Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Orchid18 · 25/03/2022 01:03

This pic was posted on an XL Bully Facebook group and is purportedly of the killer dog. It looks very cute and cuddly. Who knows what caused the dog to attack? The poor little girl must've been terrified in her last moments, a tragedy which could have been avoided. Her parents have to live with their decision to bring this dog into the home and will be haunted by what they saw for the rest of their lives.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!
oakleaffy · 25/03/2022 01:01

Good grief.
Wasn't it an XL rAmerican Bulldog that killed that poor 10 year old boy last year?
These things are brutes, bred to maim and kill bulls...so what chance a child or even an innocent pet dog?

TheGrinchsDog · 25/03/2022 00:55

@CounsellorTroi

Labs are in the top of these lists because yes they sometimes do bite/ can be aggressive. Because they are so popular - every 2nd owner seems to have a lab for eg - obviously that tips the scales a bit coz there's more labs around to possibly bite. So you get a high number of bites by Labrador reported.

I've actually known a few aggressive Labs, obviously it wasn't their fault but people just assume they are great family dogs - and mostly they are! But they need what all dogs need, training and socialisation and to never be left unsupervised with children.

I’m willing to bet that many lab bites happen because parents get them for their kids and don’t teach the kids to interact with the dog properly so it gets teased and provoked beyond its endurance. So many dogs in rescue centres are described as being unable to live with children under 14 and this is the reason.

Yes I would put good money on something like that too.

I think also the rescues are aware enough of animal behaviour to know that all dogs have the potential to bite, so understandably cover their arses with this clause even if the dog seems fine with children.

A lot of people make silly assumptions about various animals because of type/breed. At the end of the day they are animals and most of them have sharp teeth or other dangerous bits about them. Sensible people take precautions and aren't laissez faire about the potential for harm.

That doesn't mean that dogs/animals are scary and should be avoided. It means we as humans have a responsibility to be very aware of the behaviour of the animals under our care or around us.

So it's silly to cross a field full of cows. Don't walk behind a horse. Don't poke and pull at the dog. Don't frighten the cat etc etc.

Injuries happen mostly because people have chosen the incorrect animal for their situation, poor training because they can't be arsed or don't know what they should be doing and are unaware of what the behaviours mean and how to keep everyone happy and safe.

I've yet to meet a puppy born of any breed that was an inherently aggressive dog. I've only ever known truly aggressive and lots of reactive dogs (including my own dog who is a rehome from a less than ideal start) due to poor treatment and training or medical reasons.

Queeen · 25/03/2022 00:45

Of course it's the breed. This country is ridiculous for obsessing over these dangerous dogs. Something needs to be done.

CakesOfVersailles · 25/03/2022 00:42

American Bullies were bred from American Pit Bull Terriers.

Legal or not, I would not ever have one in my home or around a child.

I am sick of people and organisations - including dog shelters - peddling irresponsible myths about pit bull type dogs and 'bully breeds'. Such as claiming they are "nanny dogs" that are good family pets and were bred for family protection or companionship. Rubbish. They were bred for bull baiting and fighting. Newer lines, like American Bullies, are descended from these older lines and retain many characteristics.

It's not all upbringing, a good portion is genetics. Same with pointer dogs that point or herding dogs that herd. Quite a lot is instinctive.

These breeds snap at much higher rates than other breeds.

I feel terribly sorry for this little girl and this family, and I think it's vitally important to talk about so that other families don't make the mistake of getting dangerous breeds, whether the particular breed they purchase is legal or not.

BlusteryLake · 25/03/2022 00:37

@Zerrin13

I'm a 56 year old granny. I dont have any tattoos and I dont live on a council estate. My youngest dog is a Staffy XL Bully.
And what is it bringing to your life that a breed that doesn't savage children to death would not offer?
Babyroobs · 25/03/2022 00:32

@Zerrin13

I'm a 56 year old granny. I dont have any tattoos and I dont live on a council estate. My youngest dog is a Staffy XL Bully.
Do you worry about it being near your grandkids?
Odilla · 25/03/2022 00:31

Actually I agree with a pp that banning doesn't do much good largely because what breed a dog "is" is very difficult to legislate for. In practical terms it doesn't really work

But we do need to start having frank conversations about the potential impact of owning a powerful dog and the possible consequences of when things go wrong. To say to people that all dogs can bite but with some when they do you are looking at potential serious injury or even death. Not only from poorly trained dogs either. A dog with an undetected injury or illness can become aggressive, it happens. If it happens in your living environment and it's a powerful dog bred for fighting you will not be able to stop it. We need to hammer home this point so that people understand the risks they are taking on, without this constant Greek chorus of "soft as shite ... wouldn't hurt a fly".

