Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Queeen · 27/03/2022 21:58

They are high risk. That's the problem. You can't trust them. So what if there are a few good ones?

Indoctro · 27/03/2022 20:35

Seen this and wanted to share it.

SBT helping kids, they are such lovely wee dogs, if treated correctly.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
WizzardPjs · 27/03/2022 17:29

@tabulahrasa

I’m going to use Rottweilers as an example because it’s a breed I’m familiar with.

The job they’re bred for no longer exists, people don’t need a dog who can guard and round up cows and then pull them on a wagon to market.

So that leaves, sports, showing, pets and random people who want them as an ego boost. With rotties the latter isn’t that many as they’re not currently the fashionable choice.

So you have a split in the breed between show like and “working” line (I mean, it’s just a different type of show, but that’s what they call it).

Show line rotties are bred to not just look good enough to win a show, but also be quite happy to be at a show and be handled by strangers while being judged. So the ones that don’t end up in the show ring make good pets for most owners, they’re still too active and need a lot more engagement than some people are prepared to put in, but with the wrong owner it’s just fairly normal dog issues, bad recall because everything else is more exciting, chewing the house because they’re bored.

“Working” line though, they’re very different - they’re bred for drive and willngness to do bite work, as pets, with the right owner, not inherently an issue if someone is directing that drive into agility or putting in a huge level of training. In the wrong owners hands they are more of a risk of serious behavioural issues, but mostly, people who have one know they have one and are doing appropriate stuff with it.

If you took those dogs with behavioural issues and breed them together because you want a hard dog Hmm then treat them in a way that develops the issues then you’ve got a dangerous dog. That’s what’s happening with bull breeds.

Most sensible and informative post on this thread.

I have a working line Dobermann. I had met a few “show” types and they were lovely and d as I when I went to view these puppies I fell in love.

Boy did I learn fast that working line/show line are practically two different breeds entirely. I thought it was all about how they were brought up - massive mistake.

She can never be off lead and can never be around children. I have to travel across the country for training classes and I have to work her daily. I also had to learn learn learn quickly how to control and raise such a dog.

On the plus side - she’s a bloody good guard dog and I can guarantee nobody will mug me whilst she’s with me. She absolutely lives to work and she seems to know exactly what he “job” is. Her intelligence is off the scale, she’s sharp, she’s fast, she’s everything the breed was intended to be. She should never have been a pet dog and I have had to make many sacrifices as well as invest a shit load of time and money into making her a safe dog. I dread to think what she would be like in the wrong hands.

Ylvamoon · 27/03/2022 09:24

@Whatafustercluck - I have had a look into the American Bully XL (or smaller...)
What jumped out at me is the following:

When these cruel animal-fighting sports died out, the remaining dogs were bred together and the first bull terriers were created 🤔
When breeders wanted to create theultimate companion dogfrom these bully breeds, they began combining pit bulls with Staffordshire bull terriers and mixing in other breeds 🤔🤔

Anyone can sprout anything on the Internet. But I would be very wary, they are a young breed of dog , apparently developed in the 80's / 90's....

People who know about genetics will be able to tell you that 100's of years of selective breeding are not undone in a few decades. Some traits can easily skip a generation or two only to re surface later on.
And then there are things about genetics that we don't understand.yet. (Example, the "hairless gene" in Chinese Crested dogs is linked to bad teeth ....)

Only a naive person, believes that dogs are cuddly family pets that wouldn't harm the squirrel they chaise or go for a child because said child startled the dog.

SamphiretheStickerist · 27/03/2022 09:15

@HeadNorth

Yup, all these people viciously attacked by chihuahuas and JRTs plainly lived to tell the tale. Very different to being set upon by by a big dog strong enough to kill.
Not all of them, unfortunately. JRTs are on the death by dog list. Not often, but often enough to be noticeable.

There is no safe dog. I say that as the owner of a bull breed. He is a proper bouncy, pully Bullie. I know he is well intentioned and just over exuberant. I also know, from having had very small kids run over and grabbing my "bunny doggy" by his scruff and hugging him, that his behaviour around small, over excited children, and older people with walking frames, is much calmer and patient than anyone might expect. But I don't trust that, ever. I tell people he is friendly but is also very 'bouncy' and has a head like a brick, and isn't afraid to use it. But I can't discourage all contact as he, and the people who just want to lunge at him and pet him, need to learn better manners.

As has been said lots of times here, it isn't always the dog breed, it is the owners, the care taken in early socialisation.

Many dogs like mine were a year old when covid hit. He is now 3 and I am back trying to socialise with people and dogs. It takes time, awareness and never taking your eye off levels of excitement, tension etc.

Sadly not all people do that. Not just bull type or big dog owners. But all sorts of smaller dogs too. Nobody needs to be bothered by a dog, ever.

