Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
gogohm · 25/03/2022 07:41

The reality is that some dogs have stronger bites but all dogs require training.

Collies for instance are pretty nippy, I've certainly been on the wrong side of my dog's grumpy nature (older and just had surgery admittedly) but they don't lock their jaws in the same way, in fact nipping the sheep's ankles is instinct hence nipping kids wellies! I wouldn't trust him with a child even before he became an old grump, and he's fully trained, got his hold certificate for obedience.

Someone mentioned miniature pinchers on the thread, they are a nightmare for biting, well one particular one is, goes for my dog and draws blood, thankfully he doesn't go for it because he has eaten bigger bones!

abeanbaked · 25/03/2022 07:38

@Indoctro what hunting breeds are you referring to?

ProfessorScarlett · 25/03/2022 07:35

Yanbu. How much nanny state is needed? It was a strong muscular dog with an unknown temperament. That poor child.

Tired of dog owners who can't control or train their 'pets', my child was bitten in the park and has scars due to an uncontrolled dog attack.

MumUndone · 25/03/2022 07:35

It's such a pointless argument to say it's either the breed or the upbringing, it's a combination of both. There are some types of dog that have been specifically bred to fight, or chase, or catch rats! They have a genetic predisposition to certain behaviours. They can be trained to be fantastic family pets but the genetic predisposition is still there. Equally, there are types of dogs that have been bred specifically to be pets, but that doesn't mean they don't have the potential to bite if you don't train them properly. I have a rescue greyhound who is a big softy and very calm around people; this is a combination of his breed and his training - but I still wouldn't leave him alone with my 3 year old.

Hugsgalore · 25/03/2022 07:34

@RobertaFirmino

Well Jack Russells are nasty, yappy little fuckers but *@Justgorgeous* was asking about Labradors - who seem to be very placid.

FWIW, the parents really do not need all the finger pointing. They found out the hard way.

We've a jack Russell Cross and nasty is not a word I would use to describe him. He does bark a bit but he's certainly not nasty and the only damage he'd do to someone is cover them in saliva... burglars included.
Amelion · 25/03/2022 07:31

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_Kingdom

List of fatal dog attacks. There’s maybe more of a range of breeds of dogs featured in there than people might expect - including Jack Russells, Lakeland Terriers, German Shepherds, Dobermans, Rottweilers, Malamutes. There are then the illegal Pit Bulls, and other bull breeds like American and Staffordshire.

I think fundamentally - breeds aside - people should never have a dog they can’t control. I say this as someone whose 15kg dog was attached by a 50kg dog in the park - the owner was only about 60kg herself and had no hope of controlling it. A dog of that weight exerts a massive amount of force and you’ve no chance.

However even small dogs can attack and kill so need to be kept away from children and never left unsupervised with children.

Uttoxerley · 25/03/2022 07:30

“Eeksteek

It IS the breed. Labs and spaniels are bred to like being with people, to listen, to have weak mouths, to enjoy touch. Hundreds of generations of the survival of the soppiest! Fighting breeds were bred to react with aggression, to attack in a frenzy, to be wound up, to hold on with a crushing bite. If a lab snaps (generally out of fear and anxiety because it’s been poorly raised or it’s needs are not met) it snaps, and then runs away to safety, or can be pulled off. It will let go if hurt. It snaps in its own defence, because it doesn’t have hundreds of generations of being bred to strengthen its desire and ability to fight and attack. Fighting breeds have a much higher chance of reacting like this, and a much higher risk of causing terrible injuries if they do. It’s not their fault, and good training and a healthy environment can certainly produce good individual dogs. But that isn’t the same as saying they don’t a higher risk of killing or maiming as a breed.

Genes load the gun. The environment only pulls the trigger. Labs etc come with rubber bullets and safety catches. Fighting breeds are armour piercing rounds with hair triggers. The might not fire, but they kill if they do. All dogs can be dangerous, but big powerful, fighting dogs are the most dangerous, most often. Having one at all is quite a responsibility, but having one around a child is an unacceptable risk snd should absolutely have to consequences to stop other people taking the same risks. It’s what we do with any other child neglect, to deter other parents from making the same poor parenting decisions. The parents would face charges if the child had been accidentally killed or injured by any other weapon, because weapons shouldn’t be near children.”

Wholeheartedly agree with this. The “deed not breed” argument dangerously minimises the issue.

Indoctro · 25/03/2022 07:30

I don't see how a dog bred for hunting is any different to a dog bred for fighting.?

Both are bred to kill another animal. But why don't hunting dogs get the same amount of fear.?

Just out of interest.