Zerrin13 · 25/03/2022 00:30

I'm a 56 year old granny. I dont have any tattoos and I dont live on a council estate.
My youngest dog is a Staffy XL Bully.

CounsellorTroi · 25/03/2022 00:30

Labs are in the top of these lists because yes they sometimes do bite/ can be aggressive. Because they are so popular - every 2nd owner seems to have a lab for eg - obviously that tips the scales a bit coz there's more labs around to possibly bite. So you get a high number of bites by Labrador reported.

I've actually known a few aggressive Labs, obviously it wasn't their fault but people just assume they are great family dogs - and mostly they are! But they need what all dogs need, training and socialisation and to never be left unsupervised with children.

I’m willing to bet that many lab bites happen because parents get them for their kids and don’t teach the kids to interact with the dog properly so it gets teased and provoked beyond its endurance. So many dogs in rescue centres are described as being unable to live with children under 14 and this is the reason.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 25/03/2022 00:27

[quote XelaM]@Squiff70 Totally agree about Staffies. The "nanny dog" myth is just utterly nonsense. They have been responsible for countless fatal attacks over the years[/quote]
My DH had one growing up in a house where there were four kids. They had her from a puppy and she was a lovely dog and nanny dog suits her. Unfortunately not all are like that I agree

Babyroobs · 25/03/2022 00:20

@Squiff70

Interesting thread. I've read a lot of it, but not all of it.

A friend turned up on our doorstep this morning covered in blood and mud. She was sobbing her heart out and was clearly in shock. I guided her inside so she could explain.

Turns out she'd been out walking her dog in the local park, accidentally let go of his lead and he instantly bolted. He went straight for another dog to attack it, and that other dog's owner tried (understandably) to protect her pet. She'd ended up with a deep laceration to her hand from my friend's dog and the other owner called the police. They attended and took details. They said to my friend that they wouldn't be pressing criminal charges (against friend) but they did want to visit her at home this afternoon to discuss her dog.

This dog, in the past, has chased AND KILLED cats, but also waterfowl like ducks and geese. When I had a baby I made it clear that in no uncertain terms was her dog ever to go anywhere near my child. She understood and respected this.

Today, she stood in my kitchen sobbing and said she didn't want him (the dog) any more. Finally it appeared she was coming to her senses that he is a dangerous dog.

Oh yeah, the breed? He's a Staffie. Staffie owners are so quick to defend the reputation of Staffordshire Bull Terriers, claiming they wouldn't hurt a fly and are completely safe around children. The truth is NO breed of dog is completely safe. Not even the 'big softies' like Labs or Retrievers. We had a Collie cross (died three years ago prior to having children) who lived with two house rabbits and was the softest, daftest, sweetest dog... but I never EVER trusted him alone with the rabbits even for a second because at the end of the day, he was still a dog and all dogs have a breaking point and can snap, especially if provoked.

My friend's dog is not, in my opinion, a 'nice' dog. He isn't friendly, he isn't gentle, he isn't a softie even though my friend has consistently claimed he is. He has killed cats and water birds because he's an aggressive dog, regardless of his breed.

I do not yet know what came of the police visiting my friend. I am waiting to hear and I have genuinely no idea what the police might say. After my friend had left here this morning, I said to my partner that if a dog is capable of killing cats and large birds then it is perfectly capable of killing a child. I'll leave that there.

Someone I know had the end of their nose bitten off by a collie. I never quite feel comfortable around them after that.
TheGrinchsDog · 25/03/2022 00:17

I reported both the comments.

I mean people will have their opinions on these things. I'm a bit wary of spaniels and miniature doodle crosses because I've known a case of spaniel rage and I've been bitten by a doodle cross before.

But the opinion that poor people shouldn't own dogs is just fucking nasty! I really am a bit gobsmacked!

