Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs… To think it doesn’t matter whether it’s a legal breed or not?!

633 replies

MsWalterMitty · 24/03/2022 19:44

Just read about the recent child death in St Helen’s. It’s so awful!

The breed of dog has been released and it turns out it’s not an illegal breed. It’s called an American Bully XL, never heard of it so I googled it, even though I had an idea what it might look like due to its name.

Surely, whether it’s legal or not, this dog seems like a really stupid choice for a family!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:16

“But breed is significant.”

Not when it comes to fatal attacks it’s just not - breed comes way way down the common factors in studies.

Akitas are definitely a tricky breed and one of the few I’d never own, but they’re no more likely to kill someone.

user3837313202 · 25/03/2022 08:15

Why is everyone on this thread talking about breed and not about how they acquired this dog?

It should be a cautionary tale against privately rehoming a dog. If you get a rescue dog from a proper rescue centre, it will have been assessed for temperament and other needs. If it's assessed as (for instance) not being cat friendly then they won't rehome to someone with cats.

Private rehoming is the wild west of dog acquisition. Owners who don't have an accurate view of their own dogs needs and what sort of home might suit it. Owners who lie or minimise because they want to see the back of their dog. Unidentified medical problems that can be very expensive and / or cause pain which in turn makes the dog grumpy. And so it goes on.

My dog was privately rehomed from a friend, and I'd still never advise people to privately rehome!

Dogs temperaments are never completely about either the breed or the upbringing. There's all sorts of factors - parental temperament (snappy Pomeranians tend to create snappy Pomeranians), mother's stress during pregnancy, the environment they're raised in by the breeder (big difference between a puppy farmer's shed and someone's family living room) and so on.

But I do wish people would realise that the person holding the lead isn't always the one responsible for its upbringing. Sometimes they're a very responsible dog owner trying to pick up the pieces left by others - even if their dog is having a meltdown in public because they've seen something its scared of.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:13

But also they’ve done scientific studies on correlated factors in fatal attacks, breed isn’t significant - the top 3 by far is, a dog where it’s with people that aren’t it’s people, a history of abuse and or neglect and being unneutered.

But breed is significant. Akitas for example were bred as fighting dogs, their temperament is well known to be fiercely protective and to not back down, combined with strong hunting instincts. Never mind how they’ve been treated.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:10

www.news24.com/You/Archive/little-boy-killed-by-family-labrador-in-horror-attack-20170728

And labradors do kill children - if I remember rightly that was originally reported as a pitbull.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 08:07

The big issues with deciding it’s breeds that are the problem is that firstly identification - a lot of the “breeds’ just aren’t actually breeds. While genetics do matter Dog’s don’t inherit behavioural traits by looking a certain way but actually being mongrels. Also people are generally pretty rubbish at identifying dog breeds anyway, a reported staffy could in fact be anything at all, I’ve seen lab crosses that people were adamant were staffies. I know a Great Dane owner who is asked all the time if her giant dog is a Dalmatian.

So the “breed” is never a set thing... American xl bullies are not pedigree dogs, anything muscular gets thrown in there.

But also they’ve done scientific studies on correlated factors in fatal attacks, breed isn’t significant - the top 3 by far is, a dog where it’s with people that aren’t it’s people, a history of abuse and or neglect and being unneutered.

Velvian · 25/03/2022 08:05

I suspect that this is predominantly a man problem too. There was a thread on here a few months ago from a woman whose partner got a dog that was unsuitable for their children. He got it against her will, she was having to keep the dog and small DC separated all day and was facing getting it removed against his will.

Lalliella · 25/03/2022 08:03

@Addsverisimilitude

I've commented earlier about my experiences in ED with children having been bitten and mauled by dogs. Every single one every single time says "they've never done anything like this before" "they're such a softie" "they've always been so good around the children". And this thread is full of people saying the same thing. This is why we don't learn. (And googling images of a bully XL is mind boggling. They look like mean vicious nasty animals. How can anyone think they look cute?)
Of course they haven’t done anything like this before. Because if they had they would already have been put down. So if the dog is going to do something like that there’s always going to be a first time. I would never have anything in my house that has the slightest potential to kill a child.

Yes the parents are suffering horribly, but what on earth were they thinking? That poor little girl. It needs discussing, even if it just stops one person making this choice in future, that’s a child’s life potentially saved.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:02

I saw a Japanese Akita at a country fair once and too many children were wanting to stroke it thinking it was a husky, that is not a breed you want your child sticking it’s little hand by, why do parents let their children do this?