EV117 · 25/03/2022 07:22

I think it matters to some extent - illegal breeds tend to be ones that are specifically bred to fight and be violent. They have a strong instinct to attack just like a collie has a strong instinct to heard and it takes a knowledgeable and skilled dog owner to control them and be in charge. But it stands to reason that people who buy illegal dogs aren’t that kind of dog owner. Overall YADNBU though. Whether banned or not some dog breeds are clearly not family dogs unless you have a very experienced and responsible adult in charge, ideally a professional dog trainer (I’ve literally walked past someone who’s Alsatian dragged them through the mud because they couldn’t hold them back on a lead… great, clever dogs, but dangerous I think in the hands of someone with no clue about dogs). On the other hand, lap dogs have been known to kill babies too. I think in general many people don’t actually know how to handle dogs or understand dogs. My MIL treats her tiny dachshund like a baby and he’s a jealous little thing - no chance I would let him near a baby. Sometimes people don’t see these things like that though and it has dire consequences.

Dammitthisisshit · 25/03/2022 07:22

I also think people should have a licence to own a dog and that should involve passing an educational course too.

Yes.
So much poor dog behaviour in general around (before anyone jumps on this I’m not saying all dogs, but far too many dogs) that would be helped by this.

A license to own a dog that you can only get if you’ve done an ownership course. A registration for the dog that is linked to the license and issued once the dog has been through training classes. Registration records DNA.
Anyone mistreating a dog is never allowed a license again.
Only registered breeders or experienced rescue centres allowed to sell dogs (ie no puppy farms).
Any dangerous dog behaviour or repeated antisocial behaviour (like allowing dogs to chase birds on our local ‘dogs on leads only’ nature reserve) loses a license holders right to get any new dogs, or existing dog(s) re-homed/ put down depending on severity.
No high risk breeds allowed: because the same breeds pop up time and time again.
Paid for by fines on any dog poo left lying around which could be DNA tested as it’s all registered.

Why don’t we have this?

EvilGoldfish · 25/03/2022 07:20

I had a thread on here late last year about discovering my puppy was a ‘banned breed’. She was the sweetest, most intelligent dog I’ve ever met. Sadly (the circumstances are on the thread) we could not keep her. I was willing to upsize the house in to a cheaper area, but the behavioural problem she had needed far more experience than I had (and no vulnerable people around her - ever)

She went to an amazing rescue while still very young, straight into an experienced with large bull breeds foster home with no dc and a huge amount of land. She has now been officially adopted by them and is a wonderful, happy and loving dog.

BUT that is only because:

A) She is in a home with a very large house/extra land.

B) She is with very experienced owners who have handled large bull breeds before, and has had professional behaviourist support since five months old (provided by the rescue).

C) She is able to live in a place with no vulnerable people or stranger coming in and out. She’ll never live/be in the same room as children or the elderly.

I regret giving her up every single day and keep up to date with her progress. But I also know that if she had stayed with us in our circumstances (a family with young dc, in a smal terraced house, with visitors coming and going) then she would probably have attacked, maybe killed someone.

She must have an entire litter out there that may have inherited this behavioural problem, and I dread to think where she would be if we had just sold her on.

TheGoogleMum · 25/03/2022 07:19

I'd worry about any breed with a very young child. It's not sensible to get a new dog while you have very young children in my opinion. Some are definitely worse than others and shouldn't be around children at all. Just because some of the breed are fine if we know some are riskier than others why risk it?

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 25/03/2022 07:15

I've met a couple of American Bulls rescued from fighting home and they are the saddest, most frightening things you've ever seen. I've also met American Bull that are much loved family pets.
It has a lot to do with breeding. Some dogs were historically bred for fighting, whether it was bears, lions, each other or guarding, the dogs would have been specifically selected for breeding because of their personality traits. Even in "nice" dog breeds you will get a rogue aggressive dog and a responsible breeder or owner will recognise this and have the dog euthanized.
Some of the dogs on the banned breeds list are there because of dog fighting.
Irresponsible breeders don't temperament check the stud.

Papayamya · 25/03/2022 07:10

@RosaMoline

There’s absolutely no need for a go fund me page in the first place. A child’s funeral is basically free. Funeral Directors are FOC, so is the crematorium & officiant fee. The Funeral Directors will also make a claim to the children’s funeral fund for the cost of the coffin.
Sadly lots of people exploit the death of their child for £££s.
Mumofsend · 25/03/2022 07:10

Making money off their child's needless death Confused

Flapjacker48 · 25/03/2022 07:03

Bull breeds should be banned.

