Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
sinpola · 27/03/2022 04:53

Did they adopt this dog or buy from a friend kind of thing. Because I don't see how this dog was placed in a house with a young child so easily , a reputable adoption wouldn't have allowed this

Selena55 · 27/03/2022 03:04

I wouldn’t have left mine with a childminder with any dog breed to be honest. One of the many reasons I chose a nursery.

Dogs around small children make me nervous. Obviously some breeds are more lethal than others but I’d prefer no dog bites at all for my children thanks.

hookiewookie29 · 27/03/2022 00:56

I'm a childminder. I have a Staffy. The most gorgeous, laid back, adorable dog ever. He loves the children, they love him. I don't keep them apart because he's been brought up with the children from the age of 8 weeks and they know how to behave around him. He takes himself off upstairs if he needs a bit of peace. None of the families were concerned about us getting a Staffy, in fact they were all over the moon. Most of them have, or have had, dogs.
One family have a nephew who had his cheek biten off by a Jack Russell. Another has 2 rescue Greyhounds who have to be muzzled. We chose a puppy so he was brought up with my job. Wr would never have considered a rescue dog with the job I have.We had a Staffy years ago and she was fab with our own children when they were young. I hate the bad press Staffies get. When we're out walking he goes off his lead and never bothers with other dogs at all, but we have many dogs who won't leave him alone.
It's alright all these people saying " oh, she was bitten by a poodle but it's ok....." No it's not ok- its a dog bite. It would be a whole different story if it was a Bull terrier breed....

XenoBitch · 27/03/2022 00:51

@HeadNorth

Better in A&E than in the grave. Honestly. Think of what you are typing.
Look up how many end up in the grave. A hell of a lot more people die on the roads each year.
HeadNorth · 27/03/2022 00:43

Better in A&E than in the grave. Honestly. Think of what you are typing.

XenoBitch · 27/03/2022 00:35

@HeadNorth

Yup, all these people viciously attacked by chihuahuas and JRTs plainly lived to tell the tale. Very different to being set upon by by a big dog strong enough to kill.
It is a small handful of people who die by dog attacks each year. More people end up in A&E from being bitten by the small breeds.
HeadNorth · 27/03/2022 00:27

Yup, all these people viciously attacked by chihuahuas and JRTs plainly lived to tell the tale. Very different to being set upon by by a big dog strong enough to kill.

XelaM · 27/03/2022 00:22

It's totally laughable that people compare the bites of "small yappy dogs" to those of massive muscular fighter dogs 🙄 The meanest little beasts in dogs' clothing I have encountered were Jack Russells and Chihuahuas. Little bitey devil dogs, but I would rather get attacked by a Jack Russell or a Chi than an American XL Bully or a Rottweiler

XenoBitch · 27/03/2022 00:16

@Whatafustercluck

Dd got bitten on the face by a dog. She was lucky not to lose her sight, the bite was so close to her eye. It wasn't my sister's soft-as-shit staffie that did it to her but a small yappie little thing. It's the ones with small dog syndrome you have to watch. A bit like history's dictators.
Yes, small dog syndrome. I know someone who got their hand mauled by a chihuahua. I have known a lot of people with a lot of different breeds of dogs, and the toy/small breeds are the worse. It seems a lot of people with small dogs don't bother training shit behaviour out of them as they are "too small" to cause any damage. Jumping up is seen as cute.. when in a big dog, you would actively seek to discourage it as it can knock someone over.
Whatafustercluck · 27/03/2022 00:07

Incidentally, the dog described in this incident was not in fact a breed bred for fighting. Instead it is a breed that has had the aggressiveness purposely bred out of it to make them docile family pets. A quick Google reveals a temperament that is exactly the kind of character that fits in well with family life - playful, affectionate, soft etc.

I suspect this dog, like many others of all varieties, may have had behavioural problems due to how it's been handled and raised. I don't think the family owned it from a puppy, and this is one reason why I'd hesitate to get a rescue dog as a family pet.

It's not the breed, it's how they've been handled. Staffies have a terrible reputation but are nicknamed the nanny dog due to how great they are with children. I've met many wonderful staffies and always make a big fuss of them, they're so full of character. But would I get an adult.one from a rescue centre? Not in a million years.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 26/03/2022 23:01

@Whatafustercluck

Dd got bitten on the face by a dog. She was lucky not to lose her sight, the bite was so close to her eye. It wasn't my sister's soft-as-shit staffie that did it to her but a small yappie little thing. It's the ones with small dog syndrome you have to watch. A bit like history's dictators.
But the point I think is that if the same incident happened but the dog was a larger breed with a strong jaw and an instinct to lock on and not let go, that injury would likely have been death or at least far worse injuries. It's not about individual dogs when it comes to risk assessment.

Your poor DD though I'm sorry she (and you) went through that and glad to hear her sight was saved Thanks

Whatafustercluck · 26/03/2022 22:48

Dd got bitten on the face by a dog. She was lucky not to lose her sight, the bite was so close to her eye. It wasn't my sister's soft-as-shit staffie that did it to her but a small yappie little thing. It's the ones with small dog syndrome you have to watch. A bit like history's dictators.

ronjobbins · 26/03/2022 22:35

[quote Dontcallmebabylalala]@Bloodybridget
Agree wholeheartedly.
These parents KNEW what they are doing buying a fighter dog that is heavy, big, dangerous, designed for mauling and killing. I am a dog lover but I can’t breath properly if this kind of a dog is coming within 100 m distance from my child. My instincts kick right in, my children’s safety is absolutely paramount. I have ZERO idea of what’s in this dog’s head. Why did they HAVE to have a dog like that?
We safeguard our children, protect them from harm, we are questioned by schools for a random bruise appeared on our childrens body, we are charged for neglect leaving children unattended at home if the accident happens, but apparently having such a dangerous creature at home is fine?! How is this ok? How is this allowed? I agree that ANY dog can bite, but not every dog has such a great potential to kill.
This whataboutery about comparing risks has to STOP immediately. It was a completely preventable death. It was a direct consequence of parental decisions. It’s not an accident. They should be charged. They will never experience what their poor child went through.[/quote]
Well said

youvegottenminuteslynn · 26/03/2022 21:13

@Indoctro

Worst I see was a young child who was in the surgical ward when my son was there, his face had been ripped open by a miniature poodle. It was a horrendous state and he definitely was going to be left badly scarred. He was just over 2 years old.
This is genuinely awful, that poor little boy.

