Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Bjarnum · 24/03/2022 23:05

@Clymene

Yes, they are more like to be killed by their dads than dogs *@Lumpycustards*. But our goal surely should be zero children killed?

This was an entirely preventable death.I find the outpouring of sympathy for the parents is sickening. They may as well have sunk 10 pints and driven the wrong way down the M6 without using a car seat.

Agree
Cyw2018 · 24/03/2022 23:04

@Lifeisaminestrone

So it’s not the breed it’s the owner is just not a valid argument.

I have a cavalier King Charles. I chose it based on being biddable, child friendly and loving. If it showed any aggression with a child, it would be very easy for me to get the 7kg dog off.

Thankfully it hasn’t because it is a sweet dog and because it is bred to be a companion.

For the same reason, I wouldn’t get a terrier dog as while I could fend it off, it was originally bred to control vermin and temperament different to spaniels etc.

A bully dog went for me in the vets a couple of days ago. The owner told me, he was ‘friendly’ - she could barely control it on the lead. In my mind this was a wild dog, chalk and cheese to a family dog.

Totally agree with this. I don't think anyone should have a dog that they couldn't hold back if it suddenly decided to take off on the lead or pin to the floor if it 'turned'. My dog is 17kg and I wouldn't want anything bigger than that.

My dog is also a sweet dog who was neutered as soon as he was old enough (6 months).

Bjarnum · 24/03/2022 23:03

Eeksteek

It IS the breed. Labs and spaniels are bred to like being with people, to listen, to have weak mouths, to enjoy touch. Hundreds of generations of the survival of the soppiest! Fighting breeds were bred to react with aggression, to attack in a frenzy, to be wound up, to hold on with a crushing bite. If a lab snaps (generally out of fear and anxiety because it’s been poorly raised or it’s needs are not met) it snaps, and then runs away to safety, or can be pulled off. It will let go if hurt. It snaps in its own defence, because it doesn’t have hundreds of generations of being bred to strengthen its desire and ability to fight and attack. Fighting breeds have a much higher chance of reacting like this, and a much higher risk of causing terrible injuries if they do. It’s not their fault, and good training and a healthy environment can certainly produce good individual dogs. But that isn’t the same as saying they don’t a higher risk of killing or maiming as a breed.

Genes load the gun. The environment only pulls the trigger. Labs etc come with rubber bullets and safety catches. Fighting breeds are armour piercing rounds with hair triggers. The might not fire, but they kill if they do. All dogs can be dangerous, but big powerful, fighting dogs are the most dangerous, most often. Having one at all is quite a responsibility, but having one around a child is an unacceptable risk snd should absolutely have to consequences to stop other people taking the same risks. It’s what we do with any other child neglect, to deter other parents from making the same poor parenting decisions. The parents would face charges if the child had been accidentally killed or injured by any other weapon, because weapons shouldn’t be near children.

Excellent post.

Agree - excellent post

Indoctro · 24/03/2022 23:02

Worst I see was a young child who was in the surgical ward when my son was there, his face had been ripped open by a miniature poodle. It was a horrendous state and he definitely was going to be left badly scarred. He was just over 2 years old.

Jonny1265 · 24/03/2022 23:02

@Eeksteek

It IS the breed. Labs and spaniels are bred to like being with people, to listen, to have weak mouths, to enjoy touch. Hundreds of generations of the survival of the soppiest! Fighting breeds were bred to react with aggression, to attack in a frenzy, to be wound up, to hold on with a crushing bite. If a lab snaps (generally out of fear and anxiety because it’s been poorly raised or it’s needs are not met) it snaps, and then runs away to safety, or can be pulled off. It will let go if hurt. It snaps in its own defence, because it doesn’t have hundreds of generations of being bred to strengthen its desire and ability to fight and attack. Fighting breeds have a much higher chance of reacting like this, and a much higher risk of causing terrible injuries if they do. It’s not their fault, and good training and a healthy environment can certainly produce good individual dogs. But that isn’t the same as saying they don’t a higher risk of killing or maiming as a breed.

Genes load the gun. The environment only pulls the trigger. Labs etc come with rubber bullets and safety catches. Fighting breeds are armour piercing rounds with hair triggers. The might not fire, but they kill if they do. All dogs can be dangerous, but big powerful, fighting dogs are the most dangerous, most often. Having one at all is quite a responsibility, but having one around a child is an unacceptable risk snd should absolutely have to consequences to stop other people taking the same risks. It’s what we do with any other child neglect, to deter other parents from making the same poor parenting decisions. The parents would face charges if the child had been accidentally killed or injured by any other weapon, because weapons shouldn’t be near children.

