Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Mickarooni · 26/03/2022 15:09

@Indoctro

I did try to express that this is “for me” and my opinion. I don’t expect and never expressed that everyone should feel the same way. Equally, owners of large, strong breeds have to realise many people are unwilling to let their kid or dog near them. I’ve seen dog owners get offended but it’s their problem, not mine.

Life is inherently a risk and we need to teach our children to live with and manage risk. We cannot and should not be eliminating risks but we can reduce them. If you want a dog and have a 2 year old, I would say it’s more sensible to buy a small breed puppy i.e. a bichon frise from a decent breeder than ‘rescue’ a 3 year old American bully from a mate down the pub.

caecilius1 · 26/03/2022 14:14

@MyWinterRose
That's so harsh. Yes the parents are very foolish, but they'll have to live with that for the rest of their lives.

MyWinterRose · 26/03/2022 13:44

I feel no sympathy for the parents, they were reckless and idiotic for buying a dog like that with a toddler, they are fully responsible for her death.

I only feel sorry for that poor little girl and what she must have suffered.

This obsession with dogs the country seems to have is ridiculous and people need to get a grip and realise how dangerous any dog can be especially with children.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/03/2022 13:28

All dogs have capability of being dangerous, it's not the breed necessarily

This is true; however a certain type of owner want pitbull-types above all else, and they're not always the sort who'll take responsibility for training the dog or for having it around children

Indoctro · 26/03/2022 13:09

@Mickarooni

Because your idea of risk will be different to the next person

I have a 17kg SBT , which I purposely got due to there good nature with kids. I got him as a puppy and have spend hundreds of hours training him he is extremely well trained, he does canicross, scent classes and agility. I believe the risk of him attacking my kids is way less than many other dogs I know in family homes because he needs are fully met, his mind is stimulated daily through scent work and he has a outlet for him energy because he runs every day with and he goes to agility weekly. Yet me neighbour has a scared spaniel in her garden that gets walked round the village , to me that's a accident waiting to happen and I don't allow my kids near it, yet her husband told me he would never own a staffy as they are dangerous and I'm looking at him thinking you plonker. He is totally oblivious to the fact his under stimulated, fearful dog is very risky to his kids.

I allow my kids to fly about on Quad bikes yet my sister thinks it's dangerous and risky, she on the other hand has pony's for her kids which to me is risky

Everyone has a different view on risk and what's acceptable to them.

SemperIdem · 26/03/2022 11:25

As has already been stated the sort of people who shouldn’t own these sorts of dogs are all too often to ones who are so keen to have them.

Too many people in general don’t consider the needs of the breed they’re buying. I absolutely love Hungarian Vizslas but I cannot provide the sort of exercise they require. I think that Cane Corso’s are very attractive animals, i would never own a dog that could at adult size, outweigh me never mind my, or indeed any other child. I couldn’t own a dog that could become uncontrollable and kill someone.

So I got a lapdog, bred to be a companion, small and sweet natured. He’s a delightful little dog.

Maybe in the future I may own a Vizsla but my lifestyle would have to be dramatically different to what it is now.

I don’t understand why so few people seem to consider the dogs needs when they get one. An hour (for example) of exercise a day just isn’t going to cut it for a lot of breeds, family favourites like labs included. Jack Russell Terriers have a bad rep because once they stopped being used as working dogs, they were treated like lapdog pets and that quite simply isn’t what they were bred for. They’re small dogs with a lot of energy and need to be occupied.

Whilst people have always owned big dogs etc they didn’t have them in their houses, around their children, as the family pet. They were working dogs. This is why issues with dogs are increasing, people are fundamentally not understanding what hundreds of years of breeding has hardwired into each and every breed.

Mickarooni · 26/03/2022 11:04

@Indoctro

I’ve met many lovely and well trained SBTs and other breeds mentioned on here. I just don’t understand why you’d take the risk if you had small children to have a dog that has the potential to kill due to their sheer size. For me, it’s an unnecessary risk for the sake of a pet. I need to cross the road with my children and know there is a risk I could be hit my a car. But I need to cross the road to leave my home and I don’t need a huge dog while my children are little.