Bit mad and rolley eyed that some posters would consider me a drug dealer because of my dogs breed (used to be an office worker and I'm about as boringly straight laced as it gets really) but totally horrified at that comment and the OP agreeing! Shock

Daisycrown · 25/03/2022 00:17

*business

HiJenny35 · 25/03/2022 00:17

Same owners over and over again saying "I have one, it would never hurt a fly, softest dog ever, its the owners not the breed" this is always the same things the people on the news whose children have been killed say they thought till it turned. Yes small dogs can bite but they don't lock jaw the same you can easily kick one off or even kill it if necessary. Just look at the deaths, they are all the same pitbull, staff, bully type breads over and over again. These are a danger to people and they should all be banned. What type of person wants to keep an animal that could so easily turn and kill a child just because the animal considers it a toy or threat only someone trying to make a point would want one. Disgraceful that they haven't all already been banned and the fact that people think it's OK to take these dangerous animal to parks where children play is disgusting.

Babyroobs · 25/03/2022 00:17

Blimey. I didn't realize there had been two children killed by dogs just this month. Heartbreaking.

Daisycrown · 25/03/2022 00:16

I googled XL American Bully and the sight of it made me feel physically sick tbh. I'm an adult and I wouldn't want to be in the same house as one. Everyone agrees that they can turn any minute but what happens if it 'turns' while you're happily sleeping in bed minding your own busines......scary thought.

Andouillette · 25/03/2022 00:13

"Not sure where you get this from. Labs are working dogs and have a high bite strength, similar to a German Shepherd and pit bull. Also they can be aggressive. I have a lab who is well trained but he is an alpha male and is aggressive as far as labs go. He responds perfectly to me and my family but I wouldn't leave him with anyone whom I hadn't socialised around him. I've had far more passive rottweilers."

The post this is in response to is indeed a good one as many PP have said but this reply is correct. Labradors and similar do not have weak jaws, they have soft mouths (for retrieving game undamaged) but very strong jaws. I have a dog of an unrelated breed who is the same, he could pick up a live mouse without damaging it (and has done, goodness knows why) but he has enormous jaw strength as well. Luckily his bite inhibition is very, very good unless you are a large rat or a muscovy duck. That being said I am very aware that a large, heavily muscled dog is going to potentially cause far more damage than my DD's Chihuahuas and most other dogs in between. It is an absolute no-brainer that such dogs should not be within reach of children without skilled and knowledgeable supervision, and preferably only children who have been taught that such dogs are potentially dangerous. There are ways and means of seperating dogs from their intended target if they do bite but a dog that has truly lost its mind will be impossible to stop. Sadly people do not understand this. I have seen it once and I hope never to see it again, it was harrowing.
PS my breed has not been mentioned in this thread and they are not any of the pitbull/xl bully type at all.

saggyhairyass · 25/03/2022 00:12

Royal Mail holds lists for their postal workers of dangerous dogs.

One of the dangerous dogs on DH's "walk" right now is a Labrador. He knows a bitey JRT too.

It's part genetics, but much more it's how a dog is brought up.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 25/03/2022 00:10

(Can't believe someone suggested banning dogs entirely from council and social housing! Actually quite shocked!*

Yes

Even more shocking OP agreed.

TheGrinchsDog · 25/03/2022 00:05

There's a lot of barely veiled snobbery on this thread. Can't believe someone suggested banning dogs entirely from council and social housing! Actually quite shocked!

Yes drug dealers go for big, intimidating dogs. That is true.

But big dog doesn't = drug dealer or some scum of the earth FFS.

SomePosters · 25/03/2022 00:05

This?

Imagine telling on yourself like that.

XelaM · 25/03/2022 00:05

@Squiff70 Totally agree about Staffies. The "nanny dog" myth is just utterly nonsense. They have been responsible for countless fatal attacks over the years

marvellousmaple · 25/03/2022 00:04

@SevenWaystoLeave

I have never heard of a Belgian Shepherd or a Malinois or a Dutchie attacking a child. I'd be interested to know why you think they are "far more dangerous" as we have one

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7874237/Woman-45-mauled-death-pet-Malinois-Swiss-dog-training-centre.html

The reason you don't often hear of bites from malis or dutch shepherds is that they're not particularly common breeds to own as pets. Doesn't mean they don't or can't bite. I've worked with quite a few malis, I would never ever recommend them as a breed to have around children. They're not nicknamed Maligators for no reason.

Ta for that. First I've heard of . Wasn't a child, but still not good. They are actually very common in other parts of the world - just not in the UK as far as I can see. If they were aggressive I would think the statistics would be higher but who knows. I feel for this family . People make mistakes - we all do, but usually they don't have these kind of consequences.
SomePosters · 25/03/2022 00:04

What the actual fuck?

Poor people can’t have dogs

Do you stand by that comment?