Not sure where you get this from. Labs are working dogs and have a high bite strength, similar to a German Shepherd and pit bull. Also they can be aggressive. I have a lab who is well trained but he is an alpha male and is aggressive as far as labs go. He responds perfectly to me and my family but I wouldn't leave him with anyone whom I hadn't socialised around him. I've had far more passive rottweilers.
caecilius1 · 24/03/2022 23:02

@Eeksteek
Are you joking re Akita's jaw strength? Confused
An Akita's jaw strength is equivalent to a bull mastiff / cane corsa. There's a reason they're the drug dealer's dog of choice.

Clymene · 24/03/2022 23:00

Yes, they are more like to be killed by their dads than dogs @Lumpycustards. But our goal surely should be zero children killed?

This was an entirely preventable death.I find the outpouring of sympathy for the parents is sickening. They may as well have sunk 10 pints and driven the wrong way down the M6 without using a car seat.

SevenWaystoLeave · 24/03/2022 22:58

I work with dogs. I've never worked with a dog that was involved in a fatality, fortunately, since these are very rare, but the most serious bites I've personally known of or been involved with were:

A basset hound whose owner needed skin grafts after the dog mauled her arm.

A springer spaniel who severed two fingers from its owners hand.

A Labrador who left a child's face permanently disfigured.

Studies show recurring factors in serious and fatal dog attacks are to do with owner behaviour, not breed. Breed specific legislation is a failed concept, it does not protect the public, and it's a huge waste of resources spent targeting dogs which will never cause a problem in their life just because of how they look, and abjectly fails to effectively tackle dogs which are actually dangerous.

In the UK, the way dogs are determined to be illegal is via a tape measure. If it fits a certain set of measurements, it's illegal. If not, it isn't. A dog whose parents are known to be legal breeds can fit the measurements and so be deemed a "pit bull" and illegal. In a litter of puppies, some can be deemed "pit bull types" and so illegal and some not, even though they have the exact same parentage. It's nonsensical. Clearly a dog isn't more or less dangerous because the distance from the ground to the top of its shoulders is or isn't the same as the distance from its shoulder to its hip. But this is one of the measures they use to decide if a dog is illegal or not. It's a farce. It doesn't protect people, it just focuses resources in entirely the wrong direction.

What actually reduces dog bites is education for owners and particularly for parents who own dogs, and effective early interventions where a dog is showing problem behaviour but before it has escalated (it is extremely rare for a fatality to be the first incident a dog has ever had). But there's no interest in putting effective legislation in place because targeting so-called pit bulls is a crowd pleaser, an easy way to pretend something is being done when nothing is being done.

whenwillthemadnessend · 24/03/2022 22:57

I knew immediately on hearing this tragic story it would be a XL bully breed

So sad to have it confirmed in the news.

I saw a pup XL bully in my vets a few months ago. Owner was getting it weighed and the pup weighed 25kilos at only 4 months old. That's the same weight as my 2 year old male lab cross who has himself once pulled me over going for a squirrel. My boy is strong and I dread to think what that pup will be like fully grown.

No chance of ever stopping an attack.

Indoctro · 24/03/2022 22:57

@Cyw2018

One of my neighbours has a young intact male English bull terrier, we live very rurally surrounded by fields full of livestock (sheep, cattle, and horses including foals).

It was a very sweet and playful puppy, but is now fully grown, and I am not the only dog walker in my area who is very wary of it. I will certainly be turning the other way to avoid it when out with my dog and/or DD.

It is just not necessary to have these extremely powerful breads that have historically been bred to be dangerous, and certainly not to keep males intact past 6 months when it is possible to castrate them.

@Cyw2018 you do realise neutering dogs is the biggest cause of fear aggression in male dogs..?

A un-neutered male dog is way less likely to fight than a neutered male.

Also neutered males will often attack unneutered males, down to fear.

toomuchlaundry · 24/03/2022 22:54

I can’t understand why anyone would have such strong dogs with small children.

TheGrinchsDog · 24/03/2022 22:53

@RobertaFirmino

Well Jack Russells are nasty, yappy little fuckers but *@Justgorgeous* was asking about Labradors - who seem to be very placid.