Flickflak · 26/03/2022 10:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Indoctro · 26/03/2022 08:55

You could include most dog breeds in that category. Horses are also capable of killing a child. Cats pose some danger to babies if they curl up on top of them. Heck, a bite from a hamster could prove fatal if it gets infected and medical attention isn't sought quickly enough. Yes, precautions do need to be taken, such as not buying dogs if the Internet (that's sheer lunacy), getting a dog breed suitable for your family etc but suggesting that entire breeds should be banned as pets due to a few rogue individuals is an overreaction.

Smile

At last some common sense being spoken..

If people matched the breed with the home they can provide then far less dogs would be harming kids

SBT - highly intelligent, high energy - don't get one unless you can offer it a outlet for energetic nature - canicross / agility etc

Labs and Spaniels - dog responsible for a vast number of facial injuries to kids - Do NOT get one unless you can work it through gun dog training or agility.

If all you can offer is 2 walks a day and a family life then please only get a dog bred for this - Lap dogs - Pug , KCCS etc

Prescottdanni123 · 26/03/2022 08:44

@WindyKnickers

You could include most dog breeds in that category. Horses are also capable of killing a child. Cats pose some danger to babies if they curl up on top of them. Heck, a bite from a hamster could prove fatal if it gets infected and medical attention isn't sought quickly enough. Yes, precautions do need to be taken, such as not buying dogs if the Internet (that's sheer lunacy), getting a dog breed suitable for your family etc but suggesting that entire breeds should be banned as pets due to a few rogue individuals is an overreaction.

Indoctro · 26/03/2022 08:36

The whole banning breed thing take the Staffy, in 2021 it was voted the UK most popular dog. There is literally hundreds of thousands of Staffies living happily in homes in the UK as loving pets.

You are saying a breed should be banned because of the odd rouge dog which most likely has come from some for of abuse or neglect, or serious lack of training or owned by a complete idiot.

You have to remember dogs are domesticated animals and most will live happily in homes with humans. Control is what's needed, dogs need to be licensed in some way that controls idiots from owning them.

Also some of the deaths that have occurred aren't dog attacks as such if you actually read details, owners have taken fits and the dogs have tried to wake them by scratching and clawing at owners face. So they haven't actually attacked them, tried to wake them up.

WindyKnickers · 26/03/2022 08:33

Itshould be illegal to keep a pet that is capable of killing a child. Working animals fine, kept on farms or what have you. Highly trained assistance dogs with the correct paperwork, fine but it shouldn't be possible to buy a lethal animal off the Internet and bring it into a family home. Just like guns.

tabulahrasa · 26/03/2022 08:27

[quote Dontcallmebabylalala]@tabulahrasa
But the laws are different in the UK and US? I might have worded it wrong, but in the UK you only can have one if you have a valid reason.
There are NO reasons for a person to have an XL as a pet. “I like them” doesn’t sound like a reason to me.[/quote]
Well yes, but joining a gun club is a valid reason, or sports like clay pigeons - that is basically, because I like them.

And licensing people to have them works well, doing similar with dogs would be a lot more effective than just adding more breeds to the dog laws we already have.

Mickarooni · 26/03/2022 08:14

@user3837313202

”I'm guessing he jumped up and scratched or something? You don't state the nature of the injuries so I'm guessing you didn't break your arm or something serious.”

I had a deep scratches that bled. He also (playfully!) launched at me head as I was sitting. I had neck pain and stiffness for weeks after. I needed physio. My point is that I’m an adult and a playful big dog did hurt me. I wouldn’t have a dog of that strength around a child, even well trained, and I cannot imagine thinking it’s sensible even if you are in the same room. He absolutely wasn’t a bad natured dog, just very over excited and very strong. He was around 3 years old if I recall correctly, not a puppy but not an older dog either.

