Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
sinpola · 25/03/2022 02:41

@Joystir59 I agree!

Joystir59 · 25/03/2022 02:39

I've got a jack russell. If he's holding one of his toys in his jaws I can grab the other end of it and pick him up off the ground. That how strong a small dog's bite it. Any dog can lock it's jaws. Dogs should Never be left with children unsupervised. And all parents should teach their children to never approach or touch a dog they meet in public. Some dogs gate being touched or approached by strangers and will bite without warning. They are dogs. Unpredictable animals who require us to recognise and respect their limitations.

Joystir59 · 25/03/2022 02:23

I've just googled XL bully to see what they look like as I've never heard of them. They don't look the least bit cuddlesome to me, they look monstrous and frightening.

sinpola · 25/03/2022 02:22

@Joystir59 can't trust any dog with a child. My kid could make the nicest dog snap if I let him.
Plus a new dog takes months to settle in. New place is scary and you don't know their temperament yet anyway so have to make extra effort

Diminutivecob · 25/03/2022 02:17

I should add that the ear cropping that alot of these breeds endure as pups maybe sets them up for a wary ness of humans/vets. It’s not the nicest start in life for them to have their ear tips chopped off while conscious

Joystir59 · 25/03/2022 02:16

@RobertaFirmino

Well Jack Russells are nasty, yappy little fuckers but *@Justgorgeous* was asking about Labradors - who seem to be very placid.

FWIW, the parents really do not need all the finger pointing. They found out the hard way.

My nasty yappy little fucker never gets to spend time in the same space as a child. He could definitely inflict life changing injuries if handled wrongly by a child
Diminutivecob · 25/03/2022 02:14

Yeah I am becoming more fearful in my job because of these breeds . I remember the days when I was worried about staffies , they seem so easy to handle now, compared to their giant cousins !

oakleaffy · 25/03/2022 02:09

[quote Firefly1987]@Diminutivecob There's a Cane Corso at my local rescue centre atm-only seen a pic but it looks huge-had never heard of the breed before. I used to volunteer for the RSPCA years ago and there was an Akita that was pretty scary but the only dogs I had trouble with were a pitbull (owner in prison big surprise) which grabbed the lead off me and wouldn't give it back and almost bit me. Other dog was a staffie-the most loveable timid dog you would feel so sorry for who loved belly rubs and fuss from people but would go crazy trying to attack any dog it got near. I almost lost control of it once -was ok in the end but that was a big eye opener how dogs can change personality in a nanosecond. That volunteering stressed me out so bad not long after I quit as I didn't feel competent enough to handle some of those dogs.[/quote]
There are some alarming You Tube videos of Pitbulls attacking children-and even adults- not to mention other dogs {Usually much smaller dogs} who were just walking along the street, minding their own business.
Very very frightening.
{Captured on CCTV, mainly}

sinpola · 25/03/2022 02:08

I have an American bulldog. He's huge! So soft and lovely but even him jumping playfully at someone could seriously hurt them because of his size. Very strong

Firefly1987 · 25/03/2022 02:01

@Diminutivecob There's a Cane Corso at my local rescue centre atm-only seen a pic but it looks huge-had never heard of the breed before. I used to volunteer for the RSPCA years ago and there was an Akita that was pretty scary but the only dogs I had trouble with were a pitbull (owner in prison big surprise) which grabbed the lead off me and wouldn't give it back and almost bit me. Other dog was a staffie-the most loveable timid dog you would feel so sorry for who loved belly rubs and fuss from people but would go crazy trying to attack any dog it got near. I almost lost control of it once -was ok in the end but that was a big eye opener how dogs can change personality in a nanosecond. That volunteering stressed me out so bad not long after I quit as I didn't feel competent enough to handle some of those dogs.

Allsorts1 · 25/03/2022 01:58

Totally agree. It seems so clearly obtuse for people to constantly say that it’s the owner not the dog when clearly and time and time again it is the same breeds that cause deaths. Yes I believe that you can raise these breeds right and have a lovely dog, but unfortunately the risk is much higher and I’m sorry but the benefit of that breed existing vs the risk is not worth it. All dogs can ve dangerous, but as a dog owner the “nature” aspect of my dog is SO STRONG, she is clearly meant to retrieve things - she has been amazing at this from day dot. If she was a breed bread for fighting, no doubt she would be amazing at this too - and therefore not safe around children. Simple logic.