LittleWins · 25/03/2022 08:02

It was irresponsible to get any rescue dog with such a young child and they’ve paid the ultimate price. It is an awful tragedy.

I have two rescue dogs and only after years do I have a good, not perfect, idea of how they’ll react in situations. One will put up with being sat on, poked etc by kids and the other is an angry old man in their presence. It’s my responsibility to manage that.

abeanbaked · 25/03/2022 08:02

@Indoctro but labradors aren't bred to bite and kill. That is an issue with how the dog has been raised, potentially in the breeding if it has been dodgy but it is not really in their nature to attack. I have a retriever and her innate instinct is not to kill. When she does come upon a live animal she is unsure how to handle it as she it is in her genes to retrieve shot game with a very soft mouth or flush birds, not handle live game.

She is happy, I can assure you. We do lots of retrieving, steadiness, heel work etc. Infact the full litter went to pet homes, all of which have gotten on fine. The issues that most lab/spaniel/retriever issues will have is harnessing their dogs desire to hunt, this is usually with their noses and flushing out birds or deer, not hunting and attacking humans. Very few will be responsible for fatally injuring children in comparison to XL bull-type dogs.

The issue is a mix of uncontrollably strong dog which is bred for size, strength and its ability to lock on to things and the kind of people that buy them. Sorry, but I really do think it's the breed and the people.

toomanytwinkies · 25/03/2022 08:00

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

Yes any dog can attack but it’s never poodles found to have killed a child!!! Let’s be honest there’s a list of about 5 breeds who come up time and time again.
Yes it’s never a golden retriever is it
HeadNorth · 25/03/2022 07:57

When my kids were wee we had a Cavalier King Charles as the family dog. I didn't need to know the breed of the dog that killed to know it wasn't a cav, or a westie, or a bichon or any of the other suitable family breeds.

The point is 2 fold: these wee breeds are bred mainly to be pets so have had the aggression bred out of them; on the vanishingly rare chance they turned rogue, they don't have the size and strength to kill a child.

I think the deed not breed or no bad breed only bad owners stuff is a pile of crap. If you have a young family, get a pet that couldn't actually kill them FFS.

tabulahrasa · 25/03/2022 07:55

@HardbackWriter

People always say on this thread that it's fine because they personally never leave their dog and their toddler/child alone together - people have already pointed out that this isn't a fail-safe if you couldn't stop the dog anyway, but I'm always a bit sceptical that this is true. Really, never, for a moment? I can see how this would be true for a baby, but a three year old, say - are people really putting the dog in a different area of the house if they go to answer the door, if they do the washing up, if they're doing a task that involves going from room to room? Would you not be constantly separating the dog and the child for tiny tasks and moments? If people really are doing that then it must make life so unenjoyable and surely it's a constant reminder that you've bought a dangerous creature into the home?
You keep the dog with you, you literally just call the dog as you leave the room, because you’d be an idiot to trust a 3 year old not to suddenly decide to go harass the dog.
toomuchlaundry · 25/03/2022 07:52

@Hopefulsunrise the parents were stupid and irresponsible. Getting a dog like that is akin to driving a car without putting the little one in a car seat and no seat belt. A terrible accident waiting to happen.

Rubyupbeat · 25/03/2022 07:52

A lot of the problem is where dogs are passed around or 'bought for buttons' like this one was. They have no stability and no one knows how they were treated.
My friends daughter has a history of this, buys a dog on a whim, who is shut in the kitchen, then she gets fed up with it and gives it away.

Indoctro · 25/03/2022 07:51

[quote abeanbaked]@Indoctro what hunting breeds are you referring to?[/quote]
Labrador is definitely top of the list and the fact it's responsible for so many bites to kids proves it should not be pushed as this amazing family pet. It's not bred to sit in a house all day with kids. It's bred to work and there lies the problem.

I own a staffy which I got as a puppy and chose the breed as they are good with children, I've owned many breeds over the years but felt this was most suitable. I waited till my kids are at school and I know the staffy is highly intelligent so also needs a job to be happy.

He does agility, scentwork classes and canicross with me, this help focus his mind and use up his energy, which creates a obedient, well rounded happy dog.

If I couldn't offer him a life like this I would of got a dog bred for the lap like a pug.