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 08:14

@tabulahrasa
But the laws are different in the UK and US? I might have worded it wrong, but in the UK you only can have one if you have a valid reason.
There are NO reasons for a person to have an XL as a pet. “I like them” doesn’t sound like a reason to me.

abeanbaked · 26/03/2022 07:21

They'd had the dog for a matter of weeks - it doesn't scream "reputable breeder"

Absolutely not a reputable breeder or previous responsible owner. If a breeder won't take a young dog with issues back, that's a massive red flag for me. When we got our dog, we signed a contract to say that our dog must go back to the breeder if we became unable to look after her and our chosen people could not take her. Our breeder is always happy to help, two years down the line we still see them and I put questions to them often. Can't imagine the breeders of these dogs are overly keen to keep in touch..

tabulahrasa · 26/03/2022 07:21

@Dontcallmebabylalala

I mean licenses. Lots of lives lost. I’m happy it’s not allowed in the UK
I mean in the U.K. - guns aren’t banned, plenty of people have them legally.
ThinWomansBrain · 26/03/2022 07:15

The last overexuberant staffy I met managed to inflict a bit of pain - her tail was wagging so furiously it acted rather like a whip when it caught the back of my legs... Ouch, but I couldn't be upset!
Reminded me of my sisters cross breed rescue staffie (no idea of what the "crossed" bit was) he used to get so excited If I stayed over, he'd forget, and when I emerged in the morning - despite being very well trained, the biggest danger was a (very painful) headbut at just above knee level when he spotted me coming downstairs. He was adorable though.

ThinWomansBrain · 26/03/2022 07:06

regardless of the legality of the breed, for me it spoke volumes that after the incident the police were trying to trace the people that the family had acquired the dog from.
They'd had the dog for a matter of weeks - it doesn't scream "reputable breeder"

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 07:02

I mean licenses. Lots of lives lost. I’m happy it’s not allowed in the UK

Dontcallmebabylalala · 26/03/2022 07:01

@tabulahrasa
And it works really well… not

Newuser82 · 26/03/2022 06:54

I do agree that any dog can bite and that early socialisation and bite inhibition work is essential to raise a young dog adequately I would disagree that these are suitable dogs to ever live with young children. Bull breeds have been literally bred for strength and fighting. They have exceptionally strong jaws which would be almost impossible to open by a person when they are biting. So yes, obviously smaller dogs can and do bite and if they get the wrong place on a child could unfortunately cause catastrophic damage but they will be easier to remove while biting. A bully breed is just not going to be able to removed as easily if at all. I feel heartedly sorry for both the young child and the parents but I definitely agree that some dogs are banned in this country. This is my viewpoint as someone who has worked with dogs in various capacities all my working life.

tabulahrasa · 26/03/2022 06:49

@baglavender

On the argument that there's no such thing as a bad dog, only a bad upbringing...

It's like guns in America, isn't it. Guns don't kill people, people do, say some.

Is it realistic to expect that all people holding a gun licence will be a responsible owner?

How many deaths/injuries/maimings are we willing to accept?

But that’s literally the way gun control laws work - you make sure people who have guns are responsible people and use them only as allowed.

Guns aren’t actually banned, people have them.

baglavender · 26/03/2022 06:27

On the argument that there's no such thing as a bad dog, only a bad upbringing...

It's like guns in America, isn't it. Guns don't kill people, people do, say some.

Is it realistic to expect that all people holding a gun licence will be a responsible owner?

How many deaths/injuries/maimings are we willing to accept?

tabulahrasa · 26/03/2022 05:41

“Does this look like it's half Great Pyrenees to you?”

The thing is, it could be... mix breed dogs do not all come out looking somewhere between both parent breeds.

My current dog is a rescue where they had the whole litter, there are 2 different colours, coat length and ear set within that litter - as adults they look like very different dogs.

I’ve known a staffy cross GSD litter where all the bitches looked like crosses but the dog took nothing but size from the GSD, it just looked like a big staffy.

I’ve known lots of lurcher litters (because I grew up where they’re actually used to hunt) where you’d never have been able to tell that one parent was a full deerhound or when they added a collie in the mix some look like lurchers, some just look like collies.

So yes, some people will claim a dog is something else to pass it off as legal, but also it’s often very hard to tell what is in a mixed breed dog by looking at them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread