Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
SamphiretheStickerist · 29/03/2022 09:21

A quick google also says that these dogs should have pronged collars!

Fuck that. No dog should have one of those barbarous devices. That's a very American frame of mind. Scare a powerful dog into submission. Hurt it if it moves wrong!

Nope!

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 29/03/2022 09:19

@user3837313202

A quick google also says that these dogs should have pronged collars! (doesnt sound like family pet to me.)

This is why Google shouldn't always be trusted.

Prong collars are a means of inflicting pain upon a dog with ease, and it's a recipe for creating a dog with issues, whatever the breed. No one with any sense - and no reputable dog trainer - thinks prong collars are a good idea.

I know what a pronged collar is............. This description is from a different site:

www.dogbreedinfo.com/a/americanbully.htm

StrawberryStarfish · 29/03/2022 08:57

Labradors can be bastards. My dog has been attacked by two different Labradors in two separate incidents

Toomanylosthours · 29/03/2022 07:42

@catgirl1976

Labs and retrievers? I honestly don’t recall any incidents of them attacking children. Is that actually true?
@catgirl... I always thought retrievers were calm dogs until my dog has recently been attacked by one.
user3837313202 · 29/03/2022 07:34

A quick google also says that these dogs should have pronged collars! (doesnt sound like family pet to me.)

This is why Google shouldn't always be trusted.

Prong collars are a means of inflicting pain upon a dog with ease, and it's a recipe for creating a dog with issues, whatever the breed. No one with any sense - and no reputable dog trainer - thinks prong collars are a good idea.

sinpola · 29/03/2022 01:41

@Strictlyfanoftenyears I love Staffies but didn't think kids would be great around them because I don't trust my own kids. They can't not annoy them and when dogs snap it's because the kids are being their annoying selves

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 28/03/2022 23:36

@hookiewookie29

I'm a childminder. I have a Staffy. The most gorgeous, laid back, adorable dog ever. He loves the children, they love him. I don't keep them apart because he's been brought up with the children from the age of 8 weeks and they know how to behave around him. He takes himself off upstairs if he needs a bit of peace. None of the families were concerned about us getting a Staffy, in fact they were all over the moon. Most of them have, or have had, dogs. One family have a nephew who had his cheek biten off by a Jack Russell. Another has 2 rescue Greyhounds who have to be muzzled. We chose a puppy so he was brought up with my job. Wr would never have considered a rescue dog with the job I have.We had a Staffy years ago and she was fab with our own children when they were young. I hate the bad press Staffies get. When we're out walking he goes off his lead and never bothers with other dogs at all, but we have many dogs who won't leave him alone. It's alright all these people saying " oh, she was bitten by a poodle but it's ok....." No it's not ok- its a dog bite. It would be a whole different story if it was a Bull terrier breed....
Wow, I had no idea that childminders would be allowed to have the dog mix with other peoples children.
Strictlyfanoftenyears · 28/03/2022 23:34

@Whatafustercluck

Incidentally, the dog described in this incident was not in fact a breed bred for fighting. Instead it is a breed that has had the aggressiveness purposely bred out of it to make them docile family pets. A quick Google reveals a temperament that is exactly the kind of character that fits in well with family life - playful, affectionate, soft etc.

I suspect this dog, like many others of all varieties, may have had behavioural problems due to how it's been handled and raised. I don't think the family owned it from a puppy, and this is one reason why I'd hesitate to get a rescue dog as a family pet.

It's not the breed, it's how they've been handled. Staffies have a terrible reputation but are nicknamed the nanny dog due to how great they are with children. I've met many wonderful staffies and always make a big fuss of them, they're so full of character. But would I get an adult.one from a rescue centre? Not in a million years.

A quick google also says that these dogs should have pronged collars! (doesnt sound like family pet to me.)
LexMitior · 28/03/2022 22:18

well its possible to care about both, but its still a mystery to me why anyone would decide that they needed a dog in their house that had the ability to crush a child's head in its jaws in one. The injuries from these deaths are horrific - perhaps if parents understood just how powerful these dogs are, they might not be so bloody negligent.

Questiontellme · 28/03/2022 22:15

Ahhh yes there's always something worse isn't there @user3837313202 stunning use of Wikipedia 👌. Absolutely pointless argument.

user3837313202 · 28/03/2022 22:13

@Questiontellme

www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hereford-worcester-60907487.amp

More fur babies doing what they do best and ripping kids to shreds. That's 4 (there was the fatal attack by the Husky on a 3 month old in Woodhall Spa a few weeks ago). It's just too awful, it has to stop. I don't know how people can go on defending dogs.

In roughly the same way as people go on defending the use of cars. Except in that case it's adult humans using a piece of machinery that obeys their every command and still they screw it up.

On average, every week, one child dies and 37 are seriously injured in a road traffic collision. That's 52 per year, 520 per decade, killed by people driving cars.

According to the wikipedia page linked to by PP, in the decade 2010-2019 there were 13 child deaths involving dogs.

Your child is forty times more likely to be killed by a car driver than a dog.