FWIW, the parents really do not need all the finger pointing. They found out the hard way.

Labs are in the top of these lists because yes they sometimes do bite/ can be aggressive. Because they are so popular - every 2nd owner seems to have a lab for eg - obviously that tips the scales a bit coz there's more labs around to possibly bite. So you get a high number of bites by Labrador reported.

I've actually known a few aggressive Labs, obviously it wasn't their fault but people just assume they are great family dogs - and mostly they are! But they need what all dogs need, training and socialisation and to never be left unsupervised with children.

This is so so sad but IMO it's down not to breed as such but human error I always think.

My dog is a big boy, he's a mixed breed. He adores children and was raised in a house with 2 little boys who were really quite rough and tumble with him.

I 'know' he's good with children, I know he's never even growled even when provoked but I still wouldn't leave him alone with a child.

I wouldn't even if he was a Chihuahua! Anyone ever been bitten by a Chi? It's not fun!

Any dog has the capacity to do serious damage, bigger dogs have the capacity to do greater damage faster. It's the human's responsibility to train/socialise dogs and to never leave children alone or unsupervised with them.

In my experience of bull mixes/ staffy/ rottie/ boxer dogs etc they have all been great with children and generally giant softies but their owners were all very switched on people and this makes all the difference.

So so sad.

Sinuhe · 24/03/2022 22:53

We had a "biter" when I was growing up ... the dog was eventually put down, but not before giving a fair few family members various scars.
The final straw was when the dog bit someone's index finger off. Now, I was only around 8 when it happened, but I still remember it like it was yesterday.

Dog was a pure breed Whippet, the person who lost the finger was my uncle who just brushed passed the dog in our garden. So totally unprovoked, the dog knew my uncle as he visited regularly.

My point being, no dog is 100% safe and all dogs can cause lasting damage!

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/03/2022 22:51

However, based on the number of child homicides recorded by the police each year, we know that, on average, at least one child is killed a week in the UK
Awful.
No-one is denying some adults are vicious - there has been a lot of DM'S responsible for murdering their DC over the last few years.
I'm always more stunned when it is a woman.

DaffTheDoggo · 24/03/2022 22:50

@FungalLurkins

It is worth remembering just how rare fatal dog attacks are. There are 12.5 million dogs in the UK (according to Google) and there have been roughly 3 fatal attacks per year in the last seven years. There are roughly 33 million men in the UK and there are 600 homicides per year, as roughly 92% of perpetrators are male, we can call that 550.

So the odds of a man killing are 550/33000000 = 0.00001666666

Odds of dog killing 3/12000000 = 0.00000024

Both tiny odds but the dogs odds are a whole two zeros more infinitesimal.

So on average a man is about 50 times more likely to kill someone than a dog is.

Not saying we should ban men btw but just trying to highlight how bad humans are at rational risk perception.

The whole point of this thread is to make the point that some breeds are significantly more likely to kill you than others. Suddenly switching to total numbers for all dogs is entirely misleading. The relevant number is the proportion of people who have one of these breeds who end up being killed by their dog or it killing someone else.
WetLookKnitwear · 24/03/2022 22:46

I don’t let any kind of dog near my baby. legal or not they are beasts with instincts.

The problem is people personify their pets, even “sensible” well-to-do adults. They talk about them like they’re children and forget that they’re animals.

Nobodycarestakeitelsewhere · 24/03/2022 22:46

@Eeksteek

It IS the breed. Labs and spaniels are bred to like being with people, to listen, to have weak mouths, to enjoy touch. Hundreds of generations of the survival of the soppiest! Fighting breeds were bred to react with aggression, to attack in a frenzy, to be wound up, to hold on with a crushing bite. If a lab snaps (generally out of fear and anxiety because it’s been poorly raised or it’s needs are not met) it snaps, and then runs away to safety, or can be pulled off. It will let go if hurt. It snaps in its own defence, because it doesn’t have hundreds of generations of being bred to strengthen its desire and ability to fight and attack. Fighting breeds have a much higher chance of reacting like this, and a much higher risk of causing terrible injuries if they do. It’s not their fault, and good training and a healthy environment can certainly produce good individual dogs. But that isn’t the same as saying they don’t a higher risk of killing or maiming as a breed.