Orchid18 · 25/03/2022 01:56

Babyroobs - lots of people have pointed out that funeral costs would be covered, but not things like a horse and carriage, or a bespoke coffin. People also saying that they caused the death, so should pay for everything themselves, especially as they could afford to buy an expensive dog. I'm not saying what's right or wrong although I have more sympathy for parents of children killed in Ukraine who won't be able to have a fancy funeral 😢

CanIPleaseHaveOne · 25/03/2022 01:54

@Orchid18

This pic was posted on an XL Bully Facebook group and is purportedly of the killer dog. It looks very cute and cuddly. Who knows what caused the dog to attack? The poor little girl must've been terrified in her last moments, a tragedy which could have been avoided. Her parents have to live with their decision to bring this dog into the home and will be haunted by what they saw for the rest of their lives.
Terrified??

In PAIN.

What an appaling way to die.

CanIPleaseHaveOne · 25/03/2022 01:53

@FungalLurkins

It is worth remembering just how rare fatal dog attacks are. There are 12.5 million dogs in the UK (according to Google) and there have been roughly 3 fatal attacks per year in the last seven years. There are roughly 33 million men in the UK and there are 600 homicides per year, as roughly 92% of perpetrators are male, we can call that 550.

So the odds of a man killing are 550/33000000 = 0.00001666666

Odds of dog killing 3/12000000 = 0.00000024

Both tiny odds but the dogs odds are a whole two zeros more infinitesimal.

So on average a man is about 50 times more likely to kill someone than a dog is.

Not saying we should ban men btw but just trying to highlight how bad humans are at rational risk perception.

There is a lot in what you are saying there @FungalLurkins

I would love your analysis on life changing injuries or bad bites?

My dd got a bite on her foot Xmas eve. The dog ( a rescue mix) has a history of biting. I did not know this.

The dog is not that big but it pierced through her foot, and would not let go. Her bones were damaged, it is still not healed (3 months later), and she has a very big, livid, purple scar. Not to mention the money it cost us!

The owners were sorry for sure but according to them dd should not have run past the dog, should not have pulled her foot back because it made the dog hold on tighter, should not have shouted/screamed/cried/ as it made the dog mad, and so on.

In short everything was the fault of the child and nothing was their fault or the dogs.

AKASammyScrounge · 25/03/2022 01:49

@LabelMaker

Googled it and one of the websites said it was ideal for families. Also I don't think it's at all helpful to anyone to call it a stupid choice. They are suffering so much right now.
Not as much as the child did. Being mauled by an animal is a horrific death.
Diminutivecob · 25/03/2022 01:46

I have worked with dogs for years and I feel dread when I know a bully or a caine Corsa is coming in. When under pressure and worried they don’t just do a warning snap or growl - they go into attack mode. I can see it in their facial expression and body language the moment when they have made the decision to attack. So far I have got out of their way just in time.

I also dread Akita, and Alaskan malamutes, although they tend to try and bite when stressed then back off. But due to their size just one bite can kill.

Babyroobs · 25/03/2022 01:39

@Orchid18

Oakley - I like bully breeds, so to me it does look cuddly. I'm not saying it's not dangerous because clearly it was, but I wouldn't be frightened if I saw this dog, whereas I'd be wary of a GSD. Maybe that makes these dogs more of a risk because they do look appealing to some eyes, and are often referred to as 'cuddle bugs'. I don't agree with the breeding practices where some of these dogs end up with very short legs and squat faces leading to health problems, but that's another issue. LakieKady - it seems that the GoFundMe is to pay for the funeral. There are also various online raffles to raise funds. It wouldn't be my first thought either, but I think in some communities it's important to have a big showy send off. If it brings them some comfort and people are happy to donate then good luck to them.
Most funeral directors will do childrens funerals for no cost. No need for a Go fund me unless they want something really extravagent.
HeadPain · 25/03/2022 01:37