Turningpurple · 27/03/2022 09:03

@Whatafustercluck

People keep talking about 'these dogs are bred for fighting'. The American Bully XL is not. The aggressiveness has been purposely bred out of them to make them suitable family dogs, and good with children. Which rather indicates that it's the way they're raised that makes or breaks them. Get a KC registered puppy, love it, train it, integrate and socialise it. Don't get an adult dog, of any kind, without knowing their history, off Facebay. As I said, I'd be wary of rescue dogs for this reason, many have behavioural issues and do not make good family pets where they have access to young children.
No one can say 'aggression is bred out'.

They are also known to be protective. How are they protective if if they have no aggression. How does a dog protect something, if it has no ability to be aggressive?

It may say its true on Google. Doesn't make up true.

Its the most ridiculous statement. And why would a family need a dog of that size and power? Why would anyone pick that dog and go 'oh yeah,etc spend years and years breeding aggression out to they can eventually be family dogs'

tabulahrasa · 27/03/2022 08:55

I’m going to use Rottweilers as an example because it’s a breed I’m familiar with.

The job they’re bred for no longer exists, people don’t need a dog who can guard and round up cows and then pull them on a wagon to market.

So that leaves, sports, showing, pets and random people who want them as an ego boost. With rotties the latter isn’t that many as they’re not currently the fashionable choice.

So you have a split in the breed between show like and “working” line (I mean, it’s just a different type of show, but that’s what they call it).

Show line rotties are bred to not just look good enough to win a show, but also be quite happy to be at a show and be handled by strangers while being judged. So the ones that don’t end up in the show ring make good pets for most owners, they’re still too active and need a lot more engagement than some people are prepared to put in, but with the wrong owner it’s just fairly normal dog issues, bad recall because everything else is more exciting, chewing the house because they’re bored.

“Working” line though, they’re very different - they’re bred for drive and willngness to do bite work, as pets, with the right owner, not inherently an issue if someone is directing that drive into agility or putting in a huge level of training. In the wrong owners hands they are more of a risk of serious behavioural issues, but mostly, people who have one know they have one and are doing appropriate stuff with it.

If you took those dogs with behavioural issues and breed them together because you want a hard dog Hmm then treat them in a way that develops the issues then you’ve got a dangerous dog. That’s what’s happening with bull breeds.

RubyFruitSunday · 27/03/2022 08:52

I don't understand why anyone would want an animal in their house that could completely overpower them if it wanted to. I have a dog, I'm a dog lover but my spaniel is small (12kg) with a soft mouth and if I needed to I could easily fend him off. I couldn't say the same for something like a bully/staffy/rottie/mastiff/alsation etc... so I just wouldn't have one.

Anyone who says they 100% trust their dog not to snap are deluded - any dog can get unwell or spooked by something and act out of character.

My dog is very soft and friendly but no chance would I leave him alone with my baby.

So tragic for this little girl and her family.

Whatafustercluck · 27/03/2022 08:51

People keep talking about 'these dogs are bred for fighting'. The American Bully XL is not. The aggressiveness has been purposely bred out of them to make them suitable family dogs, and good with children. Which rather indicates that it's the way they're raised that makes or breaks them. Get a KC registered puppy, love it, train it, integrate and socialise it. Don't get an adult dog, of any kind, without knowing their history, off Facebay. As I said, I'd be wary of rescue dogs for this reason, many have behavioural issues and do not make good family pets where they have access to young children.

Turningpurple · 27/03/2022 08:42

But you can’t identify them particularly from ones that are bred to have a stable temperament and if you ban them, guaranteed they’ll just move on to other breeds.

Think we are talking about 2 different things.

I was posting in response to someone saying its not about the breed as they were attacked by a retriever.

I am saying its both breeder and owner. I am not talking about what should be done.

Just that I don't believe we can pretend the breed has nothing to do with it

tabulahrasa · 27/03/2022 08:30

“They've been breed aggressively for fighting for generations it becomes instinct similar to other breeds”

Except it’s not dogs bred for fighting though, they’re bred so that someone can pull them out mid fight and stitch them up.

It’s dogs that are bred literally just to look and act dangerous, with no actual purpose other than ego of people.

“In which case those breeds/breed subsets are suitable as family pets or even pets.”

But you can’t identify them particularly from ones that are bred to have a stable temperament and if you ban them, guaranteed they’ll just move on to other breeds.

Turningpurple · 27/03/2022 08:21

@tabulahrasa

“So why is it certain breeds again and again.”

Because there are subsets of those breed types that are bred to be aggressive by shitty breeders, then treated in a way that encourages that trait by shitty owners.

People aren’t doing that with other types of dog.

In which case those breeds/breed subsets are suitable as family pets or even pets.

