more who get caught driving without any of those things, it’s not pointless having them in place just because some people slip through the net.

XenoBitch · 25/03/2022 21:20

@tabulahrasa

“How do you control “responsible ownership” on a day to day basis?”

I think it should be similar to owning a car tbh. Paid for by owners, compulsory lessons and a licence.

Yet there are countless people on the road who drive with no license, insurance, tax or MOT. They know they are breaking the law, and they don't care. The same will apply to dogs too. The normal law abiding folk will stick the rules, and the ones who don't give shit, wont.
tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 21:16

“How do you control “responsible ownership” on a day to day basis?”

I think it should be similar to owning a car tbh. Paid for by owners, compulsory lessons and a licence.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 21:09

@tabulahrasa
Agree about it being difficult to ban by breeds. Not impossible.

But I absolutely disagree about “responsibly bred ones”. It’s as difficult as to track all the dangerous breeds and ban them. How do you control “responsible ownership” on a day to day basis? Please don’t continue this ridiculous assumption that the dog that killed this child can ever be “safe” with “responsible ownership”. Any undetected health condition, that the dog suffers, any factor that can come into play can lead to an attack. And no one stands a chance if this dog attacks.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 20:51

@Dontcallmebabylalala

We did outlaw some breeds, in the 30 years since attacks have risen.

Breeding and ownership should be regulated, not breeds - responsibly bred and owned dogs are never responsible for attacks.

If you ban breeds the people currently trying to make bully breeds larger, stronger and more dangerous will just move on to other breeds and try to make them larger, stronger and more dangerous.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 20:45

@tabulahrasa
I don’t completely understand your point,
but it’s clear that despite the danger being there from every breed, some breeds are more able to kill. They need to be outlawed. Let’s not pretend to be oblivious to the fact that the dog in question is more dangerous than chihuahua. Every dog can bite, every dog can cause serious injuries. The dog in question is designed to kill, it’s in their blood. Having a dog like this at home in incomprehensible. It should be outlawed.

FatFucker · 25/03/2022 20:27

@WonderfulYou

I hope they’re done for manslaughter

If your dog killed someone do you think you should be done for manslaughter?

If someone is driving drunk and had an accident and killed their kids, I believe they would be done for manslaughter.

How is that any different from having a dog like this?

(Although I'm not saying I hope these parents are done for manslaughter.)

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 20:26

@Dontcallmebabylalala

I agree OP. It should be considered as a safeguarding issue and families should not be allowed to have dogs like that as pets. I would ban these kinds of dogs all-together, I don’t care about the dog owners who disagree. We can’t lose any more children to this.
And when the breeds “like that” are banned just like the ones that already are banned and it only changes the breed of dog involved instead of solving the issue, what then?
Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 20:24

@Bloodybridget
Agree wholeheartedly.
These parents KNEW what they are doing buying a fighter dog that is heavy, big, dangerous, designed for mauling and killing. I am a dog lover but I can’t breath properly if this kind of a dog is coming within 100 m distance from my child. My instincts kick right in, my children’s safety is absolutely paramount. I have ZERO idea of what’s in this dog’s head. Why did they HAVE to have a dog like that?
We safeguard our children, protect them from harm, we are questioned by schools for a random bruise appeared on our childrens body, we are charged for neglect leaving children unattended at home if the accident happens, but apparently having such a dangerous creature at home is fine?! How is this ok? How is this allowed? I agree that ANY dog can bite, but not every dog has such a great potential to kill.
This whataboutery about comparing risks has to STOP immediately. It was a completely preventable death. It was a direct consequence of parental decisions. It’s not an accident. They should be charged. They will never experience what their poor child went through.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 20:24

@WaspRelatedEmergency

The parents were the dog owners. It was 11pm at night. Tbf I don't have a dog so I didn't know late night dog walking was common.
Oh, dunno if that makes more sense or not tbh, but yeah, late night dog walking pretty common, taking a baby not so much.
Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 20:02

@FungalLurkins
A young child’s life is lost. A toddler dying in such a horrible inconceivable way and you are bragging about your risk assessments. One lost life is enough!

Dontcallmebabylalala · 25/03/2022 19:59

I agree OP. It should be considered as a safeguarding issue and families should not be allowed to have dogs like that as pets. I would ban these kinds of dogs all-together, I don’t care about the dog owners who disagree. We can’t lose any more children to this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread