Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
XelaM · 24/03/2022 23:30

@Indoctro "Staffies are slowly but surely no longer the breed being blamed .. there days of been targeted by the media are over and the new dog is now XL Bully and American bull dogs.

Soon Staffies will join the GSD, Doberman etc that used to be the dangerous dogs."

ALL these breeds you mention are bloody dangerous and if any of them decide to attack, a human does not stand a chance. Also add Rottweilers to that list.

What's the point in having a dog that is much more powerful than you and that you stand no chance of controlling if it flips?!

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 24/03/2022 23:30

Were not we're

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 24/03/2022 23:30

That seems to be saying they're the perfect family dog and we're bred as such. They do look scary Confused

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 24/03/2022 23:28

Just found this on the internet fenrircanineleaders.com/blogs/fenrir-canine-blog/everything-you-need-to-know-about-xl-american-bully-puppies

montysma1 · 24/03/2022 23:27

It is both.

Yes a badly trained Yorkie is a nippy little shit. But it they don't kill people. Bull breeds do. Regularly.
These breeds are weapons bought as weird status symbols by idiots.

Indoctro · 24/03/2022 23:27

@teaandtoastwithmarmite

I agree but my friend at school grew up with two Staffies and they were lovely. Se as DH and his three siblings grew up with one. It's the owner not the dog.
Staffies are slowly but surely no longer the breed being blamed .. there days of been targeted by the media are over and the new dog is now XL Bully and American bull dogs.

Soon Staffies will join the GSD, Doberman etc that used to be the dangerous dogs.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 24/03/2022 23:26

@Changeymcgee

They can be super family dogs in the same way that any other breed can be. However, like every other breed, they need training and socialising (particularly when they are young).

It's not the dogs that are the issue, it's the owners! Sadly, most large and trainable breeds are at higher risk of being used as a status symbol and this is what is happening with bullies and similar.

I have a part bred xl Bully, he also has neo, cane corso and alapaha in him. He's an utter lummox. We made sure, from the moment we got him at 12 weeks, that he was trained and that he was well socialised. We also had firm ground rules with our child in terms of how you behave around a dog. I think this is often forgotten.

I have a part bred xl Bully, he also has neo, cane corso and alapaha in him. He's an utter lummox. We made sure, from the moment we got him at 12 weeks, that he was trained and that he was well socialised. We also had firm ground rules with our child in terms of how you behave around a dog. I think this is often forgotten.

What does neo, cane etc mean? Intrigued why you bought this breed in particular?

XelaM · 24/03/2022 23:25

American XL bullies are MASSIVE. Really HUGE. They are as broad as a good-sized coffee table and although I think they are cute from afar, only a crazy person could think this was a good family breed. They are so strong! Basically a shorter (but broader) version of an American Pitt Bull. I know crazy people claim that Pitt Bulls are also family-friendly, but it's absolute crap. What is the point in having a dog in your home that is much stronger than you and that you cannot overpower if it decided to attack?! It's total madness.

My (very robust) 12-year-old was knocked off her feet when a (to be fair) friendly American XL Bully jumped up at her to say "hello". They are such powerful dogs.

We have a very friendly toy breed and I can be 100% sure that I am stronger than him and that should he decide to bite, it is not going to be life-threatening. With XL Bullies you really can't be sure of anything

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 24/03/2022 23:24

I agree but my friend at school grew up with two Staffies and they were lovely. Se as DH and his three siblings grew up with one. It's the owner not the dog.

SevenWaystoLeave · 24/03/2022 23:22

I have never heard of a Belgian Shepherd or a Malinois or a Dutchie attacking a child. I'd be interested to know why you think they are "far more dangerous" as we have one

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7874237/Woman-45-mauled-death-pet-Malinois-Swiss-dog-training-centre.html

The reason you don't often hear of bites from malis or dutch shepherds is that they're not particularly common breeds to own as pets. Doesn't mean they don't or can't bite. I've worked with quite a few malis, I would never ever recommend them as a breed to have around children. They're not nicknamed Maligators for no reason.

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 23:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

ramabanana · 24/03/2022 23:17

If you can understand that you couldn't train out the instincts of a wild animal to keep it safely in a domestic setting, then you should realise it's the same for these dog breeds which have had years of time/effort/money behind increasing strength, aggression and have them attack in a way which makes them more likely to kill.

The same level of effort has not been made to put 'friendliness' back into these breeds to the level of lap and other companion dogs.

1 child's (or adult's) death as a result of people having a saviour complex for dangerous breeds, ignorance of the dangers they pose, or simply wanting a 'dangerous dog' is 1 too many.

dfendyr · 24/03/2022 23:14

I kept my cat away from my newborns!! (More of a fear of suffocation but still)

CanIPleaseHaveOne · 24/03/2022 23:12

@Calandor

XL bully's are very scary looking and often poorly bred but I have met some lovely well trained ones. As always it's the owner usually.

But, they are massive especially their jaw and they are muscular and bred to be 'status' dogs more often than not. I'm not a fan personally.

Stop gaslighting with the As always it's the owner usually.

One look at that dog and you know who bred it, why they bred it, and who wants it.

Lumpycustards · 24/03/2022 23:11

@caecilius1 are you maxfax? I am surprised at this. It’s not my experience.

Indoctro · 24/03/2022 23:11

@Eeksteek I agree , dogs living with kids doesn't make them kid friendly

I have a dog and when any child visits my house my dog is locked away. I do not allow kids to play with my dog or be around my dog

Unfortunately others are so sensible. Hence how my child was growled at in a friends, luckily I was there and made my kid aware to stay away from the dog. I would never allow my kids to go to that house without me though now.