Thats my point. Its not just down to owner behaviour its also down to the breed/ breed subset.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 27/03/2022 08:18

Because there are subsets of those breed types that are bred to be aggressive by shitty breeders, then treated in a way that encourages that trait by shitty owners.
They've been breed aggressively for fighting for generations it becomes instinct similar to other breeds that were breeding for specific jobs they're instincts will kick in when the situation presents without intense training to do otherwise.

The size and weight added makes it a killer.

tabulahrasa · 27/03/2022 08:06

“So why is it certain breeds again and again.”

Because there are subsets of those breed types that are bred to be aggressive by shitty breeders, then treated in a way that encourages that trait by shitty owners.

People aren’t doing that with other types of dog.

Turningpurple · 27/03/2022 06:52

However had that been a small child who he'd attacked they wouldn't of stood a chance is my point.

And yet, retrievers aren't killing kids. If it's ever happened it's rare. They have the ability to. But it doesn't happen.

Surely that doesn't support its ALL based on the owner. There's plenty of irresponsible owners about with all sorts of dogs. So why is it certain breeds again and again.

If it was down to just irresponsible owners, it would a wider range of breeds.

anotherbloodyyearofcovid · 27/03/2022 06:52

@Mumofsend

I think anyone buying a random dog off the Internet, as an adult aged dog, and mixing it with a 17 month old child is at best naive and at worst dangerous.

However, the parents have paid the most devastating price. They don't need the world to tell them they should never have bought the dog, they will hate themselves for the rest of their lives for doing so.

Don't beat people at the worst point in their lives

Shouldn't think the parents of the child mauled to death will be reading this.

People can say what they want about mad dogs and don't need to be censored by you and what you imagine others might be thinking.

NCLsim1990 · 27/03/2022 06:35

@Turningpurple
Yes my nephew was an adult fortunately, it was actually his dog which then turned on him.
However had that been a small child who he'd attacked they wouldn't of stood a chance is my point.
I've always had Rottweilers personally and I can say out of all 4 not once has any of them shown signs or hints of aggression.
Since my last Rottweiler had to be put to sleep due to illness & age, I haven't been able to get another dog my boy took my last heartstring. I don't like seeing certain breeds being attacked on these kinds of posts because in the right hands with responsible owners any dog can be part of a family; and make for a fantastic family pet.

Turningpurple · 27/03/2022 06:23

@NCLsim1990

A family retriever tried taking my arm off! Nothing to do with breeds. He gave no warning & had never previously attacked. I was that shocked I refused for him to be taken & destroyed but 2 years later he bite my nephews lips off; should of been destroyed after the first incident.
Why was the dog around your nephew? I assume he was an adult? The owners make the ultimate decision about keeping/rehoming through a reputable rescue or destroying.

Both incidents sound horrifying. But as it didn't kill you or your nephew, you have proved the point that most people are saying.

If this had happened with the dog, in this and many other cases these dogs are more likey to kill. No one is saying other breeds dont attack or dont cause damage to people.

NCLsim1990 · 27/03/2022 06:18

A family retriever tried taking my arm off! Nothing to do with breeds.
He gave no warning & had never previously attacked.
I was that shocked I refused for him to be taken & destroyed but 2 years later he bite my nephews lips off; should of been destroyed after the first incident.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
sinpola · 27/03/2022 06:17

@Turningpurple that's just unimaginable, really horrifying 😭

Turningpurple · 27/03/2022 06:02

@sinpola

Did they adopt this dog or buy from a friend kind of thing. Because I don't see how this dog was placed in a house with a young child so easily , a reputable adoption wouldn't have allowed this
I would guess its highly likely it was purchased. Probably through FB groups/pets4homes/gumtree etc

Just like the dog that killed Jack Lis was. While selling on FB isn't allowed it happens all the time. The dogs groups I am in are very quick to delete posts trying to sell dogs or puppies. But after Jack was killed, I looked at a few FB pages regarding this breed and people were openly selling their dogs.

The circumstances were very similar. Adult dog sold to a family and killed a child within days. Except Jack was a visiting child. He visited his friend who had been left in the house alone with the dog. I can't imagine the pain that caused Jack's family but also the boy who lived there who witnessed it all.

sinpola · 27/03/2022 05:52

@Sushi7 even a tall strong man would struggle.

Sushi7 · 27/03/2022 05:33

*turn not then

Sushi7 · 27/03/2022 05:32

@XenoBitch More people end up in A&E from being bitten by the small breeds.
I’d rather be in A&E having a few stitches than be mauled to death or have life changing injuries because I (and others around me) couldn’t prise a super strong beast of a dog away. Yes, any breed can then… but unless you’re super tall and super strong and bulked out, you wouldn’t be able to prise an American Bully, Mastiff or Pit Bull from its unsuspecting victim.

sinpola · 27/03/2022 04:58

@Selena55 even the smallest dog can potentially bite a babies face so your right you can't trust any dog. But a big dog could do massive damage it isn't worth the risk. I have a big dog they are very very powerful

Swipe left for the next trending thread