Genes load the gun. The environment only pulls the trigger. Labs etc come with rubber bullets and safety catches. Fighting breeds are armour piercing rounds with hair triggers. The might not fire, but they kill if they do. All dogs can be dangerous, but big powerful, fighting dogs are the most dangerous, most often. Having one at all is quite a responsibility, but having one around a child is an unacceptable risk snd should absolutely have to consequences to stop other people taking the same risks. It’s what we do with any other child neglect, to deter other parents from making the same poor parenting decisions. The parents would face charges if the child had been accidentally killed or injured by any other weapon, because weapons shouldn’t be near children.

Yes to all of this. Well said.
Eeksteek · 24/03/2022 22:46

@Indoctro

Labs do kill kids.. a quick Google throws up plenty ... everything fro JRT up can kill a baby or child.

An inquest docket is being investigated by Oudtshoorn police after a little boy was mauled to death by the family dog on Saturday.
Police spokesperson Captain Malcolm Pojie said four-year-old Peter Frans died in hospital shortly after being bitten by the Labrador shortly before 10 pm.

Two-month-old Aiden McGrew was in a baby swing inside his Ridgeville, South Carolina, home when the family dog, Lucky, mauled him. The Golden Retriever/Labrador mix pulled Aiden from the swing and tore off the child's legs. Aiden's father was sleeping while the vicious attack took place, and the boy's mother found his body when she returned home. Aidan was rushed to the hospital where he was pronounced dead.

The plural of anecdote is not data. Fighting breeds kill more people (per dog out there) and are therefore more dangerous. It’s their purpose.

In my opinion, having a dog in the house with a child is not an unacceptable risk that should be managed by the state. Having a fighting dog is and should be. It’s not an unforeseeable tragedy if a child is killed by a fighting dog. It’s completely predictable and if individuals won’t keep their children safe by not having weaponised breeds around them, the state should step in and legislate to prevent it, and prosecute to deter others from doing so. I’m sure the parents concerned thought the child wasn’t at risk and are devastated. That only gives to show that the risk should be managed by someone better able to assess it, doesn’t it?

Fairisleflora · 24/03/2022 22:45

In my opinion that call Staffie a nanny dog are just totally obscene. How thick can you get? It’s the breed AND the owners that adds up to dead children. Ok so a lab has very rarely killed a child, but bull terriers kill kids regularly. I would no sooner have a staffie in my house for my kids to play with than I would an AK47.

AllOfUsAreDead · 24/03/2022 22:44

@Justgorgeous

When has a lab killed a child ?
www.news24.com/amp/you/archive/little-boy-killed-by-family-labrador-in-horror-attack-20170728

No dog breed can be relied upon to be placid. None. They all have instincts, they must be trained, they must be kept under control and in safe environments. What happened to that family is tragic, no need to blame them. Pretty sure they don't need more of that.

Lumpycustards · 24/03/2022 22:44

By humans that is

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/03/2022 22:43

I'll probably get a right bashing for this but I'd take a punt they'd be less children killed by dogs if dogs were banned entirely from social and council housing.

Are you implying the DC and adults killed in the last decade were from council estates?
The last children whom come to mind in Ireland were both from middle families.

Articles below.

I'd link the savage attacks on sheep too but this thread is about DC however I'll assure you there isn't anythings run down in these areas.

www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/boy-who-died-after-being-attacked-by-rottweilers-named-locally-1.4210888#:~:text=A%20seven%2Dyear%2Dold%20boy,owned%20by%20the%20boy%27s%20family.

www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/locals-express-shock-after-baby-girl-killed-by-dog-in-waterford-village-1.4586480

Lumpycustards · 24/03/2022 22:43

However, based on the number of child homicides recorded by the police each year, we know that, on average, at least one child is killed a week in the UK

Published: December 2021

Lumpycustards · 24/03/2022 22:42

@Clymene

The point on the (badly written) number of deaths is that kids aren't 50 times more likely to be killed by people than dogs.
They are more likely to be killed by humans?

learning.nspcc.org.uk/research-resources/statistics-briefings/child-deaths-abuse-neglect/

Indoctro · 24/03/2022 22:37

The one breed I don't trust around my kids especially is Labrador's.

My dog has been attacked twice by off the lead labs.

My neighbour has a chocolate lab which growled at another neighbours kids when they walked past it on the street.

My friend who has two boys the same age as me, has a lab and he growled at one of me kids even though he lives with kids

This so called family breed makes me nervous around kids. I definitely wouldn't own one.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
Swipe left for the next trending thread