If the dog involved in the same attack on that part of his body had been a controversial breed with hugely strong jaws and bodies, for example the one mentioned by op, that boy would almost certainly have died.

EvilGoldfish · 26/03/2022 17:55

@ronjobbins I’ve copy/pasted this from my previous thread.

‘I know we should have done things properly to start with but my heart completely over ruled my head

We were on a waiting list for a Staffordshire bull terrier puppy, when my niece told me of a family she knew giving their 10 week old staffy female away as they couldn’t cope.

I went with full intentions of taking her to a local rescue as the details sounded dodgy (no microchip, no vaccinations, no contact details for who sold her to them) but I couldn’t bear the thought of her being picked duo as a bait dog. They had her in a tiny cat cage, no toys/bed and on adult butchers food. The first thing she did when they let her out was run up for a belly rub.

Obviously, she is completely adorable and I ended up taking her to the vets to be chipped, 1st vaccinations and to get checked over.

I know all puppy owners can say this but she is so responsive to positive training, loving and eager to please. She has only had two accidents in the four weeks we’ve had her, she sleeps at the foot of our bed and usually only needs to get up once in the night. Her little tail wags like crazy the second she sees anyone, including strangers and other dogs (dogs from a distance as her second vaccination is next week) but especially children. We are starting KC puppy scheme classes in a few weeks.’

ronjobbins · 26/03/2022 17:34

@EvilGoldfish

I had a thread on here late last year about discovering my puppy was a ‘banned breed’. She was the sweetest, most intelligent dog I’ve ever met. Sadly (the circumstances are on the thread) we could not keep her. I was willing to upsize the house in to a cheaper area, but the behavioural problem she had needed far more experience than I had (and no vulnerable people around her - ever)

She went to an amazing rescue while still very young, straight into an experienced with large bull breeds foster home with no dc and a huge amount of land. She has now been officially adopted by them and is a wonderful, happy and loving dog.

BUT that is only because:

A) She is in a home with a very large house/extra land.

B) She is with very experienced owners who have handled large bull breeds before, and has had professional behaviourist support since five months old (provided by the rescue).

C) She is able to live in a place with no vulnerable people or stranger coming in and out. She’ll never live/be in the same room as children or the elderly.

I regret giving her up every single day and keep up to date with her progress. But I also know that if she had stayed with us in our circumstances (a family with young dc, in a smal terraced house, with visitors coming and going) then she would probably have attacked, maybe killed someone.

She must have an entire litter out there that may have inherited this behavioural problem, and I dread to think where she would be if we had just sold her on.

Why did you get her in the first place @EvilGoldfish genuine question?
MyWinterRose · 26/03/2022 17:01

[quote caecilius1]@MyWinterRose
That's so harsh. Yes the parents are very foolish, but they'll have to live with that for the rest of their lives. [/quote]
I don't think it's harsh, I think the parents should face criminal charges for buying a clearly dangerous animal and leaving it with the child unattended which caused her death.

Can you even imagine what that little girl went through? I don't even know how those neglectful parents can live with themselves!

Orchid18 · 26/03/2022 16:22

@EmeraldShamrock1

It angers me the DM is the administrator on the go fund me for the poor DC.

I'd hide forever in her position.

Reminds me of some other parents who also made a poor decision re. risk posed to their children, who still don’t know what happened to their child. They certainly didn’t hide forever - paid off their mortgage with donated funds. Of course different rules apply to professional people.
EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/03/2022 16:00

The fear she must have felt in her last moments. Sad

Dysco · 26/03/2022 15:42

I agree it should be a punishable offense for adults who choose to have a dog around children if something like this happens. Poor litte sweetheart bless her, what a waste of a life.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/03/2022 15:40

It angers me the DM is the administrator on the go fund me for the poor DC.

I'd hide forever in her position.

SoItWas · 26/03/2022 15:32

I agree a small child and a new, adult dog, with an unknown temperament, are a bad mix. One cat charity I tried to rehome a cat from, said I was unsuitable, as they don't rehome where there's a child in the family under 7, in case the kid would spook the cat, and the cat would claw the kid.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/03/2022 15:31

The parents were reckless and they will have to live with the consequences of their stupidity absolutely no risk assessments considered or they wouldn't have bought the dog.
My sympathy is with the DC who lost their life.

Papayamya · 26/03/2022 15:21

[quote caecilius1]@MyWinterRose
That's so harsh. Yes the parents are very foolish, but they'll have to live with that for the rest of their lives. [/quote]
Its more than foolish though isn't it, although I am positive they wouldn't have bought it had they known what it would do, ultimately their decision to get a dog for 'buttons' and let it into their home with their children directly caused her death. Perhaps if it was punishable beyond they'll have to live with their crappy decison people would think more before doing it, after all its not them who has paid the biggest price is it.

WizzardPjs · 26/03/2022 15:17

How can people say “it’s not the breed” when its always the same breeds in these attacks??!

Swipe left for the next trending thread