Please if you have children visiting your home, separate your dogs from them. Dogs don't need to mix with other peoples kids / ever.

LunaMuffinTop · 24/03/2022 23:11

I have 2 staffie Jack Russel cross dogs they are lovely and as soft as anything they are brilliant with my niece but just because they are lovely and soft doesn’t mean I would leave them unattended with a baby/child being soft doesn’t change the fact that they could snap even the kindest of dog could bite someone.

Lumpycustards · 24/03/2022 23:10

@caecilius1

Having sutured back together a lot of lips /faces post dog-bite; the common denominator in babies, kids & adults alike was usually Rottweilers.
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/dog-breed-most-likely-to-attack-bite-you-revealed-a7166296.html
CanIPleaseHaveOne · 24/03/2022 23:09

@Unsurprised456

It’s the upbringing not the breed
Just stop.
Lumpycustards · 24/03/2022 23:08

@Clymene

Yes, they are more like to be killed by their dads than dogs *@Lumpycustards*. But our goal surely should be zero children killed?

This was an entirely preventable death.I find the outpouring of sympathy for the parents is sickening. They may as well have sunk 10 pints and driven the wrong way down the M6 without using a car seat.

I was querying your representation of statistics. On average over ten years, one child is killed a year by a dog and 52 by humans. That is excluding all car accidents, deaths in the home, fires etc which could be attributed to negligence.

Your attempt to gaslight me by inferring that I have no interest in minimising child deaths is not working here.
This is not dogs, it’s always humans. These dogs are not bred properly, not exercised, not trained, not stimulated.

It’s nothing to do with rescues either, I am sick of the cockerpoo brigade implying that their buying a puppy farmed dog is more responsible than rescuing.
Most people involved in rescue are a lot more knowledgeable than your fool who spends 1k on a dog from a breeder.

Planetbippop · 24/03/2022 23:07

I think the issue in this case is, not enough checks undertaken into the owners or the history of the dog. How do you buy a dog & then the owners need to be tracked down 🤔

For me, I cannot get my head around how a dog that's only be known for a week, was around a child of this age. A truly heartbreaking outcome.

caecilius1 · 24/03/2022 23:06

Having sutured back together a lot of lips /faces post dog-bite; the common denominator in babies, kids & adults alike was usually Rottweilers.

Eeksteek · 24/03/2022 23:06

@Indoctro

The one breed I don't trust around my kids especially is Labrador's.

My dog has been attacked twice by off the lead labs.

My neighbour has a chocolate lab which growled at another neighbours kids when they walked past it on the street.

My friend who has two boys the same age as me, has a lab and he growled at one of me kids even though he lives with kids

This so called family breed makes me nervous around kids. I definitely wouldn't own one.

Dogs are supposed to growl! They are telling you something. It’s a GOOD thing. Dogs who growl and are listened to and have their wishes respected are much less likely to bite. It’s not aggression, it’s just talking. Usually it means ‘I’m unsure and I need space’. Usually, us clueless humans don’t give it to them. We get in their space, and tell them off for growling which frightens them. Then they nip. For dogs, this is still not aggression - it’s completely normal for dogs to nip each other, but they should be taught as puppies it’s not appropriate for humans. But, if people respected the growl, the dog wouldn’t have escalated to nipping’. A dog that nips (when it could badly bite you if it wanted) is still holding back and just trying to get you out of its space. Which doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be managed, just that it’s not the ‘Aggressive dog red flag’ people think. Just because a dog is used to it’s own family doesn’t mean it will automatically love every kid, or more kids than usual. Lots of dogs are really threatened by change, and kids are loud and boisterous and can’t read signals before a growl, like eye rolling and nose licking. (Lots of adults don’t either)

These are very common issues with dogs and prime examples of why people can get hurt because they aren’t good at reading dogs behaviour and unitemtionally hinder a dogs ability to be a good dog.

dottiedodah · 24/03/2022 23:06

Sadly this couple had an error of judgement. They must be suffering terribly. Obv some dogs are more fierce than others .lab attacks slim .Staffin or husky types more prevalent. Do not leave young children alone with dogs.

marvellousmaple · 24/03/2022 23:06

@WiddlinDiddling

None of the breeds should be banned, anyone thinking that is absolutely utterly ignorant.

Not because I think some of these breeds are fluffy love-bugs who wouldn't hurt a fly, but because banning a breed INSTANTLY makes it much more desirable to the very people who should not have any dog at all - and of course, it pushes others to invent similar breeds they can easily cause to be dangerous to fuel their own egos.

the American Bully /XL bully/Toadline Bully etc etc, all came out of the pitbull ban, as dogs that were/are/probably (given the state of our law..) legal to own, that lend their owner some sort of kudos for having a muscle bound fat-headed dog they can parade around the streets and act macho over.

There are others you likely won't see, the Gull-Terr, the Bully Kutta, and then theres the one folk are less likely to recognise as a problem - the Akitas and Belgian Shepherds that are IMO far more dangerous, being owned by people who want to play at protection 'sports'...

The problem is as it has always been - some people should NOT have a dog, they should not be owning dogs, training dogs, selling dogs.

There have been 0 fatal attacks in the UK, that I am aware of - by dogs owned by people who were educated on dog behaviour, by people who were competent with positive reinforcement training, by people who bought dogs from reputable, ethical breeders or from similarly reputable, ethical rescues that assess dogs properly and put some training into them.

I have never heard of a Belgian Shepherd or a Malinois or a Dutchie attacking a child. I'd be interested to know why you think they are "far more dangerous" as we have one.
Swipe left for the next trending thread