If you are truly concerned about child deaths and serious injuries, then you'd be much better off campaigning for road safety measures than dog safety measures.

LexMitior · 28/03/2022 22:00

@DarcyBlue

Why aren't the parents prosecuted in instances like these?
They should be - and can be.

If every person who had a dog that bit people was prosecuted and banned from owning animals it would go a long way to sorting the problems that exist.

user3837313202 · 28/03/2022 21:53

I'm a third person whose dog didn't cope with KC Good Citizen classes. A young undersocialised rescue, me flying by the seat of my pants with my first ever dog and an instructor who was (with hindsight) doing lots of things wrong. In particular there were dogs of all ages mixed in with young puppies, and one dog-reactive dog who just wasn't coping.

Mine used to manage about the first 20 minutes, then bark any time another dog got near him. I didn't realise until a long time later that he was resource guarding his "territory" (i.e. his corner of the church hall).

In the end he didn't pass his bronze Good Citizen test because he didn't like his paws being touched. What I shouldn't have done (but did) was to try it anyway; he snapped, which was really my fault. There was no support with how to help him feel more comfortable with his paws being touched, and with hindsight it was far too early anyway - 6 months in and he'd only just learned to cope with being picked up, and was only occasionally seeking physical affection from me.

The silver test has the rather bizarre requirement of the dog getting in and out of a car in an orderly manner. At that point in our lives we were living in inner London, I didn't own a car, and I doubt DDog had ever actually been in a car! What would actually have been relevant would have been having public transport as an alternative form of assessment - he was great on the tube!

Good Citizen has the inherent problem of being very goal orientated - they don't mind how you get there (in terms of training methods) so long as you get there... even when it's counterproductive overall.

It's a scheme which is fine for people who have dogs that are reasonably well balanced in the first place and need some life skills. They're the sort of dogs that might jump up at a stranger in the park if undertrained, but would be highly unlikely to deliver a serious bite, much less kill a child. It does absolutely nothing for those dogs which are starting to develop, or have already developed, significant behavioural problems.

Now, what I could support would be a system where anyone getting a dog had to undergo some training, consisting of

  • before getting the dog - 4 hours of theory classes, covering things like how dogs learn, effect of diet on behaviour, positive reinforcement training, dog body language, and why a dog should never be punished for growling.
  • after getting the dog - 10 weeks of dog training classes; a standard puppy class for those getting a puppy, and a more bespoke 1-2-1 class for anyone adopting a rescue dog with issues.
But while those getting puppies from semi-respectable breeders and rescue centres would find it enforced, I suspect it would be much harder to enforce for those who buy a dog on facebook / inherit their late mother's dog / get a dog from a friend who can't look after it anymore.
Questiontellme · 28/03/2022 21:51

www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hereford-worcester-60907487.amp

More fur babies doing what they do best and ripping kids to shreds. That's 4 (there was the fatal attack by the Husky on a 3 month old in Woodhall Spa a few weeks ago). It's just too awful, it has to stop. I don't know how people can go on defending dogs.

Hyenaormeercat · 28/03/2022 21:26

I would like to see something like the KC "good citizen" training scheme made compulsory for all dogs.

I wouldn't, it nearly wrecked my dog. It was far to high in excitement levels for him. Other dogs, slippy floors, lots of sitting, waiting between 'turns'. Had the trainers been any good they would have sent me away and refunded my money.

As it was another behaviourist read a facebook post I made and contacted me for a chat. She made so much sense I withdrew him from the classes and made other arrangements. The KC classes are built for bidable dogs. They don't, cannot, take dogs with very high levles of excitement, anxiety etc into account.

Same here, I took my girl to the local class, I was made to feel like shit as my girl became over stimulated and over excited. I contacted a trainer/ behaviouralist and did 1-2-1 , she is still excitable, even at 3yrs old but calming down slowly as she matures. I'm still doing 1-2-1 and small group and will continue to do so.

judgethejudgemental · 28/03/2022 19:59

Sorry my mistake, it wasn't a big bull cross, it was a Staffy according to my friend.

judgethejudgemental · 28/03/2022 19:57

Still not worth the risk, is it. There are other breeds that can't kill. Choose one of those.

I think at this rate (another dog attack in two children this weekend) this is what might be forced upon us if people can't start using their bloody heads.

Friend of mine literally today witnessed someone's JRT being shaken around like a rag doll by a large bull cross type which was off the lead. The poor JRT was on a lead and when they finally managed to get the bastard bull off , the poor JRT owner picked her up, crying her eyes and just ran for the her car to get to the vet. What did the wanker bull owner say? "risk ya take innit, walking ya dog in the park".... Wanker.

I am a Rottweiler owner and I adore her but I would sacrifice owning any breed capable of such damage (a LOT of breeds) if it ends all this misery and fear that is only going to increase. I don't care anymore for 'oh but my staff is an angel' blah blah. There are too many wankers in the world now,

tabulahrasa · 28/03/2022 13:31

@DarcyBlue

Why aren't the parents prosecuted in instances like these?
Not a legal expert but I’d imagine because they’ve already had to suffer very horrendous consequences.