RosaMoline · 25/03/2022 07:02

There’s absolutely no need for a go fund me page in the first place. A child’s funeral is basically free. Funeral Directors are FOC, so is the crematorium & officiant fee. The Funeral Directors will also make a claim to the children’s funeral fund for the cost of the coffin.

abeanbaked · 25/03/2022 06:59

These dogs are quite frankly terrifying. I was trying to walk down a street with my DS in the pram to get back to our car. There were two outside a shop, on leads but the man 'in control' of them was clearly under the influence and the two XL dogs were jumping up at him, mouthing their leads and growling. I was just trying not to draw attention to us and was practically in the middle of the road passing slowly to get past. There was no way he could have ever controlled them had they decided to attack him or anyone else on that street.

Another owner of one I saw on Facebook trying to stud their dog out. All that they had to say was that they were looking for a bitch to breed him. IMO you shouldn't be breeding a dog unless it is to improve upon or continue on the qualities of the breed. This breed doesn't have any qualities that are conducive with living in a family home.

A few weeks ago a lab near us was killed by two bull terriers whilst out for his night time walk on a lead. They came up and attacked him unprovoked without a human in sight.

I am sorry to say, there is a common theme with the kind of people that keep them. It's all about image and status. And they are OBSESSED with telling people that they are cuddly bears that would do no harm. Or taking pictures of them with children next to them as if to prove the point that they really are so safe. 🙄

My DS and dog don't get to be next to each other atall. I could physically restrain her but I wouldn't want it to come to that. He doesn't understand boundaries yet and I would never put her into that position of feeling threatened that she had to act. They are both my responsibility to keep safe.

I'm glad I live in the countryside and I don't feel like myself or my family (including dog) are at risk whilst just going about our daily life's. I would be horrified if I came upon one of these dogs off lead and under no control. I'm seeing more and more of them out and about in towns. That poor little girl, her last moments must have been full of terror.

Turningpurple · 25/03/2022 06:59

neighbour said they'd bought the dog very cheaply - 'for buttons' was the expression used.

Either they lied to the neighbour, maybe not wanting to admit how much they spent. Or that's another huge red flag that the owner just wanted rid.

Buildingthefuture · 25/03/2022 06:55

Well, I don’t agree that selling adult dogs should be illegal. Over the years, I have “bought” (more like rescued!) a fair few adult tiny toy breeds from (fucking dreadful) breeders. Once they have served their purpose, these dogs are thrown away like rubbish, often with quite serious medical issues due to neglect and over breeding, That is not ok. Obviously the risk posed from a tiny dog (less than 6lbs) is minuscule. None of mine could even break the skin if they bit, they simply do not have the bite power. Would I adopt an adult bully breed? No. I have been adopting dogs for 20 years and always have multiples, all different breeds and sizes. But I’m not experienced enough to take on such a powerful animal.
Breeding in general should be far, far more regulated. KC registration means less than nothing and no one is looking at where these dogs come from or where they are going to. Regulate breeders and bring back licensing, so everyone who wants a dog is properly assessed to ensure they are suitable and capable.

WizzardPjs · 25/03/2022 06:48

It’s always the same breeds of dog and anyone saying “it’s not the breed … “ is kidding themselves.
Everytime I hear of a dog attack I just know it’s going to be a bully breed of some kind and it infuriates me. They should be banned. And I say that as a dog lover.

I also think people should have a licence to own a dog and that should involve passing an educational course too. And the dealing of puppies should be likened to the dealing of drugs for those not health tested and approved. The approval should include temperament testing of the dam and sire

Papayamya · 25/03/2022 06:48

They should be prosecuted imo rather than setting up go fund mes. They brought a dangerous dog into the home, no doubt through ignorance which will killed their defenceless child they're supposed to be protect. Not a popular view I'm sure, but the reality is that if they'd made different decisions she'd still be here.

ClariceQuiff · 25/03/2022 06:46

@allthatglimmers

It pisses me off they’ve got a Go Fund Me to help with costs after probably spending a stupid amount of money on the dog that did all this.
A neighbour said they'd bought the dog very cheaply - 'for buttons' was the expression used.
Papayamya · 25/03/2022 06:45

Well*

Papayamya · 25/03/2022 06:44

It’s the upbringing not the breed

The breed plays a huge part though because they're big enough and capable of killing people. Some smaller breeds or whatever might bite people, but don't kill. Even a week trained and well socialised dog like this is a risk as just like people animals can be unpredictable. I do think some proper forget they are animals and not just fluffy pets. I do feel sorry for the family and no doubts they wouldn't have got the dog if they had even a small inclination it could be a risk, but education around this needs to improve.

Swipe left for the next trending thread