People need to not pick a breed on what they like but on what type of home they can offer it

I hate seeing labs/ spaniels etc in pet homes with no jobs, these dogs need to work so if you can't work them through shooting or agility then don't get one, it won't be a happy dog.

EV117 · 25/03/2022 07:51

Interesting that it's widely seen a problem with the dog and the breed, not a problem with the breeders and the owners and the parents.

I sympathise with this but at the end of the day it’s like arguing ‘guns don’t kill people, people kill people.’ But since a few too many people can’t keep a gun responsibly it’s better not to have them available for the general public. Same with certain breeds of dog in my opinion.

LolaLouLou · 25/03/2022 07:48

I am a first time dog owner with a 9 year old child. What I have learnt, is that it has taken much more time and energy to train my child on how to behave around my dog than it has to train my lovely spaniel.

My DH's family had 'dangerous dog' types when he was growing up. But he lived on a property with grounds so large that it took three days to mow the lawn. The dogs were well trained and had a purpose.

Now his parents live in a normal house, they have two sweet, pampered lap dogs.

I suppose what I am saying is that whilst dogs may have a certain disposition by breeding or temperament. Humans entirely control the dog's environment and are therefore ultimately responsible for their behaviour.

Stravaig · 25/03/2022 07:47

Interesting that it's widely seen a problem with the dog and the breed, not a problem with the breeders and the owners and the parents.

Hopefulsunrise · 25/03/2022 07:46

If the papers are to be believed the dog was bought to stud not to be a family dog. The two result in very different temperments. The parents were naive and it's ended in tragedy.

Eeksteek · 25/03/2022 07:45

Indeed. I would not have them again. BUT if they run away, no one gets hurt. Also, they don’t run away. One of them has adequate recall - as good as my collies and better than my dozy spaniel - and one is walked on lead because she doesn’t. So I can physically prevent the breed traits from being a problem.

There were bred to track and kill small animals. They weren’t bred to fight other big powerful animals and they aren’t big powerful animals. They frequently bite (as a breed) because they are stubborn and independent and have sleep startles. But they aren’t bred to aggressively fight to the death and they don’t kill children. Cats are sleek killing machines, but they don’t kill children. Power and temperament matter. And that’s largely a function of breed.

ChickenStripper · 25/03/2022 07:44

These parents are at fault - bringing a dog into a small house like this with two young children. There is a certain "cachet" in some people about having a dog that looks like that. They had had the dog a week? The same type of dog that killed a young boy in Wales a couple of months ago! Irresponsible - that poor child.

EV117 · 25/03/2022 07:43

I don't see how a dog bred for hunting is any different to a dog bred for fighting.?

I imagine it takes a whole other type of aggression to attack your own kind - another predator baring it’s teeth at you - than chasing prey. A hunting instinct is in some ways fairly natural, a ‘fighting to kill another dog’ instinct is not. What people have done over the years is taken the most angry and aggressive dogs, with strong jaws and stocky strong build, and bred them to do something that a wild animal wouldn’t. They don’t just fight a bit, they have no sense of backing down, even if they are going to get severely hurt themselves - that’s not natural at all, wild animals don’t do that. Generally one will try and back down before they are severely hurt or killed, and this happens fairly quickly - but in a fighting pit that wouldn’t make for a good show.

Addsverisimilitude · 25/03/2022 07:43

I've commented earlier about my experiences in ED with children having been bitten and mauled by dogs.
Every single one every single time says "they've never done anything like this before" "they're such a softie" "they've always been so good around the children".
And this thread is full of people saying the same thing. This is why we don't learn.
(And googling images of a bully XL is mind boggling. They look like mean vicious nasty animals. How can anyone think they look cute?)

HardbackWriter · 25/03/2022 07:42

People always say on this thread that it's fine because they personally never leave their dog and their toddler/child alone together - people have already pointed out that this isn't a fail-safe if you couldn't stop the dog anyway, but I'm always a bit sceptical that this is true. Really, never, for a moment? I can see how this would be true for a baby, but a three year old, say - are people really putting the dog in a different area of the house if they go to answer the door, if they do the washing up, if they're doing a task that involves going from room to room? Would you not be constantly separating the dog and the child for tiny tasks and moments? If people really are doing that then it must make life so unenjoyable and surely it's a constant reminder that you've bought a dangerous creature into the home?

Swipe left for the next trending thread