Fatal attacks are actually very rare given how many dogs are owned by people. It’s not really one of those - well what did you expect to happen situations.

It is really risky to buy an adult dog from someone you don’t know. But people do it all the time and they get a dog with a hidden medical condition that’s going to cost thousands, or a dog that’s dog reactive, or chases cats or it’s not housetrained, or someone ends up with stitches... and some people luck out and get a great dog, because actually dogs are pretty blooming adaptable considering. So while it’s stupid, it’s not usually someone is going to die type of stupid and it’s perfectly legal to do.

That’s what’s pretty frustrating about the fixation on breed, the bit that should be ringing alarm bells that as a country we could do something about is stopping people buying dogs like they’re used cars or something.

DarcyBlue · 28/03/2022 11:47

Why aren't the parents prosecuted in instances like these?

Dronkey · 28/03/2022 11:23

Still not worth the risk, is it. There are other breeds that can't kill. Choose one of those.

SamphiretheStickerist · 28/03/2022 08:14

I would like to see something like the KC "good citizen" training scheme made compulsory for all dogs.

I wouldn't, it nearly wrecked my dog. It was far to high in excitement levels for him. Other dogs, slippy floors, lots of sitting, waiting between 'turns'. Had the trainers been any good they would have sent me away and refunded my money.

As it was another behaviourist read a facebook post I made and contacted me for a chat. She made so much sense I withdrew him from the classes and made other arrangements. The KC classes are built for bidable dogs. They don't, cannot, take dogs with very high levles of excitement, anxiety etc into account.

MMoon23 · 28/03/2022 06:32

@tabulahrasa

“So why is it certain breeds again and again.”

Because there are subsets of those breed types that are bred to be aggressive by shitty breeders, then treated in a way that encourages that trait by shitty owners.

People aren’t doing that with other types of dog.

Exactly this!!!!
MMoon23 · 28/03/2022 06:25

The vast majority of ‘these types’ of dogs are absolutely fine (as much as any other dog or animal would be). Staffies for example have been known to be patient and protective of children. They are a very common dog for families with no incidents.

With any child involved all dogs should be properly assessed before being brought into the home (all rescue centres do this). Buying a dog off of the internet with absolutely no idea what the history is, is very risky whatever the breed. It would never be advisable to do this.

The media perpetuates the cycle of ‘dangerous dogs’, with more dogs being bred for status and abuse, more dogs ending up suffering in rescue, increased stigma around the breed types, people not wanting to rescue them.

Dog attacks are often being attributed to staffies which is misleading. There are many breeds referred to under this umbrella and many are mixes of multiple breeds which cannot be classified as the same.

Being horrible about specific breeds is damaging and counter productive all round

Jasmin82 · 28/03/2022 01:02

Dog ownership comes with a responsibility.
A responsibility to care for the dog AND for the people and other dogs/animals your dog will come into contact with.
Far too many people get a dog with zero research into whether the dog they are getting is suitable for them/their living situation. They ignore that owning a dog is a 10+ year commitment. They want whatever is popular in their area/with their friends without considering the needs of both the dog and themselves.
Good breeders and rescues won't give one of their dogs to an unsuitable home.
Unfortunately, there are more bad breeders out there and there are, like it or not, some not so good rescues. There's one near me that is fairly notorious for not carrying out homechecks (even pre covid) and letting anyone take a dog so long as they pay money.
Legislating against the not so good rescues and bringing them into line is a fairly easy job.
However, I fear that getting rid of the bad breeders who don't health check dogs before breeding, don't do a suitability check on prospective owners or even ask questions to determine suitability so long as they get the money for the dog. Those I do worry that trying to get rid of them is potentially far too late.
The things I would like to see:

I would like to see something like the KC "good citizen" training scheme made compulsory for all dogs.

I would like to see, if not a return of dog licences, at the very least compulsory ownership classes for anyone wanting to own a dog. These classes should include information on how much it costs to own a dog, the typical life span, and that not all breeds are suitable for families. Hopefully, the classes would weed out those unsuitable to own a dog.

In addition to compulsory microchips, compulsory insurance for dogs.

There are further measures I would like to see for breeders and rescues. Good breeders and rescues will do those things already. However, I would hope that the above list would at the least reduce the bad breeders.
Whether adding more breeds to the banned breed list would work, I doubt it. I remember seeing a lot of very dubious lab crosses after pit bulls were banned. It's still a popular way of circumventing the ban of certain breeds as there's no even 50% reliable DNA test for dogs. Short of requiring all dogs to be KC registered and doing away with crosses, there's no way to prevent circumvention of a banned breed with 100% reliability. And requiring KC registration is a whole other problem.

Indoctro · 27/03/2022 22:02

@Queeen

They are high risk. That's the problem. You can't trust them. So what if there are a few good ones?
Bit more than a few , 100's of thousands in uk at the moment living happily in homes, they are very popular

12 million dogs in uk. They are the most popular breed of you take in account unregistered breeds

Swipe left for the next trending thread