[quote OohRahhMaki123]The pretty grim stats on what breeds kill in the UK can be found here. It really is shocking to see the number that have been killed within the last 2 years by these breeds.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_Kingdom[/quote]
Scary reading the details of all those attacks and to see that several were from rescue centres

Orchid18 · 25/03/2022 01:31

Oakley - I like bully breeds, so to me it does look cuddly. I'm not saying it's not dangerous because clearly it was, but I wouldn't be frightened if I saw this dog, whereas I'd be wary of a GSD. Maybe that makes these dogs more of a risk because they do look appealing to some eyes, and are often referred to as 'cuddle bugs'. I don't agree with the breeding practices where some of these dogs end up with very short legs and squat faces leading to health problems, but that's another issue.
LakieKady - it seems that the GoFundMe is to pay for the funeral. There are also various online raffles to raise funds. It wouldn't be my first thought either, but I think in some communities it's important to have a big showy send off. If it brings them some comfort and people are happy to donate then good luck to them.

Selena55 · 25/03/2022 01:27

So in cases of domestic violence, children can be removed where one parent (usually the mother) refuses to leave the violent parent (the father) because this puts the child at risk and the parents are not trusted to put the child first.

Owning a dog like this should have the exact same consequences.

Those are not family pets, they are monsters.

Firefly1987 · 25/03/2022 01:18

I was bitten by our pet labrador when I was about the same age as this poor little girl. Completely out of the blue, never happened before or since (yes my parents kept the dog! It died when I was about 6 and I loved it). My mum was in the room at the time and couldn't tell you why it happened, perhaps I poked her or woke her up, who knows, or perhaps it was completely unprovoked. Quite a bad bite-always had the scars all my life so was used to it but over the years realised it must've been worse than I thought (think my mum downplayed it out of guilt) and now the scars really bother me. Obviously I was lucky in the grand scheme of things.

Anyway, the point is my mum was in the room and if it had been a dog that is prone to a frenzied attack there would be nothing any adult could do to prevent fatal or life changing injuries. An adult supervising in this type of situation is not going to help. These types of dogs just need to be kept away from children altogether imo. Before I was bitten I'm sure my parents never would've dreamed our dog would've done that to me and we've had all sorts of labs over the years brought up exactly the same-they all had very different personalities.

oakleaffy · 25/03/2022 01:12

@CockingASnook

The type of insecure individual who wants to own a dog like an American Bully XL is exactly the sort of person who shouldn’t be allowed to own one.
Absolutely.
LakieLady · 25/03/2022 01:10

@Clymene

In the last year, 44 children have been murdered. 3 children were killed by dogs. No children should by men OR dogs.

I'm sure her parents dote on their kids. It's taken them 2 days to set up a goFundMe.

What is their GoFundMe raising money for, please?

I'd have thought raising money would be the last thing on anyone's mind so soon after losing a child.

oakleaffy · 25/03/2022 01:08

@Orchid18

This pic was posted on an XL Bully Facebook group and is purportedly of the killer dog. It looks very cute and cuddly. Who knows what caused the dog to attack? The poor little girl must've been terrified in her last moments, a tragedy which could have been avoided. Her parents have to live with their decision to bring this dog into the home and will be haunted by what they saw for the rest of their lives.
Cute and cuddly? Completely disagree there.

All I see there is bone crushing jaws.
The width of it's mouth, a baby wouldn't;t stand a chance.

oakleaffy · 25/03/2022 01:06

*I am sick of people and organisations - including dog shelters - peddling irresponsible myths about pit bull type dogs and 'bully breeds'. Such as claiming they are "nanny dogs" that are good family pets and were bred for family protection or companionship. Rubbish. They were bred for bull baiting and fighting. Newer lines, like American Bullies, are descended from these older lines and retain many characteristics.

It's not all upbringing, a good portion is genetics. Same with pointer dogs that point or herding dogs that herd. Quite a lot is instinctive*

Spot on about instinct.

We had a Lurcher puppy selected by RSPCA as a ''Good match''.
The chase instinct was hardwired into her.
Just as it is a Border Collie to herd, or a Jack Russell to catch rats.

Genetics has a large part to play in temperament and drive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread